Hartford Life and Accident Insurance Company v. King et al

Filing 55

ORDER granting 51 Motion to Dismiss; adopting 52 Report and Recommendations. Signed by District Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 3/5/13. (mka)

r = œs OeRCE u ,& tt l,
a
ns coUr

AT R- OG ,
VA
F'ED
L

MA2 2s 2 1
23
I T H E UN I
N
TED STATES DI
STR I T CO U R T
C
FO R TH E W E STER N D I
STRI T O F V I G I A JuuA c.
C
R NI
ou
tx
ecuEf
R O AN OK E DIVISI N
O
B
Y:
.
Jz
DEPt

CLE

H A R TFO R D L I A N D AC CID ENT
FE
I SU R AN CE CO M PAN Y ,
N
Pl ntf ,
ai if

C i lA cton N o. 7: cvvi
i
: 11- 411

C H A RLE S PA TRI K K I G ,d aI,
C
N
.

By:H o M i hae F.U rbans
n. c l
ki
U nied Stat D i ri Judge
t
es st ct

D ef
endant
s.

O RD ER

Thi i t r e de a ton wasr e r d t t Honor bl Ro r S. lou,Unied St t
s n e pl a r c i
ef r e o he
a e be t Ba l
t
a es

M a srt J ,purua t 28U. C.j b ()B) f prpos tndi offc,
gitae udge s nt o
S. 636() 1( , or o ed i ngs a t
c us ons ofl w ,a a r c m e d di post o O n Fe ua y 6,201 t M a sr t J
oncl i
a nd e om nde s ii n.
br r
3, he gi ta e udge
f l d a r po ta r om m e ton,r c m e ng t tt Cour g an t m oton f s m a y
ie e r nd ec
nda i e om ndi ha he
t r t he
i or um r

j gme fldbyHa to dLieandAccde I urnceCo nytklrfr l, r ne ty
ud nt ie
rfr f
i nt ns a
mpa û-a to d' pema nl
l
e j nJ nGne a an ot rpotnta be fcir fo a s ri a cam orrg t t
n oi oa
gy nd y he e il nei ay rm s etng ny li
iht o he
pr e oft H a tor lf i ur nce a gr a ci nt de t a di m e be m entpolc es
oc eds he rf d ie ns a
nd oup c de al a h nd s m r
ii
a i s i t sm ate , g a thej itmoin o t pate t ds u s $ ,6 .7 f o t
t s ue n hi
t r r n t on
to f he ris o ib re 216 06 1 r m he
i e pl a f
nt r e ded undst H a tor f a t r ys f e a c t i ur e i flng t s i er e r
o rf d or to ne ' e s nd os s nc r d n ii hi nt pl ade

a to , rn t ej i t to o tepat st ds u s ter mann itr la e f n sa d
cin g a t h o n mo in f h ri o ib re h e i ig n epe d d u d n
e
ac r i e e tt Rebe c Re d, c oroft Es a e ofAnn Gne K i f di bur ali
c ued nt r s o
c a e Exe ut
he t t
gy ng, or s s n

ac or ncewiht pa te s tlme ta e nt a dimist sa tonwihprj c a t al
c da
t he ris' ete n greme , nd s s hi ci t eudie s o l
partes.
i
'Therpor a r co ndato er ousy sae t a
e t nd e mme in rone l tts he mountr queseda at ne sf sa $ 667.67.
e t s tor y' ee s 20

Noo j cin t t rp r a dr c mme d to h veb e fld a t ec u tso t e
b e to s o he e o t n e o n ain a e n ie , nd h o r i f h
o ni n t tt r por a r c m e ton s ul be a ed i ise ie y. I i a cor ngl
pi o ha he e t nd e om nda i ho d
dopt n t ntr t t s c di y
O R D ER ED a A DJU D G ED a f l s
nd
s olow :

1
)

Ha tor sM otonfrSummayJ
rf d' i o
r udgme ( .# 1 i GRANTED;
nt Dkt 5) s

2
)

Purua t 28U. C.j2361 J n Gne a a ohe pot talbe fcai of
s nt o
S.
, oa
gy nd ny t r eni ne iires

t polc e a e PER M AN EN TLY EN JO I ED fom a s r i a cl i orrghtt t
he i i s r
N
r
s e tng ny a m
i o he
pr e dsoft H a tor polc e ;
oc e
he rf d i i s

3)

Thepa tes j n motont dibure$216 6 fom t i epl de f t
ri 'oit i o s s ,60.7 r he ntr ea d unds o

Ha tor f a t ne sf esa cos si G R ANTED . The Cl r i di e t d t di bur e
r f d or tor y' e nd t s
ek s rce o s s

$ l660. fom t i e pla f
2 , 67 r he ntr e ded undswih ache k mad pa bl t tla tor Lie az
t
c
e ya e o i- rf d f td
l
Acc de I ur nc Co pa ' a delve e t K e n W . ol,Ge r Loc Ra s & M oor
i nt ns a e m ny,' nd i r d o vi
H t nt y
ke ke
e,
LLP,c
ouns lf H a to d.
e or r f r

4
)

Th p ris j itmo int d s u s t ermanngitr e d dfnd a d
e a t ' on to o ib re h e ii nepla e u s n
e

a cr d i e es t Re cc Ree t Exe ut oft Es a e ofAnn G ne K i f di btr a i
c ue nt r t o be a
d, he
c or he t t
gy ng, or s ls l n
a co da e w ih t pa te 's tl m e a e m e ti G R AN TED .
c r nc t he ri s e te nt gr e n s
The Cl r i die t d t
ek s rce o
di bu s t r m a ni f
s r e he e i ng unds a a 1a c u i t r tt J m e W . r t c uns f r Re c
nd l c r ed n e es o a s Sho t, o el o be ca
R e d,Exe ut roft Es a e o A n Gnegy K i
e
c o
he t t f n
ng.

Thsmatri hee yDI I ED wihp eu ie a dSTRI
i te s r b SM SS
t rj dc , n
CKEN fo tea tv
r m h ci e
doc oft c t
ket he our .

Ent r M a c 5, 3
e : r h 201

4/

r 4mr . V =V ' s
r
'
Mi
chaelF.U r
banski
Unie St t Di t i tJ
t d a es s rc udge