Makdessi v. Fields et al
Filing
204
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief United States District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 1/24/2017. (tvt)
Fnl
Fpœ: OFFI u. DI COUW
CE S. ST.
.
ATROANOKQ,
VA
FI ED
L
J 2ù 2 1
AN
27
I T I E U NI
N I
TED STA TES DI
STR I T C O UR T
C
FO R TH E W ESTE RN DI
STRICT O F W R G I I
N A
R OA N O K E D I SI N
W O
A DI ED DI M M EZ M AK D ESSI
B
E
,
JUUA .
gY;
, LE
'
C A SE N O .7:
11CV 00 2
26
Pl ntf ,
ai if
V.
M E M O M N D U M O PI I N
N O
( p i Re r a Re o nda in)
Ado tng po t nd c mme to
LT. ELDS, AL.
FI
c
,
By: G l n E.C onr
e
ad
C hi fU nie St e Di t c Judge
e
t d at s s ri t
Dee
f ndant .
s
Thi pds r cvi rg sa ton tld purua t 42 U. C.j 1 cli t tt e
s one i l iht ci ie
s nt o
S.
983 ams ha hre
s pe v s y prs ofi i l f ie t pr e tt pli iffo s xua a physca a s ulsby li
u r ior ion fc a s a ld o ot c he antf ' m e l nd
r
i l sa t
ls
celma e i vi a i o hi Ei ht Ame e rg s Thepa te pr e e t i e de e i a
l t , n olton f s g h
ndm nt i ht .
ris es nt d her vi nc n
b nc til a d t e c s i p e e ty b f r t c u to t erpo ta d r c mme d to (t e
e h ra, n h a e s rs nl eo e he o r n h e r n e o n ain Gh
t
rp l ) o Ma itae J d e Pn l M e d S r e t pls a tt 28 U. C.j6 6b ( )B)
e of' f gsrt u g mea a e a g n, t u n o
r
S.
3 () 1( ,
r c mme dn j d me tf rt e d fn a t. Afe X no rv e o t e e ie e fr te
e o n ig u g n o h ee d n s tr
vo e iw f h vd nc , o h
ra o t tf lo t c u twi o mzet plitY so jcins a o tt erp r,a d e tr
e s ns ha olw, he o r l ve l he an i be t , d p h e o t n ne
l
o
j g n frt ed fn a t, . ed , gtKig, ndCa t Gal r
ud me t o h e e d n s Lt Fil s S . n a
p . li .
ha
Bac ound
ker
The pli tf ,Adi Eddi Rn e M a
a n if
b
e m z kdes i wa i a c r t d a W al ns Ri St t
s s nc r e a e t le
dge a e
.
Prs n(G aln Ri g ' a t etmeh sj1 3camsao elM a d si sp e e tdc p e o
io E le s d e' t h i i 98 li r s . k e s ha r s n e o is f
W
)
num e ous a m i sr tve c
r
d nitai ompl i s he fl d, be nni i 2007, cai ng vul r biiy t
ant
ie
gi ng n
l mi
ne a lt o
phys c l a t ks f om ot r i a es a a l gi t t he ha be n t vi tm of pror s xual
i a tac r
he nm t nd le ng ha
d e he c i
i e
a s ulsf o celma e . He hasas t sii d t the madewrte a ve ba c
sa t ' m l ts
r
lo e tfe ha
itn nd r l ompli sa ut
ant bo
fai ij r fo M ih e S t ,whob c meh sc l maei e ry Au u t2 0 . M a d si
e rng nu y r m c a l mih
e n i el t n al g s 0 6
k es
1 Theco tofesonl abre s
ur f r y if ummay ofe she et pr vi co ex f rdic son oft is s
r
vent r o o de nt t o s us i
he s ue .
has t tfed t ton De embe 21 201 Sm ih physca l a s xua l a s uled hi ove a
esii ha
c
r , 0, t
i ly nd e ly s a t
m
r
t e - l pe i i i t i c l . V i o f ag a ot re de e i c t st twhen of i e s
hr e hotr r od ns de he r e l de oot e nd he vi nc ndi a e ha
fc r
t oc d t c l doo f r i r m o lofl
ml ke he e l r or outne e va
unch ta a tas abl e M a s ir n out
r ys nd r h, oodid kde s a
o t c lwihS t i p rut oc n iu li a su tj ie b o h rimae i t p d.Afe
f he el t mih n u s it o tn e l sa l,on d y t e n ts n he o
s
tr
a wn ni s tf o t c r b00t Smih a t s o he i ae i e ae y f lt t
r ng ho r m he ontol
h, t nd he e t r nm t s mm di tl el o he
gr md,a M a s ir n i o t ve tbul . Of e st M a s it t m e ca uni,whe e
ot
nd kde s a nt he si e
fc r ook kde s o he di l t
r
her c i d sic t cos t c son li f cea t nv ntx-ays Ofi r a s ta po td
e e ve tt hes o l e wo ut
ls a nd mde e
r . fce s lo r ns re
hm t a o tieh s ia f raPh sc l ie c Re o eyKi (TERK' ts.Sx we k ltr
i o n usd o pt l o
y ia Evd n e c v r t C
' e t i e s ae ,
)
M a s wa ta f redt apr t c i c t uni a a t rprs f iiy.
kdes i s r nse r o
o e tve usody t t no he ion aclt
M a s' pr â j 1 c ant alege t t s veal W ale Ri of r
kdesis o : 983 ompli l d ha e r
lns dge fces
or hesr t d a o f ie t pr e thi f o Smih' a t k orf ie t i e v ne pr
c ta e nd/ r al d o ot c m r m
t s tac
a ld o nt r e
ompty onc
l
e
t t a c b g n. Th c u d nid s mmay j d me t a t M a d sis cams a ans
ha ûa k e a
e o d e e u r u g n s o k e s' li g i t
De e nt Ga lha ,Fil ,Ki St t r Boyd,Be lmy,a Hal a r f n'd t m a trt
f nda s li r e ds ng, mp e ,
la
nd l, nd e e e he te o
J d e S r e tf ra p o rae p o e dn s t e j6 6b)1( . S o t t ee fe ,c u e
u g a g n o p r p it r c e i g md r 3 ( ( )B) h rl h ra tr o nsl
y
e e ed a a
nt r n ppea a t r pr s ntM a s .
r nce o e e e
kdes i
J
udge Sa ge c
r nt onduc e a e de ir he rng on M a c 1 1 201 a is d he
t d n vi nta y a i
r h 2- 4, 3, nd s ue r
frtrpo ta d rc mme ain i t e c s o M a 3 2 3 r c mme dn j d me tf rt
is e r n e o nd to n h a e n y , 01 , e o n ig u g n o he
d fn a t. M a d sifldo j ci n .Afe c n u tn aX n v r ve o pet n pa t o
ee d n s k e s ie b e to s tr o d cig
o o e iw f ri t rs f
ne
t erpo ta d t e d n e te c u t v m z dt eo j cin ,a o td ter p r,a d g a td
h e r n he vie c , h o r o e l h b e to s d pe h e o t n rn e
e
j d me tt d fnd ns M a e s a p ae Th Uni dS ae Co r o Ap asfrt Fo t
u g n o ee a t. kd si p e ld. e t tts u t f pe l o he urh
e
Cic i afr d t ej d me ti paq b trv re a d r ma d d te c s a t M a d sis
rut fime h u g n n r u e e s d n e n e h a e s o k e s'
c ai s aga ns Fi l ,K i a G a lha . Se M a s iv. e ds N o.7: CV 00262,201 W L
lm
i t e ds ng, nd li r e kde s Fi l ,
11
3
5353330( . Va.Se . 201 ,rv' L pa t. 789F. 1 136( h Ci. 5)
W D.
pt24, 3) e d q r h.
y
3d 26, 4t r 201 .
2
I
The ' ri s pr e e a tonal e de e a a gtme bef e J
pa te es nt d ddii
vi nc nd r l nt or udge Sa ge i
r nt n
I
t
Nove r201 butot r s agr e t r y o t e de e pr e e dtrng t M a ch 201
mbe r 5,
he wi e e d o el n he vi nc es nt d ti he r
3
p o e dng . J d eSag n ha n w e tr dh rsc ndrpo t e o n i j g n f rte
r c e i s u g r e t s o n ee e e o e r r c mme dng ud me t o h
d fn a t.l a e s h sfld wrte o j cin t po t nso t erp r t tt ec u tmus
ee d n s M kd si a ie itn b e to s o ri f h e o t ha h o r t
o
now r s ve.
e ol .
St
andar ofR e e
ds
vi w
I aci lc e, hepl ntf c ri st bur n ofpr ng e h oft e e nt ofl sc am
n vi as t ai if a re he de
ovi ac
he l me s a l i
i
by a pr ponda c o t e d n e l r W is i ,2 7 U. 3 8 3 ( 9 0 . çl e bld n o
e , n e f he vie c . n e n h p 9 S. 5 , 71 1 7 ) t' t e f
-h r
s
howi s ehi by a pr ponder nc oft e de ...r quiest tiroff tt bei ve
ng om t ng
e
a e he vi nce
e r he re
ac o le
t t e se e ofa f ti mor pr bl t n isnone se e. Co r t Pi & Pr .o
hat he xitnc
ac s
e oba e ha t
xit nc ' nc ee pe
'
ods f
Ca. I .v , nsr Ea o esPe in Tnltf rS.Ca. 5 8 U. 6 2,6 2 ( 9 3 ( u tto
1 nc .co t. b rr nso
.
s o ' 1, 0 S. 0 2 1 9 ) q o ain
mak o te ) s e as M c a v. l e S ae ,6 9 F.d 1 0 ( t Ci.1 2 (f mig a
r s mitd ; e lo Ne l Uztd tts 8 2 2 2 4h r 98 ) afr n
i
fndn f rted fn a twheet e i e c wa i e up ie .
i ig o h ee d n
r he v d n e s n q io s)
t
Thema itaej d esrp r t e j6 6 b ( )B)ma e o l ar c mme d to t t i
gsrt u g ' e o tmd r 3 ( )1(
k s ny e o n ain o hs
c u t Maàe v.we e ,4 3 u. 2 ,27 - ( 9 6 . Gln t e a s n e o a t l fld
o r. t ws
b r 2 s. 61 0 71 1 7 ) l l h b e c f i y ie
l
me
o j cin ad src c u t e dn tc n u ta. n v r ve b tise dmus o l stsy isl
b e to , itit o r n e o o d c # o o e iw, u n ta
q
t ny aif tef
t tt r i no c e r e r r on t f ce oft r c d i or rt a e t r c me ton.
ha he e s
la ro
he a
he e or n de o cc pt he e om nda i '
'
Dimo d v.Coo a Lie & Ac ie tl s Co. 41 F.d 31 ,31 (t Ci.2 0 )(n e l
n n ' lnil f
cd n n . , 6 3 0 5 4h r 0 5 itma
q o ain mak o te ) Fe R.Ci. 7 I c nr s,hec u t sc a g dwi ma ig aX
u tto r s mitd ; d.
v P. 2. n o ta t t o r i h r e t kn
h
no deer nain of a porins o t magitae j e' rc
vo t mi to
ny to f he
srt udg s e omme ato t whih a
nd in o c
s e ii o jpi n i ma e 2 U. C.j 6 6b ()C) Al ug t e d src c u tma gv a
p cfc bé to s d . 8 S.
3 () 1( . t h h itit o r y ie
ho
ma itae j d es p o o e fn ig a d r c mme d to s G u h weg t a gh i) mei
g srt u g ' r p s d i dn s n e o n ain t c
s
ih s t er rt
c mma d a dtes u dd s rto o tej d ewarn s'tea to iya t er s o sb l yt
o n s n h o n icein f h u g ra t, h uh rt nd h e p n iii o
'
t
ma ea if r dfn ld tr n to rman wi t d src j g .Untd S ae v. d az
k n n o me ia ee miain e is t he itit ud e ie tts Ra d t,
h
4 7 U. 6 7 68 - 3 (98 ) (nena q tto mak a ctto o te ) Th r fr ,i
4 S. 6 , 2 8 1 0 itr l uoain r s nd iain mitd . e eo e n
pef r ng aX no rviw,t d src j d e mus e rie ç i no d lg be a t o iy b
ro mi
vo e e he itit u g
t xecs û s n- ee a l u h rt y
h
c i rng t a t l t si o a not m e el by r vi wi t magita e' r por a
onsde i he c ua e tm ny, nd
r y
e e ng he
sr t s e t nd
rc mme d to s' W i rv. o , 7 F.d6 , 6( t Ci.1 8 )(iain o te )
e o n ain . mme Co k 7 4 2 8 7 4h r 9 5 ctto mitd .
'
D i c s on
s us i
Am o d i t Ei ht Ame e ' pr bii a i tc e a unus lpt s nt
ng utes he g h
ndm nts ohi ton gans nzl nd
ua mihme
i osso p io o fcasi a û bi alo )t tkera o a eme sle t g a a teimae
mp e n rs n fiil s n ç lg ti n o a e s n bl a t s o u rne n t
o
r
s ey,' s cii ly, tto pr e t prs r fom vi e e a t ha
af t ' pe tcal Gt ot c ione s r
olnc t he nds of o he prs r .'
t r ione s''
M a d si 78 F.da 1 2 (u tn Fn me v. e n n, 1U. 8 5 8 3 ( 9 4). A p io e
k e s, 9 3 t 3 q o ig r r Br n a 51 S. 2 , 3 1 9 )
rs n r
al gi t tprs ofi i s ha f ie t ke p hi r as bl s f fom o he i ae m us
le ng ha ion fcal ve a ld o e m e ona y a e r
t r nm t s
t
s o t t( o j ci l, h p io e wa ic r eae u d rc n iinsp sn as sa ta rs
h w ha i be tvey t e rs n r s n a c rtd n e o dto o ig ub tnil ik
)
o s ro sh r a d (i s b e tv l, h o fca mu th veh d aG s fi in l c l besaeo
f eiu a m, n i) u j ci ey t e fiil s a a t u tce ty upa l tt f
t
m i t be he d la e,' me y,t sa e ofiG lbe a ei if r nce'' o t s tntalrs of
nd' o
l i bl 'nn l he tt
tdei r t nd fe e 't he ubsa i ik
sro shnm.I a 1 3( u t F nne , 1U. a 8 4 .
e iu r d. t 3 q oi p r 51 S. t 3 )
ng
The r po t r co me
e r e m nds a fndi of f c and c uson of 1 w t t M akde s has
i ng
at
oncl i
a ha
si
stsid tesrt o j ci ee n o ti sa d r b d mo sr tn t a h wa a s utd o
aife h s, be t lme t f h s tn ad y e n tai g h t e s sa le n
ve
De e r21 2 0 a d s fe e s ro p ysc lij is ( po t1 ,21 ECF 201) I t e
c mbe , 01 , n u fr d eius h ia nure . Re r 0 ,
. nh
a s n eo a yo j cinfo t ep ris a fn ign ce rer r tec u t d psti po t n
b e c f n b e to r m h a t , nd i dn o la ro ,h o r a o t h s ri
e
o
oft r por.
he e t
Pr ng de i r t i fe e e r quie s
ovi
lbe a e ndif r nc e r s howi Cl e t n or nar l k of d c e
ng ûmor ha di y ac
ue ar
f r t prs rs i e ess or s ey, a G e t n m e e neg i nc , b tes t n a t or
o he ione ' nt r t
af t ' nd mor ha
r
lge e ' ut l s ha c s
omiso g )f t veypu pos ofca i ham o wihknowldget tha m wilr ul.'
sins done or he r r e
usng r r t
e ha r l es t''
4
l .(u tn Fn e , 1U. a 1 ) EAl o t a ' fi r t alvaeasg iia trs t t
d q o ig nn r 51 S. t 35 . t n fkils al e o le it infc n ik ha
g
u
hes dha pecevedbutdi no,...c nnot( nsiue i lcin ofpt s nt' Fa me,
houl ve r i
d t
n
co tttj nfito
mihme . r r
'
511U. a 838. S c fc ly,G he of i lm us bot bea r off f o whih t i e e e
S. t
pe ii a l G
t
fc a
t h
wa e ads r m
c he nf r nc
c d be dr wn t t a s t nta rs of s rous ha m e s s a he mus a s dr w t
oul
a
ha
ubsa i l ik
ei
r xit, nd
t lo a he
i e e e. I a 837. The ef r , 1 pr s of i i m a be hel la e unde t Ei h
nf r nc ' d. t
'
r o e G i on f c al y
a
d i bl
r he ght
Am e e f de ng hlma c tonsofc
ndm nt or nyi
l ne ondii
onfne e onl i he knowst ti esf c a
m nt y f
ha nmat a e
s t nta rs ofs roushn a dir ga dst trs by f ii t tker as
ubsa i l ik
ei
nn nd s e r ha ik
alng o a e onabl me ur st
e as e o
a t i.'l a 847.
ba e t' d. t
A p io o fca ' s be t a ta k wld e c n b p o e t r u h
rs n fiils u j ci cu l no e g a e r v n h o g
ve
cr umsa ile de s
ic tnta vi nce howi f re mpl t tt Es tntalrs ofi t
ng, o xn e, ha he ûubsa i ik nma e
a tc was l t ndi per a i weldoc nt d, o e es l not d by
ta ks
ongsa ng, v sve, l- ume e r xpr sy
e
prs ofi i l i t pas,a t c r umsa es s
ion fc as n he t nd he ic tnc ugges t t t de e nt
t ha he f nda ofi a bei s had bee expos d t i or ton c
fcil ng ued
n
e o nf mai once ni t rs a t
r ng he ik nd hus
G tha kno a uti. Fa me.511U. a 842,11 S. .1 ( ai
mus ve wn' bo t' r r
'
S. t
4 Ct 970 quotton
makso te ) Die te i e eo a t a k o e g i no r q ie S eL.a '
r mitd . r c v d nc f cu l n wld e s t e u rd. e l t
a
8 43,11 S.Ct 1
424
. 970.
Ac or ngl prs o fc as ma notsmpl bur t i hea i t s nd
c di y, ion fi i l y
i y y her ds n he a
a d t r b s itl bit .t F v n a g ad a l t p o t a h wa i fc
n hee y kr i l y û l e
a i g
u r b e o r ve h t e s n a t
o lvo st a o vo sij r o s f in sro s s ma n te c p la iiyi
bi iu o n b iu n u y f u fce t ei u ne s y o s a e ib l f
t
ii s
t s hown,f e
or xnmpl t the me el r us t ve iy û ryi f c st the
e, ha
r y ef ed o rf unde l ng a t ha
sr y s pe e t betue ''o t the l de lned t c im i e e esofrs
tongl us ctd o r ,' r ha
t c i o onfr nf r nc
t
ik
t he sr ngl s pecedt e s ' Bri g Vi i aBe c Co r Ct..58 F.
hat to y us t o xit'' i e v. m ni a h r . rl
3d
(01)a 1 5 (4 h Ci.1 9 ) (uoi Fa c 51 U. a 8 n.8 1 4 S. .
1 , t 0 (t r 9 5 ) q tng nne 1 j. t 43 , 1 Ct
1 7 ) An çtd e n tmatrwh t e t rs c me fo a snge s t c o
9 0 . d û o s o te eh r he ik o s r m i l ol e r
i
r
m uli e s c ,a m o e t n i m a t r w he he a pr s r f es a exc s ve
tpl our es ny r ha t t e s
t r
i one ac n
es i
rs ofa tc f r a onspe s nalt hi orbe us a1pds ne si hi st to
ik
ta k or e s
ro o m
ca e l
o r n s iuai n
f ce s h ars ' Fam e ,511U. a 8 11 S.Ct 1
a uc
ik. r r
'
S. t 43, 4
. 970. Nori i dipostve
s t s ii
t tt prs rdi notgi a ncewn ni oft ds orpr e thi e
ha he ione d
ve dva
r ng he k
ot s s xpos e
ur
t t rs 1 a 848- 11 S.Ct 1
o he ik. d. t
49, 4
. 970.
A prs ofi a r m ansfe t r butt dei r t i fe e e c r
ion fcil e i r e o e
he lbe a e ndif r nc ha ge,
e n i t f e of a obvi us r s ç i on of i i l c r d w ih de i r t
ve n he ac
n
o i k. d s
pr
fc a s ha ge
t lbe a e
i fe e e m i s
ndif r nc ght how,f e mpl t tt di no know oft unde l ng
or xa e, ha hey d t
he
ryi
f ct i c tng a s fc e ty s tnta da r a t t t y we e t r f e
a s ndi ai
uf i n l ubsa il nge nd ha he
r he e or
t wa eofa da r ort tt y kne t undel ng fcsbutbeive (l i
ma r
nge, ha he
w he
ryi a t
le d abet
u omdy t t t e rs t wl c te fcs g ve rs wa is b tn il o
ns t l) ha h ik o l h h a t a ie s n u sa ta r
i
none se .' I a 844,11 S.Ct 1
xitnt' d. t
4
. 970. Buta e s c s ulr buta ,t y
bs nt uc es f e tl he
m a be hed la e f robvi rs t y mus ha kno
y
l ibl o
ous iks he
t ve wn. I a 842,11 S. .
d. t
4 Ct
1970.
M a s i 789 F. a 1 34.Furhe
kde s,
3d t 33t nnor a sa e
e, s tt d,
P io o caswh a ï al l w o as bsa ta rs t imaeh at o s ft
rs n x il o cu ly c
ne f u tnil ik o n t e l r a ey
h
may bef und feef o la lt i t y r ponde r a o bl t t rs e p i
o
r r m i biiy f he es
d e s na y o he ik, ve f
t hn uli ael wasno a re A prs ofi i ls dut unde t Ei h
he nn tm t y
t ve td.
ion fc a '
y
r he ght
Ame e i t e lr r s na e s ey,asa dt ti or r t duer ga d
ndm nt s o nsze ea o bl af t
t ndar ha nc po a es
e r
f prs ofi i l 'une a e t s of kee ng da r us me i s e c t
or ion fc a s
nvi bl a k
pi
nge o
n n af usody
unde hlm a co tons....
r l ne ndii
Fn r 51 U. a 8 4 4 (n ena q o ai nmaksa ctt nso te )
nne, 1 S. t 4 - 5 itr l u tto r nd i i mitd .
ao
I t s ci tted G c s' J
n he e ton il t t , udge Sa ge ' r po ta r omm e ton ofe s a 73Fa '
r nts e r nd ec
ndai
fr
page de a l sl m a y o t r c d e de e,i l ng wine st tmony,vi f a a
, t ied l
m r f he e or vi nc ncudi
t s esi
deo oot ge, nd
ad it d doc e a i Thr hout t i s m a y of t e de e r f e t ba d co r di tons
m te
um nt ton.
oug
, l s um z
l
he vi nc e l c s l nt a c i
be w e n pori of M a s is t s i ony, be w ee hi t s i ony a t t s i ony of o he
t e
tons
kde s ' e tm
t n s e tm
nd he e tm
t r
i a ea sa fwine s , t e saeme sM a s imadei va i a nita i r m e
nm t nd t f t s es be we n tt nt
kde s
n rous dmi sr tve e dy
f m sa i f l up i t r i wswih m e alhe lh sa forprs i tga o s a bewe n
or nd n olow
ne ve
t
nt a t tf
ion nvesi t r , nd t e
Ma
kdes is t tmony a doc nt i e de e. The r po ta s not s M a s is lc of
s' esi
nd
ume s n vi nc
e r lo e
kde s ' a k
da e a r pea e us ofge rct nnslkeGc l ma e 'a She 'i hi wrte alegai nsa
t s nd e t d e
ne i e
i Gel t s' nd G y' n s itn l to nd
t
hi t si on ofpa ta s t a r t iton asunde mi ngt c e biiy ofs h a coun s
s e tm y
s s auls nd eala i
r ni he r di lt
uc c
t.
M a d sisae t tMso jcin b ifwilhihih l e ti f cs'n tme to d o
k e s tts ha
b e to re l g lg t i ran a t' o nine r
c
gi n i ufk intwei ti t r por. The bre t n pr vi s a l pa sl a y ofpa t of
ve ns t e
gh n he e t
i f he o de
o- ge lmm r
rs
Ma
kdes ist si o a o he e de e hepr s nt sa e i t lg m os f a et hi .
s' e tm ny nd t r vi nc
e e ed, t t d n he iht
t avor bl o m
The c thass cik al r viwe t e de e M a s ha hi zi t The c thasalo
our
pe t ly e e d he vi nc
kdes i s gllgh ed.
our
s
co ucedA novo rviw oft he rng ta ci a t e bisnotd. M a sidoe no,
nd t
e e
he ai rnsrpt nd he xhi t e
kde s s t
h we r ie tf a ie o e i e c o te fo te rp r ta warn s rj cin o
o ve, d n iy ny tm f v d n e mitd r m h e o t h t ra t ee to r
a e m e oft r po ts e de e s ma y, a t c tfnds no s h diposton t be
m nd nt he e r ' vi nc um r nd he our i
uc s ii o
6
r o e he our dopt he Ta t ' e ton he e t s n c ur t um r
ne e s r 2 The ef r , t c ta st l c s's c i oft r por a a a c a es ma y
c s a y.
oft e de epr s nt
he vi nc e e ed.
The anays s po ton of t r por r co m e
l i ri
he e t e m nds fndi t t m uc of M a s is
i ng ha
h
kde s '
t si ony,a we lasm a sa e e si hi num e o m i tn c
e tm
s l
ny tt m nt n s
r us te ompli a gre nc f
ant nd iva e onnsi
n
t r or a e notc ed bl Thi pori n oft r por ofe s s m e e mpls of dic e nces
he ec d, r
r i e.
s to
he e t f r o
xn e
s r pa i
t t unde m i t ve a t of M a
ha
r ne he r ciy
kdes is ac ount . But t r por' fndi on wine s
s' c s
he e ts i ng
t s
c edi lt a s c e ry r i on t ma ot rdicr pa esa c tad c i r fe t d i t
r biiy l o l a l eles he ny he s e nci nd on r i tons e l c e n he
l ngt ml ma y of t e de . The r por r c me
e hy m r
he vi nce
e t e om nds fndi c e bl t ofi e s
i ng r di e he fc r '
t s i on de ng pe s l know l
e tm y nyi
r ona
edge o a s t n i l r s of s r ous ha m pr e e b
f
ubs a t a ik
ei
r
es nt d y
M a s ' c i d a sg ntas Smih' celm ae. Fi ly,t r po tr c
kdes is ontnue s i nme
t s l t
na l he e r e omm e fndi
nds i ng
unpe s i M a s is cr lm sa i le de e pur ri t s
r uasve kde s ' icl t nta vi nc
po tng o how t tdif r nce bewe n
ha fe e s t e
hi a Sm ih pos rs s o ousy s t n i lt tt ofi e smus ha known oft m ,
m nd
t
ed iks o bvi l ubsa ta ha he fc r
t ve
he
des t t i de a sofknowi
pie her nil
ng.
M a d sima e n s cfco j cin t t rpo tsc n l in t a t ed fn a t d d
k e s k s o pe ii b e to o he e r' o cuso h t h e e d n s i
no ha G c u lkno e oft da e pos by Sm ih be a e t y we e t r a on Sm ih
t ve t t a
a
wl dge he ng r ed
t c us he
r he e s
t
had a tm p e t ha m M a s iorbec us M a s iha t d t m t tSm ih ha a s ule
te t d o r
kde s
a e kde s d ol he ha
t d sa td
hi i t ep s o t th f ae f rh slf . ( po t 2. I t e a e eo a o jcin a
m n h a t r ha e e rd o i ie' Re r 8 ) n h bsnc f n b e to nd
'
fndi no c e re r , heco twila ptt sfndi
i ng
l a ror t
ur l do hi i ng.
M a s contndst tt r po tove e
kdes i
e
ha he e r
r mphasz d hi c e biiy pr e sand i e
ie s r di lt obl m
gnor d
e de of obvi s f t c
vi nce
ous a e y once ns t de e nt m us ha known a
r he f nda s
t ve
bout c i ng t c l
ontnui o e l
hm wi S t Amo o h rti g , a s rst te i e c pr v s t ed fn a t' o d te
i t mih.
h
ng t e h n s he s et ha v d n e o e : h e e d n s j b uis
2 M a s f t t a ur c oft r pod' f css cton i o y onepa tc a r ga d: issa e e t t
kdes i auls he cc a y he e
s a t e i n nl
riulr e r t tt m nt ha
l trc r c r ctd M a s' tsi o o t num be ofda hes nti s gr gai alrhef r d ha m
ocao a ds ontadi e
kdesis e tm ny n he
r
ys pe n e e ton fe
ea e r
9om hi c lmae i Se embe 2007. M a s icai t tt c r pr t ac r y ofhi tsi
s el t n pt
r
kde s l ms ha he a ds ove he cu ac
s e tmony on t s
hi
poi . Theco tf t sm i dic e nc i tra,gi n t f c t textnsveot revi e s
nt
m' mds hi nor s r pa y mmae il ve he a t ha e i he denc umma ied
rz
i t r por,unc le d byM a s i s ve eyundemi hi c e biiy o nume ousot rpoi s
n he e t halnge
kde s, e r l
r nes s r di lt n
r
he nt.
7
mus ha e
t ve xpos d t m t li pro c
e he o zs i r ompli t s e ng pr eci n bec us ofhi vu ne a ltes
a n s e ki
ot to
a e
s l r biii
a pa ti ae as a t ;Sm ih' ga a flaton,M a s isr putto a a slt h a physc
nd s nm t s uls
t s ng fii i
kde s ' e ai n s ric nd
ial
dia ltes a t fve i heght a t ee yea a dif r nc s be we n M a s a
s biii , nd he i -nch i
nd m n- r ge fe e e t e
kdes i nd
Sm ih asc lma e pr e e o ousy s tntalrs ofs ro ha a Sm ih' 11 days
t
el t s es nt d bvi l ubsa i iks e i us nn; nd
t s 5
ofs gr ga i a t de enda s enc mt r wih hi m us ha putt m on notc t tli
e e ton nd he f nt ' ot e s t m
t ve
he
ie ha ls
ds iln r hit r (ncu i ijt t a t e i maei Fe r ay20 0 prs ne as b tn il
icp ia y so y i ldng nt y o noh r n t n b u r 1 ) e e td u sn ta
r
rs ofha m t M a s ia hi c lm ae.
ik
r o kde s s s el t
I hi i ,i i undiputd t tfom 2007 t 201 M a s m a c
n ndsght t s
s e ha r
o
0, kdes i de ompl i s a
ant bout
beng uzne a e t physc la s xua a s uls 9om ot ri a e . l i a s undiput d t t
i
l r bl o
ia nd e l s a t
he nm t s t s lo
s e ha
Sm ih a s ule a ha med M a s i on De mbe 21 201 . a t t t r fe , prs
t s a t d nd r
kde s
ce r , 0, nd ha , he ea tr ion
ofii l c l d t tM a s ic ul no l rbe s f y ho ed i t ge r lpopulto a
fc as onc ude ha
kde s o d
onge
a el us n he ne a
ai n t
W a lnsli
le tdge. The de e nt di no ,howe r ha t be fto hi i hti r ac ng t
f nda s d t
ve , ve he nei f ndsg n e hi he
pe c ptonsa
re i
boutt ce lm a e t tdie t d t i ac i ns
he l t s ha r c e he r to .
M or ove , t c tca
e r he our nnot tnd t t t r por i no es e de e unf ry evaua es
i ha he e t g r vi nc , ail
l t
wines c e biiy, o i pr ry r i on a l k t r i r c ng is fndi
t s r di lt r m ope l eles
ac he eof n ea hi t
ngs a
nd
c l i . The we g oft e de e i c t st tt e de e n s ne rac u ly s w o
onc usons
i ht he vi nc ndi a e ha hes f nda t ve t a l a r
he r M a
a d kdes is c m pl i sofprorphysc lors xua celm ae as a t bef r t De e be
s' o ant
i
ia
e l l t s uls o e he c m r
21 2010,i i n ,and t t t alegai ns i M a s ' pror c
,
nc de t
ha he l to n kdes is i ompl i s we e of doubtu
ant
r
fl
ve act i a e nt t ta W a lns Ri m e a he lh pr es i
r iy n ny ve ; ha
le
dge nt l at of sonalha as es e M a s i
d s s d kde s
a f und no r as f hi t be a s gne t a sng e ce l a he ha r que t d;t tM a
nd o
e on or m o
s i d o i l l, s
d e s e ha
kdes ii
s s
s r i a lf s nt nc f a br a doubl m tr r w hie i 201 Sm ih w a w ihi ni ye r of
e v ng ie e e e or ut l
e l de , l n
0, t
s t n ne a s
c mpltn hi sn e c f rc ra lig; t a Smi a d M a d siwee ca sfe a t e s me
o eig s e tn e o aj ccn 3 h t t n
h
k e s r ls iid t h n
3 I t r or o i i c et tSmih' e ctdr ea edaei J 1 201
nmae ec ds nlne ndiat ha
t s xpe e el s t s une 7, 9.
8
s cliy l ve ; a t t t vii e physc l a a dif r nce be wee t c l m a e a
e tr' e l nd ha he sbl
t
i a nd ge f e e s t n he e l t s nd
Smih' ga a fla i a s r ga i tm e di notpr e G e fags't t e e re e
t s ng f iton nd eg e ton i
d
es nt t d l ' o hes xpe inc d
r
c r to ofi i l ofda r i m ant i ng t c l as i e t The e de alo i c t s
oreci ns fc as
nge n i ani he e l sgnm n .
vi nce s ndi a e
t tt de W ale Ri polc e ,i a esw e e as i d a c l m a es o y i t y a ee t t
ha m r
l ns dge i i s nm t
r s gne s e l t nl f he gr d o he
a r nge nt a a i ae who r f e t r t r t hi c loutoff a f ii s ey wo d be
ra me , nd n nm t
e us d o e u n o s el
e r or ls af t ul
i me ael plce i s gr ga i f pr t c i pum os s pe ng a i tgai 4 I ne 1
m di t y a d n e e ton or o e ton
e , ndi n nvesi ton. n ary
fve m o hs a Sm ih' ce l m a e, M a
i
nt s
t s l
t
kdes i neve r f s d t r 'u' t hi ce l a f t t t
s
r e u e o et n o s l, ac ha
t
t r ne t c edi lt ofhi cai t the hi s ftul f a e f r hi s f t f o Sm ih
mde mi s he r biiy
s l m ha
m el r y e r d o s a e y r m
t
be or Dec mbe 21
f e
e r .
M a d s is p i r o j cin i t a te rp r d v td o l tle p r g a h t
k e s' rmay b e to s h t h e o t e o e ny l e aa r p s o
r
a yzng whehe t dif r nc be wee Sm ih a M a s s obvi usy pr e e a
nal i
t r he fe e es t n
t nd
kdes i o
o l es nt d
s t nta rs of s ro ha m t M a s i t t t de e nt m us ha known of i.
ubsa i l ik
e i us r o
kde s ha he f nda s
t ve
t
M a s i ar s t t t s e de
kde s gue ha hi vi nce of o ous r s w i hi c e f de i r t i f e e e
bvi
i k ns s as or lbe a e ndif r nc
be us t de e nt f ie t r buti wih a tonale de e. Theco tc
ca e he f nda s al d o e t t ddii
vi nc
ur anno ag e
t r e.
Fis, h S p e Co r h se p e syrj ce t en to t a < p io o fca whowa
rt t e u rme u t a x r sl ee td h o in h t û rs n fi il
a
s
t wa e of a s bsa ta rs ofha m t a i t ma ne rhe e s be he d la e t rt
ma r
u t n i l ik
r o n nma e y ve t l s
l ibl mde he
Eiht Am e e i t rs wasobvi a a r s na e prs ofk i woul ha notc
g h
ndm nt f he ik
ous nd ea o bl ion l al
d ve ied
i. F r r 51 U. a 8 2 (mp ssa d d . tl tatiro f c ma ifrk wld efo
t n me, 1 S. t 4 e ha i d e ) û-ha re f a t y n e no e g ' m
r
t obvius i ohe wor ,doesnotme n t ti mus d s ' JL a 844 (mphassa d)
he
o , n t r ds
a ha t t o o. .. t
' I
e
i dde .
Se ond, he de e nt di o f r buta t tm ony t tt dif r nc s be wee t ce lm a esi
c
t
f nda s d f er e t l es i
ha he f e e e t n he l t n
age hei ,di c plna y hi t y,a ga af ii ton di notne s arl s gna t tc ngi t
, ght s i i r s or nd ng fla i
d
ce s iy i l ha ha ng he
cela sgnme f s ft r s nswaswa rnt Se jaa 8 ( i t tofii smay
l s i nt or aey ea o
ra ed. e . t 45 notng ha fcal
l
4 The c tfndst tt s i
our i ha hi mmedit s gr gai polc is fq lfe asa r as bl r s e t t
ae e e ton iy tel uaiis
e ona e epons o he
undeni e i r trs t men co ctd ofvi e ci sandt n co i d f rl pe i i a s l prs n
abl, nheen ik hat
nvi e
olnt rme
he ntne o ong rods n mal io
celma de o co lct t tma es alt ove tm e t physc co ac.
l y velp nfi s ha y c ae, r i , o
ial nt t
9
(
e c p l bit i ihe k e t u eli fcsb t le e (letu omdy ta t rs t
s a e i l y f t y n w he nd ryng a t u beiv d ab i ns t l) h t he ik o
a i
t
wh c t ef csg vers wa is b tnilo n n xse f).
ih h a t a ie s n u sa ta r o e itn
1
W e g ng t e de e a a whol i l ng wines c e biiy a ot r f cor
i hi he vi nc s
e, ncudi
t s r di lt nd he a t s
e h sz d i t erpo ta t e o j cinst eeo t c u tfnd b ap e o d rnc o t
mp m ie n h e r nd h be to h rt , he o r i s y r p n ea e f he
e de et tnone oft de e nt knew be or M a s r n o ofhi celon De e be 21
vi nc ha
he f nda s
f e kdes i a ut
s l
cm r ,
201 t housng hi i t s m ec lwih Sm ih pr s n ed a s t ntalrs t tSm ih wo d
0, hat
i
m n he n
el t
t eet
ubsa i ik ha
t ul
c us h m s ro h r Th s tec u t o cu e t tt d fn a t aee tte t j d me t
a e i eius am. u ,h o r c n ld s ha he ee d ns r n ild o u g n t
Co uson
ncl i
F rra o sd suse heen,h c u t l o e z M a d siso j cinsa i tra .
o e s n ic s d r i t e o r wil v m l k e s' be to s mmaeil
e
o wi o tme i a da o tt ma itaej d esrp r.Ba e o tet erp r a dt ec u ts
r t u rt n d p he gsrt u g ' e o t sd n h h e o t n h o r'
h
X novo r viw o t evi nc asr lce i t so rin,t c tconcude t tM a s
e e f he de e efe td n hi pilo he our
l s ha kdeqi
ha f ie a tilt pr vehi c s by apr po r nceoft evi nce. The e o e t co twil
s a ld t ra o o
s ae
e nde a
he de
r f r , he ur l
e tr u g n f rted fn a t.Ana prp it o d rwil n e ti d y.
n e j d me t o h ee d n s
p o rae r e l e tr h s a
E E T i XN Ndyo Jn ay 2017.
NT R: hs
a f aur
,
Chi
ef
1
0
ie Stt sDititJ
t d a e src udge
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?