Stout v. Hobbs et al

Filing 4

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 10/13/2011. (tvt)

OFFI U. DI M UA
CE B. BX
AT FrJNOKE,
I. .
),
VA
!)

I TH E U N I D STA TE S D I
N
TE
STR I C O U R T
CT
FO R TH E W ESTER N D I
STR I O F VI G I I
CT
R N A
R O A N O K E D I ISIO N
V

DE BO R AH K .STO U T,
Pl ntif
ai f ,

OCT 13 n 1
. ,1
C
JUL ' t ' ') ' 'C'ERK
. ; tJ k J
BY:
D

Ci lA c i N o.7: c 00482
vi t on
11- vM EM O M N D UM O PINIO N

V.

W EN D Y S.H O B BS,W AR D EN ,
FLUV AN N A CO R R EC TI N A L
O
CEN TE R FO R W O M EN ,ET AL.
,
D efendant
s.

By:Sam uelG . is
W l on
U ni ed States Di t ctJudge
t
s ri

Pl i ifDebor h K .St tbrngst sa ton f rc
antf
a
ou i hi c i o ompens t y da a s de a a or
aor m ge , clr t y

rle, n ij n tv r le t r d e salg dvilto so h rFis, g t , n Fo re nh
eif a d n u cie eif o e r s le e oain f e rtEih h a d u te t
Am e
ndme rght . She al gest tt def nda sha dic i i t d aga ns he ; eala e
nt i s
le
ha he e nt ve s rm na e
i t r r t it d
a ns he ; olt d he e
gai t r vi a e r qualpr e ton rg s diplyed dei r t i fer nc t he m e c
ot c i i ht ; s a
lbe a e ndif e e o r dial

ne d 'mpig du o h rfe d mso s e c , x rs in a dc ie a ds b e tdh rt cu l
e s i n e p n e re o f p e h e p e so , n hoc ; n u j ce e o r e
,
a unus puni hm e . Bec e St hasf ie t s a e a c a m f r le , rc pl i i
nd
ual
s nt
aus out
a l d o t t l i or e i f he om a nt s

ds s e wih u p eu ie
imis d t o t rj d c .
Fe a Rul ofCi lPr e e8()2)rquie a' hor andpl nsae ntoft cai
derl e
vi oc dur a( e r s f t
s
ai ttme
he l m
s ngt tt pl de i e ildt r if' Fe R. v. 8a ( .Thi fmiirr ei
howi ha he ea r s ntte o ele . d. Ci P. ()2) s a la ul s
'
gr a l r l xe f
e ty e a d oïpr s pli if,and ltga swih m e iorousc am ss d notbesym id
o e a ntfs
ii nt t rt i
l i houl
t e

byt hnialnzesofpladi Se Be tv.CiyofHa on,775F. 1 1 -78( h
ec c l
e ng. e audet t
mpt
2d 274, 277 4t
Ci.1 ) Therlxai ofRul 8a)2 i no,howe r wiho lmis A c tmus bea e
r 985 .
ea ton
e ( () s t
ve, t ut i t. our t bl
t di ce n f o t c pl ntt pa te bei s d a t a l ged c
o s r r m he om ai he r i s ng ue nd he le
onduc on w hi h e c c a m
t
c a h li
r t . Though r a
es s
el xed,t s a
he t ndar s ilde andsge r lc r e,a i doesnotr uie
d tl m
ne a ohe enc nd t
eq r

cou t toc j r upquesi ne rs rl pr s e t t m.'1 at1
rs t on u e
t
tons ve quaey eentd o he ' d. 278.

St utha ,i t sc e, es nt d t c t t a e g e n- ge c
o
s n hi as pr e e he our wih n i ht e pa ompli ag ns ni
ant ai t ne
de e nt . The gr ofde e nt i l
f nda s
oup
f nda s nc udesa r
ange ofpr e s onaltt e ,f om pr s w a de
of s i
il s r
i on r n
t buidi m a ge t om buds a The c pl i i l s t e def nda s
o l ng na r o
m n.
om a nt nc ude hos
e nt--ofen
t

tng taly- i ade a ld tm e i ofeve soc uni fom J nua y 3,2011t Aug t1
a en i l n
t ie i lne
nt c ng r
a r
o
us 4,
2011. I t cour i a e t di ce n a alege c tt i lvi a i f om t stm elne, ti
f he
t s bl o s r ny l d onsiutona ol tons r hi i i i s
t tSt w asas i d t a c l w ih a di ag ee bl hom os xualr m a e who pr f r ed t us
ha out
s gne o e l t
s r a e
e
oom t
eer o e
a f n t c r a e ai i t ce l a t s f n c ed St t be c d and ha nos bl eds
a o icul t r n he l, nd hi a aus
out o
ol
ve e e .

De piet g ea de a li t c
s t he r t t i n he ompli ,nowhe ea et aleg vi a i ofSt '
ant
r r he l ed ol tons
outs
c tt i lrght ati e t a i vi ua a t o e n t t gr aci i c er.Nor
onsiutona i s trbut d o ny ndi d l c or r ve o he oup tng n onc t
i t c ta et a c i pa tc a c s ofc
s he our bl o s rbe ri ul r our es onduc t pa tc a consiutona vi a i .
t o riulr
tt i l oltons
W hie t pl a ng r esdo noti pos a e c i s a r on St ,s m us of e s e
l he e di ul
m
e n xa tng t nda d
out he
t f r om
f t d on whi h t def nda s c n ba e a ans e oron whi h t co tc n bas a opi on.
oo hol
c he e nt a s n w r
c he ur a
e n ni

Ac o dngy t ec u t ldimisS o tsc mplit t o t rj d c f rfiu et saea
c r i l ,h o r wil s s t u ' o an wih u p eu ie o alr o tt
cl i .
am
x 'e

.

-*
.. *
..

EN TER :Thi 13 h da ofOc obe ,2011.
s t y
t r

z.

.'
e'
xr

E STA TES D I
STRI J DG E
CT U