Bates et al v. Strawbridge Studios, Inc. et al
Filing
90
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 5/9/2012. (lab)
G EM SOFFl t. Dl coUc
cE ) sm
S.
AT R- KE, <
FIED
L
I THE UN I
N
TED STA TES DI
STRI COU RT
CT
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF V I I I
CT
RG N A
RO AN OK E D I I ON
V SI
MA 9! 2 1
t
22
JULI ,
A D
B '
CHARLESM .BATES, g,
qt 1,
Ci lA c i N o.7: CV0021
vi ton
11
6
Pli if ,
antf s
M EM O R AN DU M O PI I N
N O
STM W BRI E STU DI S,l C. #!DG
O N , g
k,
.
By:
Hon.Gl n E.
e Com'd
a
Chi fUnie St t D it i tJ e
e
t d a es s rc udg
D e e nt .
f nda s
Ch re M . tsa dDo n L. ts(olcieyr fre t a ih panif' fld
als Bae n n a Bae c l t l ee rd o s t e litfs' ie
e v
t
)
t sdi r iy a ton f de a a i a br a h ofc r ta i tSta i St os I .
hi ve st c i or f m ton nd e c
ontac gans r wbrdge udi , nc
(t rwbrdg ' a J Doe,a u no e o ea ntofSta i Thec ei
dsta i e' nd ohn
)
n nk wn mplye /ge
rwbrdge.
as s
p e e tyb f r tec u t nS rwbrd esmoinf rs mmayj d me t F rt ra o st a
r sn l e o e h o r o ta ig ' to o u r u g n . o he e s n h t
f l w,t moton wilbede ed.
olo he
i
l
ni
Fac ualBac ound
t
kgr
The f l ng f c sa epr s n e i t lg m os fvor bl t t pl i if . Se
olowi a t r e e t d n he i ht t a a e o he antfs e
And ro v. b ryLo b .n .47 U. 2 2, 5 ( 9 6 (o igta ale ie c mus b
es n Lie t b v Ic, 7 S. 4 2 5 1 8 ) n tn h t 1 vd n e t e
c n tu di t elg t tfvo a l t t ep ryo p sn s mmayj d me t.
o sr e n h ih mos a rbe o h a t p o i g u r u g n)
Sta i i a s hoolphot r phy busne sbas d i Dur m , t Car i The
r wbrdge s c
og a
i s
e n hn Norh olna.
c
ompanyempl pho ogr phe swho s r ceci si f ure n sa e a t Diti to
oys t a r
e vi lent n o te tt s nd he src f
Col bi The c i n s phot a a e pr
um a.
le t '
ogr phs r oduc d a t c pa sN orh Ca olnapl nt
e t he om ny'
t r i
a .
The pl i if , ho r s de i Bo
a ntf s w
e i n onesM il V i g ni ,a s ope a e a s hoolpho og a y
l, r i a l o r t c
t r ph
bus ne s l J nua y of2008, he e e ed i o a co r c w ih Sta brdge, ls ntt w hi h
i s. n a r
t y nt r nt
nt a t t r w i ptr ua o
c
St a brdge pur has d t pl ntf s s
rw i
c e he ai i f ' choolphot a ac ount a a e t e pl t m t
ogr phy c s nd gr ed o m oy he o
E
M
.
ha ea co si Vigi a a Norh Ca olna.Unf runaey,hepa te 'r ltons p quikl
ndl c unt n r ni nd
t r i
o t tl t
ris ea i hi c y
s ur d a Sta brdge t nui t d t pl i tf s'e pl ym e .
o e nd r w i
e na e he a n if m o nt
I J yof2009, hepl ntf sfl a a ton f rbr ac ofc r ta ns Sta rdgei
n ul
t ai if ied n c i o e h ontac gai t r wb i n
sa ec t Sta i r movedt a ton t t sco tondi r iy gr ndsa fld
t t our. r wbrdge e
he c i o hi ur
ve st ou
nd ie
c e cai sa ns t pl i if . Se Si hta Sound St os I v.Sta i St os
ount r l m gai t he antfs e g nd
udi . nc.
r wbrdge udi .
I .No 70 CV00 38( . Va 2 0 ) Th p risulmaeyn g tae as tlme t
nc, . :9
3 W D. . 0 9 . e a t t tl e o itd et n
e i
e
a e m e i M a of201 t tr ol d t rdiput
gr e nt n y
0 ha es ve hei s e.The s tl ntag e m e ti ude t
e teme
r e n ncl d he
f l ng pr son.( pa tesag eet tnet rwils y, ie,pu ih,br dc t o i a
olowi
ovii . The ri r ha ihe l a wrt bls oa as, r n ny
ot rwa pa tcpa ei negai ordipa a ng c
he y rii t n
tve
s r gi omme sab t ot r'
nt out he he .'
A ppr m a e y sx m ont l t r i N o m be of201 Trna La ade c le
oxi t l i
hs a e , n ve r
0, i
pr
a ld
Stawbrdge st lfeenumbe a s
r
i ' ol r
r nd poket am ae c t rs r i r pr s nttve. La a
o
l usome e vce e e e a i
pr de
wa a tmptng t l a et l ts hoolphot a t tha be n t ke ofhe t e gedaug e ,
s te i o oc t he as c
ogr ph ha d e a n
r e na
ht r
who ha be kild i a c ra i nt An e o a he da e ' s hoolha me i d t t
d en le n a ccde .
mplyee t r ught rs c
d ntone ha
t phot a m i ha be n t ke by t pli if . W he La a m e i ne t pl i if '
he
ogr ph ght ve e a n he antfs
n pr de nto d he antfs
na e , hec t rs r i er pr s nttver ponde wih de oga o yc me sabou t
m s t usome e v c e e e a i es
d t r t r om nt
t he
co e.Ac or ngt La a t r pr s n a i sa e t tt pl ntfswe et ...
upl
c di o pr de,he e e e t tve tt d ha he ai if r t
not
rp tb e'ta çhe c udn t etu td'a dta çhn sg ts ba ( ta rd e h dt g t
e u a l, h t s y o l o b r se , n h tç ig o o d S rwb ig ) a o e
' t
'
t
ivov di alws i. ( p a eDe la !6)
n le n a ut' La r d c. t .
'
La a s e nty vi ie he da ht r s s hool A fe r l yi t c m e sm a
pr de ubs que l s t d r ug e ' c
. t r e a ng he om nt de
a
boutt pl i if , pr i r a t S
he a ntf s La ade nquied s o d t s hoolw oul de w ih pe e ...who ha
why he c
d al t opl
d
s aba rputto ' ( prdeDe l a !9.
uch d e ain. La a
'
c. t )
2
On M a 9,2011 t pl i if fld t sdi riy a to agans Sta i and is
y
, he antfs ie hi ve st ci n i t r wbrdge
t
unknow n c t e s r i e r pr e a i ,a s r i c a m s ofd a a i a br c ofc r t
us om r e v c e es nt tve s e tng l i
ef m ton nd ea h
ontac .
Th r a tr S rwb ig mo e t ds s t ec mp an p ru n t Rue1 ( )6 o teFe e a
ee fe , ta rd e v d o imis h o lit u s a t o l 2 b ( ) f h d r l
Rul ofPr e e On M a c 5, 2,t cou tde e t motont dimi s
es
oc dur .
r h 201 he r nid he i o s s .
Upo t ec mplto o ds o ey Sr wb ig fldamoinf rsl r u g n .
n h o ein f ic v r , ta rd e ie
to o l
mmayj d me t
The c the d ahe rng o t moton onM a 4,201
our l
a i n he i
y
2.Themoton ha be n f lybre e a i
i
s e u l if d nd s
rpe f r vi w .
i or e e
St
andard ofR e ew
vi
Un e Ru e5 , na r o s mmayj d me ti a p o raeçft mo a ts wst a
d r l 6 a wad f u r u g n s p r p it t he v n ho h t
i
t eei nog n ied s u ea t a ymaeilfc a dt emo a ti e tte t j d me ta a
h r s e un ip t s o n tra a t n h v n s nild o u g n s
matro lw. Fe R. v. 5 a .Fo ap ry' e d n et r ieag n neis eo maeil
te f a ' d. Ci P. 6() r at s vie c o as e ui s u f tra
'
f c t a od s mmayj d me t imu t eç u ht a ara o a l j r c udrtlnav r it o
a to v i u r u g n ,t s b d c h t e s n b e u y o l et
s
r ed c f r
t non- ovi pary. Ande s 477 U . a 248. I de e m i ng w he he t gr nta m oto
he
m ng t '
'
r on,
S. t
n t r ni
t ro a
in
f rs mmayj d me tt ec u t s viw terc r i t elg tmo t a o a et t e
o u r u g n ,h o r mu t e h e o d n h ih s fv rbl o h
n n mo n p ry Ter ' Fl o Fa ho s I c v. ri tn Id s.n .7 3F.d6 4 61 ( t
o - vig at. rys o r s in sn . Bu l o n u .lc, 6 2 0 , 0 4h
nz
Ci.1 8 )
r 9 5.
Di cuss on
s i
D ef aton
am i
Bas d on t sa e nt aleg dl m a byt c t rs r i r pr e i , t
e
he t t me s l e y de he usome e vce e es nàtve ' he
pl ntf s fr ta s ta cl i f r de a a i a i tSta brdge.The pl i if a l ge t tt
ai if i s s er
a m o f m ton ga ns r w i
a ntf s le ha he
r pr e a i w a a tng w ihi t s pe ofhi e pl m e w he t s a em e sw e e m ade
e es nt tve s c i
t n he co
s m oy nt n he t t nt r
,
1As oft sda e, t pl ntfsha bee una e t confr t i iy oft si vi .
hi t he ai if ve n bl o
im he dentt
hi ndi dual
a t tt sa e nt we eha mf t t rbusne sr put ton.I movi f s
nd ha he t t me s r r ul o hei i s e ai
n
ng or umm a y
r
j g n o t eme i o ti cam, ta rd ema e fu ag me t: 1 ta teplitfs
ud me t n h rt f h s li Srwb ig k s o r r u ns ( ) h t h an if
s
h v fie t p o et a t esae n sweema ei tefrtisn c ; 2 t a t epanif
a e ald o r v h t h ttme t r d n h is n tn e ( ) h t h litfs
h v fie t p o u ee ie c e tb ihigt a t sae nsaef le ( )ta tesae n s
a e ald o r d c vd n e sa ls n h the ttme t r as ; 3 h t h ttme t
aee p e so so o no a d()t the aep oe tdb aq aiidprvlg .Fo t e
r x rs in f piin; n 4 ha t y r r tce y u l e iie e r h
f
f l wi r s ,hec t s g e swih Sta i eon a 1f fo sa c l st tt
olo ng ea ons t our dia r e t rwbrdg
l our r nt nd onc ude ha he
cam mu tb d cd db aju
li s e e ie y ty.
To esa ih a ca m f de a ton t rVigi al w, hepl ntfsmus frts
t bls li or f ma i mde r ni a t ai if
t is how t t
ha
t def nda pu ihe a f s f c ua sa e ntt tco r a ha mst pl i if ort
he e nt bls d ale a t l t t me ha nce ns nd r he antfs he
plitfs rp tto .Hya dv. gh o Te h. r s Co.6 0S. 2 7 6 7 0( . 0 )
anif ' e u ai n ln Ra e n c Sev . , 7 E.d 4 , 5 Va 20 9 .
Thepli if m us a s s
antfs t lo how ç ha t de e ntkne t tt sae e wa f leor be ivi
ç t he f nda
t
w ha he t tm nt s a s , le ng
t tt sa e e wa t e,ac d ar as na eba i f rs h be if ora t d ne i nty i
ha he tt m nt s nl l ke e o bl ss o uc le , c e glge l n
fii t deemi t f t onwhiht publc tonwasba e ' J . Defmaor wor ar
alng o tr ne he acs
c he iai
s d. #=
'
a t y ds e
ac i bl pe K
tona e r
.
i te p eu ieap ro i hso h rta eo p o e so Fu t v. vesd
f h y rj dc es n n i r e r d r r fsin. se Ri ri e
He l c r As ' l c, 7 S. 2 8 8 8 ( . 0 3 .ç ea tr sae n sma icu e
at ae sm n .5 5 E.d 5 , 61 Va 2 0 ) r fmao y ttme t y n ld
h
saeme sm a by i e e ,i i ton,ori i ton. Hylnd,670 S. 2d a 750,F ea s
t t nt de nf r nce mplcai
nsnua i '
' a
E. t * ç l o
Se el v. elsFa co Ba N . . Ca eN o.7: 1 001 201 U . Di t LEXI 9376,a *1
w l W l r
nk. A , s
1 CV
24, 2 S. s .
S
t 7
( , Va. a 27, 2)(d den t ysae ntne dnotbema i die ttr i, n
W D. J n. 201 ç fmaor ttme e
A
de n rc ems fwhe
co i rng t s a e e ç s aw hol i l ng an i plca i ,i e e e ,ori i tonst t
ns de i he t t m nt a
e, nc udi
y m i tons nf r nc s
ns nua i ha
r a o byc u db d a fo t esae n ,i c risadea t r me s g .)( u tn
e s na l o l e r wn r m h ttme t't are
fmao y sa e' q oig
'
Hylnd,670 S. 2da 751.
a
E. t )
4
A.
Evi
dence oft A le d St e e s
he l ae at m nt
l mo n f rsl r j d me to t emeiso t epanif ' ea to cam,
n vig o l
mmay u g n n h rt f h litfs d fmai n li
Sta i fr ta g st tt pl ntfshavef ie t pr f rs tce e de et e t bls
r wbrdge is r ue ha he ai if
a ld o ofe ufi int vi nc o sa ih
t tt aleg y de a t y sae e t we em a aspl i t i co pl nt Cii t
ha he l edl f ma or t tm n s r de
ed n her m ai . tng he
Vig ni Supr m eCour' de ii n i Fed. ndBa o Batm o ev. r hfel 3 S. 2d 405
ri a
e
ts c so n
La
nk f li r Bic i d, E.
( .1 3 ) Srwb i g e h sz sta a(ufiin n be'o ted fmao ywo d mu tb
Va 9 9 , ta rd e mp a ie h t t fce t mn r f h e a t r r s s e
s
'
Gs t n i l pr n asaleg ' B ic i l 3 S. 2d a 41
tubs a taly ove
l ed. r hfe d, E. t 0.
'
I t rc pl i ,t pl i i f s cii a l a l d t tt c t ers r c
n hei om a nt he a ntf s pe fc ly lege ha he us om
e vi e
r pr s n a i t d La a t tt pli if çç r no r putbl a co d notbetuse a
e e e t tve ol pr de ha he antfs çwe e t e a e nd ul
r t d, nd
t n sg ts b d( ta ig )h dt g tiv le i alws i.'( mp . t 7)l rs o s
hig o o a S rwbrd e a o e n ov d n a ut' Co l a ! . n e p n e
'
t Sr wb ig ' moin frs mmayj d me t tep anif h v s b te ad caainfo
o ta rd es to o u r u g n,h litfs a e u mi d e lrto r m
t
La a t tde c i t sae e sma by t c t m e s r c r pr s t tves La a s
pr de ha s rbes he t tm nt de he uso r e vie e e en a i . pr de'
de c i i m i st ale tonsi t pl i if 'c
s rpton nor he lga i n he antfs ompli .Ac r i t t d l rto t
ant co d ng o he ec a ai n, he
r pr e ai sa e t tt pli if we eç r t bl 't tthe c d no betused, a
e es nt tve t t d ha he antfs r s epu a e,'ha i y oul t r t ' nd
not
t
'
t a çh n sg ts b d ( ta rd e h dt g tn o v di alws i. ( prd De la !6)
h t t i g o o a Sr wb i g ) a o e iv l e n a ut' La a e c. t .
t
'
W hie Sta i t kesi s wih t f c t tt de l ai is l,ac q ai m a ks
l r wbrdge a
s ue t he a t ha he car ton,t ef l ks uot ton r
a ound t a lge sa e nt , hec ti c nc d t tt pl i if 'e de e i s t intt
r
he le d tt me s t our s onvi e ha he antfs vi nc s ufk e o
s if t sanda d s tf t i Bic i d.
atsy he t r e orh n r hfel
B.
Trut or Fal i y
h
st
St a i ne a gue t tt pl i tf s ha f ie t pr f re de e w hi h w oul
r wbrdge xt r s ha he a n if ve a l d o of e vi nc
c
d
t nd t pr t f st oft s a e e si ques i
e o ove he aliy he t t m nt n
ton.Cii t de ii t tm ony ofis
tng he pos ton es i
t
pr i nt K e t St a b i ,a de a a i f om va i t r pa te ,St a i
es de , nne h r w r dge nd cl r tons r
r ous hid ri s r wbr dge
m ant i t tt pli if C enottu t t i ma ng pa nt o t i lga
i ans ha he antfs t
wer
r sworhy n ki
yme s n her e l
o lg to s'a dta tec u l ç i n te j yag o rp tto i teb sne sc mmt t .
b iain , n h th o pe t d o no o d e uain n h u i s o miy'
'
d
'
( .n S p o S mm. . t8) I r s o s ,h p anif h v p o fr dd ca ainsfo
Br i u p. f u J a . n e p n e t e litfs a e r fee e lrto r m
i vi s who ha ha pos tve e renc s wor ng w ih t m ,a w ho a e w ilng t a t t
ndi dual
ve d ii xpe i e
ki
t he nd
r li o tes
t t pl i if 't sworhi s a r pu ai n i t busne sco muniy.
o he antfs nlt t ne s nd e t to n he i s m
t
Unde Vigi alw,t is oft t apli ifha s fcintypr ve t f st of
r r ni a he s ue ç her antf s ufi e l o n he aliy
whe
t alg dd fmao ysae nsi aj r q e to . od nv. l n, 2 SE.d2 3 2 7
he le e e a t r ttme t s u y u sin' r a Ko l 61 . 2 0 , 0
'J
ma
( 2005) Viwi t e de i t lghtmos fvoa et t pl ntfs t c t
Va.
. e ng he vi nce n he i
t a rbl o he ai if ,he our
c udest tr as bl m i co d dif ra t whe he t s a e e t a l ge y m ade a
oncl
ha e ona e nds ul f e s o
t r he t t m n s le dl
bout
t pl n if we etu orf le.Ac or ngl t co ti c nvi e t tt is off liy mus
he aitfs r r e as
c di y, he ur s o nc d ha he s ue ast
t
b d cd db t j r .
e e ie y he u y2
C.
Fac or O pi on
t
ni
Fo i tida g me t Sr wb ig c n e d , si ddi isRul 1 ( )6 moi n t a
r t hr r u n , ta rd e o tn s a t i n t e 2 b ( ) to ,h t
s
t ale d sa e nt ar e es i ofopi on r t rt satm e soff c . Se W J TV
he l ge t t me s e xpr sons
ni ahe han t e nt
a t e LA-
v. v n 5 4S. 2 3 3 3 2 ( . 0 2 tTu ee r sinso o no 'wh c d no c n an
Le i , 6 E.d 8 , 9 Va 2 0 ) s r xp e so f piin, ih o t o ti
'
pr bl f le f cualc
ova y a s a t onnotto ,ç anno nor ly f m t ba i ofa a ton f
ai ns i
c
t mal or he ss n c i or
dea ton. Thi is t i t toffliy,prs salga quetont bede i db t
fmai '
). s sue,mlke ha ast eent e l si o
cde y he
c t H yl nd, S. 2d a 751 C n de e m i ng w he he a s a em e i f toropi on,a c t
our . a 670 E. t . t t r ni
l
t r t t nt s ac
ni
our
ma notiolt onepori oft sae nta is fom a t rpori oft sae nt' I
y
s ae
ton he ttme t sue r nohe ton he ttme . Z
'
I t d,t c tmus c i rt sa e nta awhol .'L.
nsea he our
t onsde he tt me s
e' d
u
x
2To t e entStawbri chalengest adm isi lt oft pl ntfs'e de on t is of
he xt
r
dge
l
he
s biiy he ai if vi nce he s ue
f siy,t cour i consr ned t concl t tsuch evi i y isuesar be t suied f
al t he
ts
tai o
ude ha
dentar s
e ter t or
det mi ton a t al
er na i t ri .
6
Appl ng t eprncpl ,t c ti t bl t c l de,a ama trofl w, ha t
yi hes i i es he our s ma e o onc u
s
te
a t t he
s a e e s a i s a e pur e es i ofo ni t tc nnotf m t ba i ofa a tona e
t t m nt t s ue r
e xpr sons pi on ha a
or he s s n c i bl
cli f de a ai Gi n t c nt xti whih t sae e swe emade a t f c t tt
am or f m ton. ve he o e n c he t tm nt r
, nd he a t ha he
c t me s r ierp e e tt a d dta 4h n sg t oba (ta rd e h dt g tivove
uso r e vc e r sn ai d e h t t i g o s d S rwb ig l a o e n l d
ve
t
i alw s t't c r r m ansc nc t tt al ge sae e sc d ber a ona y
n a ui 'he ou t e i onvi ed ha he le d t tm nt oul
e s bl
unde soodt i yt e se eofd a tr fcs Be a eillae nt clal i yi
rt o mpl he xitnc
efmaoy a t. c us tsttme s e ry mpl ng
t e senc off t a ea to easde a ton,'Swe e v.I Cor ,993 F. 1
he xit e acs r c i nabl
f ma i '
nglr TT
p.
2d 063,1
071
( t Ci.1 9 )t ec u tsu a l t c n ld t a Srwb ig i e tte t sl r u g n
4h r 9 3 ,h o r i n be o o cu e h t ta rd e s n i d o l
l
mma yj d me t
on t sgr
hi ound. Se as PBM Pr .LLC v. ea J ms Nutii n Co. 678F.Supp. 39
e lo
ods.
M d ol on rto
,
2d 0,
401( D.Va 2009)( tngt ta opi o ma c tt ea tona edefmai i ic be
E. .
noi ha n nin y onsiut ci bl a ton ft an
ras bl i eprtdt de lr ori yunt efcs.
e ona y ntr ee o cae mpl nz a t)
D.
Oualfe Prvie
iid i lge
Fo isfna a g ntwih r s c t t me isoft de a ai cl m ,Sta i
r t i l r ume
t e pe t o he rt he f m ton ai
r wbrdge
a s rsta tecam i s j c t aq aiidp i lg .Un e ti c mmo lw d f n e E
s et h t h li s ube t o u lfe rvi e d r h s o n a ee s ,ç
e
a
c mmu iai n ma ei g o f i , nas be tmatri whc tep ro c mmu iaigha
o nc to , d n o d at o u j c te n ih h es n o n c tn s
h
a i e e t o o e a dut l l m or l ors i l i qua ii dl prvie d i m a t a pe s
n nt r s , r w s
y, ega , a , oc a , s lfe y i l ge f de o
r on
ha ng a c r s
vi
or e pondi i e e tordut ' Gr tCoa t lExp e s l v. lng on,3 S. 2d
ng nt r s
y. ea
'
sa
r s - nc. Eli t
34 E.
8 6 8 3( .1 8 ) hl tep i lg i o tndsuse i c n e to wihsae n sr ltd
4 , 5 Va 9 5 .W ie h rvi e s fe ic s d n o n cin t ttme t eae
e
t e pl
o m oyme ma tr ,i hasalobee a id i ot rc r lm sa e i whih bot pa test a
nt te s t
s
n pple n he icl tnc s n c
h ri o
c mmt c to h da itrs i t s b e t t r S e eg, he k mpv Lo d nCo ny
o miain a n ne et n he u j c mat . e , ..Ec tn a . u o u t
e
Pub.Sc .263F.Supp. 1 1 ( D. 2003)( ani t tçheprvie a is
hs,
2d 043, 061 E. Va.
expli ng ha t i lge pple
t
br dl t alsae e sr l t t ç mpl
oa y o l t tm nt e aed o e oyme m a tr , pr ded t pa te t t
nt te s' ovi he ris o he
c mmt c to h v ad t o itr s i t es b e t te'; e n v. c e, s No 9 o miai n a e u y r nee tn h u j c matr) Gre e Zu k r Ca e . 7
2406,1 U. App.
998 S.
LEXI 221 a * ( hCi.Se .9,1 )( di t ta i vi ls
S 02, t 4 4t r pt 998 hol ng ha n ndi dua'
c m t i a i t t Sec e a y oft N a waspr ec e by a qua ii d prviege whe et
om m c ton o he r t r
he vy
ot t d
lfe i l , r he
c mmt c to d s rb dia p o raeb h v o b aNa yo fc ru frp o to ) An r ws
o miai n e cie n p r p it e a ir y v fie p o r moi n ; d e
v. . inUnv.Ca eNo 3:7 v 4 , 0 8U.. s. S 4 0 , t# 3( D. . a
Va Uno i , s . 0 c 4 7 2 0 S DitLEXI 0 01 a 3 E. Va M y
1 , 0 8 ( oi t a t ec ar ma o au iest d p rme t a a itr s i tes b e t
5 2 0 ) n tng h t h h iwo n f nv ri e a t n h d n nee t n h u j c
y
m a trofhe a lge y defm aor saeme , ndt tt loft pa teswho wer prvy t t
te
r le dl a t y t t nt a ha d
al he ri
e i o he
c mme t, icudn su e t, d nsrtr, n p rn s as i a a itrs i tes b e t
o n s' n l ig t d ns a mi itao s a d ae t, lo û d n ne et n h u j c
'
h
matr) A s o n o maiei ne e sr t o ec meteq aiidp iie e Lai r v.
te '. h wig f lc s c say o v r o h u l e rvlg . rmo e
f
Bly o k 5 8S. 2 1 9 1 ( . 0 0 .
a lc , 2 E.d 1 , 21 Va 2 0 )
Ha ng r vi wedt e de ei t i tntc s ,t co ti una et c l t tt
vi e e
he vi nc n he nsa a e he ur s bl o onc ude ha he
saeme salege y ma b t c t rs r cer pr e t tvea epr e t d b t qua ii
t t nt l dl de y he usome e vi e es n a i r ot c e y he lfed
prvie Fort prvie t a y,Sta i mus s
i lge.
he i l ge o ppl r wbrdge t how t tbot isr pr s nttvea
ha h t e e e a i nd
La a eh dc re p n igd te o itrssi tes be tmatr S eS ae v Lo mi
prd a o rs o dn uis r nee t n h u jc te . e u r z . o s
Ar rdUS.
mo e
LLC, s No. 1 BCVB6 0 20 0U. Dit LEXI 1 9 5 a * - ( D. .
Cae 3:0
9 , 1 S. s. S 2 33 , t 8 9 E. Va
De . , 01 )( od n t a t ed fn a tfi dt s o t a t eq ai e p i lg p oe tda
c 7 2 0 h li g h t h ee d n al o h w h t h u lt d rvie e rtce
e
i
s a em e m adet a W a gr e e pl ee r ga di t t r i ton ofone oft de e nt s
t t nt
o
l e ns m oy e r ng he e m na i
he f nda '
amo e tu kd ie s wh r t eewa n i dc to ta t es be t te rltdt ted te
r r d r c rv r , ee h r s o n iain h t h u j c matr eae o h u is
oft W agee e oye ) W hieSta i mant nst tisrprs nai ha a
he lr ns mpl e . l r wbrdge i ai ha t e e e ttves ve
l gii a e i e es i pr ry s r i i a po e i lc t e ,St a i ha f ied t es a i h
e tm t nt r t n ope l e v c ng
t nta usom r r wbr dge s a l o t bls
t tLa a ha a c r s
ha pr de d ny ore pondi i e e ti l m i a
ng ntr s n ea ng boutSta i sf ie busne s
r wbrdge' al d i s
r a i hi w ih t pl i if . l ee a La ad e phasze i he de a a i
el tons p t he a ntf s nd d, s pr e m
i s n r cl r ton:
ldi notund sa why t sc t e s r i er pr e atve wass yi
d
ert nd
hi usom r e v c e es nt i
a ng
t s t ngst m e whe Iw a sm pl t y ng t o a n a phot ofm y
he e hi o , n
s i y r i o bt i
o
d u h e, n al ne d dhm t tlmewa y s t y ( ta rd e c ud
a g tr a d 1 l e e i o el
s e ,he Sr wb i g l o l
ge m et pho o,orno,t y c d notge met phot lhad no i e e t
t he t
he oul
t he
o.
ntr s
i hea i t s ba kbii c
n rng he e c tng omme s
nt .
( prd De la !7. Fo t e era o s b s do tec re t e o d t ec u tst bet
La a e c. t ) r h s e s n , a e n h u rn rc r ,h o r i ma l o
c ude, am at roflw,t tt sa e t a is a epr e t d by t q ii d prvie
oncl as
te
a ha he tt men s t s ue r otc e
he ualfe i lge.
Ac o dngy, ta rd ei n te tt dt s mmayj d me t nt meiso tepanif'
c r i l Sr wb i g s o n ie o u r u g n o he rt f h litfs
l
de a a i c am .
f m ton l i 3
Il.
Breach ofCont
ract
S rwb ig h sas mo e f rsl r j d me t nteplitfs cam f rb e c o
ta rd e a lo v d o l
mmay u g n o h an if' li o ra h f
c r c .To s
onta t
uppo t hi c am , hepl n if a lget tt sa e nt m a by Sta i s
r t s l i t aitfs le ha he tt me s de
r wbrdge'
c t e s r c r pr s nttvewe ei die tvi a i oft 201 s te
usom r e vie e e e a i
r n r c olton he 0 etlmenta e m e ,
gr e nt
purua t whi h t pl i if a Sta i ee e sy a e d t r fan fom s yi a hi
s nt o c he antfs nd r wbrdg xpr s l gr e o er i r a ng nyt ng
ne tveordipar gi a
ga i
s a ng boutt o he .
he t r
3Srwbrd ha as mo e frs
ta ige s lo v d o ummayj g nto t pl nif'rq s frp nii
r ud me n he aitfs e uet o u tve
dam agesas oci ed wih t rdef i cl m . Alhough Stawbrdger
s at
t hei amaton ai
t
r
i ecogni t ta cor aton
zes ha
por i
may be labl f c
i e or ompensa or da agesf def m a or sat
t y m
or a t y t ement made by an agenti t cour e a
s
n he
s nd
s
cope oft agent' e pl e ,Stawbrdgeemphasiest a cor a i cannotbe labl f punii
he
s m oym nt r
i
z hat
por ton
i e or
tve
dam a unl s i aut ied ors equenty r ii t agentsconduct SeeOber oecklnM v.Lvl
ges es t horz
ubs
l atfed he
'
.
br
i
e,
3 S. 2d68 68 ( 1 7) Addiinal S rwb i ee h%ie t a t r c vey o pu tve
62 E. 2, 7 Va. 98 . to l ta rdg mp z s h t he e o r f nii
y,
dam a i a def a i cas r r t pl ntfst pr ac ualmalce by cl rand c nci
ges n
am ton e equies he ai if o ove t
i
ea
onvi ng
e de e Gov' M ir Re .l c v. a ks ,6 4 S. 2d6 ,70( .2 6)
vi nc .
t co s. n . J c on 2 E. 3 Va 00 .
A st cour not durng t hearng on Stawbri smoton,and,bas on t f ual
he
t ed i he
i
r
dge'
i
ed
he act
cicums a
r
t ncesi ii by t pl ntfsa t tme ofor a gument t cour doesnotbeleve t tt
dentfed he ai if t he i
al r
, he
t
i ha he
pl ntf shave f ecas s fci evi
ai if
or t ufi ent dencet war a t s i i ofapunii damagesques i t
o r nt he ubm sson
tve
ton o
t ej y.Th ,b s d o t c re rc d,hec r i o teo nint tt ep tved ma scam
h ur us a e n he u rnt e or t ou t s f h pi o ha h unii a ge li
c
annotgo f war
or d.
9
Unde Vigi alw,t e s nta elm e sofa c us ofaci f rbr a h ofco r tar
r r ni a he s e il e nt
a e
ton o e c
ntac e
()alg l biaino ted fn a t otep anif; 2 av oain o b e c o t to lg to
1 e a o l to f h ee d n t h litfs ( ) i lto r r a h f ha b iain;
g
a d( )c n e u n il nu yo d ma et t epanif.Ha e v. y s 6 S. 2 1 5 1 7
n 3 o s q e ta ij r r a g o h litfs mlt Ha e , 41 E.d 1 , 1
( . 00 ) Pr o o d ma ei a ç s e ta ee n 'o acam f rb e c o c nrc, n
Va 2 7 . o f f a g s n ç s nil lme t f li o ra h f o ta t a d
e
'
i a lte t pr t te e e w a r nt di m i s loft c a m .' Su i e Co i ng Ca e LLC v.
l itr o ove ha l m nt r a s s s a
f
he l i ' nrs ntnui
r.
W rg t6 S. 2 1 2 1 6( . 0 9 (nen lctto a dq o ainmak o te ) l
ih, 71 E.d 3 , 3 Va 2 0 ) itr a i in n u tto r s mi d . n
a
t
addii t pli if ha thebur n ofpr ngwih r s bl c rant t a o of
ton, he antfs ve û
t
de
ovi
t ea ona e e ti y he m unt
d ma e a t ec us fo wh c t e rs td; p c ai na c ne tlec r tf r te
a g s nd h a e r m ih h y eul s e ulto nd o j ct amo o m h
e
r
bassoft r c y. l t age r lr l ,da esf br a h ofco r c sa elm iedt t
i
he e over ' d. (
'
As ne a u e mag or e c
nta t r i t o he
pe ni r l s s t ne ' I
cu a y os us ai d. d.
'
I mo i f rs mmayj d me twi r s e t otep an if' ra ho c nr c cam,
n vng o u r u g n t e p c t h litfs b e c f o ta t li
h
Sta i c le st s tcinc oft e d ewih r s c t t ee e of
r wbrdge ha lnge he ufi e y he vi enc t e pe t o he lm nt
c ns q e ta ij r o d ma e Al o g tepanif manant a t ealg db e c h s
o e u n iln u y r a g . t u h h litfs it i h t h le e r a h a
h
r ule i l tbusne so
es t d n os i s pporunii ,Sta i c e t tt e de pr f r d byt
t tes r wbrdge ont nds ha he vi nce ofe e
he
pl i if dem ons r t st ts h l s s a e pur l s ul tve a cn
a ntf s
t a e ha uc os e r
e y pec a i nd nnotbe es a i he w ih
t bls d t
r ao a ec rany Br i S p o M o. o Sl J a 2 .
e s n bl e tit .( .n u p. f t f r l
mm. . t 3)
Viwi t e denc i t lg m os f vo a et t pl ntfs howe r t c ti
e ng he vi e n he i ht t a r bl o he ai if,
ve , he our s
u a l t c ncu et a Sr wb i g i e tte t s mmayj d me to ti g o n .Aste
n b e o o ld h t ta rd e s nild o u r u g n n h s r u d
h
c tnotd dlrng t he rng ont i tntmoto t pli tfsma bee il d t a a r of
our e zi he a i
he nsa
i n,he a n if y
ntte o n wa d
nomi lda a si t e ntt tt y a et bl t e t bls a t lco pe a o y da a swih
na m ge n he ve ha he r ma e o sa ih c ua m ns t r m ge t
ras bl c rant Se Crs v.Mer M org. ndanc.343S. 2d308,311( 1 )
e ona e e ti y. e it
to. t Fu l ,
E.
Va. 986
(fimi t a r ofnomi da gesi abr c ofc rc a tonwheec
afr ng he wa d
nal ma n ea h onta t ci
r ompenst y
aor
10
d ma e weeno etbl h dwi ra o a l c rany .Co rsh verc g ie ta n mi l
a g s r t sa i e t e s n be etit) u t a e o n z d h t o na
s
h
da
mage ,i a opra ecic sa e , n bes fce t s tsyt dn a e e tofaprm a
s n ppr it r um tnc s ca
ufi int o aif he m ge l men
i
f c ec ef br ac ofc r tt rVigi a lw.Se M imes aLa r M ut l . v.
a i as or e h ontac mde r ni a
e r ot wve s
. ns Co.
Bazi4 2F. p' 4 , - 3(t Ci. 01 )( odn t t o n l a g swees fi in t
tl, 4 Ap x 0 515 4 h r 2 1 h lig ha n mi a d ma e r u tce t o
stsyt ed ma eee n wh r tep an ifs fee a a ta ls o ij yb t su a l t
aif h a g lme t e e h litf u frd n cu l o s r nur u wa n b e o
p o et ea u t fd ma e ) W e tl Is lto . v. o r , 6F. p' 2 , 9 - 9
r v h mo n o n g s; se' n uain LP M o e 31 Ap x 91 2 7 2 9
n
(t Ci. 0 9 ( od n t a t epanifsfi r t p o ec mp nstr d ma e ddn t
4 h r 2 0 ) h li g h t h litf al e o rv o e ao y a g s i o
u
pr cl t pl ntf fom e t bls ng a 1oft ne es a y el m e s f ra br c ofc r c
e ude he ai i f r
s a ihi 1 he c s r e nt o
ea h
ont a t
cli unde Vigi alw)
am
r r ni a .
W hiet e de em a uli ael e t bls t tt pl ntfss f r d no c e ntal
l he vi nc
y tm t y sa ih ha he ai if ufe e
ons que i
ij r o da g o a yknda d tu ,h th yaen te tte t p e al nter r a ho
n u y r ma e f n i n ,h s t a te r o nild o rv i o h i b e c f
c r c cai ,he c t sc nc d t tt r o d i s fc e tt pe mi t scai t pr e d
onta t l m t our i onvi e ha he ec r s uf i n o r t hi l m o oc e
t til Ac o dn l,h d fn a t' to frs mmayj d me twi as b d n e wih
o ra. c r igy te e e d n s mo in o u r u g n l lo e e id t
l
r s c t t pl i i f 'cl i f rbr ac ofc t a t
e pe t o he a ntf s a m o e h
on r c .
C onc us on
l i
Fo t era o sae , ta rd e smoinfrs mmayj d me t nt me iso t e
r h e s ns ttd S rwb i g ' to o u r u g n o he rt f h
pl n if 'cli swilbede e The Cl r i die t t s nd c riid co e oft s
aitfs am
l
nid,
e k s r ced o e e tfe pi s hi
memor ndlm opi on a t a co nyi o de t alcot e ofr or
a l
ni nd he c mpa ng r r o 1 ms l ec d.
ENTER: i 9 d yo Ma , 01 .
Ths
a f y2 2
ChifUnied St t DititJ
e
t
aes src udge
11
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?