Graybill v. Clarke

Filing 31

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge James C. Turk on 10/26/2011. (tvt)

C

I TH E UN I
N
TED ST ATES D I RI C O U RT
ST CT
FO R TH E W ESTERN D I
STRI T O F V I G I A
C
R NI
R O AN O K E D IVISI N
O

: OFFI L.i.fdEl
CE i$ ) l
ATROANOS J t . Cltr i
l l?
f '?
E,b.
f
t
FI ED
L

2CT 2s 2:1
1
JULA
BY; I c

' :sy cutqs
. .. k . ,
.
-

.
'

7

PA UL C.G M YBILL,JR .

Ca e N o. 11 00331
s
7: CV
Pe ii r
tt one ,
V.

M EM O M N D U M O PI O N
NI

H AR O LD C LA R K E ,DI EC TO R
R

By: J m esC . k
n
Tur
Se orUnied St t s Di t i tJ
ni
t
a e s rc udge

R es
pondent

Thi m a t r br
s t e , oughta a pe ii f a w rtofha s c puspur ua t 28 U . C.
s
tton or
i
bea or
s nt o
S.

j225 i beor t cour uponPeii rPa C.GrybilJ .smotonsf i el t y
4, s f e he t
ttone ul
a l, r' i or ntrocuor

ij n t rle .Up nrviw o t rc r ,h c u t o cud st a t e mus b sl rl
n u ci eif o e e f he e o d t e o r c n l e h t h y t e l
ve
mmaiy
de e
nid.

Asap ei n r ij n to tmp rrl af r sa e ta r iayr me yp irt til1
rlmiay nu cin e o ai fo d n xr o dn r e d ro o ra,
y
t ep rys e i t ep ei nayij n to mu td mo taet a: 1 ç i lk l t s c e
h a t e kng h r lmi r n u cin s e nsrt h t ( ) d s iey o uc e d
he
ont meis'( t i lkeyt s frirpaa eham i t a enc ofprlmi r rle,'
he rts 2) s s i l o ufe re rbl r n he bs e
' he
ei nay eif'

( )iheb ln eo e ute tpsi hi fv r'a d( )S nij ncin i i t ep b i itr s.
3 l aa c f q iis i n s a o , n 4 ç nu to s n h u lc n ee t'
t
'
a
'
Se W i erv. tla Res ce Defns Councll .555U. 7,20 ( ) A s ngofa
e nt Natrl our s e e
i.nc,
S.
2008 . howi
ts r ng pos i lt 'ofha i i uf i i n ,be aus t s a r r quie a s i t tha m i
st o
s biiy'
nn s ns f c e t c e he t nda d e r s how ng ha r s

çi l ' I a 2 Ea h o t e efu fco smus b stsidbeo ei tro u o yij n tv
dkey. d. t 2. c f h s o r a tr
l
'
t e aife f r ne lc t r nu cie
1 Tem por y r tai ng or sar is d onl r r y, when t m ovantpr
der e s ue
y a el
ar esr ni
he
ovest the wils f
ha
l ufer

ij y i r le i no g a t dbe o et a ve s pat c ul benoii d a ha e o poruniyt r s on
nur f eif s t r n e f r he d re ry o d
tte nd v p t t o e p d.
Se Rul 6 ( ) Fe r lRul o Ci lPr c du e S h a o d rwo d o y ls u i s h tmea a
e e 5 b , dea es f vi o e r . uc n r e ul nl a t ntl uc i s
h a ig o ap ei n r ij c in c ul b a rng d.Asi i ce rfom t ous tta peiine i n t
e rn n r lmia y nun to o d e ra e
t s la r he te h t tto r s o
e tte t a prlmia y ij nci ,t c ur fnds n b i upo whi t grnthi a t mpo ay
n ild o
ei n r n u ton he o t i o ass n ch o a m e r r
r tai ng or .
esr ni
der

rle i warntd.Rea Tr hAboutOba l v.
eif s ra e
l ut
ma,nc. FEC,575F.d 3 347( hCi.200 ,
3 42, 4t r 9)
vac t bv,rma dbv,c r.grntd,1 S.Ct 2371( 0) rafi i patrma dbv,
aed e nde
e t a e 30
.
201 , e fnned n rse nde
6 F. 355( hCi.201 .
07 3d
4t r 0)
Thec t ssa d diposton oft sha a a ton,bas d on Gr ybilssa e i e t
our ha t ye s ii
hi be s c i
e
a l' t t d ntnt o
a e hi a r dy-e t pe ii a a t c e t ;t c tdi e t d hi t s i t
m nd s lea l ng hy tton nd ta hm n s he our r c e m o ubm t he
n e e by Oc obe 3,2011. G r ybils it d s ve a ot rm o i i t a w ih
m ndm nt
t r
a l ubm te e r l he
tons ns e d, t

hundr dsofs
e
uppori doc
tng ument,as ng t c tt die tprs ofi i st m a e e i
s ki he our o r c ion fcal o ke xc ptons
t pr s pr dlr r r ng pos a phot opi ,a l w lbr r a es a a ki f
o ion oce zes ega di
t ge,
oc es nd a i a y cc s, nd s ng or
a tonaltm e t n end,s t he coul s i y m or doc e aton t t c t By or r
ddii
i o m
o hat
d ubm t et e um nt i o he our .
de

e e e Oc obe 1 2011, hecour gr nt d Gr ybilt n da t s
nt r d t r 7,
t
t a e a l e vs o ubmi a s tpli sae e t
t hor, an tt m n

ofa n ndme st thes ekst a t hi j225 peii a als ofdoc nt t the
ny me
nt ha e o dd o s
4 tton nd it
ume s ha
w a st s i i s
nt o ubm t n uppor oft pe ii The Oc o r 1 or r s cii aly di e t d Gr bil
t he tton.
t be 7 de pe t c l r c e ay l
N OT t s a ot doc e a i a t stm e.
o end ny her um nt ton t hi i

I Gr y ilstrt to f ritro u oy ijmcier le ( oi n1, a kstec u t
n a bl' is moi n o ne lc tr nt tv eif M to )he s h o r
t or rt pr s lbr y s r s , s Bid,t prntc es ofdocum ent f om hi c put r
o de he ion i ar upe vi or M . r o i opi
sr
s om e
t l s. I t s cond m oton,Gr ybila ist tBi d ha pr vi d hi w ih t s doc e s
i e n he e
i
a l dm t ha r s o de m t he e um nt .

The e or M oton li m oota wilbede ed o t tg ound.
r f e, i
s
nd l
ni n ha r

I hi s ondmoton ( oton1) Gr ybilcamst tonelbrra ha vebaly
n s ec
i M i 1, a l li ha
i a in d r l
pr m ie t s hedul hi f at t of30 lbr r perodsbewee Ocobe 1 a 29, 1,
o sd o c
e m or o al
i ay i
t n t r 7 nd 201 but
w he t w rte lbr r c e
n he it n i a y al ndari s d,Gr ybilwasnots he ed f a lbr y tm e durng
s ue
a l
c dul or ny i ar i
i

t stme s n.He a s rst tofi i sd e o ' m fo t s he ei r t iton f hi
hi i pa
s e t ha fcal t m ved'hi r m he c dul n eala i or s
r
f lng M oton Ia w ih an i e t i e f r w ih hi pr pa a i ofhi ha as s i s o .
ii
i
nd t
nt nt o nt r e e t s e r ton
s be ubm s i ns
H e a kst c tt or rof i i st alow hi t us t lbr r dur ng e h pe i of
s he our o de f c al o l
m o e he i a y i ac r od

avalbiiye r da f t ne t e monhs(nt mi l nuay201 s t thema
ia lt ve y y or he xt hre t i o d-a r 2) o ha
y
i om pl t a lne ded r s r h.
k
c
ee 1 e
e ea c '
'
Gr ybil salega i i M oton 1 f i t de o t a e t the w ils f ra ir pa a e
a l' l tons n
i 1 a l o m nsr t ha
l uf e ny r e r bl
ha m i t a e e oft r
r n he bs nc
he eque t d c ti t r en i
s e our n e v ton.The c l nge 1 w lbr r s he e
hale d a i a y c dul
i s d onl a f w da be or he fl d M oto l , nd he of e s no e de t tde e nt ha
s ue
y e
ys f e
ie
in l a
fr
vi nce ha f nda s ve
r f e t r s t s hedul oro he wi e m a a r nge e s f hi t conduc l galr s a c
e us d o evi e he c
e
t r s
ke r a m nt or m o
te
e e r h.
M or ove ,G r ybildoes no s a e a pa tc a l ga i s t tr qui e r s r h orot r s
e r a l
t t t ny ri ul r e l s ue ha e r s e ea c
he wi e
e a n how m o e lm ie ac es t t 1 w lbr r w ilc us a pa tc a ha t hi a lt t
xpl i
r i t d c s o he a i a y l a e ny r i ul r nn o s biiy o
pr e hi l lcl i s t t coul f r dr s l biiy t pr pa e wha he c i st be t
es nt s ega a m o he
' or e es . na lt o e r
t
t onsder o he
pe f c l albrefdoe notqua iy a ir pa a e ha m .2
r e t eg
i
s
lf s r e r bl r
Gr ybila s f l t a l ge a f c s i s
a l l o ais o le ny a t n uppor ofhi c us y a s ri n t tt
t
s oncl or s e to ha he
lbr i n i s d t s hedul w ihouti l ng hi na e be a e ofi a sw e e r t la i
i ara s ue he c
e t
nc udi
s m
c us tci l r e a i tng

a ns hi i s wa
gai t m n ome y.Adamsv.Rie 40F. 7 74 ( hCi.1 (i ngi t s
c , 3d 2, 4t r 994) fndi nmae'
r t la i c ai t be f i ous w he e i tf ied t c ai a f c ua a l ga i t ndi t
e a i ton l m o
r vol , r t ta l o ont n ny a t l le tons e ng o

s
uppor hi bar a s ri 'ha dee tsa tonsweer t it y)( ti itr l
t s e s e ton't t fndan ' ci
r ealaor omitng nena
q ttons. AsGr bilsuns
uoai )
ay l' upporedr tlai cai i lgalyfi ous hefist
t eaiton l m s e l rvol , al o
de
monsr t lke i
ta e i lhood ofs ce son t sc am .
uc s
hi l i

2 se e. ,Lewi v. Ca e 5l U. 3 ,351( 9 )(idi t tt saecvi rg t cam o
s
e, g.
s v, 8 S. 43
1 96 fn ng ha o tt i l ih s li f
deni ofac st t cour,i at mus pr
al
ces o he
t nm e
t oduceevi
dence t lm iatonsofa sr r hi una e
hat i t i
cces ende ed m
bl
t fl i talpl ng or caus hi t s i pl di s t
o ie nii eadi
ed m o ubm t ea ng o echni l de ci t i wa dimise
caly fi ent hat t s s s d

wi u c nsd r to oft eme is. l Grybilwih st p s eas p rt lws t r sn acvi rg t
t t o ie ain h rt) f a l s e o uru e a ae a ui, aiig i l ih s
ho
cl m f de alof acc s t cours,he wilfr tbe r r t e
ai or ni
es o
t
l is
equied o xhaus admi sr i r
t
nitatve emedi on t s
es
hi

is et a1lveso t prs sr me e 'p o e ur , rua t 42U. C. 1 97ea , ndt c e tt
su o 1 e l f he ion' e dis r c d e pu s nt o
S. j 9 ( ) a o onsn o
pa ng a $3 0 flng f ef o hi i t tus a c un . As i i c e rf o hi c r e ts bmi so t a
yi
50.0 ii e r m s nma e r t c o t
t s l a r m s u r n u s i ns h t

he h s no ye e a td a nitai rme e i c mpl nc wih jl 7ea ,te c r wilno
a t t xh use dmi sr tve e dis n o i e t 99 ( ) h ou t l t
a
consr hi moton asa s at ci lrght ac i
tue s i
epar e vi i s ton.

G r ybilt f l t s i f al f el m e s oft W i ert t s a t w a r ntt
a l hus ais o ats y 1 our e nt
he nt es , o s o r a he
i e l u or r lefhe s e . The c tw ilde r le on M o i 1 ac di y. An
nt r oc t y e i
e ks
our l ny e i f
ton 1 cor ngl
a o i t or rw ili s The cl r w ils nd a co oft s or rand A ppe x t pe ii ne
ppr pr a e de l s ue.
ek l e
py hi de
ndi o tto r

a c
nd ouns lofr or f t r ponde t
e
ec d or he es
n.

ENTER:hs 2 J ' d yo Oco e, 2011.
ti
X a f tb r

'

orUnied St es D i ' Judge
t
at
s ct