Riddle v. New River Valley Regional Jail et al

Filing 5

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 6/30/2011. (tvt)

*( R 'OF IEUS DS . o
y s Ks FC .. ITC uc
AT ROANOKE,
VA
r,ED
aL

I TH E U N I ED STATE S D I
N
T
STRI T C O U R T
C
FO R TH E W ESTER N D I
STR I O F V I G I I
CT
R N A
ROANOKE DI I ON
V SI
M IC H A EL TO D D W D D LE,

JUN 82 2 1
21
J A
ULI
BY;

!DLEY CLERK
L

C i lA cton No.7:
vi
i
11CV 00304

Pl nt f ,
ai i f
M EM O M N D U M O PIM O N
V S.

N EW R I
VER V A LLEY RE G I N A L
O

JAI c & ,
L,

By: Sam uelG .W ison
l
Unied St es D i ri Judge
t
at
st ct

D ef
endant
s.

M i ha lTodd Ri e,a V igi a i a e pr e ng pr K , i e t s c vi r gh s a to
c e
ddl
r ni nm t oc edi
o t l d hi i l i t c i n

p s ntt 42U. C.j1 ale ngt twhe heco ane a utt f sr c sa t
urua o
S.
983 lgi ha
n
mpli d bo he ood evie t he

Ne Rie ValyRe in l alCs eji' , fiesif r dhi t a i h c mp an df rh r
w v r le go a J i t a1) o fc r n o me m h t f e o lie u te ,
h
'
tej i s p rne e t ul k e hm a t ej irt e ta al wi ghm t b ta serdt a
h al u e itnd n wo d e p i t h al ah r h n lo n i o e rn fre o
Vign aDe rme to Co r ci n (
r ii pat n f re to s VDOC)p io fcl y.Ridl s e t ej ia dt e
rs n a ii
t d e u s h al n h
s rnt nde ,a asr i ,he s ks onl t be t a f r e t a V D OC pr s n. The c t
upe i e nt nd elef
ee
yo
r ns e r d o
io
our

co l st tt a tonmus bes
ncude ha he ci
t umma iydimis d,purua t 28U. C.j 1 5A( ( ) a
rl s se
s nt o
S.
91 b)1, s
l gal fi ousl
e ly rvol .
l a eshave no cons iutona r gh t be ho e i a pa tc a pr s n o i a prs
nm t
tt i l i t o
us d n ny r i ul r i o r n
i on

wihmor fvorbl c tons M e c v.Fa 427U. 21 224( 976)
t
e a a e ondii . a hum
no,
S. 5,
1 .

Th i ta d cso t a sg tec n it oap riu a i ttto i n ts b e t o
e ni l e ii n o si n h o vc t a t lr nsi in s o u j c t
i
c
u
a tunde t DuePr s Clus ,at
udi
r he
oce s a e lhought degr eofconfneme i one
he
e
i
nt n
prs m a be quie dif r f om t ti a he .The c
i on y
t f e ent r ha n not r
onvi ton has s tci nty
ci
ufi e l
e i s d t def ndan ' lbe t i e e tt e pow e t St t t c i hi
xtngui he he e
t s i ry nt r s o m
r he a e o onfne m
i any ofispr s
n
t i ons.

lA compl ntfl by an i at chalengi t conduc ofan ûofic orempl
ai ied
nm e
l ng he
t
t t er
oyee ofa

g ve n nal niy'ma bes
o r me t e tt ' y umma iydimis dun rj l 5 b ( )i t c liti çrvolus
rl s se de 91 A( ) 1 f he ompan s k i o ,
f
m alc ousorf l t s a ea cl m upon w hi r i m a be gr ed.
ii
ais o t t
ai
ch elef y
ant '
'

1 a 2 4 2 M o e v r a imae spa eo c nfn me ti n c s aiys b e tt t b o d
d. t 2 - 5. ro e , n n t ' lc f o i e n s e e s rl u j c o he r a
dicei oft eparisma gi t prs Gat v.Ta or 946F. 340, ( hCi.
s rton hos te na ng he ion. son
yl ,
2d
343 4t r
1 ) Seeas Stiklrv.W aes 989F. 1 138 1 1( h Ci.1 )(i ngnoe l
991.
lo rc e
tr,
2d 375, 0- 38 4t r 993 fndi
qua
pr ec i vi a i n w he e i na e w ih s nt nce t s r e i s a e prs f ciiy s ntl pe i
ot ton ol t o
r m t t e e
o e v n t t i on a lt pe ong rod

i l alaiwihl sfvor ec tons.
n oc j l t es a abl ondii )

Ri dea p a st alg ta b c u etef o i b te a VDOC prs n t a a tej i,
d l p e r o le e h t e a s h o d s etr t
io s h n t h al
he ha a c tt i lrghtt be t a f r e t a V D OC f ciiy. H e i m i t ke Be us hi
s onsiutona i o
r ns e r d o
a lt
s sa n. ca e s
a l ga i f lt i plc t a c tt t o ly pr e t rght t c tw ils m arl
le tons ai o m i a e ny ons iu i na l ot c ed i , he our l um
iy

ds s t ea to wih u p eu ie p rua tt j1 1 A( )1, sfiolu .An a p o rae
imis h ci n to t rj dc , u s n o 9 5 b ( ) a rv o s
p rp it
or rwilbe e e e
de l
nt r d.
The C l r i di e t d t s nd c e oft s m e or ndum o ni a a om pan ng
e k s r c e o e opi s hi m a
pi on nd cc
yi
or rt pl i if
de o a ntf .

E E T i - dyo Jn , 0 1
NT R: hs ' a fu e 2 1.
Ffl
U nied St t D i t i tJ
t
a es s rc udge