Hamlett v. Northwestern Regional Adult Detention Center

Filing 5

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 06/14/2011. (kab)

N FRK' A CE U.S. SQ COUA
S OFFj
DI
T ROANOG ,VA
FL
LED

I TH E UN I
N
TED STATES DI
STRI T C O U RT
C
FO R TH E W ESTER N D I
STR I T O F VI G I I
C
R N A
R O AN O K E DI I O N
V SI

J 1ù 2 1
UN
21
J A
BYULt C.
:

,

D

PA UL R AN D O LPH H AM LETT ,

CLERK

RK

C A SE N O .7:
11CV 00267

Pl ntf
ai if,

M EM O R AND U M O PI I N
N O
VS.

N O R TH W E STER N RE G I N A L
O
AD ULT D ETEN TI N CEN TE R,
O

By: Sam uelG .W is
l on
U nied StatesD i ri Judge
t
st ct

D efendant.

Pa Randol H a l t,a V igi a i a e pr e di pr K ,t l t s ci lrght a i
ul
ph m e t
r ni nm t oc e ng o
i ed hi vi i s cton

p ru n t 4 U. C.j 1 8 algn t a ji o tcas a te No twe tr Re ina Ad l
u s a t o 2 S.
9 3 le ig h t al fi il t h
rh se n go l ut
Dee i Ce e (dhe j i' vi ae hi c tt ina rght by srp s ac ng hi f
tnton ntr û al' oltd s onsiuto l i s
t
)
ti e rhi m or

c n rb n i fo to oh rg a d a dimae .Th c u t id ta t d f n a ti n ts b e t
o ta a d n r n f t e u r s n n t s e o r fn s h t he e e d n s o u j c
t s tunde j1 a wilt r or,s mmarl dimist sa ton.
o ui
r 983 nd l,heef e u
iy s s hi ci
l

H a l t a l gest f l i s
m e t le
he olow ng eque e ofe nt on whi h hi cl m sa e ba e On
nc
ve s
c s ai r s d.
A pr l1 2011 t i a esi Ham l t' pod w e e t d t l a t pod t a l ofi er t
i ,
, he nm t n
ets
r ol o e ve he
o low fc s o
c
onduc a s r h oft ar a. Fe lng a sr ng ur t urna e H a l t as i he c d us t
t ea c
he e
ei
to
ge o i t , m e t ked f oul e he
r sr
e t oom be or l vi a or r bu hi r ques w asde e a t
f e ea ng s de ed, t s e
t
ni d, lhough he s w ot ri t
a he mna es
be ng alow e t us t r s r m . Onc outoft s a c ar a a i s e di co f t H a l t
i
l d o e he e too
e
he e r h e nd n om
s m or, m e t
a ke a he of i e i he coul us t r toom ,a a i t r que tw asdeni d. Fi l a
s d not r f c r f
d e he esr
nd ga n, he e s
e
naly,
ha fa hourl t r a s gea alow ed H a l t t g t t r t oo . The of i r t d e r one
l n
a e , er nt l
m e t o o o he esr m
n, fce s ol ve y
w ho had used t res r
he t oom t lne up al t r t oom w al f a sr p search. H am l t aleges
oi
ong he esr
l or ti
et l

t tt ofk e ssrp s r d a oxi ael t l ma ei aes sdeby sde,i pl i sg of
ha he t r ti ea che ppr m t y weve l nm t , i
i n an i ht

ot ri aesa sa f W he Ha lt quesi d t pr dur t ofi ert dhi t ti he
he nm t nd t f .
n m et
tone he oce e, he fc ol m ha f
r us t c
ef ed o ooper t wih t s ar h, woul r c veadici i r c r
ae t he e c he
d e ei
s plna y ha ge.

Ha etbeleve t srp s rhwa ûornot ngbe a ea last 1 oft pe et t
mlt i s he ti eac s s
f
hi c us t e ll 0 he opl ha

g rls ac dh dDi i t eijmo t . Hes e tej i, h l ngn t srps a c a
wee e rhe a p n h lr uhs'
' u s h al c al ig he ti e r h s
e
t lega . Asr le ,he s e m one a y dn a s pa
d l l'
i
'
e if
e ks
t r m ge , ymen ofhi fnes a r duci n ofhi
t
s i , nd e to
s
c i i s nt nc ofi pr s e .
r m nal e e e m i onm nt 1
1
1

ds algoveni bodis... a bes ddie tyunderj 1 f moneay,d lr or
l oc
l
r ng e c n ue rcl
983 or
tr ecaat y,
orij tver i whee...hea tont ti aleg t beunc tt i i e nt or
nunci elef r t ci ha s l ed o
onsiutonalmplme s
e c e a polc s a e e ,or na e, e a i orde s on ofk i l a ed a
xe ut s
i y t t m nt di nc r gul ton,
ci i
t aly dopt nd

pr
omul t d by t tbody' ofi r ' M onelv. w Yo k Civ De .ofSoc a Se v c s 436U .
gae
ha
s fce s.
'
l Ne
r t pt
il r ie ,

S.658,690( 978) A gove nt eniyi la eunde j1 3,
1 .
mme al tt s ibl
r 98 howeve,onl whe t e iy
r y n he ntt
is l i atmovi f r e'be nd t de i ton.Pol Count v.Dods 45 U. 31 3
t ef s û ng o c ' hi he prva i
k
y
on, 4 S. 2, 26

(1 1 .tlhus t e iy' ofi a polc mus ha plye apa ti t algedvi ai of
98 ) c- ,he ntt s fcil iy t ve a d r n he le
olton
f rllw.OklhomaCiyv.Tutl,471U. 808,81 - ( 985 .
edea a
a
t
te
S.
7 818 1 )

Plitf n me o l t j i a ad f n a tb t al t saefcsp o i iga yln
an if a s ny he al s ee d n, u f i o tt a t r v dn n ik
s
bewe nj ipoiya dt ec re to a o fc r'alg dyilg la t. Ac o dn l p an ifs
t e al l n h o rcin l fies le e l l a cs c r igy, litf
c
e
c mpan a ans t ej i i wih u f cu l rlg l u tn e Ac o dn y tea to wil e
o lit g i t h al s t o t a ta o e a s bsa c . c r igl,h cin lb
ds se wi o t eudc , t s a t o2 U. C. 1 5 b () a lg lyfio o .
imis d t u prj ie pl u n t 8 S. j 91 A() 1, s e al rv lusz
h
r

1 Pl ntf i advied t s i acton ofcrm i fnesand r
ai if s
s hat atsf i
i nal i
educton i crm i penali of
i n i nal
tes

i rs me taeno f r o r le ge r l a a lbl u rj 1 3.
mp ion n r t o ms f eif ne al v ia e nde 98
y

Pu s n t j 1 5 b)1,a s ona p a tc bea trd k tngt c r mu tdimisa
rua t o 91 A( ( ) s o s r cia l fe oc e i he ou t s s s n

acton fld by a prs
i ie
ioneragai tgove nmentof al t i f
ns
r
fci s hat s ound t be f i ousorm alci ort
o
rvol
i ous hat
f l t s ae a cl m upon whih r i m a begr e .
ais o t t
ai
c elef y
ant

2

The Clr i die t d t s nd c e oft sme or ndum o ni n a a ompa ng
e k s r c e o e opis hi m a
pi o nd cc
nyi
.,#
.- '
.
z. '
..
'
v'
'

or rt pl i if
de o a ntf .

,
x e.

.
.X

I. .'
y

EN TER : Thi ,
s S

day ofJ ,2011
une
.
le St t sD it i J
t d a e s rct udge

3