Coleman v. Jabe et al
Filing
133
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 5/16/14. (eot)
ctEe s orFl u.:. sm coUr
De Df
ATR- ou .
vA
FI
LED
I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI CO URT
CT
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF VI NI
CT
RGI A
ROANOKE DI SI
VI ON
M>Y 15 2 9
11
JUUA .
BY:
, ERK
CL
ERK
JEFFREY COLEM AN,
Pl nt f ,
ai i f
C i lA d i N o.7: v51
vi
on
11c 8
V.
M EM OM NDVM OPI ON
M
JOH N JABE,e aI,
t .
By:Sam uelG .W is
l on
Unie St t sDit i tJudge
t d a e sr c
D ef
endant
s.
Pl i ifJ fr y Col m a aVigi ai ae who cli t bt at i e e pr tci
antf t ft
t n, r ni nm t
a ms o
s nc r , aci ng,
s
Saa M usi , orgnal br tt spr s a i pm s ntt 42U. C. 1 a t
l;
lm ' ii ly ough hi o e cton ua o
'
S. j 983 nd he
Rei ousLa Us a l tt i lz dPes Act42U. C.j2000c -1e se
lgi
nd e nd nsiutonaie rons ,
S.
c t q.
(t PA' , g i theVign aDe a t n o Co rcin (1
I
RLUI ' a ans t r ii p rme t f re to s G
)
VDOC' a dag o po VDOC
' n ru f
)
e ly e f rd ma e a ij n tv a dd caao yr le t r d e saln ls o alg d
mp o e s o a g s nd nu cie n e lrt r eif o e r s o g it f le e
wr
ongsr l t t Col a sr lgi uspr t c s The co tr f r e t m a trt Unied St es
e a ed o em n' e i o
ac i e .
ur e e r d he te o
t
at
M agita eJ
sr t udgePa aM e Sa ge f raRe ta Re m mendai p s n t 28
mel ade r nt o
por nd co
ton urua t o
U. C.j636( ( )B) a s fldarpor r omme ngt tt c tg a t dee ns
S.
b)1( , nd he ie e t ec
ndi ha he our r nt he fnda t'
motonf s
i or ummayj
r udgme o mos ofCol n' cams Colma v.J be, 2W L
nt n t
ema s li . e n a 201
7801 2 ( . Va. .26,201 .Thec tadoptdese ilya1oft Magitae' Re t
72 W D. Dec
2)
our
e sntal l he
srt s por
a dRe o nd to a dd s se o g a td s mmayj d me t nal Co e n scams
n c mme ain n imis d r r ne u r u g n o lof lma ' li
e c p f rhsRLUI A camsf rij nci a dd caao yrle r ltn t f l VDOC
xeto i
P li o nu t n e lrt r eif eaig o oz
ve
r
polces Colma v. a ,201 W L 1
ii . e n J be 3
20901 ( . Va. a . 2013 .Lae,t c t
4 W D. M r 25, ) tr he our
g a edt defnda s moto frs
r nt he e nt' in o ummayj me ont ermani cams Colma v.
r udg nt hos e i ng li . e n
J be, 3W L 4084762( . Va Aug.1 201 ) Ne l amont ltr bu wihi t tme
a 201
W D. .
3, 3 . ary
h ae , t t n he i
pemitdbyRul 5 e oft Fedea RulsofCi lPr e ze,Colma movedfr
r te
e 9() he
rl e
vi oc dlr
e n
o
1
r onsde aton ofm os oft cou tsr i s.Fo t m os pa them a a glment t c ur
ec i r i
t he r ' ulng
r he
t r,
de r l s he o t
ara yrj ce o ag me t ta aefi oo s Th c u t o n i a p o rae ho v r t
le d ee td r r u ns h t r rv lu . e o r f u d t p r p it, we e ,o
r onsde hi cli st tt VDOC sngl ve
ec i r s am ha he
i e ndora gr i polc e vi a e hi rght
nd oom ng i i s olt d s i s
unde RLUI a hel a e de ta y he rngt a r st m .The c t w co l
r
PA nd d n vi n ir a i o dd es he
our no
ncudest t
ha
t def nda sha s
he e nt ve hownt polc e m' t l s r srdi mea off t rng ac
he ii s e he ea t e ti ve
ns urhe i
ompeli
lng
g v r me t nee ta de tr j d me tf rted fn a t.
o en n i tr s n n es u g n o h ee d n s
TheVDOC hasasngl ve polcy( r i Pr dur
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?