Atkins v. Schwartz et al

Filing 8

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 10/28/2011. (tvt)

O pRK' OFFI U. DI COURT
s
CE S. ST.
AT ROANOKE,
VA
F! rr
. 7

I TH E U N I
N
TED STATE S D I
STR I C O U R T
CT
FO R TH E W ESTERN D I
STR I O F VI G I I
CT
R N A
ROANOKE DI I ON
V SI
D AV I ATK I S,
D
N

02T 3 1 2 1
21
J A(
ULt 1
BY;
D

'W
'
C

CA SE NO .7: V00493
11C

Pl ntif
ai f ,

M EM O M NDUM OPI ON
NI
V S.

KATHY SCHW ARTZ, & ,
c

By: Gln E. nr d
e Co a
ChifUnied St e Dit i tJudge
e
t
at s s r c

De e
f ndants.
t)
D a d A t ns a V i gi a i a e pr e ng pr K ,f l d t s ci lr ght a ton ptr ua
vi ki ,
r ni nm t oc edi
o
ie hi vi i s c i
l s nt

t 4 U. C.j 1 8 ,algngt a t ed fn a tji o t asha ede rv d hm o a p o rae
o 2 S.
9 3 le i h t h e e d n al fkil v p ie i f p r p it
m e c lte t nt i vi a i ofhi c tt i nalrght . Fi ng t tAt ns a l a i nsf l
di a r a me , n olton
s onsiuto
i s ndi ha ki ' leg to ai

t saea cli a tonabl t rj1 t c twils
o tt ny am ci e mde 983,he our l ummarl dimist a ton.
iy s s he ci
I

At ns s isonsi c t t f l ng s que eofe nt fom whi h hi cli
ki ' ubm s i ndi a e he olowi e nc
ve s r
c s a ms
a ie.At nssa e t thes f r fo S-ypogl mi ,'s i tr s a he dac , orwhi he
rs
ki t t s ha
ufe s r m ûl
l
yce a' e zze , nd a hes f
ch
ha be n pr s rbed I ti
s e e ci
ma rx.On Se embe 7, 1, fcal ta f red At nsfom t
pt
r 201 ofi i s r nse r
ki r he

No f l Ciyji t t eRo kn h m-- n s n u gRe in l al thej i'.Afe h sfrtd y
rok t al o h c ig a la i o b r go a J i (é a1) tr i is a
l
t
'
t r , es o et an re if r dhe t a h h dp e iu l b e ic r eae a tej i a d
hee h p k o u s ,n o me r h t e a r vo sy e n n ac rtd t h al n
t ta docort r ha pr vi l pr s rbed at
ha
t he e d e ousy e c i
i
doubl pori dit'be us o hi
e ton e ' ca e f s

h p lc mi.Th n rei fr dAti st a t ej iû i n t ra h p gy e m' At i
y ogy e a e u s n ome k n h t h alt d o te t y o lc mi ' kns
d
sg e ar la et alw j ime ia p ro n loo ti h sme ia r c r a e p ce t e
in d ee s o lo al dc l e s n e t b an i dc l e o ds nd x e td h
nur e t si hi up t s a doct .
s o gn m
o ee
or

I t eg nea p p aina tej i, kn ta e p o e t i mst ohe i tsf r
n h e rl o ulto t h alAt is r d d r p ry t o t r nmae o
e
e r f i hi sl- rce efor t tc r g s media c ton. W henhebega getng
xta ood n s efdie td f t o çontol hil c l ondii '
'
n ti

LERK

hea c ,c d s a s dizi sa bl vii n, i or e t ntre t thebele d t s
da hes ol we t , z nes nd uny so he nf m d he ls ha
i ve he e
s
ympt r ule fom adr i hi bl s rlve . Thentr et d hi t tno docorhad
oms es t d r
op n s ood uga e l
zs ol m ha
t
or r d nur e t c c At ns bl s ara no onehad o de e as c a di tf rhi . On
de e
s s o he k ki ' ood ug nd
r r d pe i l e o m
Se e be 1 2011, ki fld agre nc des rbi hi s
pt m r 0,
At ns ie
iva e, c i ng s ympt a compl i ngt t
oms nd
ani ha
ofk il we ede ng hi te t e f rhi hypog yc m i A nur er ponde a sng hi
t a s r nyi
m r am nt o s
l e a.
s es
d, dvi i m
t tt m ed c lde rme wa silwaii f rl um e a i 'a t the c dfl a
ha he
i a pa t nt s tl tng o t
doc nt ton' nd ha
oul ie
medialr ques ora k a ofk e r r ng ta por t t medialuni f e
c e t s n t r ega di r ns t o he
c
t or xami ton.
na i

I t d,At nsa
nsea
ki ppeaed t g ivanc r pons a s ntt s rf ar ue tf m e ca
l he re
e es e nd e he he if eq s or di l
t eat ent
r m .

Thi r ques wasf wa ded t t ntr e who had ofk il brng At nst t m e ca
se t
or r
o he zs ,
t as i
ki o he di l

u io S p e r1 , 01 .Th r , ed s o rdt tt j id dha eme ia r c r fo hi
nt n e tmbe 5 2 1 e e h ic vee ha he al i v d c l e o ds r m s
prori r e ai n,i l ng doc e ai n oft ditt ta s ci ithad or r d f rhi
i nca c r to nc udi
um nt to
he e ha pe als
de e o m
dzi t ttm e.Het d t nm s s s ul c i t tpr vi l or r s c a d e .
lrng ha i
ol he
e he ho d ontnue ha e ousy de ed, pe i l i t
W he he sildi notr c vet dit hefld m o e gre nc .On Se embe 1 2011
n
tl d
e ei he e , ie
r iva es
pt
r 9,
,
ofk il or r hi m ove t t m e ca de rm e , r hi m e c obs r a i c l ha
t a s de ed m
d o he di l pa t nt whe e s dial e v ton el d
bl o t wal and bl
ood n he ls
oody ts ueson t foor I t media uni, alo c dno wac
is
he l . n he
c l t he s oul t th
t e son,ply boar ga e wih ot ri t s ors
elvii
a
d m s t he nma e , howe eve y da a hi t lphoneus e
r r y, nd s ee
ag

wa lm ie Nlr esc c At ns t mpe atr a bl pr s tr r gul l butdi not
s i t d. zs he ked ki ' e r tze nd ood e sle e ary,
d
c c hi bl s ar
he k s ood ug .

At nsas t nur ewhy heha be n m o d,a s s i ç a e o yom
ki ked he s
d e
ve nd he a d,t us f
Bec
greva ' She s i t tbe us he had a ke f m e c lt e t en , f c al ha hi m o d
i nce.
'
a d ha ca e
s d or di a r a m t of i i s d m
ve

t t m e c luni s t tt m e c lsa fwoul moniorhi c to At nst n Gl d
o he di a t o ha he di a t f
d
t s ondii n. ki he e
g i va esa a a s com pl i ng t tt nur e ha or r d hi m ove i r t la i f hi
r e nc nd ppe l ,
a ni ha he s d de e s
n e a i ton or s

greva es I r pons ofi i sa s hi t tm e ca saf woul moniorhi condii a
i nc . n es e, fcal dvied m ha di l t f
d
t s
ton nd

c n u t t t ej i d co , owo l i a etefn l a o (ilte t n .
o s l wi h al o tr wh ud û v h i a s y n h s r ame t'
h
h
'
At nssaest thi s
ki t t ha s ympt sha g t n wor e.Hebe iveshi bl s ri
om
ve ote
s
le
s ood uga s
t oppi m or ,' ha l tw ei ht a he r c vesno bl s r c c o t e t e f hi
ç
dr ng
e ' he s os
g , nd
e ei
ood uga he ks r r a m nt or s

he c .At nss t he ntr ea t s rf,s e ng $2, 000 i damage .
ada hes ki ues he ad zs nd he he if e ki
500, n
s
1
1

Thec ti rquie t dimisa a tonorcam tl byaprs rpr e ngt
our s e r d o s s ny ci
li ied
ione oc edi q
f m a pa r s i i de er i st ac i o c ai i f i ous m alc ous or f ist s a e a cl i
or
upe i f t t m ne he ton r l m s rvol , i i , a l o t t
am

o whi rle ma begane 28U. C.j1 5 b)1 .I or t saeacam i a
n ch eif y r td.
S.
91 A( () n der o tt li n ny

fd r l i la to ,h pli tf sS ta ta alg to smus bee o g t r iearg t orle
e ea cvi ci n te anif ûl cu l le ain
l
t n u h o as ih t eif
a
bovet s c a i l ,'o one t ti E a i eon isf c 'r t rt n m e e y
he pe ultve evel't
ha s t usbl
pl
t a e,' a he ha
rl

t onceva e. BelAt. . Two y,550U. 5 570(
i i bl ' l lCop v. mbl
c
'
S. 44, 2007) Afe ar vi of
. tr e ew
At ns salega i , heco tc udest thef l t alegef c ssai a pl usbl c am
ki ' l tons t
ur oncl
ha
ais o l a t t tng ny a i e l i

a tona eunde j 1
ci bl
r 983.

To saeac us ofa tonunde j 1 aplitf mus esa iht heha be n
tt a e ci
r 983, anif t tbls hat
s e
de i d ofrg sg r nt e by t Consiu i orlwsoft Unied St t sa t tt s
prve
i ht ua a e d
he
tt ton a
he t
a e nd ha hi
de i ton r s t d f om c
prva i e ule r
onduc c m it d by a pe s a tng unde c orofs a e l w . W e t
t om te
r on c i
r ol
tt a
s

v. ki , U. 42( 988) At nsriest e cli ,ba e onhi al to a hi
At ns 487 S. 1 . ki as hre ams s d
s legains bout s

me ia c r a tej i:( )d lb rt idifrn eb ten s t p an ifss ro me ia
d c l ae t h al 1 eieae n fee c y h ure o litf eius dc l
ne df t prviusypr ci ddit ( rtlai byt nurefrpli ifss si of
e or he e o l esrbe e ;2) eaiton he s o antf ubmison
g ivanc ; ( dei rt i fee byt s ift pli ifsne f t dit
re es and 3) lbeae ndifrnce he herf o antf ed or he e.
A pr s ofk i l sde i r t i f e e e t a i a e' s r ous m e c ne vi a e
i on t a ' lbe a e ndif r nc o n nm t s e i
di al eds ol t s

t Ei hAme nt Se Esel v. mbl,429U. 97,1 2 ( 976) A c ttto l
he ght
ndme . e tle Gn e
S. 0 1 . onsiuina

vo ai ni t sc ne tn ole b t a o j ciea das b e t ec mp e t Th o j cie
ilto n hi o tx iv v s oh n b e tv n u j ci o on n . e b e tv
v
com pone i m e i t de i ton i û ufk i nty s r ous ' Fa m erv.Br nnan,511 U . 8
nt s t f he prva i s i t e l e i . r
s
'
e
S. 25,

834( 994) A s fce l s ro me c lnee i C t tha be ndignosdbyaphysca
1 . ufiinty eius dia d st ha s e a e
one
iin
a ma tngte t ntoronet ti s obvi ust te n al pe s woul e iy r ogni
s nda i r a me
ha s o
o ha ve ay r on
d asl ec ze

tene e st frad do ' atnin. I ov S r v , 35F.d2 5 2 ( t Ci. 0 ) The
h c siy o o rs te to ' k . h e e 5 3 2 , 41 4h r 2 08 .
'
s be tvec mpo n i me i ap io o fca i l eieaey id fe e t'ta i i heû n ws
u j ci o ne t s t f rs n fiils s lb rtl n ifrn y h t s f i o
d
'
k
ofa dir r a e es i rs t i aeheat o s eya Fn me ,511 U. a 837.
nd sega ds n xc sve ik o nm t
lh r af t ' r r
'
S. t
A cli c
am once ni a dia e m e bewe n a i a ea medi lper o lr r ng
r ng s gr e nt t e n nm t nd
ca s nne ega di
dignossa c s ofte t ntdoesnotg ne aly i i t t Ei h Am e e . W raht
a
i nd our e r a me
e r l mplcae he ght
ndm nt
i

v Coln , 6 F.d 8 , 49(t Ci. 98 ) Qu sinso me ia j g n aen t u jc t
. lis 7 6 2 41 8 4 h r 1 5 . eto f dc lud me t r o s be t o
j d ca rv e t e j1 3.Ruselv S e fr 5 8F.d 3 8(t Ci. 97 ) Mo e v r
u iil e iw md r 98
s l . h fe , 2 2 1 4 h r 1 5 . r o e ,
m e c m a pr c i e doe notsat a f de alc a m ,Es e l 429 U . a 1 1 nordoesm e e
di al l a tc
s
t e e r li
t le,
S. t 05- 06,
r

ne i nc i dignoss Sosbe v. uphy,797F. 17 ( hCi.1 6)
glge e n a i. e e M
2d 9 4t r 98 .
At nsm a beabl t pr t theha a s rousme c lne d f rte t e ofhi
ki
y
e o ove ha
s ei
di a e o r a m nt
s

h p gy e a Hehms l b l v st a tej i me ia safs o di daeyha ete td
y o lc mi. i ef ei e h t h al d c l tf h ul mme itl v rae
e
hi condii i Se e r2009,a co di t a docorspr s rpton a not d i ol m e ca
s
ton n pt mbe
c r ng o
t ' e c i i s e n d di l

r c r sfo h sls siti t j io b sdo Ati ' e b l e r o te t n t tad co
e o d rm i a t tn n he al r a e n kns v r a rpo t f r ame t ha o tr
a a oh r al drc n l p e cie .Ont eoh r n ,h me ia sa f i terme ia
t n t e j iha e e t rs rb d
y
h te ha d te d c l tf,n h i dc l
j d me t d tnn n dt tAti ' o i o a t e o s r e iddno warn a i dae
u g n , ee i e ha kns c ndt n s h y b e v d t i t ra t n mme it
i

a p it n wi t j ido t ro p o i ighm t ed u l po to de ap e o sd co ha
p on me t t he al co r r v dn i h o b e rin it rviu o tr d
h
or r d afe o e v ng hi s
de e tr bs r i
s ympt sa s
om t omeuni ntfe ea le tmeperod. Thecozs of
de ii d ri r i
i
lr e
a ton t y be i ved a opr a e w ast c i hi i t m e ca t i f cl e obs r a i of
c i he le
ppr i t
o onfne m n he di l m t or os
e v ton

h sc re ts mp o , it o t i oh rr ltdrc r , n rpo th i fn i st t ej i
i u r n y tms wat o b an te eae e o ds a d e r t er idng o h al
4

doc or s t thec d de dewhehe a addii na te t e s d bepr crbe 1 At n
t , o ha
oul ci
t r ny
to l r am nt houl
es i d. kis,
s i s ons of e no i c ton t tm edi als a fm e ber kne f l et pr vi t
ubm s i
f r ndi a i ha
c t f m s w aiur o o de he
pr vi usy di tpos a s t nta rs ofs r ousha m ,gi n t e l ton a ca e t y
e o l e
ed ubs a i l i k e i
r
ve he va ua i nd r he

pr ded i t at r tve. Thi s r ofdia ee ntbewee t pai ntand medialsaf ove
ovi n he le na i
s ot
s gr me
t n he te
c tf r
t a opra e cotr e oftea m e sm pl doe nots
he ppr i t
ls
r t nt i y s
uppor a c ai ofdelbe a e i f e e e as
t lm
i r t ndif r nc
r qui e t s a e a c tt i lc ai .
e r d o t t onsiutona l m
A t ns alega i a s s a e no a tona e c a m t tt s r f w a de i r t l
ki ' l tons l o t t
c i bl l i ha he he i f s lbe a e y

i fe e t hi s rousme c lne ds To brng amedia team e cli agans no m e c l
ndif r nt o s e i
di a e .
i
c l r t nt a m
i t n- di a
pr s n pe s
i o r onne ,a i a e m us s w t s h ofk i l w e e pe s ly i ve w ih a de a
l n nm t
t ho hat uc t a s r r ona l nvol d t
ni l

ofte t nt de i r t l i e f r d wih prs docor 'team e ,o t c ty a horz orwer
r a me , lbe a e y nt re e t ion t s r t nt r a il ut ied
e

i fe e t t prs physca 'mic
ndifr nt o he ion
iins s onduc.Mite v. or 8 F. 8 85 (t Ci.
t lir Be n, 96 2d 48, 4 4h r
1 .
990)
At ns a s rs t ta t rhe t d t s rf a
ki s e t ha f e
ol he he if boutt di tdoc or ha pr c i
he e
t s d es r bed

pr vi usy, hes rf s d ha m a s et medialsa fpr de t tdit i t d of
e o l t he if houl ve de ur he
c t f ovi d ha e , nsea
f war ng At nsr s ba t t ntre. Ba e on At ns f l et a l f c s
or di
ki eque t ck o he ls
sd
ki ' aiur o lege a t

d mo tai d lb rt i dfee eb t ji me ia saf h salg to sas f it s w
e nsrt ei eae n ifrnc y he al dc l t f, i le ain lo al o ho
ng
t tt s rf t cty a o d a m ic
ha he he if a il ppr ve ny s onduc byt tsa f M or ove , he s rf rghtuly
t ha t f.
e r t he if i f l
r i o hi s a ft de e m i usng t i m e ca expe ts ,t pr rc l s oft e t e f
eled n s t f o t r ne, i he r di l
ri e he ope otr e r a m nt or

At ns c r nts
ki ' ure ympt
oms.I a 855. Fort s r as ,At ns c am st thedi no r ceve
d. t
he e e ons ki ' l i ha
d te i

a prp it me ia c r mu tb sl rl d s se , ru n t j1 1 A( )1 , o fi let
p o rae dc l a e s e l
mmai imis d pu s a t o 9 5 b ( ) f r alr o
y
t
sa e a c a r
t t l in.

1 I a4iv n ers o s d tdS pe e 1 , 01 , n reifr dAtista seh d
n re a c ep n e ae e tmb r 7 2 l a u s nome kn h t h a
o d r dhi adlbei s c d l a d ano ta o da whe tej i s r e o y mo ni a
r e e m a tc na k ai n
y
on ry n ys n h al e v d nl r ng nd
e ng m eal Anot r pons dat Se ember20,2011,sat t tw hie At nswas i t m e cal
veni
s.
her es e ed pt
t ed ha
l ki
n he di
uni,saf s e ent hi m eal wih a ni tm e s
t t f upplm ed s
s t
ght i nack and at r ta on weekends.
hid r y

Fi ly,At ns algai pr denos
nal ki ' le tons ovi
uppor fracam unde j1 3t tt nure
t o li
r 98 ha he s
move hi t t m e ca uni i o de t r t lae a i thi f tlng agreva . To saea
d m o he di l t n r r o e ai t gans m or ii
i nce
tt

rtlain cai a ina et rj1 3,a i t mus alegefct s t e t de tae
eaito l m cto bl mde 98 n nmae t l a s ufkint o monsrt
t tt ofk ilt t al ge yr t it y a tin r s et t e r s ofa c tt i na l
ha he t a ook he le dl eala or c ç e pons o he xe cie
i
onsiuto ly
pr e t rghto t tt ac is l vi a e s h a r g .' Ada v. c 40F.d 7 7 (t
ot c ed i
r ha he t t e f ol t d uc i ht'
ms Rie, 3 2, 4 4h
e nm es
tt i
Ci.1 .At nsma snet roft es ngs Becaus i at haveno consiutonal
r 994) ki ke ihe hes howi .

rg tt aj ig iv n ep o e t e At i wa n te e csn ac n tt to a rg twh nh fld
i h o al re a c r c d l , kns s o x r iig o siui n l ih e e ie
r
g i va e a
r e nc s bouthi m e c lc r . M or ove ,hi ow n a l ga i i c t t tt nlr e m o d
s di a a e
e r s
le tons ndi a e ha he zs
ve

hi t t m e ca t ti o de t moniorhi m e c c ton and notwih a i e t
m o he di l mi n r r o
t s dial ondii
t ny ntnt o
pt s hi . Theco twils ma iy dimi sAt ns r t iton ca m asfi ous pur ua t
mih m
ur l um rl s s ki ' eala i li
rvol , s nt o

j1 5 b()
91 A() 1.
I s r, kns alg to d n td mo taeta a yo a t ej i h sa tdwih
n ho tAt i ' le ains o o e nsrt h t n ne t h al a ce t
de i r t i f e e e t hi m edi alne orr t la e a i thi i vi a i ofhi
lbe a e ndif r nc o s
c
eds e a i t d ga ns m n ol ton
s

c tt i lrght Ac or ngl t c ti t tAt nsha f ldt saeany j1
onsiutona i s. c di y,he our tnds ha ki s aie o tt
983

cam a dwil imist c mplitwi o t rj dc i ise trt Ana pr p it o de wi
li n l d s s he o an t u p eu ie n t niey. p o rae r r l
h
l
is t sda
s ue hi y.
TheClr i die t t s nd c e oft sm e o a
e k s r c ed o e opi s hi m r ndum o ni a a compa yi
pi on nd c
n ng
or rt pl ntf.
de o ai if

ENTER:Ths4. d yo oco e, 2011.
i î a f tb r
Chi Unie Stt Diti tJ
ef t d a es src udge

6