Turner v. Augusta County Library

Filing 4

MOTION for Reconsideration re 3 Order Dismissing Case by John Paul Turner. (Attachments: # 1 Appendix, Supplement and Attachments)

VI
RGI I :
N A

A y
-M+Aè v; .
*'

FO VF 7J
o Tuesday
x

> V A M4
1

Jè vc
z

FOMM G
V

July, 2011.

John Paul Turner,
against

-A

Appellant,

Record No . 110197
Court of Appeals No . 0066-11-3

Commonwea1th of Virginia,

Appellee .

From the Court of Appeals of Virginia

Upon review of the record in this case and consideration
the argument submitted in support of the granting of an appeal,
the Court refuses the petition for appeal.

A Copy r
Teste :

P t icia L .

a

ing

n

Clerk

A
ep ty

l rk

kpm M ix (à) ')
-(

VI N I :
RGI A

A '
-MzC vf '
dj
'

FSVF AC U- > VA M*,- FO VY G
.
X
e .
o
x

Monday

4 21st Jè vf March, 2011.
1
z

John Paul Turner ,

against

-A

Appellant ,

Record No . 110197
Court of Appeals No . 0066-11-3

Commonwealth of Virginia ,

Appellee .

From the Court of Appeals of Virgin ia

On February 9, 2011 came the appellant , in proper person ,
and filed a motion seeking leave to file an nAnders ' supplemental
l
petition for appeal

this case .

Upon consideration whereof , the Court den ies the
appellant 's motion .
A Copy ,
Teste :

Patricia L . Harrington, Clerk
.

r*
.

Deputy Clerk

A> d x ( :
wn i ' ,
àm )

YI W N f .
R
x '
--

u 2- L- - . - .J - . J '
- . J-- . LJL
. -Z. 1

J,fzCo z o < , J O tigzoo Fia
z X ut f W## a: J ' vtt = r y
P z
d

t. 2 t
â 8h

A yO Jn e ,0 1
= J au 2 1 .
Pettone ,
ii r

J Pa Ttme ,
ohn ul u r
a ns
gai t

Rec r N o.0066- 1 3
od
1-

Re ponde .
s
nt

Commonwe lh ofVigi a
at
r ni,
Upon a Pe ii f a W r tofA ct l oce e
tton or
i
ual nn nc

Be or J sKele Pety a Seni J
f e udge
s y, t nd
or udgeBumga dne
r r

J hn Pa Tt lrpe ii t sCo tf awrtofac n i e epuruan t Cha e 1 3 of
o
ul m e ttons hi ur or i
hll nnoc nc
s t o ptr 9.

Til 1 2o t eCo eo Vigni-Hec n e shei in c nt fma u a t r ma iu n o wh c h
te 9. f h d f ri a
o tnd s n o e o n fcu i
ng r a w f ih e
j
Wa COW i t i t Cicu tCour o
S I Ced n he r i
t fAugzt Count on Fe u r 1 1 1
ls a
y
br a y 6, 995.

Co ej1 .- 2 .0p o ie ta ço nyo eg ei o frawrto a ta i c n e . . a ll
d 92 3 7 1 r v d s h t# l l n p t in o
l
t
i f culr e c ) . b s
mo
u o . . a c n ito ma b fldb ap t in r' By o d rd tdF b u r 1 , 0 9,hi Co r
p n . (J o v ci n y e ie y ei o e .
t
' r t ae e r ay 2 2 0 t s u t
sl rl dimis Tnm e ' peii f am i ofa nmli
lmma iy s s ed
rs tton or
t c
nnoce er ga di t s m econviton he
nc e r ng he a
ci

c alng si Msp e e t eiin Se Tu n rv. mmn we lh No. 7 0 - ( . . p. b 1 ,
h le e n
r s n p t o . e r e Co n at . 01 2- 93 Va Ct Ap Fe . 2
t
2009) Tlr rsprs ntpeii t vi atsCodej1 2- 1
. lne ' e e tton hus ol e
9. 327.0.
Ac or ngl D lne i no e ild t t wrtandhi peii i sl a iy dim is d.
c di y, r r s t ntte o he i
s tton s lmm rl s s e
A Co s
py

!
'
.

, ,.N
A- h

.
b

.
,

/ .
,

Tes e: ( k
t
/

j

N
.

y

, z.
!
.
-

.

! cl k
h er
'

U

h...
.

ï.
,

x

Y
k
x

l
s

1Tu ne as alege hewa con ctd ofma a zi maiuat i Aug t Count Cic t
r r 1o l s
s vi e
nufdlrng rj ra n usa
y rui
Cour on J uar 22,1 97 a t th i i e oft a ofe e Tum e pr desno evi nceofs a
t an y
9 nd ha e s nnoc nt h t f ns .
r ovi
de
uch
c c i Tur rs isac ofi or roft AugusaCount Cic tCour da e J nua y 22,
onviton. ne upple opy m de
he
t
y r ui
t td a r
1 ,dim isng a t tto t r o n'lld by hi . TheJ az 22,1 or rdoe noti ca e
997 s s i
t ii n o e pe 'ie
pe
m
anu y
997 de
s
ndi t
Tum erwa c ce ofa ofe eon t tdae. W e donotc i rwhe he Tt wri e il d t aw'i
s onvi td
n f ns
ha t
onsde
t r m
s ntte o rt
ofa ua im oc nce pe t ni t a c c i he ha notpr n t e s .
ct l r e
r ai ng o onvi ton
s
ove o xi t

SU PR EM E CO U R T O F TH E UN ITED STA TES
O FFIC E O F T H E CLE R K
W A SH I G TO N ,D C 20543N
0001
J y 1 2011
ul 3,

J P.Tur r
ohn
ne
2237 Hn y M t H i a
nke
. ghw y
Chur hvil VA 24421 281
c le,
- 4

1E:USCA ( no.115048
k
DC)
USCA ( no.1 241
4)
0- 7
D e M r Tur er
ar . n :

Thepa r and or swe er cei d on J y 1 2011.The epa r f i t c pl wih
pe s
der r e ve
ul 2,
s pe s a l o om y t
t Rul oft sCour a a eher wih r l e
he es hi
t nd r
e t etmz d.

Yo ma se rviw o ad cso o l b fl at l p tto frwrto
u y e k e e f e iin ny y ii i y ei n o i f
ng me
i

c rir n.Thepa r you s it a e no c tu t be ape ii f wrtof
e to a
pe s
ubm ted r t onsr ed o
tton or i
c rir r. Shoul you c
e to a i
d
hoos t 5l apetton f wrtofc ri a i you m us s
eo e
ii or i
e tor r,
t ubmi t
t he
petton wihi t 90 da tm elm i a l d unde Rul l oft Rul oft sCou t A
ii
t n he
y i i t lowe
r e 3 he es hi
r.
Copy oft Rul oft sCour a as
he es hi
t nd ampl pe ii n f awrtofc ri ar a ee l e
e tto or
i
e tor i r nc os d.
Addii ly,a t or sbeow a
tona l s he der l ppea t be dif r nt you m us s
ro
fe e ,
t ubmi s pa a e
t e rt
pettonsf e ch.
ii or a

Si e el
nc r y,
W ilam K u e ,Clr
li
tr ek
By: xe

>
Erk Fos um
i
s

( 479202) 3392

En os es
cl ur

3 x *on al,.)
up
l (
l

q'

YI G I I :
R N A

#at & . lo Y ## . *O C a.o F
L x f a T J XMJJ a HAY
J yV Jn e , 0 1
.
au 2 1.

Ia 2 t
; #h

u--xrial to Judge Wbod

J Pa T= e ,
oM ul
r
ag ns
ai t

Pettonc ,
ii
Rc o, No.* 66- 11 3

l
Tume ax alg % wa c n it of u a t ngmn ' mn i Au u t Co
rl l a
e
s o icz mu fce
n . . n g sa j
co* on J ue 2A 1 7 e * h i i -ntoft oFen- .T'
a
*
e s nM
.
-

Ci i
mut

pm vi n e a - ofs a
dœ o viuch

c c a T= œ S
onvi uo
UPPE- a c of= or oft AugusaCo t Ci ui CoM H. M J opy
dœ
he
t c y m t
1 =

22.

l 9 . i iqn a' tG nt = m n' H b hi n eJ u 2 1 97o e d e n tid- 9 7 d- *i g w i o o
'5l y m.
M e 2. 9 r o s o n i
T= œ wu convi e of= oFM - o t td t W edo notconsde we t T= e i enute * ae t
c
n ha a e.
i r
e
rs
ld
ofa œ i
ct nnoce e
nc
' ' g œ aO nviton hehasnotpr vent e s
ci
o
o xit
l

Sun a , a uay 1 2 1l W X' f
d # J n f 6. 01
- >e

.ud Thoma H.
l ge
:

Wood.whos ved f 25 Y m ble - , v o > er or
u
year i t 251 Cicti u a4we u - t e r: N ge,
s n he
r lt
x

a prmae h x dc s nd i
e r aes f August Count
or
a
y.
di Frday nl
ed i
ght
ARerbaelngl cani ung
cer W ood di ofrenal
.
ed
L lleatUniee t of r
qilr
v y M gi a Transii
ni
tonalCare
Hospial hi daught .
t . s
er
SalyWoe . d.
l
sai
Rupen Shah. chi
ef
de y c
put omm onwealh'
ts
atom eyo zuo t Cot
t
fk
a mt who spentaboutan
y.
hotrwih W ood. Ni
l t
and s
f iy on Fri
am l
day.

aa a f
eter-

Me eu C- to
heu th

c e g e 1 U : l V b)
ov a e
0 S W
out- u ent, any ev - - u l data that

l xne ia

aœoke in a e ter or e @ bOM aM th@
a- ke is - 33n* rather *
I-N-'M
1n* the lungs- ta leas * - 1: ke
1
breate ng in so- ne elal'* aecoe he ct- ett ntcotin- O baeco sx ke;
e

aM t K %

M

eir e t- are lem p Y t

eu cer o Ja

ag* * te

ry lk, M l at

h + % e king
e

arte bei dia- su < th tt.
ng

œ ea , œ y < > bi e

te = nael e

ti ae- >

<a e
on-

e by a d- th

s- te e ue e %h@ s- be
e
l
aw; or a u '- M g c oe

e> we

eoM l e e
i- tt- , > - r,
âs M e by the D> g H ox ment l- niata tton on :*>

te er 6, l tn Doeket > .
9*
8K & , v e >* , tn tta nat*n
.

lx l to- ia one ot % * aafz
elt thera- tie-lly actls
ubstaneel knou .

p >- ex- - e u -

tion < ll bring apirit
ual ato- e
aM a H u on f as m k
bor
nele n
g
Judge - * .
.
*4

e

lov e
onu oe n a œ
M
l
oved Nt s c and fe
eak. coth
A
ci etes. Shah sai f H fe dile e neho
gar t d, @ne'
l
t
hough he qui smoki ot @ l eiA l H ght bt
ng
akx btngdj
lr i a
w11 eause ok t*.
t1
jmg C
t ancer' '
Unl he
ike altu eatm l M al-

3*1- (V
iro u ly re iM
x H Ao n- a k- e - tbe M
m

> - % e %. Al1 M l
( * t : œ a y i < * - *)
: e
ke n

l e. wg o a e
m .4-

- , R - He/I
a'V

:. M H V C TM Cm
3.

* < - e * dt* hy be
ia a e u eu on I hm

d s rbe t ej g asa nm on - - 4- 1
e c i d h ud e
**
m:ng
or

I that th* Fœ e
D> g e e ltm u oa e te
'eteâ M ltrat
ae
ion œ 11

aecel f
M

>

F ' -.
?
Jo

Jzi-?
- /

Pw l 'a > l ' m er
'
'N
IIISAAII Awee I' m
IJJ
IP
Nt
+
!
r l ln r kG. *al wy
'Ix k
- i l
tht hule VA 21 *1 2 4
' fc lp .4 . :1
'

'

-

J

Att hxe ( -(
ac nt 1) 1)

J 29-1
9N- 99T 1 3
31 5

w #>e **a >4<e

t dN I l Lt Uj k .
* H .
u. R. x .
c
?

e .ud

% P+
VIRGINIA :

IN THE CIRCUIT COVRT Oe AUGUSTA COUNTY
& ***
*'

.m % y
.x

--N lœM> e- *.N ''k+.
- M
.
a #
, . ; ' I.'* ..
. g . ) #A '
..
.

JOHN PAUL TURNER

I1 J 2 !
A:

.
$

'='.%1$
e k4i ;
L *.;

V .

+
<

N.
j
.

COMMDNWEALTH DF VIRGINIA . ET AL

OKPER
The court e havlng considered the varlous pleadtngs and

doeuments filed by the petittoner. ts of the opknton that
this matter ought to be dism tssed .
It is accordingly ORDBRED that the Petitkon to reopen
and the amendment be , and hereby are . dism lssed .
It ts further ORDRQRn that a eopy of this Order be

mailed to the petttioner.
ENTER :
.

#

DATE: Janulr ,
N zz. 1997

V>
x
A Tr' ane m .or '.r'$
o* w
w
. , wy
r w J - .'
.!
Tes1 4.

e
o

t.-.w
..
.

.)

;:- 1
!7: -w
2>

.

.

c .Jcf A t e n t.< zj
. ta
t :) )
.
.

3

C 24 468 391
Tum e , ohn Pa
rJ
ul

W hatW @ Deçl
ded
Yourm nson pa e swe >
i
m nt >
e tte e t t sY est
n ilm nt o hi

t e tve Aprl1.2000, heda ewe i taly >
H fx i
i
t
t
nii l

t you
M

P r3 CFR 36 6d e ii m n inp y n = s bu t d xo tn a c whe av t ni
e 8
.6 i lt so a me l
y
u j o i ni u n e n e- :
i a
nc memt d f moO t n 60da f a f ony oram ide
e or
bs
ys or el
s mœ or W ehav ve i d wih
.
e rie t
Augum Cot y J i an M i dl Ri rRegi lJ lt tyou we m mand i ie rcusody
mt a l d d e ve
ona ai ha
m
e n i t
o M a 3,2003 whem you s v a 180 da R n e f t c t ofc
n mh
er ed
- y t nce or wo ox s onki
buing t t
o he
de i ncyofa mi or M am s t u % ve ' . e yourm nson pam e e tveM a
lnque
n .
ul,
- '
no'
i
nl Fœ i
y
3,
2003,t 61 day ofi = e a i f l
he *
nc r ton oloe g t dae o y f ony c viuon.Yo<
he t f our el
on c

b n st we r m' e c eJ n 1 2 0 , d t y uwe ml.* fo j i.
e e s > e me Fe dv u e , 0 3 le ae o > e
* r m al
W ee l
nc oe aVA Fo= 21 87 ' o biiyPe i Awe Ata hme /whih e nnn
- 68, '
Di lt nson
t c nt
c xpll
i en f t a con i yoœ a neft.
mpo nt x o
c- ng
is

Evl
dence Used t Decl Your Cl m
o
de
al
I ms ng oœ de ii we 1* t f l ng e de
n ki
c sow
I he olowi vi nce:

* Dx = e t fo teVi aCi i Co o Au e Co n r ev do I e
ns r m h e
mut M f g
u l x i e n w me 1 ,
8
*

20
08
No
iscai l te da e Fe
ton e tr t d b-

2.201
0

. VA Fo 21051 -, mp ov dPe in Elkb l yVei ainRe l ( tr nW i
=
- 6 1 I r e nso i ii ric to m Veea +
t
No Chid ) = eve o Nove
l= , i d n
me 2.201
0
* VA Fo= 21- 41 M edia Ex>
8 6,
cl
Re ë v e v onNove r2, 0
m
ie
m%
201
* Summ o ofea i v ei d on Nove e 2,201
m ngs
ve
m
0

à a h nt $
tt c me 9)

'

e ar entof
1
t r
ans ff r
ais
.
e
,
s
't
.

j. ..
;
j
.

J n PTu n r
oh
re
2 4 83 4
46 9

u
.
4

. ,
2
,

..
''
ki
rt
.
*
m'
. .
*

.

!

'1 .
.. .
/. k

6. ..
1!
: .
.
1
.

,

' k.
.
..
' , .
'

.
' .'

.

.
1.

.

.

..y:
.y(.
3. t
.7 i.
J j,
éi-;
î..
:
'('?
. :.
. ''
-> LA

j

.

um entof
g aj
o
'
?
.
. .

j.
q
. tt
t
.

.

k

,

:
'.
$

.

'k
Jk

.
..
.

.

'

'
.

g.
..
.
(
..'
ij
.;j
';:
:
7'

'

.

',

.
'
.
'

;
!
.

.

.

'
%
J h E h' .
: .
.
'

k
w

.

'

.

l'
.
, .q!
!.
tç
!1
.
.

.

uj

!
'

'

'

.rs
y

)
y
' ,J

'
.
'
.
'

l

C
d
'
'

- '

.
!
.1

x

+

. . ç
1 ! .
t,
$

,

.
.

y. . ..x . . : ..
$ ;, .
.
. v tl , ; .
'f
ù
'

. .
. ,
.

. t . .'
. > . .
.
.

.

.

. V.à ,j -.+!'...... ....-..... ' ..
, . -#k 'k.. :,' .. .. .' o , '. . ' - ?
# . . ) g .
# p
.
.
.
.

.:,
.
:
.

.

f
.

'
';. . o.'.. .
k v t i.;t.r
r f :.t
.,
y

J (.j
. /,'
Iy
*j.
.

4?
qj
),
.

.k
.

a

.

.,,.t
., r .
'.)
.

.
.

#

'

Decson Revlw O m e De ii
li
e
er cs on
Januaa 1 201
5, :
I
NTRO DUCTI
ON
n er cor r tec t tyou a eavee a oft Vi t m Er a Pea e i You s e
e ds el t ha
r
tr n he ena
a nd c tme.
ew d
i t N a fom Oc oG r1 1 t De m be 4,1
n he vy r
t
6, 967 o ce r 968,fom M ay 31 1 t Augus
r
, 970 o
t
28,1
970.&om J e 6,1 t Aug t4,1 ,fom J 3,1 2 t Augus 31 1
=
971 o
us
971 r une 97 o
t , 972,
fo Nove r28,1 t M ay 28,1 a fom J y 11 1 t M a 1 1 78.
rm
mbe
976 o
977 nd r ul , 977 o y 7, 9

Res t fom you m e alh t e
uls r
r nt ealh xam e t ihed aclni ldi
sabls
i ca agnossofps hotc
i
yc i
dior r noto he wie s ci d.n e ps chol s r vi we yourr or a no e you
s de ,
t r s pe se
y ogit e e d
ec ds nd t d
ha a r t rc
ve ahe omplc t ps hi c hit wih mx r exa pl ofl ng, a blng.
i aed yc ai
soq t me ous
es o r
i

dsone sae nsa dasl-mm sdda osso 'xse ta n uo i' Youh v a
i itd ttme t n efi e ie i f e itnil e rsa'
j
.
ae
l tdwo khso a d ah so o sve sg i = tlg l r b e rs li i al
i e r itq n ita f e e lnsc e a p o lms e utng nj i
mi

tm e.C= enty you wor on aChrs u te f r t tyou i rt fom yourpa e s
i
l
k
ia
r e x m ha
nhe ied r
r nt

a dlv b y usl i atalro tepo e . (i a eaMpb '
n ie y o refn rie n h rp o
n
')
DM ng t e e ,you haddi c t gi ng concs n we sa r poled ahit of
h xm uly vi
ie nm r nd e
sol

v a lmi dsca rlto s p .Yo G et bo da mo dwu q t e ty c
e i t o il eainhis < c wu ra nd o
e
ui uh mi.
e
n qewa e ie c o sg i a ti a= eto tou h qo esnga dc mml cto .
r s vd n e f inscn mp i n f h g t rc si n o l ain
nl
n mkl and s e h we etnge ilM d cmlmma i m t l e a s i i
ng
m c
r a nta
i l tntal h oos s ocatons.You
de e ha ng haluci tonsbutdi G le you ha t a lt t pr di tt ngs You
nid vi
l na i
d i ve
ve he biiy o e c hi .
mi mi e a sgnika pn
ni z d ny i t nt mnoi alhoug admitd t s epn noi t
a t
h
te o om
m d hought. n e
s
ps hol itf l you we eca bl ofmanag ng yourou G ne sbutyou a e lkey
yc og s e t
r pa e
i
st
r i l
unabl t be ga nG ly empl
eo
i l
oyed duet sgni ntt
o i sca houghtdior r odd G ha or an
s de ,
vi s d
belef c it ntwih aps hotcpr es ,a i lt t a
i s ons se
t
yc i oc s nd nabiiy o dequa ey s al i e ac .
t l ocily nt r t

Enttementt nons a i oconne t d pe i fro. Và effeetiv* Mc eh 6 . ZQQQ.
il
o
e e
e e nson,
You a e una e t s c ea f l a s e taly gni uloc upa i duet dia lt
r
bl o e ur nd olow ubs i l nf
c ton
o s biiy.
Rec dss
or how you a e 60 ye r ol ha al lofe aton r m re a fnihi
r
a s d, ve eve
duc i e td s i s ng
colege, nd ls wor d f ltm ewhen you we e i t Navy. Si t you ha
l a a t ke ul-i
r n he
nce hen,
ve
wor d pM -i f t Pos Om c f a y ra a s % e s fe oye a wor
ke
tme or he t
e or ea nd lo n el- mpl d nd
ked
on yo te f . n ee de e s
ur r e =
vi nc howsyou ar diabld duet yourdia ltesof
e s e
o
s biii

p y h tcdio d rm: h p de so . ( kel to be permanent)
s c o i s r e d y e n in li y
My serviee-conneeted and Marc: 15. 2009 effeeti penaion from
ve
Navy ia for my over 42 years of aetive and reserve savy Duty.

( yea's, 3 mont and 1 daya.)
42
he
5

à ac me (
tt h nt :)

o.
,
CO M M O N W EA LTH o VI N I
/ RQI A
Se r t y o heCommonwe lh
c ear ft
at
POST OF CE BOX 2
FI
4M

RI
CHMOND, RGI A 23 8. 45
VI NI 21 2 4

D e m be 1 201
ce r 3, 0

M r.John PaulTum er
2237 Hankey M ount n H i ay
ai ghw
Chur le, A 24421 281
chvil V
- 4

D earM r.Tum er
:

Ia wrtng w ih r ga d t yourpe ii f a pa do
m ii
t e r o
tton or r n.

Yo ma s i a he pe ii f t Gover ' c i ai f l wi a
u y ubm t not r tton or he
nors onsder ton olo ng
t ye r waii perod fom t dat t tyourpe ii w a de e You w ilbe abl t
wo a
tng i r he e ha
tton s ni d.
l
eo
a k f r a he pa don i Dec m b 2011
s o not r r
n
e er
.
I youwoul lke t pr
f
d i he operr sor i ofci lrght f m , e er pond t t s
e t aton
vi i s or plas es
o hi
ofice.
t

Si r y,
nce el

Gr
eg nni
g,
Extadii a Clmenc
r ton nd e
y

àtt me (#)
aeh nt

CLERK' O FFI
S
CE
SUPREM E CO URT O F VI I A
RG NI
In Reft J
ohn P ul '
a
1 ' Tum e RecoM Fo. 11 97
Pom '
r,
01

l Re:
n Appe st Supr Cou o Vi ni ( f. / / 0)
al o
eme d f r a e f 7 1 1
gi
DearAppel :
l
ant
You ar bei pr ded wih t f l i i or aton i r
e ng ovi
t he ol ng nf m i n esponse t t notce ofappealt
ow
o he i
hat
you r
ecentyfl wih t s Coud. Pl
l ied t hi
ease r t s i or aton c ef l as t tm e l t i udi t
ead hi nf m i ar ul
y
he i i s, ncl ng he
mi
fl oft n i ofappealwih t Cour ofAppeal and paym en oft fl f ar m andat y and a
ing he otce
i
t he
t
s
t he ing ee. e
i
or
f l et f l s
ai
ur o ol
ow uch r r ent wi r ti t di i ofy appeal
equiem s l esul n he sm ssal our
l
.

I or t appeala crm i case f om t Cour ofAppeal ofVigi a t t Supr e
n der o
i nal
r
he
t
s
r ni o he
em
Coud,am ong ot r r ent t appealng pady orhi/ ator m us t t f l ng
her equiem
s, he
i
s her t ney
t ake he ol
owi

j i ctonalseps'
ursdi i
t .

Rul 5: Petton f Appeal
e 17. ii or
.

( )Pr e t e ortl l r T ?'.I c s fri el nttn a p la g a pe lt bewih mei, o s lmus
h oc dt f / Al s l t/ f oun el o pp l s ds p e lnts p a o
r
/ de ##tI
a
tout rt c un e t
c y wi terquie nsofAnd r v Cal b na, 6U. 738( 96 , n Br v iar n t Vr naStt
ompl t h e rme t
h
e s . f r i 38 S. l 7) a d own . v de ) igii ae
j
/
#fl/v/ ??23 Va 5 ,3 S. 2d58 ( 989 . nc inc te e t c ns i rquie t tl ( )ap tto f
# lt?I g, 8 . 51 85 E. 7 1 ) I ompla e h r wih, ou el s e r d o ie 1 eiin or
' W
appealwhi r er t anyt ng i t r or whi mi a guabl s
ch ef s o
hi n he ec d ch ght r
y uppor t appealand whi demonsr est t s
t he
ch
tat o hi

Cot tc l e ' c ns in iuse amiai oft meisortea pe l ( )amoton lrla et wi r w a c nsl a d
l ot ls o ce to x n ton he rt h p a; 2
r ns
i b e v o t a s ou e; n
hd
( )amoton fra e e so oftmet a l tea p lnto tl as p e ntl tton fra a. ep ttonf
3
i b n xtn in i o low h p el t 5e u plme a peii o ppe lTh e i or
a
i
appealand t moton l l t wihdr ascounselshoul s tcaly cie t /?:cr Al t ee pl ngsmus be
he i br eave o t aw
d pecii l t o 1l/,x. l hr eadi
t
s ved on opposng cotns and upon t clentand m us cont n aceris e pr di evi
er
i
l el
he i
t ai
ttcat ovi ng denceofs s vi Thi
uch er ce. s
f' twilr e upon t moton t ext i oftme upon isr pt butwilnotr e on t moton t w ihdr untl
our l ul
he
i br enson i
t ecei ,
l
ul
he
i o t aw i
t sCourtconsi st casei ise iet i udi any s ement petton f appealt tmay be tl
hi
der he
n t ntr y, ncl ng
uppl
al ii or
ha
ied.

T
eterxns à nlstrati
dml
on, J
ohn P. Tur
ner, F
l'e No. 2
4

39l

An ' er ' is sM l t the 3e 1 of th Doubk DoctH ne of X* 1 of the C
l
àM s'
ar o
*
e
>
ode
of Fe em l Rer lations for veterans .

àttachn nt (:)
e

'

.

Aev- .
''
s. . .
.. '
w

IA.m ns: vkx
p .l ajF i.
s , mg o
g

.

A

' ' t ' ' .- '.
*
.
.
J ..
lq
'i
;
''
.
'
l'
k 't
' .
,
(k
.

.

.

é )y
;
.
r 145.
y
! he
k
'

b
'
'
'
4
'
x
k
I
'
d
Z
z
C
e
.'
'''''
''.
,''
j''
''
j'
.''
/'
'

e
'

U
.x., k y
,
.
. ,.
.
w

. ..
..

..
z
?
.

'
z

'

.

.

j

k

z
k// - t
p/'
p
Z q
k
N.
VN
/y
N
N
)
,
.
d'e
/?
.'
/

.

i'.
'.
..'i k

.
i-i-.
'
.
,
.

-

-h
'.$
'
',
.

.
..

)j

- . -- - - . .
-.
- -

. -/ . si-t.;:.
. . . k s'
- . > h;
j
.
ç
C'.
'

.

.
.

.
.

.
.
.

1

.

. x!
i.
.

è

-

.

w

-

.

.

js .,zoy'
. N uj
p -, x
x

T
.
t .>
+
,

.-.- ..'' ,xr +;
.
.
'
g .
:
t-:w z.:-,') j -e
tk :.
: rk
x (- ! *ê
=<t
.
z
'
.
'
.
.
.
u
o
x.
.
w
, .
=
.
z
.
o
.

;
'

,

.

'-.

-.
.
-

.

.

.

+3

k
œ

<
w
.
=

m
X

=.-

>z
p

..
.
M
n.k

-.

.

M

.

G)

J
'

ç
C

p .
o d

t
e
r
:
;
e
e

*'
4j
Cu
c
> N

=
*

.
.

?/ '
?'
/?
.'
/
/

'
:
N
Y

A,

.

'
.:
r.
i
e

z.

'''
,/
/
/

.

?'
'
'
'
!
;
'

(.
'
j
)

r?
k:

.

lpg
Ikf
k,r
,.-j
.
rk
t
à
dlrj
jlj,
kïjrljy
l:'
rk

..
1:
:
1
2
.
:
.

k

g
d
'

-'-'
''.'
,'
.-''
.. '.
.
b
.

t
.

w ' e C
M
'
..
w uu
1

.
.

/
,

**
'

d: !.
:i g
s) (
j- !
: q
j
E

<.; . .o .
.
.

o
/

X
N
N
/>
'

cj
>

.- r
. m

S6 G r <'
.
' D a c'
.
= c a
<
O
m

j
a
z
A

i '' ' '*
i' '- ' E
'
* '- ' '

,

=

N
O
O>
c vl O ,m
o
C A
.
-4
z
+7 %d '2 C '
. V eJ
O O t
n
< .- - r +7 cl> -*
4
.
*)*1 Z G e 0
r

jr 4
.j .
.

m ; J:
. :f
X :
1J
,
1o
,S
?
Ay

4t
e
m
..j
:j
a

. . '.*
5

.

:*
v
jj
;.

.
.

N
.e.
*rA.
.:
%
e%.
. ee

'.-1
.
1
.

.
,
1
.
.

ê.

A'*
. .
l :

:.
1

/

: r
5 W
' -A
r,
N
4
.

c
''
'
k
q

!
'
)
l
@
f
'r
'
j
(
'
''
.'

<
X
r >
.j
m RN
jz q
s )
q) f
-l
N r ,
d

1
C
V
W
t & .
Q'
5
*
+. C
c S

ç'
g

;
i

= =

O

kPp
c
o7
C
q
:

V
e
t

C c4
<

- -

I1
f:
'
.
.
.
31j
$.
y
#+
r
r1
*
.
.

jk
i:
,I
.1
r.
.
!
(
,
k
$
)

1

.- -

i
'

/

/
/
'
,
'
'
'

.
< () *'#
' : ;*
*

O 7
D

. .

j
K
k

-. .-

*I% O Q
r i Y
J- +D m e7
Q
M
(
n
O
,
&1rl .- O* Q
* 21 Y
r
* . k
f :
Q

,

''';''.
''i''
''
'
'
... ..
'.
-. .
.
:

:
7

=
=

.

r #&
-.

'

d'' 2
//.?
,/
?

=
=

L' x u,
o
' x

''

'

.

- -

-

.
-