Al-Habashy v. Commonwealth of Virginia, Department of Juvenile Justice

Filing 50

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 02/28/2012. (rkc)

CL :oFFl '
ERK'
ce
u s Dl
ATRQANOG. sT.cotr
l
FI
L ,VA

EP

FEB 22 2 1
92
I TH E UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FOR TH E W ESTERN DI
STRI O F VI
CT
RGI A
NI
RO AN O K E D I SI N
VI O
AM I AL- ABASH Y,
NA
H

JULAI
I LDUDLE CLERK
M
BY: *

Ci lAc i N o.7:
vi ton
11cv00306

Pl nt f ,
ai i f

M EM O M NDUM O PI ON
NI
C O M M O N W E A LTH O F V IR G IN IA ,
D EPA R TM ENT O F JU VE NILE
JU STI E,
C
Def
endant.

By:Sa ue G .W is
m l
l on
U ni e St e Di t i tJudge
t d at s s r c

Pli ifAm i AlHaba hybrngst saci pur ua t Til V1 oft Ci lRi s
antf
na s
i hi ton s nt o te I he vi ght

Ac o 1 6 , 2U. C. 20 0 , t e . 2 0 ) a an th re o e,h Vign aDe rme to
t f 9 4 4 S. j 0 e e s q ( 0 6 , g is e mply r te r ii pat n f
J nieJ tc (: J'. AlHa s a Afia Amei nfmal,alege t ts a idf
uve l usie ( ' 1 - ba hy, n rc n- rca e e l s ha he pple or
DJ )
a poston a a pr ton s r i ora t tDJ r f e on t ba i ofr c a r lgi t hie
ii s oba i upe v s nd ha J e us d, he s s a e nd e i on, o r

h ro e ng a t e as c n -o n itr iw.DJ h smo e f rs mmayj d me t nte
e r ve rn h r e o d r u d n eve
J a vd o u r u g n o h
g oundst tAll a hy ha note t bls aprmaf ci c e ofdic i i ton a t te n
r
ha -- bas
l
s
sa ihed i a e as
s rm na i nd ha ve
as umi s ha ,s hasnots
s ng he s he
hownt tDJ ' pr f r dr a o f isde i i we e
ha JS ofe e e s ns or t c sons r
pr t xt l AlHa s ha ofe e s ve a moto i r pons i l ng am oton t n nd,a
ee ua . - ba hy s f r d e r l i ns n es e, nc udi
i o me
m oton t r pe di c r a m oton t c i ue t ti da e,a a m oton f vol nt z
i o eo n s ove y,
i o ontn he ral t nd
i or u a y
di m i s . The c twilde A ll a hy' m oto be a e s hasdone ltl d i t l s
s s al
our l ny -- bas s i ns c us he
l
ite ur ng he a t
s x m o hst pa tc pa e i o pr e ut he ca e,a ha i t d e s nta l s r e d he ca e
i
nt o r i i t n r os c e r s nd s nsea s e i ly c e ne r s

fom a r a i lt si And, ca eAll a s ha ofer d ltl mor t n s c ai n i
r dve s ra e tng.
be us -- ba hy s f e ite e ha pe ul to n
l
supportofherpri a f e cas and becaus s hasf l t of erorf ecas any f sshow i
m aci
e,
e he
aied o f
or t
act
ng

1Acc di t AlHabas , t Ciy ofRoa
or ng o hy he t
nokepa hers ay,buts w a r c uiedby,i eviw e by,
ys
alr
he s e r t
ntr e d

hrdb , n a s r t DJ s p r io s ( . Rep. tS mm. . - , C. No 3 .
ie y a d nwes o J u evs r. Pl' s Mo. u J 1 2 E. F. . 8)
s

r

+a

t DJ Spr f r r a onsf risa tonsa eme epr txtf rt a uldic i i ton,t co t
hat J' ofe ed e s
o t ci
r r ee o ml wf s rm na i he ur

wil rn DJ ' moi nf rs mmayj d me t
l ga t JS to o u r u g n .
1.

I t lghtm os f vor bl t All a s y, t f c sa e a f l s 2 Alla s wor
n he i
t a a e o -- ba h he a t r s olow . -- ba hy
l
l
ks
f rD J i t 23A D i t i tCo tSe v c U ni i Roa
o J n he
sr c ur r i es t n
noke, igi a. D J i e v e
V r ni
J nt r i wed A l
-

Ha s a eghto he i vi uasf ai obai n s r ior'ope ng i t 23A ofi . A
ba hy nd i t r ndi d l or t
pr to upe vs ' ni n he
fce
pa oft e uppe -e DJ e pl esc
nel hr e
r lvel J m oye onduc e t i er e oneofwhom wasa Afi a
t d he nt viw,
n rc nn e v e , J fr d hr
Ame ia f m ae. Afe t frtr
rc n e l 3 tr he is ound ofit r i ws DJ ofe e t eeoft eni
hos ne
i vi l a s c i er e AlHaba hywa notn
ndi dua s e ond nt viw- s
s
mong t ofer es Afe t i e viw,
he f e . tr he ntr e

AlHabahycompl ne t Rodne Hub d,t die orofhe ofiet as anAfia
- s
ai d o
y bar he rct
r fc and lo
rc nAmeia ,t to oft pa lssa aedt se pdu i t i e ve a t s dee ve
rc n) ha ne he neit ppe r o le rng he ntr iw nd hat he sr d
a s condi t r i w.Hubba d i si a e All a s scai sa i o d he t thef
e
ne ve
r nve tg t d -l ba hy' l m nd nf nne r ha
ound
no ir gul rte i t i e viw pr es , ha DJ wo dno gi he as c it r i a
re a ii s n he ntr e oc s t t J ul t ve r e ond n e vew, nd
d f
t tt pa lha r nke he tfhoutofni c ndi ts4 (
ha he ne d a d r it
ne a dae . Hubbar Af 3,E. F. 27- )
C. No. 1.
.

2Thoug AlH a s i c r tyr pr s ntd byc e, s ha pr ee drr seuntlr e l As
h - ba hy s urenl e e e e
ouns l he s oc de o
i ec nty.

s c tec u tieal c n tu sh rfln s Se Beu et Civo Ha tn, 75F.d1 4,1 7 (t Ci.
u h,h o r l rl o sre e i g . e a d tv. t f mno 7 2 27 2 8 4h r
b y
i
1 8)
9 5.
3Thec thi i st sf tf l a et taci bl Til V I dic i i ton i notlmie t c
our ghlght hi ac uly war ha tona e te l s rm na i s
i td o onduc
t
bewe n i vi l ofdif r r ce .TheSuprmeCour ha e ai t t i t tc e ofr ci
t e ndi duas
feent a s
e
t s xpl ned ha, n he çontxt a al

dici n to i tewok a eweh v rj ce a yc n lsv peu t nt ta e o e wil tdsrmiae
srmiain n h rplc
a e ee td n o cu ie rsmpi ha n mply r lno ici n t
o
a antme eso (e)o rc .t c ueo tema yfct o h ma moiain,two l b u wiet
g is mb r f h r wn a e Be a s f h n a es f u n tv to i ud e n s o
pr s asamatroflw t huma bengsofonedei bl gr wilnotdic i nae a i tot rme sof
e ume
te a hat
n i
fna e oup l
s rmi t gans he mber

tergo p' On aev S n wne Ofs oeS c .5 3U. 7 , 8( 9 8 (iigCatn d v. ria 43 U..
h i ru .' c l . u do r fh r v s, 2 S. 5 7 1 9 ) ct
'
n sa e a Pat , 0 S
d
48 , 9 ( 9 7 Ho v ra alg t no dici n to lsss mep ru sv neswhe o eo moek y
2 4 9 1 7 :. we e, n l ai f srmiain o e o es a ie s n n r r e
e o
plye si t pr s f l wihi t s mepr e e cl sa t pli if Se Coaai v.Gov' ofD. , 97a r n he oce s al t n he a
otctd as s he antf. e
ns
t
C.No.

2 6 ,1 9 W L9 6 5 a * ( hCi. e 1 ,19 )
23 99
4 5 , t 4 4t r F b. 9 9 9 .
4Hubbad satd i a afda tt tt pa ne rc i r dr ce,r lgi ora ohe i pe misbl
r t e n n fi vi ha he nel ve onsde e a ei on, ny t r m r s i e
f t i rac ngisdecson;r her t t e i vi sw hor c ve s co it r e spef r t be t
acor n e hi t ii at , he hr e ndi dual
e ei d e nd n eviw
ro med he s
durngt rit ve s wer abl t a tcul et rdie e inc wiha knowl
i hei ner iw , e e o ri at hei rct xpere e t nd
edgeoft Cou tSe vc
he r r ies

Un t a dp e e td t ms l e a b i gb t r uaiidt a t eo h ra p ia t. ( b a d Af. - E. F.
i n r s n e he ev s s en e t q l e h n h t e p lc n s Hu b r f 2 4, C. No.
e
f
2 - . Ea ho tetrep n lssp o ie smi rra o ig ( e Ga io Af.E. F. . -. rol f,
7 1) c f h h e a eit r vd d i l e snn . S e n s n f, C. No 272 Car lAf.
a
,
E. F. 2 - . h watrAf.E. F. 2 - )
C. No. 7 3 S o l f, C. No. 74.
,
e

All a hy cli st tDJ de i t hieawhie fm a ef t poston. w ha e r
t ve
- - bas
l
am ha J cded o r
t e l or he ii 5

t t t oft tal ge dec so budge c si f c f r dt cl i oft Na ur lBrdg
he nzh ha le d ii n,
t ut n a t o ce he osng he t a i e
J nieCore tona Ce e ,a pt s ntt de rm e t lpolc DJ pl ce t l i of
uve l
r c i l ntr nd, l ua o pa t n a iy, J a d he ad- f
r

s p rne e o teNau a Brd efclt it t p o ains p ni o o e i .( b ad
u eitnd nt f h trl ig a i y n o he r b to u e s r p nng Hu b r
i
Af. -4, C. No.27- )Tha bengt c e noneoft ni i eviwe sfledt posto
f 3 E. F.
1. t i he as,
he ne ntr e e il he iin.
Reg r e s AlHa hy tld adic i nai c r wiht EqualEmpl
a dls , - bas ie
s rmi ton ha ge t he
oymen Opporuniy
t
t t
Com m i son a l ng t ts w a q ii d f rt pr ba i s r i orope ng, ha o
s i legi ha he s ualf e o he o ton upe v s
ni t t ne

paneita
ls ppea e t se p durng t i er e a t tt t e fna it w e ewhie.EEOC
rd o le
i he nt viw, nd ha he hr e i lss r
t
wa una et concudeDJ ha dic i na e a i tAll a s c os d isfl on t c r e,
s bl o
l
J d s rmi t d gans -- ba hy, l e t ie he ha g
l
d s ntAllaba hy arg -o- uenotce.Shefld t sl ws ton J ne 29,2011 wihi t
nd e
-- s
l
i htt s
i
e hi a ui
u
, t n he
r quiieni t da ofr c vi t EEOC' notc
e st ney ys e ei ng he
S ie.
Si emeei t tde dlne howe r Alla hy hasbe l st n punc ua .Afe s
nc
tng ha a i ,
ve , -l bas
en es ha
t l tr he

fldt sa tonpurua tt Til VI,42U. C.j 1 ,a t ADEA,a afe t c t
ie hi ci
s n o te I
S.
981 nd he
nd tr he our
dimis dt j 1 1a ADEA cai byc e oft pa tesa grntdAlHa s s
s se he 98 nd
l ms ons nt he ri nd a e - ba hy'
motont n
i o mend he Til V I cli , Alllbas be n t s r ssa t r pondi t e
r te I am
--a hy ga o how e it nce o es
ng o m ai m e s ges i e r t r e ,a ot r que t . O n N ove be 1 2011 A ll a s a ke
l s a , nt r oga o i s nd her e s s
m r 8,
, - l ba hy s d
t c tf r a e e i oftm e t n e he co pl i a f r a de a ofhe pe ng
he our o n xt ns on i o m nd r m a nt nd o
ly
r ndi

d p sto Ov rDJ ' o j ci n ,h c u t a eAlla a h tna dto a d y t n n h r
e o i n. e JS be to s t e o r g v -l b s y e d i n l a s o me d e
i
i
c
ompl i a e e d t dic r de lnet J nua y 1 201 l a to t c t
ant nd xtnde he s ove y ad i o a r 3, 2. n ddii n, he our
or r d A lll ba hy t r s
de e -- s o e pond t D J ' di c r r que t .A ll a hy di notc pl w ih
a
o J S s ove y e s s - - bas
l
d
om y t
t to de orr pond t a ofDJ S o he e f t t de e he a i t d f l d a untm e y
ha r r es
o ny
J' t r f ors o pos r nd nsea ie n i l
5Hubba d, o t ot ha saedi hi afi vi t tafe te s ond r
r n he her nd, tt n s fda t ha tr h ec
oundofi evi ,hel r
ntr ews eaned

ta b de ct wo l frely feswhr wi i DJ adta, usatt DJ p l y anwl Ii-f
ht ug t us ud oc aofs le ee t n J n htp run o J oi , e y adof
h
c

i vi lwoul flt pr bal s r s va nc Thus atrt s ondr
ndi dua
d il he o ton upe vior ca y.
, fe he ec
ound,het no f t raci t fl
ook urhe ton o il

tev c n p st n.( b r Af. , C. No 2 - .
h a a t o ii Hu bad f 3 E. F. . 7 1)
o

r pons t a outt ng m o i t c m pe ,cam i t beuna et pa tcpa ei dico r
es e o n sandi
ton o o l li ng o
bl o ri i t n s ve y
duet ava m e ca condii 6
o
gue di l
ton.
DJ moved o De mbe 28,2011t dim isf lc ofpr ec to a g ng t tAl
J
n ce r
o s s or a k
os u i n, r ui ha H a hy ha notpari pat d i herc s i a s t ntve way ot rt t as t cou tf
bas
d
tci e n
a e n ny ubs a i
he han o k he r or

e tnso so tme So n atr o J n ay 1 , 01 , Jfldamoin frs mmayj d me t
xe in f i . o fe , n a u r 2 2 2 DJ ie
to o u z u g n .
On J nua y 1 t Alla s r s nde t t m o i t dim isf l k ofpr e uto sa i
a r 3 h, -- ba hy e po d o he ton o s s or ac
l
os c i n, ttng

t ts : ve pr i d da e f he de ii n'be a es wasi dia l una et do s '
ha he 4 r ov de t s or r posto ' c us he
ne
t c ly bl o
me
o,7
'

t a s eh dç o t r u hata mai aj sme tb fl gti c s , a t a s ewa ç on
h t h a ç ne h o g ru t du t n y ii h s a e' nd h t h s l ig
g
c
n
'
d
t bes t ts goul unde t cic tnc s' OnJ nuay 1 h, - bas as f
he tha he c dj r he rumsa e .
' a r 7t AlHa hy ked or
anot rsxt da e e i ofdicov r a ane tildat Si daysl tr s r ponde t
he i y- y xtnson
s e y nd
w ra e. x
ae , he es
do

t moinf rs mmayj d me t Fo rd y a trta, h a k do ea anf rp r sint
he to o u r u g n . u a s fe h t s e s e nc g i o emiso o
nme he c ant( c s hadno ye donede piet c tha ngt c grntdl vet
nd r ompli whih he
t t
s t he our vi wie a e ea o
dos i or rt rvi he j 1 1cli Alla hyt nrti c e,
o) n de o e ve r 98 am. -- bas he eaned ounslmove a i t
l
d gan o
ext nd di c r and c i t t i ,a s afe m ove t vol a iy di m i s The co t
e
s ove y
ontnue he ral nd oon t r
d o unt r l s s .
ur

t a1t outtndi motonsunde a s me a hea d a gumenton DJ ' motonst
ook l he sa ng
i
r dvie nt nd r r
JS i o

ds s a d frs mmayj d me to F b u r 1 , 01
imis n o u r u g n n e r ay 6 2 2.
II
.

A loge he ,s nc J a y 1 201 AlH a hy ha fl a m oto t e e t
t t r i e mw r 7, 2, - bas
s ied
i n o xt nd he
di co r pe i t o m otonst co i t t i l a m o i t n e a m oton t r ope
s ve y r od, w
i o ntnue he ra ,
ton o m nd,
i o e n
di c r a r s tt di c r dea i s a m o i f a e e i oftm e t r pond t
s ove y nd e e he s ove y dlne ,
ton or n xt ns on i o es
o
6Ass wa pr es i he i biiy t pa tci t i dic r i t i t ntca e Alla s wasflng
he s of sng r na lt o ri pae n s ove y n he nsa s , -- bahy
l
ii
ano he ac i n i t W ese n Dit i tofVigi a All a s v. r e Scot Halv P. & A s oci t s 7: l c
t r to n he
t r sr c
r ni , -- ba hy Da r n
l
t e C.
s a e , 1 - v-

0 58 ( . . . c l , 0l ) l ta cs , - b s yi s igh rfr ratr y Th tatr e rpe etd
0 5 W D Va De . 2 2 1. n h t ae Al ah s un e ome tone . a to n y e rsne
Ha
AlHa a h i ad s se c s i whih s ecame volto so Til Vl, 1 1 a dt eADEA a rs
- b s y n imis d a e n c h li d i a in f te l j 98 , n h
Ae he
i e viwedw ihRoa
ntr e
t
noke Ciy Sc sa t s hools t de i d t hiehe asaKr nston s ci it' Se
t hool nd he c
ysem clne o r r
ç a ii pe als. e
t
'

AmiaAlla ah v. a o eCivS h, :7 c -0 6 ( . Va Se t2 2 0 )
n -lb sa Ro n k t c .70 -v0 4 0 W D. . p. 4, 0 7.
'se S a,not 6.
e upr
e

4

DJ ' moinf rs mmayj d me tFa damoint ds s pls a tt Ru e41a( ) DJ
Js to o u r u g n, n
to o imis t u n o l ()2 . J
r
a guest ti lg ofA lH a hy' c
r
ha n i ht
- bas s onduc t f r s s ul no be alow e t r s tt
t hus a , he ho d t
l d o e e he

ltg ton tme i a t slt da e.The c ta ee wih DJ
ii a i i lne t hi ae t
our gr s t J.
AlHa hy has f wha e rr as f ie t f fl e n he mos bascoblga i a a
- bas
, or t ve e on, a ld o ulil ve r t i i tons s
ltga .De piet tf c ,s s e mor tmet pr e ut he c ebec us s hasbee
ii nt s t ha a t he e ks e i o os c e r as
a e he
n
t m a et di c rr l vanta m a e i le de e't tw oul a l he t f ly r s nd t
& bl o s ove e e
t
nd t r a vi nc ' ha
d low r o u l e po o

DJ ' motons M uc t t con r r All a s hasbe n gi n ampl opporuniy t dic r
JS i .
h o he ta y, -l ba hy
e ve
e
t t o s ove
r lvan a m ae i le de . I t a s ha c ent dir ga d DJ Sc
ee t nd t ra vi nce nse d he s hos o s e r J' omm unia i ,
c tons
i e c tor r ,ove l t c ts s i ious ha i ofhe va i m otonsr ga di
gnor our de s
r ook he our ' olc t
ndlng
r r ous
i e r ng
di c ve y a a endm e ,a ot r s s r n herc s f o a r a i lt s i M or ove ,
s o r nd m
nt nd he wi e c ee
a e r m dve s r a e tng.
e r
A l l a hy' couns ,gi a m ea ngf opporuniy i o c r , d f e s no e de e
-- bas s
l
el ven
ni ul
t t n pen ou t coul or ca t
vi nc
s
ugge tng t tgr ntng a tonaltm e w o d l ad t a dif r ntr s ti t sc e.
s i ha a i ddii
i
ul e o f e e e ul n hi as

Ac or ng y, heco twilde All a s smoto f e enso oftme,f rcon i nce ,
c di l t
ur l ny -- ba hy'
l
i ns or xt ins i
o
tnua s
f Rul 41 di m i s ,a t a end.
or e
s s al nd o m
1
11.

DJ ha mo e f rs mma yj d me t ntego n sta Alla ahyc n o etbiha
J s v d o u r u g n o h r u d h t -- b s a n t sa l
l
s
prm af ce c s ofdicrmi to a t te n a s i s has s hasnots
i ai ae
s i nai n nd ha ve s um ng he , he
hown t tDJ S
ha J'
pr f r d r a onsf isdecsonswe epr txt l The c r agr esand fndst tAlHa s
ofe e e s
or t
ii
r ee ua .
ou t e
i ha - ba hy
ha f iedt e t bls aprm af c ec ebe a es ha ofe e no hi m or t n s ulton
s al o sa ih
i a i as c us he s f r d t ng
e ha pec ai

S -l b s yr so d dt temoinfrs mmayj d me to J n a y2 s 01 ,wowe ksb fr s e
Al a ah ep n e o h t o u r u g n n a u r 3 2 2 t
l
o
e eoe h
ma et s e u s fra e tn ino tmet rs n t temoinfrs mmayj d me t
d hirq et o n xe so fi o epo d o h to o u r u g n.

i s ppor o i,a m o e r t DJ ha ofe e lgii t a nondi c i i t r r as nsf r
n u
t f t nd, r ove , hat J s f r d e tma e nd
s rm na o y e o o
is a tonst tA ll a hy ha f ie t unde ne.9
t c i ha -- bas
l
s a ld o
nni
Til V I pr bisdi c i i ton i e pl m e tba e on r e a r lgi See 42
te l ohi t s r m na i n m oy n s d
ac nd e i on.

U. C.j2000e2()1.Alla s ma prvaii he Til VI cli i oneoft wa .
S.
- a( ) -- ba hy y e ln r te l am n
l
wo ys
Fis,s maypr entdie torcr um sa i e de t the r ceorr lgi wa amotvai
rt he
es
rc
ic t ntal vi nce ha r a
ei on s
i tng

fco i DJ ' a to s Holndv. ah. me . n .4 7F.d2 , 4( t Ci. 0 7 .
a tr n J S cin . l
a
W s Ho s l c, 8 3 08 21 4h r 2 0 )
Sec
ond,s m a at mptt s ts yt t ts to i M c
he y te
o a if he es e ut n Donne lDo a Cop . Gr n,411
l uRls
v. ee

U. 79 8 ( 973) whihwoul alow he t riea i e e eofds rmi tr itnt Se
S. 2, 02 1 , c
d l
r o as n nfr nc
ici nao y ne . e
i ;W hiev. W aseSe vs,
d. t BFI t r .LLC,375F. 288,295( hCi.200 .
3d
4t r 4)
The frtse i t M c
is t p n he Donne lDoucl t ti t e t bls aprma f i c eof
l
as es s o sa ih
i ac e as

d srmiainb s wi gt a ( ) h panifi ame e o ap o e tdg o p ( )tep anif
ic i n to y ho n h t 1 t e lit s mb r f r tce r u ; 2 h litf
f
a pida dwa q aiidf rtep iini q eto ( )tep an ifwa rj ce d s ieh r
p l n s u lfe o h osto n u sin;3 h litf s ee td e pt e
e

q ai to ; n ( ) h p an ifwa rj ce u d rcru tn e t t v rs t a
u lkains a d 4 t e litf s ee td n e ic msa c s ha gie ie o n
t
i ee eoft a ' dici nai EEOC v. asRoe k & Co.243F. 846,851( h
nfrnc mlwf srmi ton.
ul
Se r buc
,
3d
4t

Ci. 0 ) s eas i n. (Th S p e Co r ha ma eice r h tb c us t ef cso gv n
r 2 01; e lo i 2 $ e u rme u t s d t la t a e a e h a t f ie
t
c s sd c s a iy wilva y't sf mul ûsnotnec s a iy a ia e ...o dif rngf t l
a e ne e s rl l r hi or a i
e s rl pplc bl
t fe i acua

st to a W ha i ciialwihr pec t t f rhee nti t t pli ifde nsrt s
iuains' t s rtc t es to he ou t lme s hathe antf mo taelj

9s mmayjdg n i a po raewh nçh pedig ,h dso eya dsls r maeil o fl, n
u r u me ts p rp it e t e la n ste ic v l nd ico ue tras n e a d
t
a yafd vt s o ta teeinog n n is ea t a ymaeilata dta temo a ti e tldt j d me t
n fia is h w h t h r s e uie su s o n tra fc n h th v n s nie o u g n
t
a amatro lw. F d R. v P. ()2 .Th pat mo igfrsmmayj d me t e r teb r e o
s te fa ' e . Ci. 56c() e ry vn o u r u g n b as h u d n f
'
i or i t c toft bassf ism oi a i ntf ngt epa t oft r co d whihde o tat t
nf m ng he our he i or t ton nd de iyi hos rs he e r
c m nsr e he

a sn eo ag n ieis eo maeila t Ceoe Co p v. tet4 7U. 31 , 23(98 .I rve nga
be c f e un su f tra fc. ltx r . Cart, 7 S. 7 3 1 6) n e iwi
s mmayj d me t to u d rRul 5 ,hec utt s d a alu tfa l ifrn e i fv ro t no mo ig
u r u g n moin n e e 6 t o r t t rw ljsiibe nee c s n a o fhe n vn
mu
p r ' Uni dSae v Caol aTrn fnn rCo, 78F.d8 2 8 5(t Ci.1 9 )(in And ro v Liet
at ' t tts . r i a so e .9 2 3 , 3 4h r 9 2 ct g es n . b ry
y.
e
n
i
Lo b .n .4 7U. 2 , 5( 9 6)
b y Ic, 7 S. 42 25 1 8 ).
I h r ep n et DJ ' moinfrsmmayj d me tAlHa ah a p ast ma eaco smoinfr
n e rs o s o JS to o u r u g n, - b s y p e r o k r s to o

smmayjd metb th mae n agmeti sp ot f r to by n camig(n orcl)ta DJ hs
u r u j n, u se k s o ru n n u p ro hemoin eo d li n ic rety h t J a
ofrdn e le c i s p o t fi po io .Towh tv re tn AlHa a h s e ssmmayj d me tii
fee o vd n e n u p r o t st n
s i
ae e xe t - b s y e k u r u g n,ts
de e f t r as sat i t sopi on.
ni d or he e ons t ed n hi ni

6

h wa no hrd (rfrdo n t r moe , t. E d rcru tn e whc gv rs t a
e s t ie o ie r o p o td ec) un e ic msa c s ih i e ie o n
i e e eofunl ' dici nai ''atrtoni orgi l (iai omitdl.
nfr nc
awf s rmi ton.'(leai n i na) ctton te )
ul
l t e oye c n esa ih aprmaf ci c eofdic i i ton, hebur n of
f he mpl e a t bls
i a e as
s rm na i t
de
pr tont n s fst t empl rt ariult algii t ,nondic i naor r as f ris
oduc i he hit o he
oye o tc ae e tma e
s rmi t y e on o t

c alng da to S eln v. n t 41 F.d3 8 3 ( t Ci. 0 ) f h e o e s tsis
h l e cin. tri c Te e, 6 3 3 , 45 4h r 20 5 .I t e mply r aife
e
isbur n,t pr s
t de he e umpto ofdic i nai n e t ihe byt prm af i c s dia a s a
in
s rmi to sabls d he i ace a e s ppe r , nd
t em pl e m us s
he
oye
t how t tt e pl r spr f r d r as w e e m er l a pr t xtf
ha he m oye ' of e e e ons r
ey
e e or

dici nai Jz Tostsyt prtxtrq rmen,hee oye mus de
s rmi ton. #. aif he ee e uie tt mpl e t monsrt t tt
tae ha he
a r ee oy e de i i wa a t ly ba e onan i ope f t ort tt de e nts
dve s mpl m nt c son s cua l s d
mpr r acor ha he f nda '
pr f e r a onswe e smpl ç
ofer d e s
r i yç
unworhy ofc e nc ' EEOC v.Cl y Prntn: Co. 955F.
t
r de e.
'
a i i
,
2d

936,9 ( h Ci.1 (ii Te De tCmt Afar v. di 450U. 248,256(981
44 4t r 992) ctng x. p' y. fis Bur ne,
S.
1 :.

Ap yn te esa d r ,ti ce r h t Ji e t ldt s mmayj g n .Fis, plig h s tn ads i s la t a DJ s ni e o u r ud me t rt Al
t
Ha hy ha f ie t esa ih aprma f i ca eofdic i na i .1 Even ass j tats
bas
s a ld o t bls
i ac e s
s rmi ton 0
um ng ja he
ha s tsi d t frtt eese i t M c melDouclst t All a hy ofe snot ngm o e
s a ife he is hr t ps n he Dor l
a es, -l bas
f r hi
r

t a s c lto ta DJ rj ce h rt e cru tn e gvi rs t a ifrnc o u lwf l
h n pe uain h t J ee td e md r ic msa c s i ng ie o n n ee e f na u
di c i i ton. l ed, he e ie ba i ofA lH a s s c a m i t ts w a a qualfed
s r m na i
nde t ntr s s
- ba hy' l i s ha he s
ii

me e o ap oe tdca sa dt a DJ rj ce h r Th o l t ic msa c 't whc Al
mb r f r tce ls n h t J ee td e. e ny f ru tn e'o ih c
H a s a l esi t tone oft pane i t a a e t s e p1 and wask ta t ndjj t
ba hy lud s ha
he
ls s ppe r d o l e 1
t te yg o
no

( rc nAmeia a pl a t' rs o s s' u i gt eitr iws ( . s M o . u J 9
Afia
rc n p i n sl e p n e 'd rn h ne ve . P1Re p. t S mm. . ,
c

1 ca eAlHaba hy ha pr s t no die to cic sa ile de eofdic i i ton, s m us
0Be us s
s e ened
r c r r um tnta vi nc
s rm nai he t
atmptt s tsyt M c
te
o aif he Donnel Doualsts.
l
a et
' Ont spoi , t c t est tAlla s ha ofeedf m sus d byt paneit d i t
1 hi nt he our not ha -l bahy s fr or
e
he
lss urng he
i e vi Thepaneita us ofse pi appe r t ha tkenexensvenotsdu i t i eviw- a las a
ntr ew.
ls cc ed le ng
a s o ve a
t i
e rng he ntr e
te t s

e tn iea teoh rwop neit.( s Mo. u J 1-2 . C. 3 - )
xe sv s h te t a l s Rep. tS mm. . 9 2 E. F. 82.
s
,

E. F. 38. Alla hy' na dopi o r r ngt pa it'i e ve d a ,
C. No. ) -l bas s ke nin egadi he nelss ntr iw eme nor
w iho m or ,doe noti c t c r um s a sgi ng r s t a i er nc ofdi c i i ton.
t ut e
s
ndi a e i c t nce vi ie o n nf e e
s rm na i

Se
cond,e n i t cou ta s m e t tAllaba hyhasesa ihed aprm af c ec e,
ve f he r s u s ha -l s
t bls
i a i as
DJ ha s tsid isbur n ofa tc ai a lgii t a no s rmi t yr a o f ris
J s a ife t de
riultng e tmae nd ndic i naor e s n o t

c
onduc.Se Ada v. s oft Uni ofN. - imi on, F. 550,559
t e ms Tr. he v. c.W l ngt 640 3d
-560( h Ci.
4t r

2 1.W i r s e tot eutmaehiigd cso DJ h se pan dta i wa meey
01 ) t e p c t h li t rn e iin, J a x lie h tt s rl
h
f l w i de rm e alpolc by pl c ng a r e l l i of e pl e i o t pr to
olo ng pa t nt
iy
ai
ec nty a d- f m oye nt he oba i n

s pevs rp sto wiht ers lt a n n o tennea pia t weehr df r h j b
u r io o iin, t h e ut h t o e f h i p lc ns r ie o t e o ,
i l ng t t e a i an sw ho ale y r c i d i pe s i e pr f e i lt e t e . Tha
nc udi he hr e pplc t
l gedl e e ve m nni s bl e er nta r a m nt
t
r a o i w holy l gii a e a ute l nondi c i i t y. A nd w ih r s c t D J S f iur t
esn s
l e tm t nd t ry
s rm na or
t e pe t o J' a l e o

ofe All a hy a s ond i e ve Hub r ha sa e unde oah t tt t e i vi l
fr -l bms
ec
nt r iw, ba d s tt d
r t ha he hr e ndi duas
who r c ve s c i t l e pero d t bes durng t i i e ve s we e a et
e ei d e ond n ewiws f nne he t i her nt r iw , r bl o
ariult t i die te re wih a knowl dg oft Cour Se vcesUni, nd pr e ed
tc ae her r c xpe i nce t nd
e e he
t ri
ta
es nt

t ms l asbengbetrqualfedt nt ohe a i nt.(
he eves i te
ii ha he t r pplca s Hubbar Af. E. F. 27d f 2-4, C. No.
1) I a ton, c oft t e pa lsshasofee s nafda t t t efc t t
. n ddii ea h he hre neit
frd wor fi vis o he fe t ha
i r si efco shadnobe rngont re uainsofAlla hy.( eGani o Af.
mpemisbl a tr
ai
hei val to
-- bas Se
l
s n f,

E. F. 2 - , rolAf.E. F. . - . h watrAf.E. F. . 74. I r s o s ,
C. No. 7 2. r l f, C. No 27 3 S o l f, C. No 2 - ) n e p n e
Ca
,
e
ttd e o l s t
All a s o fr not ng m o et n r tr t d a lga ins1 And assa e pr vi us y, de pie a
-l ba hy f e s hi
r ha eie a e le to .2
m e ni ulopporuniy i open c t A lH a s s c
a ngf
t t n
our , - ba hy' ouns lc d poi t orf r c tno
e oul
nt o o e as
e de e s w i t tDJ ' pr f r d r as w e e pr t xt lorunw o t ofc e nce.
vi nc ho ng ha J S ofe e e ons r e e ua
rhy
r de

1Toh rs mmayj dg n rs ns, --b syh satc e sae nsb sv rlndvd as(o
2 e u r u me t epo e Alla ah a t h d ttme t y e ea i iiu l sme
l
a
u sgnd) e adn alg ddici n to a DJ.Th sae nsaeg n rc u s p o td, n o frl t moe
n i e rg r ig le e srmiain t J e ttme t r e ei, n u p re a d fe il r
te
t n opi onsandunr ae a dot .Notoneoft e tbls est tA lHa hy s r r d dic i i to i t s
ha
ni
eltd nec es
hem sa ih ha - bas ufe e s rm nain n hi
c s Thec tas notst anum be oft saemen sweea r typr pa eda sgned s ey d i t
a e.
our lo e hat
r he tt
t r ppaenl e r nd i
quarl urng he
pei A lH a s cl m st havebe n t i1t pa tci t i t sca e.
rod - ba hy ai o
e oo l o ri pae n hi s

8

Co e nty,Allaba hy ha f ie t r ie age neis ofma e i f tt tDJ S
ns que l -l s
s al d o a s
nui s ue
t ral ac ha J'

e pa aini pzeyp ee t a, ndt ec u t l ga tDJ ' moinf rs mmayj d me tl
x ln to s l l rtx u la h o r wil r n Js to o u r u g n .3
r
lV .

Fort r s nssatd, hec t l de All a hy' motonsf extnsonsoftme,
he ea o t e t our wil ny -l bas s i or e i
i
f c tnua s f Rul 41dim is l a t a e Furhe , hec twilg an DJ Sm o i
or on i nce , or e
s s a, nd o m nd. t r t our l r t J' ton

frs mmayj d me t
o u r u g n.
ENTER:Thi 28t day ofFe u r 201
s h
br a y, 2.

UN I
TED STATES D I
STRI J D GE
CT U

1 M or r Kre adeso terueaplitf flo i po n aTieVI a to . .h e itn eo
3
eove , t lg r ls fh o t
l
anif olws n rvig t l cin, . te xse c f
l

s mea v ree o me tato i rq ie ' Jme v. o - lnHa l n I c, 6 F.d3 , 7 (t Ci.
o d es mply n cin s e urd. a s Bo zAl
'
e mio . n .3 8 3 7l 3 5 4h r
t
20 4 .Ana v ree o me tato i adsrmiao yath tt d es l afcllh tr , o dto s o
0)
d es mply n cin s ici n tr c ta t v rey fe ts te ems c n i n , r
a
i
be ei o t plitf' e o me t' 1 .(ne l u tt nmak o te .
n ft fhe anifs mply n. d itma q oai r s mitd)
s
'
o

Durngor lar e ,A lla hy' cou els e e t c det tDJJSacua hii de sondi not
i
a gum nt -- bas s ns e m d o once ha
l
' t l rng cii d
appe t bea a in gi ng rs t Til Vl labiiy.Thus t onl c i bl adve s empl e a tonwas
ar o n cto vi ie o te I i lt
,he y onceva e
re
oym nt ci

DJ ' fil t o frAlla ah asc n itriw frtep o ainspevs ro e ig( p sto ta, u t
JS alr o fe -- b sy e o d neve o h r b to u rio p nn a o i n h td e o
te
l
i
b d e c t, sn v rfle b a yo ewh di rc ieasc n itriw) Asar sl o DJ' d nil f sc n
u g t us wa e e i d y n n o d e ev e o d ne ve .
l
eut f JS e a o a e o d
itr iw, -lb sys fee noc a g i tl, od ces i p y, ora sg me tn s iti o d te, n
neve Alla ah u frd h n e n ie n erae n a n e sin n , o hf nj b uisa d
t
s ha i ntfednow a i whih t de alofas co it viw woul a fcthe f t r e pl e t DJ '
he s de ii
y n c he ni
e nd ner e
d fe r u u e m oym n . JS
empl e aci wast r f ea s i onl t mos i a nai s ns V i d t ought slns A I
oym nt ton
he eor dvere n y he t m gi tve e e. ewe hr
hi e , H a s scli f l a t m os f m e a l elofi r
ba hy' am ais t he
t unda ntl ev
nquiy.