Canada v. Davis et al

Filing 89

ORDER ADOPTING REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS in their entirety 84 and 86 ; Canada's objections are OVERRULED; judgment is ENTERED in favor of defendants Davis, Wright, Payne and Turner; denying 85 Motion for Preliminary Injunction; and Canada's remaining claims are DIMISSED and STRICKEN from the court's active docket. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 1/29/2013. (tvt)

G FRKS OFFI t. . sm r I
CE l Dl A e
S
AT RoM oKE,
VA
FI
LED

I TH E UN I
N
TED STA TES D I
STR I C O U R T
CT
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI O F VI NI
CT
RGI A
R O A N O K E D I SIO N
W
K ELVIN A.C AN A DA ,
Pl ntf ,
ai if
V.

W A LTER D A VI e aI,
S t .
D ef
endant
s.

)
)
)
)
)
)
)

J 2S 2 1
AN
23
J AC
ULI

E% LO K

Bï

D (
J

C i lA c i N o.7: v00569
vi ton
11c

ORDER ADOPTI REPORT
NG
AND RECOM M ENDATI
ON

By:Sam ue G.W is
l
lon
U nie St e Di t i tJudge
t d at s s r c

Kevi Ca da, Vigi ai t pr e ngrr s brngst sa i puruan t 42
l n na a r ni nma e oc edi
/ e, i hi cton s t o

U. C. 1 8 a an t n mb ro Re Ono S aeP io (I P' e ly e , l gn
S. j 9 3 g is a u e f d in tt rs n t
ROS ' mpo e s al ig
)
e
va i l t tt def nt us d exc sve f ceag ns hi ,f ie t pr t c hi ,a
rousy ha he enda s e
es i or
ai t m al d o o e t m nd
dipl ed dei r t i fe e et hi me c lne ds Ca da s e dn a t rt tsaut
s ay
lbe a e ndif r nc o s dia e . na e ks m ges mde ha t t e.
Theco tha a pt d t opr vi Re t nd Rec
ur s do e w
e ous por a
omm e tonsi vi Ca
nda i nvol ng nada s
'

j1 camsi t spa tc a ca e i whiht c tds se Ca da' camsag ns
983 li n hi riulr s ,n c he our imis d na s li ai t

s v r l o d f n a t f rf iu et saeacam, e e amoin frap ei n r ij ncie
e e a c - e e d ns o al r o tt li d nid
to o rlmiay n u tv
rle , n g a td s mmayj d me tn fvo o t erman n d fnd nsa t Ca a as
eif a d r ne u r u g n i a r f h e ii g ee a t s o n d '
cli sofde i r e i fe e e. The c tt n a sg d t r mai ngcl m st Unie St t
am
lbe at ndif r nc
our he s ine he e ni ai o t d aes
M a sr t J
gita e udgePn a M .Sar nt who hed ati on De embe 6, 2. On J nua y4,
mel
ge ,
l ral
c
r 201
a r

201 M a srt J
3, gitae udgeSarentfld aRe t Re omme tonpurua t 28U. C.j
g ie
por and c
ndai
s nt o
S.

63 ( )1( rc mme dn e tyo j dg n i fv ro tec re to a o fc rd f n a t
6 b ( )B) e o n ig nr f u me t n a o f h or cin l fie ee d ns
OfierW at rDa s Se g ntW ilam W rg ,Se ge ntPa Pa
fc
le vi, r ea
li
iht r a
ul yne, Ca an De yne
and pt i wa

Tu n r ( No. 4. Ca a aha flda o j cint t a Re o t n Re o n to ,
r e. ECF 8 ) n d s ie n be to o h t p r a d c mme dain
pa ty r ie ai a g nt m a i hi ea le pladi a ofe i not ng s t ntvei
rl et r tng r ume s de n s rir e ngs nd f rng hi ubsa i n

r s o s t t eM a itae sfndn s ( No. 7) Ca d fie t o j c t t eRe r a d
e p n e o h gsrt ' i ig . ECF 8 . na a ald o be t o h po t n
Re o n ain c n enn h smoin frp ei n r ij n to .( No 8 . Ilnte
c mme d to o c r ig i to o r l ay n u cin ECF . 6) ç l h
mi
g

'

a s n eo atmeyfldobe t n, dsrc c u t e dn t o d c ad n v rve b t
b e c f i l ie j ci a itit o r n e o c n u t e o o e iw, u
o
i t a m us onl s ts y is ft tt r i no c ea e r on t f c oft r c d i or t
ns e d
t y a i f t el ha he e s
l r r or he a e he e or n der o

a c tt r omm e ton. Dim ond v.Col alLie & Ac i ntl . , 6 F. 31 31
c ep he ec
nda i ' a
'
oni f
c de ns Co.41 3d 0, 5

(t Ci. 0 5 .Th c u t sstsidt a t eei n ce rer ro tefc o ter c r
4 h r 2 0 ) e o r i aife h t h r s o la ro n h a e f h e o d.

Ha i r ve dt Re rsa dRe o n ai n , n d ' o j ci n t eeo a dp rie t
vng e iwe he po t n c mme d to s Ca a as be to s h rt , n e t n
n
po tonsoft rcor denov i ac or ewih j636( () t co ta e swiht
ri
he e d
o n c danc t
b)1 ,he ur gr e t he
M a sr t J
gitae udge' r omme tonsrga di t e r ofj
s ec
ndai e r ng he nty udgme i fvoroft dee nt
nt n a
he fnda s

( No 8 )a dd n a o p ei n r ij n tv rle ( No 8 )o Ca a asrmanig
ECF . 4 n e il f rlmi ay n u ci e eif ECF . 6 n n d ' e i n
c ai s
lm .

Ac or ngl i i he eby ORDERED a ADJUDGED t tt M agita eJ e'
c di y, t s r
nd
ha he
sr t udg s

Re o t a dRe o n to saeADOPTED i t ere trt ; n d ' o j cin a e
p rs n c mme dain r
n h i n iey Ca a as be to s r
OVERRULED;u g n i ENTERED i fv ro d fn nsDa i, rg tPa n a d
j d me t s
n a o f ee da t vs W ih , y e n

Tu r Ca a asmo inf rp ei n r ij n tv r l f sDENI a dCa d ' rmann
me ; n d ' to o r l a y nu cie ei i
mi
e
ED; n na as e iig
c am sa eDI I
l i r SM SSED a STRI
nd
CKEN fom t c tsa tve doc t
r he our' c i
ke .
TheCl r oft Cour i DI
e k he
t s RECTED t s nd ace tfe co oft sor rt t
o e
riid py hi de o he

pl ntf
ai if

E E Jnayéi ,03
NT R: aur . 2 1.
j

.0,v1
s.-.
.'.e
e*-*
-. . .
u r
*
#
.'
m.

e.e
. '

..
A'

.
..r
..

P
.
.
.3'
.T
''
.'
,.
.
rA

..
,-

.

p
*
.'
#<
'

.'
e
'

.
#
.'
y'
'

V

M
.

I
TED STA TES D I
STR I J D GE
CT U