Neal v. Circuit Court Danville, VA

Filing 3

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 09/21/2011. (kab)

CLERK:OFFI t S. ST. at'
CE J, OS Cotrl
ATROM OKE,
VA
, x
w.
FI
LED

I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI CO URT
CT
FO R TH E W E STER N D I
STR I O F V I G I I
CT
R N A
ROANOKE DI I O N
V SI
B O BBY A .N EAL ,JR.
,
Pett oner,
ii
V.

DANVI
LLE CI
RCUI CO URT,
T
R es
pondent
.

)
)
)
)
)
)
)

SEP 22 1
1
J A C.
ULI D
BY:'
' DEPU

, L
ERK'
C ERK

C i lA cton N o.7: cvvi
i
11- 00438

M EM O R AND U M O PI I N
N O
By:M i hae F.U rbans
c l
ki
U nied St es D i ri Judge
t
at
st ct

Bobby A .N e , J . pr e ng pr s , fl t s pe ii f w rt of ha a co pus
al r , oce di
o e ied hi tton or i
be s r ,

purua t 28U. C.j2254.OnM a 1 2011 Ne lwasf
s nt o
S.
y 9, , a
oundno guit byr s ofi a t
t ly ea on ns niy
i t D mw il Cic t Cour on c r s of a s ul a ba t r a r i tng a r s . N e ha
n he
le r ui
t
ha ge
s a t nd t e y nd es s i r e t
al s
a r nty bee co m it d t t ca e ofCe r lSt t H os t i Pe er bur V igi a. Se Va.
ppa e l
n m te o he r
nta a e
pial n t s g, r ni
e

Code.j 1 2- 82. ets whe a dee nti Vigi a i ound no g ly by ras of
9. 1 2, eq.( n
fnda n r ni sf
t uit
e on
i a t he i c mit i untrl t t c t oft Com mi so rofM e a He lh of
ns niy, s om ted nvol a iy o he usody he
s i ne
nt l at

M e t Readai .Nea a a st bec le ngt c tsfndi t thewa no guit by
nal tr ton)
l ppe r o halngi he our' i ng ha
s t ly
r as of i a t H ow e r N ea ha no sa e a s ngl i e lgi e or c za e c a m f
e on
ns niy.
ve ,
l s t t t d i e nt li bl
ogni bl l i or

r ifunde j225 Furher i a r he s e da
ele
r
4. t , t ppeas e ks mage ,whih a e nota l e i ha as
s c r
vaiabl n be

pr ee ngs Pr ie v.Rodrgue 411U. 475 (973 ( be c pusi t rme f asae
oc di . es r
i z,
S.
1 ) ha as or s he e dy or tt
pr s ne who c l nge t f c or d z a i n ofhi c i m e a s ks i m e a e o s di r
io r
hale s he a t lr to
s onfne nt nd ee m di t r pee e

r l s) Stl f t r i a ast tNea ha f l t e us a poe i cam hema ha
eea e. il urhe, t ppe r ha
l s aied o xha t ny tntal li
y ve
unde j225 Pr s r 211U. a 475( fdealcou tc nnotgrntahabe peii unls t
r
4. eie,
S. t
ae r
r n
a
as tton e s he

peiine has trtexha td alsaec trme es a ia e . Ac or ngl f a1t e
tto r
is
use 1 tt-our e di valbl)
c di y, or 1 hes
ras t cour dimis sNea' peii wihoutprj ce.
e ons he t s s e
ls tton t
eudi
(
'

EN TER:Thi
s

- a of Se e be ,2011
' y
a
pt m r
.
*

nie St t D i t i t udg
t d a es sr c
e

: