Miller v. Zych

Filing 4

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 06/27/2011. (kab)

@ = m OFFI t..DI eotr r
CE ls R
l
A DANML VA
T
LE,

F
1

JN ?2 j
U.
.u
IN '-1F UN ITED ST ATES DIS-- I T C O U R T
II x
IR C
FO 1 r -E W lX IEI D IST RI T O F VIR G IN I
4 rll
CS'q tN
C
A
R O AN O K E 1 1SlO N
)lV
I BE1 I E-tO
4-- IlIAN M lluutl
l l t,
r
Pl ntff
ai i

W AR DEN ZY f> ,
II
Defendant.

)
)
)
'
)
)
)
)
'

J
UL

E%

o û c
w

Ci lA c i N o.7: - vvi ton
11 c 00290

M EM O R AN DU M O PI I N
N O
By: l on.Jac on L.K i er
'
I
ks
s
Seni U nied St es D i ri Judge
or
t
at
st ct

lo ctlta M ilr afd rlimaep o e tngp o s ,ie a tnu t Or e'tâ l
t b r th n Ie, e ea n t r c el r e fld n û j nci d r'h t
i
l
ve
c tueasa cvi rght e
onsr
i l i s ompli pul ua t Bi nsv. x UnknownN a
a nt - nt o ve
s
Si
med Az nt ofFe r l
e s
de a

Bur a ofNae is, I. 388( 971, t j iditonvese i 28U. C.j l .Plitf
eu
rote 403 . S.
J
1 ) wih urs ei
td n
S.
331 anif
na esast e s e cel
m
l ol l kndantW a de Zyc o t l nie St t Pe t nt a y i Lee Coun y,
n
r n
h f he t d a es nie i r n
t

Vigni (tJ 1e '.'hi mate i beor mtf s re ng, s n t 28U. C.j1 A.
r i a 'tSP -e' l s tr s f e l or ce ni purua t o
) S. 915
Afe r e ngpl ntf' sl s i ldimist aci wihoutprj c f rfii t saea
tr eviwi ai iès bbmison, s s he ton t
eudie o alng o tt
cl i u
a m pon whi h r i m a be gr nt d.
c elef y
a e

ll i i iale s t f l ng t e s i hi c -pl i t Pl i ifw ilbe flng a Bi pns
'a ntf- l ge he olowi - t n s ol a n . a ntf l
a
n
ii
y
a ton i t nea fttr aierhe ex us shi a i s r tve r e e asr qui e by 42 U .S.
c i n he r ttle '
t
ha t s dm ni ta i em di s c r d
C.

j)
997e() Pl ntf rquessa ij tont)prve USP Leesaffom bl ki hi a lt t
a . ai if e t n n unci ( e nt
tf r
oc ng s biiy o
e us hi a i sr tver medi .1 ecli st tsaf o nhi m ala es e t at r ys
xha t s dm nita i e
es 1 am ha t f pc s i ddr s d o to ne ,
U nied St es Ator
t
at
t neys.Congrcss- ann a t Bu e u01Prs '(l
l
n
nd he r a : ions $ ' sld- lntc
BOP' i Ata i
)

Re onall ie t ' O fs e. Pl ntf f t rc pl nst the i i s gr t on be us of
gi
l r c or s tc
ai i f ur he om ai ha
s n e ega i
ca e
i tt i
ns iutonalconqi i som e (fwhi ar vald and ot s ar f i ed.
-etons,
)
ch e i
her e abrcat
Pl ntI l aied li t tcl l sand adl i st'ti cl m st t D epartuentofJ tce
ai i)-' l 's or ain
l
n
- ni l tve ai o he
n
l
l
us i

(û ' and at nie St e Atol y' Ofs . t S1 Lc saf c i cae f mspl ntf
i
DOJ'
)
t d ats t ' s lce . ) e t f onts td or
ne
)
ai if

RK

l

i e d t il w ih t D O J be aus t f y sw e e a l ge y U ni o m Com m e c a Code
nt nde o 5 t t he
)
c e he o m
r le dl
fr
r il

(t
ûUCC')Ien dtc - nt . Pl i i-aleg h ne dst edoeume st fl i c 'a
' i lul s antf l es e e hes
ne
f
nt o ie n oul nd
t
a i s r i pr e ngs Pl ntI ha no r c ve t s doc e sbac a t rt rs i ur
dm ni tatve oc edi . ai iT s t e ei d he e um nt
k f e hei e z e.
Pl i ifs e t I ' doc e st W a de Zyc afe hi convi ton,a Zyc s i he i
a ntf how d he J
CC
um nt o r n
h tr s
ci
nd
h ad
s
no a a t r y a pl iRifs
t n t o ne nd a lt f houl a l i sr tve y a
d d - ni t a i l ppea hi co c i
n
l s nvi ton.
U sl Lee t cied pl nt f f vi atng an i ttli
à
hen t
ai i f or ol i
nsittonalr e f pos
ul or sessi U cc-len
ng
i

doc e s a t l pl nt 1* r tcs t y wer notI C( doc e s. Pl ntf w a c c e a
um nt lhtugh ai i1 a g l he
e
. - um nt
J >
ai if s onvi t d nd
i a i s r i el a alng t i tt i lc
s dm ni tatv y ppe i he ns iutona onvi ton. U SP Le s e nty c r d a
ci
e ubs que l ha ge nd
convi ed pl nt f w ih atem ptng t ext tand t
ct
ai if t t
i o or
hreat Unied St es Ator
en t
at
t neys i G eor a.
n
gi

U SP Le s af alo cha ge pl i i fw ih t -at a i ol e. Pl ntf a isguitt t
e t f s
r d a ntf t ht s nd ns enc
e
ai if dm t
l o he

i olncec r butar st hedi nott ea e saf' USP Leesa fconvit d pl i ifoft
ns e
ha ge
gue hat
d
hr t n t f
.
tf
c e antf he
cha ge ,s c h i a i s r tvel a alng. t Sl l e s a fc r a co c e pl ntf
r s vhi h e s dnnni ta i y ppe i
J à - e t f ha ged nd nvi t d ai if

(fseai lb ar books butpl î ifa guest thi c l t c es e t t a ta pli tf
) t lng i r y
,
antf r
ha s elmae onf s d o he c nd a n if
shoul nothave been convi ed.
d
ct

Asars toft Dicplneleai Ofie (C)lO' tndi pli ifguit oft e
e ul he s i i - rng fc r k - ' ' ng antf ly hes
l
1 1 )i
c
onvi o ,U SP Ie s a lpl c d pt i i fi a s ec alhous ng uni t tlm is hi a lt t
di ns
- e t f- a e a ntf n p i
i
t ha i t s biiy o
c m uni at w ih t pubrc. Pl i i- a sle npl nsaboutt e c ot he hast w e r t
om
c e t he
i. a nt (- l t ol ai
1
h l hes
o a , he

be ng hc r c ve t i ufq i amountoft t pa t ort h po rher ceves t dit
ddi
e ei d, he ns lcent
oo h se 00t wde
e i , he ry
t l ,t l ofr ng l cri s t lm ied t ephone cals, t s e loft uni, a k of
oiet he ack eadi nat al, he i t el
l he m l he t l c
acces t pers
so
onalpr
opery,and st l t
t
af's hreat ofharm .
s
Pl ntf ' ant t s ar erlqi ehar agai tI Lee st f.Pl ntf r
ai if w s o t t in nal
ges
ns -JSP
af
ai i f equest asr i
s elef

t be t
o ransf r fom t speei housi uni and f ol U SP lee and t r ve hi pers
br ed r
he
al
ng t
r'
n
o ecei
s
onal

pr ry. Pa adoxialy- ai îfs hcdtesnttst Itga i butwa st hi te t nt'o
ope t
r
e ) pl ntf ays
l l k ii ton
ek
nt s s r a me 't
t

lm us di n i sa ac i 01c a m fl d by a i at i 1det r i t t a ton o
t s z s ny ton - l i ' e
i
n nm e f
e nane hat he c i r

'1e fr ts a r i l s c ai sba e
l1 è s t nda d nc ude l m
'
sd
upon û 1 i s abl l rte s l lt y, i a m s01i r nge e ofa l gali e es w hi h
t 4 ndi put y ne il s ega heor ' i i
a
' cl
*nf i m nt
e nt r t c
cl ry doesnotcxi t' (rcl na ' her t e Cf ct lcont ntonsa e c ea l bas e s ' N eizke v.
ea l
s ,' ) ai s w e h sa ua
e i
r l ry el s .
' t

W ila ,490t. 31 327( 989 .Thes con salda- i t fmiirsa r f amotont
lims
.S. 9,
/
1 )
e d t a l s he a la tndad or
d
i o

dimisundt' r Rul ofCi lPr edue l b)6) a e ptngt pli ifsfdua
s s
u Fedcal e -vi oc r 2( ( , c e i he antf a l
a l aton a t ue A c pl ntnee t s tan pl n s a e e oft c a m s i t tt
leg i s s r . om ai
ds k hor d ai t t m nt he l i how ng ha he
a

pl de i entte t r i 'a s lce ûI- t lalgai ...t r s arghtt r i abo
ea r s ild o clel' nd uls int tll ua le tons o aie i o elef ve
ae
t s ul i lvel.... lelAt.Cor v.Twombl 550U. 5 555(
he pec atve e
' 3 1 l p.
'
v,
S. 44,
2007)(nt na
i er l
quottonmaksomitd) A pli ipsba i frr ifkrquiesmor t nlbesa
ai
r
te . antf
ss o ele se r
e ha a l nd
c usons....- l -- r or t pli i) mus i le t t s fcintt sa eal t
oncl i
' d. lhe ef e, he antt- t - lge àcs ufi e o tt l he
a

eimens01jhe cain. las v.71 DupontdeNe a s& Co.324F. 761 765( hCi.
e t -t l l l ' 3 s 1..
-'
6
p our
,
3d ,
4t r
2003)
.
lov ev ,de e n i i vhe he acon pl ntsatsapl usbl c am f r le i $a
- / er t r nn ng v t r
l
n ai t e
a i e l i or e if s :

cone -pecGcts t lquie t t viwi eo tt dlw onisj da e re .a
txts , a k hat' ls hc ' e ug ur o i
e '
e
a
t udi l xpeinc nd
e
com m on s
ense.' A s çf v.l ,
' hcrlt gbal

- -

U.
S.

- .
-

,

1 S. .1937,1 ( a 18,2009 .Thus a
29 Ct
950 M y
)
,

cour s c ni ae
t cre ng ompli unde Rul 1 1)6)t n i ntl pla ngst taeno e il t a
ant r e 243( r de ik e di ha r t ntted o n
a
a s pton oftut be aus t y c i tofno m or t n l l a c l i . 1 A lhough 1
s um i
r h c c he ons s
e ha abe s nd onc us ons d. t

lber l cons rt pr se com pl nt Il i v.kene 404I. 51 5 21( 972) 1donota t
i aly
t te o
ai s, -q nes l r s
.S. 9, 20- 1 ,
J
c
-

-

ast i at sadvocat yua spont devel ng st tt y and consiutonalcl m st i a e
he nm e'
e,
e
opi at lor
tt i
ai he nm t

f ldt ceal rie01tef eoft conpl nt elmckv.Car l 1 F. 241, ( h
hie o l ry as 4 h ùc he l ai .Se 3
rol, 07 3d
243 4t
Ci.1 97)(-ti J,c l i ;Be ult. CiyofLll on,775F. 1 1 ( h Ci.
r 9 1utg, . olcunng) a retv. t
aupt
2d 274, 278 4t r

cot t a enote c e t as um et r eo1a oc e f t pr s pl i if .
zs r
r
xpe t d o s
he ol * dv at br he o e antf)
-0 s a e a cl i u rBi
1 tt
'
a m nde vensv.Si t nknow n Nam e A ce sofFe r lBur a of
x l
d
nt
de a
eu

Na co i s 403I . 388(1 l ,apl i ifmus ale t tade e nti af de a ag ntwho
r tc ,
JS.
97 ) antf
t lge ha
f nda s e r l e
ac ed u rt e c orofa hort and e ge i u o tt i
t nde h ol
ut iy
nga d n nc ns iutonalc
onduc . H ow e r pl i if
t
ve , a ntf

f ist saea y cam a an th s l d fn a ta dr l so c ncuso a dlg l ag nt
al o tt n li g i s te o e ee d n n ei n o l ins n e a jr o o
e
co tt t a cl i . A Bi
ns iu e a m
vens cl i nr qtiesa s l i otpc s lf ul on t pa tofa
an e l
r
hlw ng - r ona a t he r
de enda eih ba e on t def nda ' pe s alc
f
nt t er s d
he e nt s r on onduc ora he ' c
t not r s onducti exe uton of
n c i

t d e ntsp i esorctstl
he ef nda ' olci
ltl
ms.Se Fihe v.Wts nct M e r ia Ar a Tr nst
e s r ' a hi on topolt n e a i
Aut r,690 1. 1 ll l! 43 ( t Ci.l 2) a ogatd o ot rgr
ho .
72: 33. 42- 4 h r 9S . bx o n he oundsb Cnt o
y y. f
Ri r i v.M cla i 5 U. 44 ( 99l .Se as la m e v. e n,511U . 8 8
ve sde
-ughln, 00 S. l ) e lo - r r Br nna
'
S. 25, 39-

40 (99 (i ngt tta etw i yi j1 camsi a i bl i Bi nsa ons a vi
1 4) fndi ha rs a nvol ng 983 li s pplca e n ve di , nd ce
ve s ) Pli iff l t ma t ss nga ns t d bnda .Pli ifmeel al st the
r a. antf ais o ke hi howi gai the el nt antf r y lege ha
s e t t det ntt c do ent t e us d li i tt tonaleo d i a l rhe w a
how d o he bnda hk tum s hat a e n s ns iu i
nvi on f e
s
ale dy t l gL ly (1t e c ge E e lndan c l n ove t n t co c i ast ta hort
r a btnd l t )- h har . l f
i
z
t ou d ot rur he nvi ton ha ut iy

i ve td i a he ofi al Se 28C.7 j5 1l (eq rnga a ofi tt i lc nviton
s se n not r teî . e
1.
R. 4 .9 r uii ppe l nsiutona o ci
byaDH( t)beappe lddie l t t a o it 1(1 Re o lOflc ) Furhemor,
)(
ae rcty o he pprprae 3) à gina t e . t r e
)

4

ot
e ca ed y
he heor
es
at
super sor labiiy tnder: 1
vi y i lt t
%
. 983 m ay n bc pr di t onl on t t y ofr pondc
,
s l or.
tperi

Pl nt1-)ist esabls t d i ton ofa b i huma ne d ort def nda '
ai i7f 1 o t ih he eprva i
- q
1
asc
n e
he e nts

dei r t i fkrnce.sq W isl v.Seie,5(1U . 294,298, ( 991 .W he c rci
lbeae ndil e
-- tt
q
n
tr ) S.
303 1 )
n ore tonal
pers
onnelm ake com m ent t m ay eols iut ver abuse (rhar m ent t
s hat
ltt e bal
) ass
, hose com m ent al
s one

do notrs t t l velofan Ei ht A m e
i c o he e
g h
ndm e vi a i See Coli v.Cund 603 F. 825,
nt ol ton.
lns
v,
2d

827( 0hCi.1 ,ctd fvorbl i Moodyv.Grle,885F. 865( hCi.1 (a e
1 t r 979) ie a a y n,
tv
2d
4t r 989) tbl)
( publs (ttnga ageneal ul t tveba ab eofi tsbyg r , t mor
un ihed) sai s
r r e ha r t us nmae
uads wihout e,
doe notsat aconsittonalcai ) Pl i ifa s f ist des rbehow t c lng t hi
s
te
ttli
l m . antf lo a l o c i
he hale es o s

dicplnayc ei woul n beba edbyle tv.
s i i r onvitons
d ot n'
l cl Humphe 51 U. 477, ( 994)
ry, 2 S. 487 1 .
SeeEdwaçsv.laiok,520 t. 641( 997)( di Ie a ple t as tt tal d
rl 3ls
S.
l
hol ng - ck p is o ui ha lege
l
c tt i lfa i prsl dici i r pr e les .ll ntf f l t a lgeany s t i d
onsiutona l ws n itn s plna y oc dtr ) 3ai if ais o le
usa ne
See Lew i v.Cas 518 U . 343,
s
ev,
S.

35 (l .li l'aditi,c tma noti tt eermi lc r bas o apl di fom
0 996) 7nal), src our y nsiut î na hages ed n ea ng r
t
an i cer ed,pr se pl nt f
ncar at
o
ai if

1 1t et e on ra o s ld snist ea to Ni o tp eudc , rua tt 2 U. C.
7 -h br g ig e s n , il s h ein vt u rj ie pu s n o 8 S.
0
h
j1 1 b) 1,f fii t saeaclin uponwhiir ill ybegrntd9 5A( () or alng o tt al
'
cn ele-na
a e l
1Pli ifi advie tathe h atIas t kenon ha sci lc pl nsora l pr vi l dim is d a
antf s
sd h
ad e t hrl
- bea vi om ait
ppeas e ousy s s e s
hi ol s orf f lng t sat a kl l up w hi r lfI a bf gr ct d, See, R.( il v.Unied Stt .e a.
-v ou
br aii o t e ;ai on ch ele ' y z a e
m
n
e, ,M ler
t aes t l,

No.l I 7(l11(i.Ieb.9,2(lI (
0- 543 t 7r '
A.
) ) appea! s is d a fi ousa e iel wihou mert; ilrv.Unied
dim s e s rvol nd ntr y t t il Nfle
t
St e .e q: No l l)c - 2 9 ( .) (a ( c . 9 2 l )( s s e a lg l fi o o sa to l M ilr v.Sc i t
at s t .4 . :( v 0 9 6 N 1. 1 . l t 2 , 0 0 dimis d s e a l rv l u cin ' le
J
y
,
hm d ,
No. :0 c - 128( , . . t . 1 2)0 ( imisdwrhpeu eto lc o s betmatr uidcin ;
l1 -v0 1 N D Ga St 2) (l) ds se i rj ditfr a k f u jc te j rs ito l
pt ,
t
.

-

M il rv.Njktj g.No.I0 -v 01 0 ( , . . uy2 2)0 (rligamoint ds s wihp eu iea d
Ie
l - . ),
i .k
at
.
:9 c - 7 0 N D Ga J l - (I ) galn
t
to o imis t rj dc n
fn ng t e ac i bs i a i e a l cki ilI erttst esabts t e eol pl e l ,k o afdea t n r e s ' .
idi h ton - o l us bt ud a ng l ' i ' o t ih h - et ac f e l t o tov r y'
npl
'u t
n
)
-

'1c Cl k i die ed t)s d eo e oft sm c l a um opi on a t ac ompa ng
lA er s r ct ( en pis hi n or nd
'
ni nd he c
nyi
or rt pl ntf
de o ai if
1fN --:l ' '?' I1 k'lhi
(
e

'r day o1Jtne,201l.
- l
*:
!
!

.-,. .. . . .
.,. . .. .

Seni U nied St t s Di t i tJ
o
t
a e s rc udge