Canada v. Davis et al

Filing 62

ORDER ADOPTING REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS ; adopting Report and Recommendations re 45 Report and Recommendations ; granting 20 the healthare workers Motion to Dismiss; GRANTING the correctional workers' motion for summary judgment 32 with respect to Canada's claims of deliberate indifference to medical needs and for injunctive relief, and the correctional workers' motion for summary judgment 32 is DENIED in all other respects. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 10/31/2012. (tvt)

CL S OFFI U. . DI .COURT
ERK'
CE S ST
AT ROANOKE,
NA
FI
LED

I TH E U N I
N
TED STAT ES D I
STR I C O U R T
CT
FO R TH E W E STER N D ISTR ICT O F V IR G IN I
A
R O A N O K E D I ISIO N
V
K ELVI A .C AN A D A ,
N
Pl ntf
ai if,
V.

W ALTER DA V I etaI,
S
.
D ef
endant
s.

)
)
)
)
)
)
)

OCT 3 1 2 1
02
JULA c 7 '
I , t
C RK
BY;
DEPUW CL

C i lA ct on N o.7: v00569
vi
i
11c
O R DER A D O PTIN G R EPO RT
AN D RE CO M M EN D A TI N
O

By:Sam ue G . is
l W l on
U ni ed St D i tri Judge
t
ates s ct

K e vi Ca da,a V igi a i a e pr ee ngrr s ,brngs t sac i pur ua t 42
l n na
r ni nm t oc di
/ e i hi ton s nt o

U. C.j1983ag ns anumbe ofRe Oni Stt Prs n e o es alegi vai l t tt
S.
ai t
r
d on ae io mplye , l ng rousy ha he
d e nt us d e e s ve f ce aga ns hi ,f ie t pr e thi , di pl ye delbe a e
ef nda s e xc s i or
i t m a l d o ot c m and s a d i r t

idfee et hi me ia n e s Ca a as e sd ma e a wel sd ca ao ya ij n tv
n ifrnc o s d c l e d . n d e k a g s s l a e lr tr nd nu cie
r le . Thr e o t def ndant ,D r Ti ot M c i N ur e V i kiPhi ,a N ur e M el ni
ei f
e f he e
s . m hy Brde, s c
pps nd
s
a e

Sc t (het alhcaewor r',ha fldaRul 1 b)6 moint dimisCa da'
o tt t t r kes' ve ie
he
)
e 2( () to o s s na s
c pl i f r f lng t sat a c a m on whi h r i fca be gr nt d. A nd f oft de e nt ,
om a nt o aii o t e l i
c ele n
a e
our he f nda s
O fi e W a t rDavi ,Se gea Pa Pa
tc r le
s r nt ul yne, pt i D e a Tt me ,
Ca a n w yne u r and Se ge tW ila
r an
li m

W rg t(h t o rcina wo k r ', a efldamoi nfrs mmayj d me ti whc t y
ih t e t re to l r e s' h v ie
c
)
to o u r u g n n ih he
a s r t tt r aen mae ilis so fc, nil gt m t j d me ta amatro lw.Th
se tha hee r o tra sue f a t e tti he o u g n s te f a
n
e
co tha r e r t m a t rt U nie St t M ag sr t J
ur s ef r ed he te o
t d a es
i t a e udge Pa e a M .Sa ge f ra Re t
m l
r nt o
por

a Re omme tonpurua t 28U. C.j636( ()B)
nd c
ndai
s nt o
S.
b)1( .
TheMagitaeJ ha tldarpor tndi t t( )Cana sc ai fist saea
srt udge s ie e ti ng ha 1
da' ompl nt al o tt
cai ag ns t he lhcaewor r,( t r a enodiput ofmae ilfc onCa da'
l m ai t he at r ke s 2) hee r
s es
tra a t
na s
cai ofdei rt i feenc t me c ne a ns t c rcina wor r , ()t e
l ms
lbeae ndifr e o dial eds gai t he ore to l ke s and 3 her
i nobai f or rngijmci r le .TheM a itaeJ t r f er c
s
ss or de i n t tve eif
gsrt udge he eor e omme
ndedg a tng
r ni

t he lhc r w or s m oton t di m i s a t co r to lw or r 'm o i n f r s m a y
he a t a e
ker ' i o s s nd he r ec i na
ke s t o o um r

j g n wi r s c t Ca a a sd l e aeidfee et me ia n e a dij n t er l f
ud me t t e pe t o n d ' ei rt n ifrnc o d c l e ds n nu ci ei
h
b
v e
c a m s H ow e r M agi ta e J
li .
ve ,
s r t udge Sa ge f
r nt ound que to off tunderyi Ca da'
s i ns ac
l ng na s
r m a ni a l ga i a ns t co r c i lw or r a r om m e d t tt co tde t
e i ng le tons gai t he r e tona
ke s nd ec
nde ha he ur ny he

b ln eo termo inf rs mmayj d me t
aa c f h i to o u r u g n .
Nop ryha o j ce t t eM a itaesRe o t ndRe o n ai n.ç lnt
a t s be td o h g sr t' p r a
c mme d to d j he
l
a s n eof tmey tldo j ci n ad src c u t e dno c n u ta# n v rviw, u
b e c a i l ie be to , itit o r n e t o d c c o o e e b t
i t d m us onl s ts y is ft tt r i no cl a e r r o t f e oft r c d i o de t
ns ea
t y a i f t el ha he e s
e r r o n he ac
he e or n r r o
a e t r com m e ton. Di m o v.Col a Lie & A c i ntI . , 6 F. 31 31
cc pt he e
nda i ' a nd
'
oni l f
c de ns Co. 41 3d 0, 5

( hCi. ) Thec ti s tsidt tt r i nocla e ont fceoft r c d.
4t r 2005 .
our s aite ha hee s e r nor he a
he e or
Ac or ng y,i i her by O RDERED a ADJUDGED t tt M a sr t J
c di l t s e
nd
ha he gita e udge sRe r a
' po t nd

Re
commendain i ADOPTED i ise iey,t he lhc ewo kes motont dimis(
to s
n t ntrt he at ar r r' i o s s ECF

No. 0 i GRANTED,hec ne to a wo k r ' to f rs mma yj d me t ECFNo 3 )i
2 )s
t o cin l r es moi n o u r u g n (
.2 s
G R AN TED w ih r s c t Ca da' cl i s ofde i r t i f e e t m e ca nee a f
t e pe t o na s a m
lbe a e ndif r nce o di l ds nd or

ij n tv r l f a dt c re to a wo k r ' to f rs mmayj d me ti DENI i a1
nu cie ei , n he o r cin l r e s moin o u r u g n s
e
ED n l
ot rr s c s
he e pe t .
The C l r oft Cour i diec e t s a c r ii d c oft s or r o t pl i if
e k he
t s r t d o end e tf e opy hi de
he a ntf .
EN TE R : Oc obe 31 201
t r , 2.

X

.

zA
,
z
'

.

z'

V

z

.
=

.

UN I
TED STA TES D I
STRI JU DG E
CT