De'lonta v. Clarke et al

Filing 56

ORDER denying 39 Motion to Compel; granting in part and denying in part 20 Motion for Summary Judgment; granting 31 Motion for Protective Order; dismissing claims and terminating named defendants. Signed by Judge James C. Turk on 09/11/2012. (kab)

CL SOFFI t.:. :m cœ R'
ERK'
CE J Dt
r
ATRM NOKE,VA
FIED
L

I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI CO URT
CT
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF VI NI
CT
RGI A
R O AN O K E D I I O N
V SI

sEF 112 1
02
JSL C, U L M CLERK
J
E

BY:

O PH ELI A ZRI D EC N TA
A
EL
LO

E W CL
PU
ERK
Ci lA c i N o.7: - vvi t on
11 c BB483

Pl ntf ,
ai i f
V.

By: H on.
Jam esC .Tur
k
H A R OLD C LA R K E,etal,
.
Se or Unied St e Di t c Judg
ni
t
at s s ri t
e
D e endant .
f
s
I a cor ne w ih t a co pa ng M e or nd Opi on, ti he e O RDERED
n c da e t he c m nyi
m a um
ni i s r by

a ADJ
nd UDGED t t( )Dee nt'M oinf SummayJ gme tont gr ndo
ha 1 fnda s to or
r ud n he ou f
QuaiidI
lfe mmuniyi GRANTED ast Pl nifscamsf rmo tr da
t s
o aitf li o neay mage unde 42
s r
U. C.j1 ( . 20 , ndt Clr i diecedt tr naealDee nse e Sa a
S. 983 DktNo. ) a he ek s r t o emi t l fnda t xc pt rh
Pr t a pa te t t a ton;( Defnd nt'M oto f Pr e tveOr r( .No.31 i
uit s ris o he ci 2) e a s in or otci de Dkt
)s

GRANTED;( )Plitf' j 1 8 camsfrij n tv a dd caao yr l fa ans te
3 an ifs 9 3 li o n u ci e n e lrt r ei g i th
e
mo igDee d n sa eDI M I ED u d r2 U. C. 1 5e ()b f rfiu et saeacam;
vn fn a t r S SS n e 8 S. j 91 ()2 ( ) o alr o tt li
()P anifsM oint Co e ( tNo. 9 i DENJ a d( )t tee tn ta P anif
4 li t
f
to o mp l Dk . 3 ) s
ED; n 5 o h xe t h t litf
r ie saelw cams s c camsaeDI M I ED wih u p eu c u d r28U. C.
as s tt a li , u h li r S SS
t o t rj die n e
S.
#13 c . antf scai ag ns Saa Pr t rmanpe ngbef et cour.
67() Pli if l ms ai t rh uit e i ndi
or he t
The C i r i die t t s nd a c r ii co oft sO r ra t a com pa ng
e k s x c ed o e
e tfed py hi de nd he c
nyi

Me a
mor ndum Opi on t t
ni o hepr s Pl i ifa co e f De e nt ,
/ e antf nd uns l or f nda s

ENTE

R: s
Thi

gW

t
z

cj .
s '

/ M a ofSept m be ,201
y
e r
2.
.

J

H on. J e C. lk
->
am s Tt
r
Se orUnie St t s D it i J
ni
t d a e s rd udge