Sensabaugh v. Shortt et al

Filing 15

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge James C. Turk on 3/21/2012. (tvt)

u

h
.. , t,R'
ï #
U
ATROANOV ,
VA .
FlPD
?
-

MA2 2 12 1
22

FNTHU IEETDE RCRCVCGRA
IRTE WET SAIS ITO TIOIT
O H ENT DR TSDS I RU I
S N T F N

J A C,
ULI D
av;

DP Lv
E gy

R O AN O K E D I ISIO N
V
D O NN I W A YN E SEN SA BA U G H ,
E
Ci lA cton N o.7: c 00443
vi
i
11- v-

Pli c
ant
M EM O M N D UM O PIN IO N

STEPH A N I SH O R TT,etal,
E
.

De ndant.
fe
s

By: H on.Jam es C .Turk
Seni U nied St es D i ri Judge
or t
at
st ct

D onni W a Se a ugh, oc ed ng pr s ,fl d a c vi r gh sa ton pur ua t 42
e yne ns ba
pr e i
o e ie
i l i t ci
s nt o

U. C.j 1 Thi c ei pr s tybef et Cour onwhatt Cour consr sa amoi
S.
983. s as s eenl or he
t
he
t tue s ton

t atro a n i p ir u g n , n e Fe . Ci . 5 () ( tNo. 4 .
o le r me d t ro j d me t u d r d R. v P. 9 e . Dk . 1 )
s
Thi Cour pr vi l dimis Se a ugh' c s f fiur t saeacli ( .
s
t e ousy s sed nsba s a e or al e o tt am. DktNo.

1 ) Howe r s eq l t Cour lanedt tSe a ughha malda Ame d
0.
ve, ubs uenty,he
te r ha ns ba
d ie n
nde
Compli prort hi c s be ng dimis d. Acc di y, heCour va t isprordimi s l
ant i o s a e i
s se
or ngl t
t caed t i s s a

o de t s ei t Ame dCompli sae acam u whihr le c dbegrntd.( .
r r o e f he nde
ant ttd li pon c eif oul
a e Dkt
No.1 .TheCour r ewedt Ame
2)
tevi
he
ndedCo antbutdi nottnda ne e de eo
mpli
d i ny w vi nc r

cli t tco ds vi sr ni unde 28U. C.j1 5() s t Cour dimis dt
ams ha ul ur ve cee ng
r
S. 91 e, o he
t s se he
Ame
ndedCo aitf f l et saeacam.( t No.1 .
mpl n or aiur o tt li Dk.
2)

I hi moto t a ndt Cou tsj me tSe a ughmake t f l ng
n s in o me he r' udg n ns ba
s he olowi
a g ns:( )t tn1w s t t tlsa ' c us t yweeçs ..beor Jnuay2
r ume t 1 he e a uis ' il tnd'be a e he r çend . f e a r 2,
s
201 '1( hepai t $350flngfea i e ildt alwy r a ( hes dha be n
2' 2)
,
d he
ii e nd s ntte o a e , nd 3) houl ve e
gr ed l
ant eavet nm end hi Com pl nt A ddii l Sens
o
s
ai .
tonaly,
abaugh appearst r at i an
o est e, n

a e a e f m , he ar e she m a i hi Co pl i a Am e
bbr vi t d or t
gum nt
de n s m a nt nd
nded Com pl nt
ai .
'TheCour c tuest sa a a s ri t Sens ba s r hi co pli ont t def nt.
t onsr hi s n s e ton hat
a ugh eved s m ant he en enda s

E , CL
' ERK
Y

A moint atro a n afn lu g n u d rF d R. v P. 9 e ma b g a tdi
to o le r me d ia j d me t n e e . Ci. 5 () y e rne f
ne esay14)t a ommodaea i eve ngc ng i c r lnglw;( t a co frne
c sr ;1 o cc
t n ntr ni ha e n ontoli a 2) o c unt o w

e de enota ia ea ti ' ( t c rec ace rero oflw o prve manie tij tc '
vi nc
valbl t ralor 3) o or t la rr a r e nt fs n usie.
,
'

Pa .n . . . Na 'FieI s Co.1 8F.d3 6 4 3(t Ci.1 9 )(iainso t d .
c l s Co v Am. tl r n . , 4 3 9 , 0 4h r 9 8 ctto mit )
e
F rh r r ,ie o sdeaino aj d me t fe ise tyi a e ta r iayrme ywhc
u temo e C c n i rto f u g n a tr t nr s n xr o dn r e d ih
r
s ul beus ds rngl 'l (ntr lquotto maksomitdl s eRo ns v.W i
ho d
e pa i y. d. i ena
'
ain r
te ; e bi on
x
Fitai Cor ,599F. 403,411(t Ci. 0)
lrton p.
3d
4h r 201 .
Noneoft agume sad nc dbySe a ughstsyt Rul 59( sa r Thee
he r
nt va e
ns ba aif he e e) tndad. r
ha be n no c
s e
hange i t c r lng l w a Se aba ha notpr s nt ne e de e t t
n he ont oli a nd ns ugh s
e e ed w vi nc ha

waspr vi usy una ia et hi .Fi ly,Se a ugh ha f ie t pr s nta e de eofa
e o l
va lbl o m
nal ns ba
s a ld o e e ny vi nc

û nietij tc 'i hi c s ,des t wha t Cour bele i hi snc r beleft t
d fs nusie'n s a e pie t he
ma
t ives s s i ee i o he
con r r Se a ug sa g e t thi l w s t s ul t tl s a ' c us t y w e e s r d
t a y. ns ba h' r um nt ha s a uis ho d t il t nd' be a e he
s
r e ve

be or J nua y 22,201 i unpe s i f rt r as . Fis, he e i no i c ton t t
f e a r
2, s
r uasve o wo e ons r t t r s ndi a i ha
Sens ba h f l d t pr rpr edur st s r hi lw s t a t s r i ewoul be
a ug olowe he ope oc e o eve s a uis nd hus e v c
d
i f ec i und r Fe R . v. 4. Spe ii a l t r i no e de e t ta s m onsw a e r
ne f tve e d. Ci P.
c tc ly, he e s
vi nc ha um
s ve
i s d i t sc e;nori t r a e de e t ta wa v r ofs r c w ass
s ue n hi as
s he e ny vi nc ha
ie
e vi e
ought Se ond, nd,
. c
a
m or i po t nty,e n i Se a ugh ha pr ry s r d hi Com pl i on t t n def n s
e m r a l ve f ns ba
d ope l e ve s
a nt he e
enda t ,
pr pe s r c doesnott u p t sCour ' oblga i t dim i s l galy m e il s c ai spur ua
o r e vi e
r m hi
ts i ton o s s e l
rtes l m
s nt

t 28U. C.j 1 5()
o
S.
91 e.Addii ly,Se a ugh' agume t thei e ildt a atr y
tonal nsba s r nt ha s ntte o n tone
be us hepa dt flng f ei unpe s i Alho t Cou tgr nt d Se a ug s
ca e
i he ii e s
r uasve. t ugh he
r a e ns ba h'
a i a i t pr ee i f r a pa rs whi h u rc r a n c r um s a e w oul e il hi t
pplc ton o oc d n o m
upe i , c nde e t i i c t nc s
d ntte m o
a courtappoi ed ator
nt t ney,asnot above,t Courtwasoblgat t di m i hi case under28
ed
he
i ed o s ss s

U. C j1 5()f f l et saeacli
S. 91 e or aiur o tt am.Thus Se a ughwa no e ildt ac t
, ns ba
s t ntte o our
a
ppoi e a t ne
nt d tor y.
Fort f eg ng r as ,t Cour de e Pl i if sm o i t a t rora e t
he or oi e ons he
t ni s a ntf ' ton o le
m nd he

j d me t Ana p o raeo d rs al hsd yis e
u g n . p r p it r e h lt i a su .

ENTER:T ip dyo Mac 2 1.
hs x a f rh 02
Z
S ' Unie St t D it l tJ
t d a es s rc udge