Stinnett v. Astrue

Filing 16

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 6/21/2012. (ssm)

CLERK' OFFCE U,. DIX COURT
S I S S
AT ROANOKE,V
A
FI
LED

J 2 12 1
kN
02

FRHENTTSAI RCRC IGNA
ITHU IEETDEDSO TCUI
O T WE DR TSITIVRIT
N E S N S F OR
T
ROAN O KE DI I ON
V SI

)u
.
a

JULA . D
I
CL
E
BY:
. ov
j
y

JI R .STI N ETT,
LL
N

Ci lA c i N o. 7: CV 00282
vi ton
11
Pl i if
a ntf ,

M EM OM NDUM OPI ON
NI
MI
CHA EL J.A STRU E,
Com mi sone ofSocilSecziy,
si r
a
l t
r

By:

Honor bl Gln E.Conr d
a e e
a
Chi fU nie St t s D it i tJ e
e
t d a e s rc udg

De enda .
f nt
Pl i ifhasfl dt sa ton c le ngt tnal ii o t Comm isone ofSocil
antf
ie hi c i hal ngi he i decson f he
si r
a
Se ziy de ng pl ntf s ca m f s e e als c iy i om e be t unde t Socil
ctrt nyi
ai if li or upplm nt e urt nc
neks
r he
a

Sec iyAc,asn nde 42U. C.j1381: sq.Jziditonoft sc ti purua t 42
urt t me d,
S.
. e lrs ci
!
hi our s s nt o
U. C.j1 c( , c i or aesj205( oft SocilSe urt Ac,42U. C. 405( .
S. 383()3) whih nc port
g) he a c iy t
S. j g)
A sr f e t d by t m e or
elce
he m andaand a gum e s it d by t pari ,t i s now bef et
r
nt ubm te
he tes he s ues
or he

co ta e whehe t Comm isone ' fnalde i i i s
ur r
t r he
s i rs i
c son s uppore by s t nta e de e,or
td
ubsa il vi nc
w he hert r i '
t he e s '
good c us ' o ne es ia e r m a ng t ca et t Co m i sonerf f r he
a e't c s t t e ndi he s o he m s i
or u t r

c n ie ain.S e4 U. C. 4 5 g .
o sd rto e 2 S. j 0 ()
Thepl i if J l R.Stl et wa bor o J nua y 1 1 ande n ualy c
antf, il
i t, s n n a r 4, 966
m
ve t l ompl t t
eed he
eeve h gr dei s hool M r .Stnne'wor i t e ry 1
l nt a n c . s i t
t ked n he a l 990sa a s r n prnt r Si t t
s c ee i e . nce ha
tm e s hasnotwor o a r ul r bas s Forpu pos soft s c e,gi n t l ngt oftm e
i , he
ked n eg a
i.
r e
hi as ve he e h i
snce pl i t f s l tr ul rw or a tviy,i i a sl e t tM r .Stl e thas no pa t r l va
i
a n if as eg a
k c i t t s s lm d ha
s im t
s e e nt

wor ( 25 .Se 20C. R. 41 965.
k. TR ) e
F. j 6.
On Augus 27,2007,M r . i t tl a a i to f s em e a s c liy i m e
t
s Stnne t i ed n pplca i n or uppl nt l e tr t nco

be t Prort t ttme,s ha fld f z o he a i tons f di a lt be t
neks. i o ha i
he d ie otr t r pplcai
or s biiy neks. By

memor ndlm opi on a or re e e M a c 21,
a z
ni nd de nt r d r h 2003, hi c ta fr e t de alofoneof
t s our fim d he ni
pl i ifse rira ia i f rdiabiiy i ur nc be ft and s eme a s urt i
antf a le pplc tons o s lt ns a e ne is
uppl nt l ec iy ncome

be t .Se Stl tv. r ha tCi l tonNo. 01CV001 (ones J) Dlrngt pei
neks e imet Ba n r, viAci
2:
32,J , .. zi he rod
of tm e pror t t c t de s on i t te le c e,M r .Stnnet a i d f a r ce ved
i
i o he our ' ci i n ha ari r as
s
s i t pple or nd e i

s e nt ls c iy i om ebe ft on t ba i ofas m aof m dior nlAc r ng t t
uppl me a e urt nc
ne is he ss
o t or s de
co di o he
A dm i s r tve Law J
ni ta i
udge i t i t ntc s , r .Stnne t ea le pe i ofe il m e t SSI
n he ns a a e M s i t' ri r rod
s
ntte nt o

be ft ç sce s da r ntywhe he hus nd d e i 2004 a s be n t r cevebe ft
ne is t
wa m e ppa e l
n r ba i d n
nd he ga o e i
ne is

f t rs untlherac da eg e n.He r ourese e de he ei biiyf SSl' (
or hei on i e he ge ihte
r es c xc e d r lgi lt or . TR
'

1 ) Th splitf wa c mp le t ra pyfrs p lme tl e u iyic meb n t wh nhe
0 . u , an if s o eld o e p l o u pe na s c rt n o e eks e r
f m iy' e ilm e t be sonhe de ea edhus nd' wagee r rsa ountende
a l s ntte nt o neft
r c s
ba s
a ne ' cc
d.
M r . Stnne t m os r e a i a i was de e upon i ta c i r ton a
s i t'
s
t ec nt pplc ton
nid
niil onsde a i nd

r c i r ton. She t n r uese a rc ve a 7: novo he rng a rviw beor an
e onsde ai
he eq td nd e ei d -.
a i nd e e f e
Adm i sr tveLa J
nitai
w udge.I a opi on dae Aprl1 201 t La J ea s dee mi t t
n n ni
t d i , 0,he w udg lo tr ned ha
M r Stnne t snotdia e TheLa J
s. i t i
s bl d.
w udgef
oundt tpl ntf s f r fom s ve ei r nt
ha ai if ufe s r e r mpaime s

o t eb s so d g n rtv ds d sa e fb o aga ar c n ij r t t lf k e , hso y
n h a e f e e eaie ic ie s ,ir my l i, e e t nu y o he e t n e a it r

o ac h l ndd u a u e t b c oa us wihs o te so b e t, mao d p e sv ds r e,
f lo o a r g b s , o a c b e t h rn s f r ah a j r e r sie io d r
a xey a d armoeh so yo s iu e a h a a h s TR 1 ) De pt t i c mbn to o
n it, n e t it r f ez r s nd e d c e .( 2 . s ie h s o iain f
1Somat f m dior r a e c a e i d by physc s omst ta e notf l expl ne by anoher
o or s de s r harctrze
ial ympt
ha r
uly
ai d
t
dior - physc l o me al Sympt of s t or dior r a e notvoltona .Somaof m dior r a e
s der
ia r nt .
oms
omaof m s de s r
ii l
t or s de s r
ditesi a ofe i rs alocc tona, ca mi, hera pe t of u i ng. sedior si udebody
sr sng nd tn mpai oci , upai la de c orot s c s f nctoni The s der ncl
dys phi dio de ,c ri dior r hypoc
mor c s r r onve son s de ,
hondrass pan dior r s tzai dio de ,undifr ntae
i i, i s de , omai ton s r r
fe e itd
s t or dior r a s t o m dio de notohe s s iid.Bodydys r cdio de difr s wha
omaof m s de , nd omaof r s r r
t rwie pecfe
mo phi s r r fe s ome t
fom ot r s ma ofr dio de s i t t i i c r c eied by pr c ton wih pe c ve defct i ph i l
r
he o t o m s r r n ha t s ha a t rz
eoc upai
t r ei d e s n ysca
a aa
ppe r nce.K ahe i A .Philps Ove ve ofSomatzain,i Th M e c M a ua f rHe lh Ca ePr fs i n l,
t rne
li , r iw
i to .! e rk n l o at r o e so as
1
ac ii
s de sove e
he :/ . r kmu uascoe pr e sona yc arc dior er/o t o= - and f ttous dior r / N iw
/- me c
l.
ofs i vps hiti s d ss maof

o s maiain.t (atvstdJ n 1 , 01)
f o tzto hml ls ii u e 5 2 2 .
e

-

-

-

-

i r nt ,heLa J
mpaime s t
w udgehedt tM r . i tr t i s tc e fmc i c pa iyt e
l ha s Stnnet e ans ufi i nt t tonal a ct o ngag
e
i a lmie r ng oflg wor a tviy. TheLa J
n i t d a e iht k c i t
w udge a s s d pl ntf sr sdualf tona
s es e ai if e i
unc i l
c pac t asf l s
a iy olow :

Afe c r fz c i e ai n oft e ie r or t t r i
tr a e t onsd r to
l
he ntr ec d, he mde sgned fndst tt
i
ha he
cai nthast r i lf nci na ca ct t pe f m lght kasde i di 20
l ma
he esdua u to l pa iy o ror i wor
fne n

CF 41 .6 ( e c p ta s s o l n tci ld e so wo ka heg t; he
R 69 7b) x e t h t he h u d o l a d r r r t ih s s
mb
c n onl oc sona l c o h,c a a soo s nee t c nge posu e
a
y ca i ly r uc r wl nd t p; he ds o ha
tr s
b ify,i pl c e h hourwiho la ng he wor sai n;s i mode ael
re l n a e, ac
t ut e vi
r k t to he s
rt y
lm iedi c en r to s ca pe f m onl smpl , c
i t n onc tai n; he n ror
y i e non- omplxt ks ands
e as ;
he
c nnotwor wih t publc bu c wor wih ot rpeopl a ound.
n
k t he
i , t an k t he
e r

( 1 - 0 .Gi e s c ar sd a f n to a c p ct, n a trc n ieaino pan if a e
TR 9 2 ) v n u h e iu l u cin l a a iy a d fe o sd rto f litf s g ,
e a i a pr o w or e r e e,a wel ast tm on f om a voc t ona e r ,t La
duc ton, nd i r
k xpe i nc s l esi y r
a i l xpe t he w

J gedee mi dt t r . i te ans hec pact ope f m s ve a s ii lg wor ols
ud
tr ne ha M s Stnnetr t i t a iyt ror e r l pecfc i ht kr e
e si i sg t a tnlm be i t na i le
xitng n i nik n l r n he tona cono y.Acc di y,t Law J
m
or ngl he
udgeuli ael
tm t y
co l
ncuded t tM r .Stnne ti notdia e a t ts i notnow e il d t s e e a
ha s i t s
s bl d, nd ha he s
ntte o upplm nt l

s urt i ome be ft. Se g n. 20 C. R.j41 920( . The La J
ec iy nc
neis e e ,
F.
6. g)
w udge' o ni wa
s pi on s
a pt d as hefna de i i of heCo m i sone
do e t i l c s on t
m s i rbyt Soci lSe urt dm i sr ton' Appe l
he
a c iyA
ni ta i s
as

Counci.Ha nge use a 1 vaia ea i sr tver m e e , r . i t ha now a ald
l vi xha t d 1 a lbl dm nita i e di s M s Stnne t s
ppe e
t t sc t
o hi our .

W hie pl i if ma be dia e f ce ti f ms ofe pl m e ,t c u i lf c ual
l antf y
s bld or ran or
m oy nt he r c a a t
de e mi to i whe he pl i ifwa dia e f a1f r ofs t talganf e pl
t r na i n s t r antf s s bld or 1 o ms ubsan i i ul m oyme .
nt

Se 42U. C. 1 2c a.Theeaef elmensofpr whihmus beconsdee i ma ng
e
S. j 38 ( ) r r our e t
oof c
t
i rd n ki

s ha a lss Th s ee n saes mmaie a f lo : ()o j ci eme c lf csa d
uc n nay i. e e lme t r u rz d s ol ws 1 b e tv dia a t n
ci c li dn s ( ) h o no a dc ncuso o te tngp y iins ( )s b e tv e d n e
l a fn ig ; 2 t e piins n o l ins f r ai h sca ;3 u j cie vie c
ni
3

o p sc l n fsain o i ar n s a d srbe tr u hacama t tsi n ;a d( )
f hy ia mn ie tto s f mp ime t, s e ci d h o g li n ' e tmo y n 4
s
t c am a ' e a i voc tona hit r r sdua s ls a ag Viek v.Fi h,438 F.
he l i nts duc ton, a i l so y, e i l kil , nd e. t
nc
2d

1 5 ,1 5 - 0(t Ci. 9 1; d r o v. bio f 2 8F.d 8 0, 51( t Ci. 9 2 .
1 7 1 9 6 4 h r 1 7 ) Un e wo d Ri c f, 9 2 5 8 4h r 1 6 )
Afe a r e of t r cor i t s c e t c ti
tr eviw
he e d n hi as , he our suna e t concude t t t
bl o
l
ha he

Comm isone ' fna decsoni s
s i rs i l ii s uppore s tnta e de
tdby ubsa il vi nce.Ba e ont e de ebef e
s d he vi nc or
t Admi sr tve La J
he
nita i
w udge t c tbei ve t t La J
, he our le s hat he w udgepr pe l dee mi d t t
o ry tr ne ha
pl n ifsph i a pr e sa enots s ve e c i r dsngl ori co bi to ast pr ve
aitf
ysc l oblm r
o e r , onsde e i y n m nai n, o e nt
pe f ma of lght lves of wo k i whih s i pe mit t c nge poston atwi12
ror nce
i e l
r n
c he s r ted o ha
ii
1.
Ho ver t c ti una et co l t t Com misone haspr pery c i r d a 1t
we , he our s bl o ncude hat he
si r
o l onsde e 1 he
e de e r l tng t pl i ifs no xe tona i pa r e s c i tng ofde e s o nn e y, nd
vi nc e a i o a ntf
ne ri l m im nt , ons si
pr s i n, xi t a
s a of m di or r The c r ntm e c r co d c nt i r por s fom t o ps c ogi t who
om t or s de .
ur e
di al e r o a ns e t r w
y hol s s

ha s e M r .Stnne tove t ls s ver ye r . Bot ps c ogit i caed t pli if
ve e n s i t
r he a t e al a s3 h y hol ss ndi t hat antf
e renc a sg fca tl lofe i ld f nc i I ed, hevocai na expe t esiid
xpe i es i nii n eve
motona ys u ton. nde t
to l
r t tfe
t t c i rngt lmia i notd i t m or r e ps hol gi a as e s e , r . i t
ha , onsde i he i t tons e n he e ec nt yc o c l s s m nt M s Stnne t

woul beuna et peror an s tnta ganf a tviy.( 76) TheAdmi srtveLaw
d
bl o f m y ubsa il i ul ci t TR .
nitai
J
udge dec i d t gi an w e g t t m or r e ps hol c l r por ,no i t t t
lne o ve y i ht o he
e ec nt yc ogi a e t tng ha he

ps hol s ha s e pl ntf on o y t oc sonsa t tt r wer i onsse esi t
yc ogit d e n ai if
nl wo ca i
nd ha he e e nc it nci n he

rpor. ( 24) Howe r t c tbeive t tt fndi fom t onl t teai
e t TR .
ve , he our le s ha he i ngs r he y wo r tng
ps hol sswhos r t a a ofr co d,a ees e i ly c it nt Stt d dif r l t
yc ogit
e epors ppe r e r r s ntal onsse . a e fe enty, he
2Theco t not
ur has undera nt consdera tonal
tke o
i ddii media evi nc s it byt pl nift t Appe s
c l de e ubm ted he aitf o he
al
Councldtrng isc i r i ofpl ntf' r que tfrr viw oft Adm i sr tveLa J e' decson.
i li t onsdeaton
ai its e s o e e
he
nitai
w udg s ii
3Thec rnta m i srtver or doesno i ud r porsfom m e a heat s ilsswho s w pl ntf
ure d nitai ec d
t ncl e e t r
ntl lh pecait
a ai if
i cor cton wihhe e rira ia i frs a s l iy be ft.
n me i
t r a le pplc tons o ocil ecz t ne is
r

4

o yt m e a he t s ilsswho ha s en M r .Stnne t a whos r porsa ecure l
nl wo nt l alh peca it
ve e
s i t, nd
ee t r
r nty
ofr co d,i c t t ts e re essg fc tlm ia i bas d on emotona dysuncto
e r ndi a e ha he xpe inc i niian i t tons e
i l f i n.
I lg oft sf c ,a gi n t tM r .Stnne twa pr vi l a r d s e e a s c t
n i ht hi a t nd ve ha s i t s e ousy wa de uppl m nt l e miy
i om ebe ft ba e on ps hi ti i par nt t c tfnds'
nc
ne is s d
yc arc m ime ,he our i '
good c us 'f r m a oft s
a e'or e nd hi
c s t t Comm isone f f t rde l
a e o he
s i r or urhe veopme a c i r ton.
nt nd onsde a i
Ass
ugge t d a
se bove t r i good r s t belevet tt r i e rirps hi ti a
, he e s
ea on o i ha he e s a le yc arc nd
ps hol gi a e de epe t ni t M r . i e t Howe r t admi sr tver or c r nty
yc o c l vi nc rai ng o s Stmz t.
ve , he
nitai ec d ure l
be or t c ti l
f e he our nc udes r pors f om onl t o ps hol s s bo h ofwhom ha tea e M r .
e t r
yw
yc ogit , t
ve r t d s
Stl e t on a r gul r bas s D r D oug a K e f r s it r por s co r ng hi t e t e of
im t
e a
i. .
l s f e ubm ted e t ve i
s r a m nt

pli iffom M a 1 2006 t M a c 5,2008. Ba ed on hi ci c eval ton,Dr Ke f r
antf r
y 6,
o rh
s
s lnial
ua i
. fe

d a n s d a j sme tds r e wih alit a d d p e sd mo d. Att e tme o h siiil
ig o e du t n io d r t r ey n e r se o
x
h i f i nt
a
e i i Dr Kefe not aG AF of42, ih hi s GA F i t pa tye ra 45. D r Ke f rs
xnm naton, . f r ed
w t ghe t
n he s a s 4 . fe '
tea m e not s i c t t t M r . Stl e' e re d sgnii a tuc ua i i he
r t nt
e ndi a e ha
s
im t xpe i nce i fc nt l t ton n r
t

s
ympt t ogy.Att tmeo hi ls c i ca not onDe e be 11,
oma ol
he i f s a t lni l e
c m r 2007, . fernot t t
Dr Ke f
ed ha
r i
t
pl ntf sove alco tonwas' bou t sme' ( 368 .M r .Stl et ceased teatngw ih
ai if r l ndii
' t he a . TR ) s im t
a
'

Dr Keferbe a e s co d no l ra f d hi s r c .
. f
c us he ul
onge for s e vies
Aboutt o ye r l tr on J nua y 1 201 M r .Stnne ts w Dr Lol Byr a he
w
a s ae , a r 2, 0, s i t a
. a d, not r
ps hol it Att tmeofi ta i er e Dr Byr pe f r e s ver lps chol ca t t .A
yc og s. he i
nii l nt viw, . d r o m d e a y ogi l ess
Be k De es i I nt r r veae am od r t lve o de e s o Bas o t t ss a he
c
pr son nve o y e ld
e ae e l f pr s i n. ed n he e t , nd r

1 Th go a a s s men off nc i ng, o GAF,su e t rpoth ci ca ' j g n o tes be ts
e lb l s e s t u toni r
i s d o e r te l ins ud me t f h u j c'
ni
oveal l lof fmc i ng.A GA F s r be wee 41 a 50 i i c tve of s i s pt sor a s rous
r l eve
t toni
co e t n
nd
s ndiai
erous ym om
ny e i
i par e i s alocc tona, sho f nci ng.Am e i nPs hiti A socito ,Dignosi a St tsial
m im ntn oci , upai lor c ol u toni
rca yc arc s ain a tc nd aitc

Ma ua o Me tl sr es48(t e .e trv 2 0 )
n l f na Diod r 4h d tx e . 0 0.

o ciia o s r ain Dr By dda n s dr c re t j rd p e so mod rt s v rt a d
wn ln c l b e v to , . r ig o e e u rn mao e r sin, eae e e i n
y,
pa c d s r r Dr Bp d not a G AF of 65. on Fe r a y 16,201 Dr Byr c pl t d a
ni i o de . .
ed
5
bur
0, . d om e e

m e ca as es me ofpl n itsm e t la lt f wo k-e aeda tvii .Dr Byr not dlmie
di l s s nt aitf' n a biiy or r r l t c i tes . d e i t d
t s rousy lm ie ca ciy f mos wo k-e ae e otonalf to . She esi e t
o e i l i t d pa t or
t r r l td m i
unc i ns
tmatd hat
pl i ifse i ldif te woul c us he t bea e 9o wo k mor t nt e tm e pt
antf motona fkuli s
d a e r o bs nt m r
e ha hr e i s r

mo h. ( 489 . As prvi l noe whe as t c ie t i c ofDr By d'
nt TR )
e ousy td, n ked o onsd r he mpa t
. rs
ps chol ca fndi ,t voc tona e r i c t d t ts h lm ia i woul r nde M r .
y ogi l i ngs he a i l xpe t ndia e ha uc i ttons
d e r s
Stnne tdi a ed f ra1 f m sofw o k.
i t s bl o 1 or
r

l he o ni t Admi sr tveLa J
n r pi on,he
nita i
w udgealonotdt tanone m i ng sa ea nc
s
e ha
xa ni tt ge y
ps hol s pr e amentl lhe l tononAprl21 2008.Thecour obs v s ho
yc ogit oduc d
a heat vaua i
i ,
t er e , weve ,
r
t tt se l tonwascomplt dbe or r c i ofDr Byr sps c ogi l t ya t r o e
ha hi vaua i
e e f e e ept
. d' y hol ca sud nd,he ef r ,
doe no r pr e a as e s e ofa 1oft m e alhe lh e de enow ofr c d.
s t e es nt n s s m nt 1 he nt at vi nc
e or
Aspr vi usy not t Adm i sr tve La J
e o l
ed, he
nita i
w udge co i r d Dr Byr sr por t be
nsde e
. d' e t o
i e aly i onsse . I i tu t tt ps hol itdi notls s cii c i ca o e vai
nt m l nc it nt t s r e ha he yc og s d
it pe fc lni l bs r tons
whi h doc e he over l di gnoss On t ot rha Dr By d di a i se va i
c
um nt r
al a i .
he he nd, . r d dm nit r rous
ps hol c t s si he ofi e, nd r e e edt r s t oft s t t i hereva ua i ofM r .
yc ogi al e t n r fc a ef r nc he e uls he e es s n
l ton
s

Stnne t c ton.M or t t poi , e on he tani a e renc Dr Byr c d be
i t' ondii
s
e o he nt bas d
r r i ng nd xpe i e, . d oul
e c e t r c ze s m pt s of de es i a al e y,wihoutlsi e c i vi l
xpe t d o e ogni y om
pr son nd rxit
t
itng a h ndi dua
obs r a i whih s
e v ton
c uppore he dignosi i es i n. Furhe mor e ptast dif rng
td r a
tc mpr so
t r e, xce
o fe i
5 A GAF s or bewe n 61 a 70 r pr s nt onl s m e m id s pom s or s e dit uly i s i ,
c e t e
nd
e ee s y o
l ym t
om
fk t n ocal
oc upatona,or s hoolf nci ng,butgenealy f nci ng prty w el w ih s
c i l
c
u toni
r l u toni
e t l, t ome m ea ngf i e pe s nal
ni ul ntr r o

r lto s i .Ameia Ps c iti Aso ito , a n si a dSaitc l n l f na Dio d r 4 (t e tx
eain hps
rcn y harc s cain Dig o tc n ttsiaMa uao Me tl s r es 7 4h d.e t
rv. 0 )
e 2 00.
6

as es me sofpl i ifsGAF, her porsofDr Byr a Dr Ke f ra ef l c it n .Bot
s s nt
antf
t e t
. d nd . fe r uly onsse t
h
ps hol s spr
yc ogit oduc d f ndi w hi h i c e t tM r .Stnne t l veloff toni i poor
e i ngs c ndi at ha s i t' e
s
unc i ng s
,

a t t s i t bl t dea wih sr s f lst tonsorm a a o it ada a i whe
nd ha he s ma e o l t te s u iuai
ke ppr pra e pt tons
n
c
ongontd wih pr e ofda l lvi
e t obl ms
iy i ng.St t dif r n l nom e alhe lh s c aitwhoha
aed fe e ty,
nt a t pe i ls
s
a t ly e
cual xami d M r .Str t ha ofe e a s esi t ts i now c pabl ofr t i
ne
s ime t s f r d ny ugg ton ha he s
a e eum ng
t r gulr wor a tviy. l s h c r um sanc s t c ti una e t c l t tt La
o e a
k c i t n uc ic t e , he our s bl o onc ude ha he w
J
udge sas e s e oft m e a hea t r pors i s
' s s m nt he nt l lh e t s uppore by s bs a i le de .
td
u t nta vi nce

The e i as wha m o ef ndame alpr e i t sc s Asnot a ve a he
r s ome t r u
nt obl m n hi a e.
ed bo , not r
Admi sr tveLa J
nita i
w udgepr vi l dee mi dt tM r . ime t e il dt s e e a
e ousy t r ne ha s Stl t was ntte o upplm nt l
s ct iy i ome be t ba e o a s t onn dior r I ha ne r be de e mi d t t
e l t nc
r
neks s d n oma of
s de . t s ve en t r ne ha
pl i ifha bee s ce sulyte t df t sc ton, t s doe not w s f rfo s h
antf s n uc s f l r a e or hi ondii or hat he s no ufe r m uc
aps hiti pr blm .Thec t ert ndst tpl i ifsne cli f s e e als ctrt
yc arc o e
our und sa ha antf
w am or upplm nt e liy
i
ncom e be ft m us s a o f l on is own m e is H o eve ,gi n t s tofc r tm s a es
ne is
t t nd r a l t
rt . w r ve he e
i c l t nc
whi h unde le t s a a , i w o d c rai y s em r as bl a a o i t f t
c
r i s hi ppe l t ul e t nl e
e ona e nd ppr pr a e or he
Com m i s o rt r c i i tf om aps hi ti ti or rt de e new he he M r . i t s il
s i ne o e e pt npu r
yc a r s n de o t nni
t r s Stnne t tl

s f r fom t pr e s whih l d t t e tbls e of s a dignoss The c r nt
ufe s r
he oblm
c e o he sa ihm nt uch
a
i.
ure
a i sr tver c dgi snos h i c tona i t cou t viw,heps hol ca e de
dm nita i e or ve
uc ndia i nd,n he r' e t yc ogi l vi nce
s
whih doese s i t c r ntr c dt ndst s ppo tpli tf sc am ofdia lt
c
xit n he ure e or e
o u r a n if l i
s biiy.
Ont ohe ha a as umi t tM r . i t d no e re es em o ede pl
he t r nd, nd s ng ha s Stnne t oes t xpe inc om
r e y
r t d ps a rc co t o w hi h pr
oo e ychi t i ndii n
c oduc physca s m pt s t r i s er a on t be i ve
es
i l y om , he e s om e s o le

t the e ina c tons ma be s j t co r t oug a oprae me a he t
ha r moto l ondii
y
ubed o ntol hr h ppr it ntl alh
7

te t e . I e i he a s s ntofpl ntf sm e t a lt f wor r l t d a tviy,Dr
r am nt nde d, n r s es me
ai if
n al biiy or k-e a e c i t
.
Byr de i t of e any opi on a t w he he t s rous lm ia i w e e pr e des t
d clned o f r
ni s o
t r he e i
i t tons r es nt pie

te t nt orwhehe t pr e c dbee cedt pess i tniey.( 488) Thus
r ame ,
t r he oblms oul
xpe t o rit ndei tl TR
.
,
f t de l e i nec s a y t as e t i whet r M r . Stnne t has m e t dur ton
urher ve opm nt s
e s r o c ran
he
s i t
t he
ai

r quie nt e t bls dunde t Ac f re il nt obe is Gi na lhes cr lm sa es
e r me s sa ihe
r he t o ntteme t neft . ve 1 t e icz t nc ,
t c tbe ivest tt r i ' d c e'f r mand oft sca e t t Comm isone f
he our le
ha he e s '
goo aus ' or e
hi s o he
s i r or
f t rde l pm e and c i r ton.
urhe ve o nt
onsde a i
For t r a ons saed,t c r fnds '
he e s
t t he ou t i
'
good c us 'f r m a of t s c s t t
a e' or e nd
hi a e o he
Comm isone f f rhe de opme a c i r ton. An a o it or rwilbe e e ed
s i r or u t r vel
nt nd onsde a i
ppr pra e de l
ntr
t sda Upon r m a bot s de w ilbe alow e t pr s nta tona e de e a a g e .
hi y.
e nd, h i s l
l d o e e ddii l vi nc nd r um nt

l t Comm isone i t bl t de i t sc ei pl i ifsf vor ba e on t e si r co d,
f he
s i r s ma e o c de hi as n antf a , s d he xitng e r
a m a be s e nt d by a to me a heat e de e,heComm isone wilconduc a
s y uppl me e
ddii nal nt l lh vi nc t
si r l
t
ne a i s r tve he i
w dm nit a i
arng.
The Cl r i die t d t s nd ce tf e c esoft sopi on t a1 c
ek s rce o e
rii d opi
hi ni o l ouns ofr c d.
el e or

DAT D:T i l t dyo ln ,0 2
E hs x * a f u e2 1.

Chi fUnie Stt DititJ
e
t d a es src udge

8