Hall v. DLC Management Corporation et al

Filing 18

MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER denying 4 Motion to Dismiss. Signed by Judge James C. Turk on 10/14/2011. (rkc)

Download PDF
CLERK' OFFI U., ST. : C: 8 DI COURT ATROANOKE, VA FI LED ûCT 1i 2 1 91 I TH E U N I N TED STA TES D I STRI CO UR T CT FO R TH E W ESTERN DI STR I O F V I G I I CT R N A ROA N OK E D I I ON V SI J A C.DUDQ X CL ULI Y ERK r BY; R EBEC CA J.H ALL , C aseN o.7: v11-c 298 Pl ntf , ai if M EM O R AN D UM O PI O N NI A ND O R D ER ' DLC M A N A G EM EN T C O RPO R ATIO N a nd D ELH A I A M ER ICA ,l C . ZE N , By: Jam es C .Turk Se or U nied St e Di t i tJudge ni t at s s r c Def nda s e nt . Beor t Cour i Dee a DehazeAmei l (i l z '' Motont Dimis f e he t s fnd nt l i rca nc.k haie' s i o s s De l purua t Fe r Rul ofCi lPr dur 1 b)6 ( No. . antf flda Opposton s nto deal e vi oce e 2( () ECF 4)Pli if ie n ii ( No.1 .A he rngwashedonSe e r29, 1.Thematri now rpef ECF 2) ai l ptmbe 201 te s i or diposii s ton. Upon r vi w oft pa te 'a gu e s D e ha ze' M oton t D i m i s i DEN I e e he ri s r m nt , l i s i o s s s ED. Backzround Pl i tf fl d he Com pl i ton J 27,201 a l gi s s i a n if ie r an une 1, le ng he lpped a f l i a pa ki 1 a nd e l n r ng ot t Sout e tPl z a t c ne ofEl c rc Road a Gr ndi Road i Roa hw s a a t he or r e ti nd a n n noke,Vi gi a on r ni De e r3 , 0 9 P an ifalg si h rCo an t a t s b e tp r i ltwa o wd c mbe 0 2 0 . litf le e n e mplit h the u j c akng o s m a ma ge byDee ntDLC Mana me Cor r i Ct '.Pli iff t ralege nd na d fnda ge nt poaton DLC') antf urhe l s t D el ze r ed pr hat hai ent opert att Sout es Pl St i m al t oper e a Food Li gr y y he hw t aza rp lo at on ocer s or Pl i ifs a e i he Com pl i t to D e e be 30, t e. a ntf t t s n r a nt ha n c m r 2009, s H a lw ast de e nt ' M . l he f nda s i t e a ass h ha t r g t a s et def nda t 'pa ki l w a r s bl s f O n nvie nd uc d he i ht o s um he e n s r ng ot s ea ona y a e. l De e r30, c mbe 2009, s Halwal d t ough t pa ki ltt r t Food Li e r nc On M . l ke hr he r ng o owa d he on nta e. he wa t t e rnc ,s si dont ac ie'a flt t gr r y o he nta e he lppe û k c ' nd el o he ound,n urnghe s f The bl ij i rel i tn a to ao efo t s ij re . nsa t ci n r s r m ho e nu is Pli ifalgest tdeenda s()owe he adut t us odi r caet ha t antf le ha f nt 1 d r y o e r nay r o ve he paki l pr miesi aras bl s ec ton'( o dheradut t war herofalunsf r ng ot e s n e ona y af ondii , 2) we yo n l ae c tonsi ispa ki l pr s sofwhih t de e nt kne orby t us ofor na y ondii n t r ng ot emie c he f nda s w, he e di r c r s o l h v k o ( )o dhe ad t t u eo dn r c r t rmo ef r ino j csfo ae h ud a e n wn; 3 we r uy o s r iay ae o e v o eg be t r m t paki l prmie wihi ara ona etme;a ( owe heradut t us or nayc r t he r ng ot e s s t n e s bl i nd 4) d y o e di r ae o r m ove t na ur a um ul to ofi e ors e he t al cc a in c now f om t pa ki l w ihi a r a ona e tm e r he r ng ot t n e s bl i a t rt s o m e fe he t r nded. I 1. Di scussi on A c pl ntm us i ude a s ta pl i s a e e oft c ai unde whi h t om ai t ncl hor nd a n t t m nt he l m r c he pl de i e ildt r if Fe R. v. 8()2) Unde t noi pl di sa r ea r s ntte o ele . d. Ci P. a( . r he tce ea ng tndad e pl d by t f r c t , pl i ifne d onl (g ve t de e ntnotce ofwha t m oye he ede al our s a a ntf e y l i he f nda i t he cli i ... ndt gr am s a he oundsuponwhihir t. Erc onv. r ,551U. 89,9 ( c t ess' iks Padus ' S. 3 2007) (ii BelAt. . Twombl 550U. 5 5 ( ) l consdei amoto t ctng l lCop v. y, S. 44, 55 2007). n i rng in o dimisunderRul 1 b)6) t Co ti oblg tdt a ce tastuealoft c ai ' s s e 2( ( ,he ur s iae o c p r 1 he ompl nts f cua a lga i a t t f c si t lg m os f r bl t t pl i if Gira a v. a t l le tons nd ake he a t n he i ht t avo a e o he antf . a r t no J on,521F. 298 302( h Ci. ) I or rt s vi amoint dimis ho ve , ohns 3d , 4t r2008 . n de o ur ve to o s s, we r a c mplitsifa t lalgai mus bee ht riearg t rlefa t s ultve o an ' d lcua le tons t noug o as iht o ei bove he pec ai g l -' Bel A t. 550 U . at555. evel' l l, S. A tis c e t sca e i not ng bu a r i si a f l ac i The pl i ifa l gest t t or , hi s s hi t outne lp nd a l ton. a ntf le ha s w a D e ha ze' i t e a t ts si he s l i s nvie , nd ha he lpped a f l i t pa ki l w hie on he w a t nd e l n he r ng ot l r yo 2 t Foo Li gr e y s o e o r t d by Del i . De ha ze c er t tPl i i ff l i c he d on oc r t r pe a e ha ze l i ount s ha a ntf e l n ode enda D LC ' pa ki l , rw hi h D e hai e ha no c r ,a t tt r i not ng i f nt S r ng ot ove c l z d ont ol nd ha he e s hi n t Pl i if s c pl nti c i D e ha z e row e he a du y ofc r . Se ond,D e ha z he a ntf om ai ndi atng l i e ve d r t ae c l ie a gue t te n i i di ow e Pl n ifa dut i w o d notha di co e t bl ck i e t tt r s ha ve f t d ai t f y, t ul ve s ver d he a c ha he Pl i i falege y s i d on us ng a or na y dut ofc r and t t c pl ntf l t a ntf l dl lppe i n di r y a e, hus he om ai ais o a l ge Del i br ac d is dut le ha ze e he t y. l i t ue t tt Pl i if s c pl i i nott m os a tuly dr f e pl adi t sCoul t s r ha he a ntf om a nt s he t rf l a t d e ng hi ' t hase rs e ThePl ntf doe no s par t o iscai a i te c oft def nda s ve e n. ai if s t e ae ut t l ms gans a h he e nt, i t a l pi t m i t t ra m a ng ge r la l a i ofdut br c and ca e. l i ns e d um ng he n oge he nd ki ne a leg tons y, ea h, r ts al o tue t tPl ntf ne r a l s a s ii d y b e c by D el i e, he t n t f c s r ha ai i f ve lege pec fc ut r a hed ha z ot r ha he a t t tissor wa i t s ha t t e s n he hoppi c ntrwheet Plitf fl.Howe ,ona1 b)6)moin, ng e e r he anif el ver 2( ( to a Pl i if s c pl i ne d notbe pe f ct i m us sm pl c ai û noug f c st s a e a cl i a ntf om a nt e r e ; t t i y ont n û e h a t o tt am t r i ft ti pl usbl on is f c ' Be lAt. 550 U . a 570. Her ,Pl i i faleg t ts o ele ha s a i e t a e. ' l l, S. t e a ntf l es ha he w as an i t ofD el ze'i nviee hai , ndeed,s wasatt s he he hoppi pl becaus s want t shop at ng aza e he ed o D e ha z s Food Li s or l i pos i e t tD e hai e o e no dut t t Pl i if Butt l i e' on t e. t s sbl ha l z w d y o he a ntf . he Cour c nnotde e m i t ta t s s a oft pr e ngs Pl ntf sa e t be gi n a l ng ta t r ne ha t hi t ge he oc edi . ai i f r o ve o l as a t pl a ng sage ast f de alc t r l t lbe a d s ove y r e and s m a y e h t he e di t , he e r ours e y i i r l i c r ul s on um r j udgme moinst detnediputdfcsa is sandt dipos ofun rt i cai .' nt to o i s e a t nd sue o s e meiorous l ms' Swir e c v.SormaN. ,5 U. 5 51 ( ) Dehaiema bea et s c e ona ekiwiz e A. 34 S. 06, 2 2002 . l z y bl o uc e d s ummayj r udgme motona as e ntsa i t pr ee ngs butt r i note ht nt i t ubsque tge n he oc di , hee s noug o di m i st sa ton he e. Upo a r vi oft a l ga i i t c pl i ,t Cour fndst t s s hi c i r n e ew he le tons n he om a nt he t i ha 3 t Pli ifma outaplusbl cli a i tDe e ntDel i a dec i st dimist he antf kes a i e am ga ns f nda haze nd lne o s s he c pl n a t stm e. om ai t t hi i l 11 C oncl i 1. uson Fort r a onssatd a ,Del ie' Moto t Dimis( No.4)i DENI he e s t e bove haz s in o s s ECF s ED. The Cl r i die t d t t a m i c pi oft s o derand o ni n t a 1c e k s r c e o r ns t o es hi r pi o o l ouns lofr co d. e e r E E T i / dyo Oc br2 1. NT R: hs Y a f t e,0 1 o e o Unied St t D i ti ni r t a es s r c dge 'Asno e a e, De hai a s ar t d bov l ze l o guest tbec us t Pl ntf aleg t bl c i e w a no a o n and obvi ha a e he ai if l es he a k c s t n pe ous condii s ca ton, he nnotaleget tDel z hasbr c isduy.Unde Vigi apr s sIabiiy I onewho l ha haie ea hed t t r r ni emie i lt aw, exe cs c r ove apr iesû r ies ontol r em s t owest i tet dut t us o di r c et m ai ai t pr m iesi a he nvie he y o e r nay ar o nt n he e s n r a ona y s ec to a unl sada r c ton i ope andobvi ,hei tehast rgh t a s e e s bl af ondiin, nd, es nge ous ondii s n ous t nvie he i t o s um t a t ep e s sa ei s c c n iin. Ro lt W a Rik , n . S t , 3 S. .d 1 7 1 ( .1 7 ) h t h r mie r n u h o d to ' l R' v n s l c v. mih 2 7 E 2 5 , 61 Va 9 7 ' ( i t n o t d .Th fc t a t blc iewa n ta p r n t t ena e e ea t etmeo t eP an ifsfl ct i mit ) e a t h t he a k c s o p a e t o h k d y t h i f h litf al ao e doesno f e os a c z e c a m undert l w . t or cl e ogni abl l i he a

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?