Hall v. DLC Management Corporation et al

Filing 18

MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER denying 4 Motion to Dismiss. Signed by Judge James C. Turk on 10/14/2011. (rkc)

CLERK' OFFI U., ST.
:
C: 8 DI COURT
ATROANOKE,
VA
FI
LED

ûCT 1i 2 1
91
I TH E U N I
N
TED STA TES D I
STRI CO UR T
CT
FO R TH E W ESTERN DI
STR I O F V I G I I
CT
R N A
ROA N OK E D I I ON
V SI

J A C.DUDQ X CL
ULI
Y ERK r
BY;

R EBEC CA J.H ALL ,
C aseN o.7: v11-c 298
Pl ntf ,
ai if

M EM O R AN D UM O PI O N
NI
A ND O R D ER
'

DLC M A N A G EM EN T C O RPO R ATIO N
a
nd
D ELH A I A M ER ICA ,l C .
ZE
N ,

By: Jam es C .Turk
Se or U nied St e Di t i tJudge
ni
t
at s s r c

Def nda s
e nt .

Beor t Cour i Dee a DehazeAmei l (i l z '' Motont Dimis
f e he
t s fnd nt l i
rca nc.k haie' s i o s s
De
l
purua t Fe r Rul ofCi lPr dur 1 b)6 ( No. . antf flda Opposton
s nto deal e
vi oce e 2( () ECF 4)Pli if ie n
ii
( No.1 .A he rngwashedonSe e r29, 1.Thematri now rpef
ECF
2)
ai
l
ptmbe 201
te s
i or
diposii
s ton.

Upon r vi w oft pa te 'a gu e s D e ha ze' M oton t D i m i s i DEN I
e e
he ri s r m nt , l i s
i o s s s
ED.

Backzround

Pl i tf fl d he Com pl i ton J 27,201 a l gi s s i
a n if ie r
an
une
1, le ng he lpped a f l i a pa ki 1 a
nd e l n
r ng ot t
Sout e tPl z a t c ne ofEl c rc Road a Gr ndi Road i Roa
hw s a a t he or r
e ti
nd a n
n
noke,Vi gi a on
r ni

De e r3 , 0 9 P an ifalg si h rCo an t a t s b e tp r i ltwa o wd
c mbe 0 2 0 . litf le e n e mplit h the u j c akng o s m
a ma ge byDee ntDLC Mana me Cor r i Ct '.Pli iff t ralege
nd na d
fnda
ge nt poaton DLC') antf urhe l s
t D el ze r ed pr
hat hai ent
opert att Sout es Pl St i m al t oper e a Food Li gr y
y he
hw t aza rp
lo
at
on ocer

s or Pl i ifs a e i he Com pl i t to D e e be 30,
t e. a ntf t t s n r
a nt ha n c m r 2009, s H a lw ast de e nt '
M . l
he f nda s
i t e a ass h ha t r g t a s et def nda t 'pa ki l w a r s bl s f O n
nvie nd
uc d he i ht o s um he e n s r ng ot s ea ona y a e.
l

De e r30,
c mbe
2009, s Halwal d t ough t pa ki ltt r t Food Li e r nc On
M . l ke hr
he r ng o owa d he
on nta e.

he wa t t e rnc ,s si dont ac ie'a flt t gr
r y o he nta e he lppe
û k c ' nd el o he ound,n urnghe s f The
bl
ij i rel

i tn a to ao efo t s ij re .
nsa t ci n r s r m ho e nu is
Pli ifalgest tdeenda s()owe he adut t us odi r caet ha t
antf le ha f nt 1
d r y o e r nay r o ve he
paki l pr miesi aras bl s ec ton'( o dheradut t war herofalunsf
r ng ot e s n e ona y af ondii , 2) we
yo n
l ae
c tonsi ispa ki l pr s sofwhih t de e nt kne orby t us ofor na y
ondii n t r ng ot emie
c he f nda s w,
he e
di r

c r s o l h v k o ( )o dhe ad t t u eo dn r c r t rmo ef r ino j csfo
ae h ud a e n wn; 3 we r uy o s r iay ae o e v o eg be t r m
t paki l prmie wihi ara ona etme;a ( owe heradut t us or nayc r t
he r ng ot e s s t n e s bl i nd 4) d
y o e di r ae o
r m ove t na ur a um ul to ofi e ors
e
he t al cc
a in c
now f om t pa ki l w ihi a r a ona e tm e
r he r ng ot t n e s bl i
a t rt s o m e
fe he t r nded.
I
1.

Di
scussi
on

A c pl ntm us i ude a s ta pl i s a e e oft c ai unde whi h t
om ai
t ncl
hor nd a n t t m nt he l m
r c he

pl de i e ildt r if Fe R. v. 8()2) Unde t noi pl di sa r
ea r s ntte o ele . d. Ci P. a( .
r he tce ea ng tndad
e pl d by t f r c t , pl i ifne d onl (g ve t de e ntnotce ofwha t
m oye
he ede al our s a a ntf e
y l i he f nda
i
t he

cli i ... ndt gr
am s a he oundsuponwhihir t. Erc onv. r ,551U. 89,9 (
c t ess' iks Padus
'
S. 3 2007)
(ii BelAt. . Twombl 550U. 5 5 ( ) l consdei amoto t
ctng l lCop v.
y,
S. 44, 55 2007). n i rng
in o
dimisunderRul 1 b)6) t Co ti oblg tdt a ce tastuealoft c ai '
s s
e 2( ( ,he ur s iae o c p r 1 he ompl nts
f cua a lga i a t t f c si t lg m os f r bl t t pl i if Gira a v.
a t l le tons nd ake he a t n he i ht t avo a e o he antf . a r t no

J on,521F. 298 302( h Ci. ) I or rt s vi amoint dimis ho ve ,
ohns
3d , 4t r2008 . n de o ur ve to o s s, we r a
c mplitsifa t lalgai mus bee ht riearg t rlefa t s ultve
o an ' d lcua le tons t noug o as iht o ei bove he pec ai
g
l -' Bel A t. 550 U . at555.
evel'
l l,
S.

A tis c e t sca e i not ng bu a r i si a f l ac i The pl i ifa l gest t
t or , hi s s hi
t outne lp nd a l ton.
a ntf le
ha
s w a D e ha ze' i t e a t ts si
he s l i s nvie , nd ha he lpped a f l i t pa ki l w hie on he w a t
nd e l n he r ng ot l
r yo

2

t Foo Li gr e y s o e o r t d by Del i . De ha ze c er t tPl i i ff l i c
he d on oc r t r pe a e
ha ze
l i ount s ha a ntf e l n ode enda D LC ' pa ki l , rw hi h D e hai e ha no c r ,a t tt r i not ng i
f nt
S r ng ot ove
c
l z d
ont ol nd ha he e s hi n
t Pl i if s c pl nti c i D e ha z e row e he a du y ofc r . Se ond,D e ha z
he a ntf om ai ndi atng l i e ve
d r
t
ae c
l ie
a gue t te n i i di ow e Pl n ifa dut i w o d notha di co e t bl ck i e t tt
r s ha ve f t d
ai t f
y, t ul
ve s ver d he a c ha he
Pl i i falege y s i d on us ng a or na y dut ofc r and t t c pl ntf l t
a ntf l dl lppe
i n di r
y
a e,
hus he om ai ais o
a l ge Del i br ac d is dut
le
ha ze e he t y.
l i t ue t tt Pl i if s c pl i i nott m os a tuly dr f e pl adi t sCoul
t s r ha he a ntf om a nt s
he
t rf l a t d e ng hi
'
t

hase rs e ThePl ntf doe no s par t o iscai a i te c oft def nda s
ve e n.
ai if s t e ae ut t l ms gans a h he e nt,
i t a l pi t m i t t ra m a ng ge r la l a i ofdut br c and ca e. l i
ns e d um ng he n oge he nd ki
ne a leg tons
y, ea h,
r ts
al o tue t tPl ntf ne r a l s a s ii d y b e c by D el i e, he t n t f c
s r ha ai i f ve lege pec fc ut r a hed
ha z ot r ha he a t

t tissor wa i t s
ha t t e s n he hoppi c ntrwheet Plitf fl.Howe ,ona1 b)6)moin,
ng e e r he anif el
ver
2( ( to
a Pl i if s c pl i ne d notbe pe f ct i m us sm pl c ai û noug f c st s a e a cl i
a ntf om a nt e
r e ; t t i y ont n û
e
h a t o tt
am
t r i ft ti pl usbl on is f c ' Be lAt. 550 U . a 570. Her ,Pl i i faleg t ts
o ele ha s a i e t a e.
' l l,
S. t
e a ntf l es ha he
w as an i t ofD el ze'i
nviee
hai , ndeed,s wasatt s
he
he hoppi pl becaus s want t shop at
ng aza
e he
ed o

D e ha z s Food Li s or l i pos i e t tD e hai e o e no dut t t Pl i if Butt
l i e'
on t e. t s sbl ha l z w d
y o he a ntf .
he
Cour c nnotde e m i t ta t s s a oft pr e ngs Pl ntf sa e t be gi n a l ng
ta
t r ne ha t hi t ge he oc edi . ai i f r o
ve o
l as a t pl a ng sage ast f de alc t r l t lbe a d s ove y r e and s m a y
e h t he e di t , he e r ours e y i i r l i c r ul s
on
um r

j
udgme moinst detnediputdfcsa is sandt dipos ofun rt i cai .'
nt to o i s e a t nd sue
o s e
meiorous l ms'
Swir e c v.SormaN. ,5 U. 5 51 ( ) Dehaiema bea et s c e ona
ekiwiz
e
A. 34 S. 06, 2 2002 . l z y bl o uc e d

s
ummayj
r udgme motona as e ntsa i t pr ee ngs butt r i note ht
nt i t ubsque tge n he oc di , hee s noug o
di m i st sa ton he e. Upo a r vi oft a l ga i i t c pl i ,t Cour fndst t
s s hi c i
r
n e ew
he le tons n he om a nt he
t i ha

3

t Pli ifma outaplusbl cli a i tDe e ntDel i a dec i st dimist
he antf kes
a i e am ga ns f nda
haze nd lne o s s he
c pl n a t stm e.
om ai t t hi i l

11 C oncl i
1.
uson

Fort r a onssatd a ,Del ie' Moto t Dimis( No.4)i DENI
he e s t e bove haz s in o s s ECF
s
ED.
The Cl r i die t d t t a m i c pi oft s o derand o ni n t a 1c
e k s r c e o r ns t o es hi r
pi o o l ouns lofr co d.
e
e r

E E T i / dyo Oc br2 1.
NT R: hs Y a f t e,0 1
o
e o Unied St t D i ti
ni r t
a es s r c

dge

'Asno e a e, De hai a s ar
t d bov
l ze l o guest tbec us t Pl ntf aleg t bl c i e w a no a o n and obvi
ha a e he ai if l es he a k c s t n pe
ous
condii s ca
ton, he nnotaleget tDel z hasbr c isduy.Unde Vigi apr s sIabiiy I onewho
l ha
haie
ea hed t t
r r ni emie i lt aw,
exe cs c r ove apr iesû
r ies ontol r em s t
owest i tet dut t us o di r c et m ai ai t pr m iesi a
he nvie he y o e r nay ar o nt n he e s n
r a ona y s ec to a unl sada r c ton i ope andobvi ,hei tehast rgh t a s e
e s bl af ondiin, nd, es
nge ous ondii s n
ous t nvie
he i t o s um

t a t ep e s sa ei s c c n iin. Ro lt W a Rik , n . S t , 3 S. .d 1 7 1 ( .1 7 )
h t h r mie r n u h o d to ' l R' v n s l c v. mih 2 7 E 2 5 , 61 Va 9 7
'
( i t n o t d .Th fc t a t blc iewa n ta p r n t t ena e e ea t etmeo t eP an ifsfl
ct i mit ) e a t h t he a k c s o p a e t o h k d y t h i f h litf al
ao
e
doesno f e os a c z e c a m undert l w .
t or cl e ogni abl l i
he a