Thomas v. Omicron Development Corp. et al

Filing 21

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 9/11/2012. (lab)

ILERKS OFFI U. DI COURT
CE S. ST.
AT R- OKE, ,
VA
FIED
L

sEP 112 1
92
I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FO R TH E W ESTERN DI
STRI O F V I I I
CT
RG N A
ROAN OK E DI I ON
V SI

).
E
y

J A , Dk
ULI
R

B w

W I AM W .
LLI
THO M A S,J ,
R.
Ci lA c i N o. 11 cvvi ton
7: - 00588
Pl n if
ai t f ,
M EM O R AN DU M O PI O N
M

OM I
CRON DEVELOPM EN T COU OM TI
ON
a MI
nd CHEAEL BASTO,

By:Gln E.Con a
e
rd
Chi fUnie Stt sDititJ
e
t d a e src udge

D e e nt .
f nda s

1
.

Pr e
oc duralBac ound
kgr

W ila W . o s(tho s' rt eé litf ', pan ifp o e dn p os ,ie a
l m Th ma df ma'o h s anif ) a litf r c e ig r e fld
i
p
c pl i i t U nie St t s Di t i tCour f t W e t r D it i tofVi gi a o D e m be
om a nt n he t d a e sr c
t or he s e n s rc
r ni n ce r

1 , 01 .( c e No 1) Th c mplit me Omir nDe eo me tCop(i co ' a
4 2 1 Do k t . . e o an nn s co v lp n r d
omir n' nd
)
isPrsd n Mih e Ba t (% so' a d fn a t.Th ma alg sawiev reyo p tn il
t e ie t c a l so t t ' s ee d n s o s l e
Ba )
e
d ait f oe ta
c am s i udi ûla ce Afe Tr s a o Fr udr'ç s i na i 'a t ei sons
l i ,ncl ng tar ny tr u t nd/ r a 'çdicrmi ton, nd f
'
hom nva i

a dp y ia tr as' ( c e No. ! 6) Li eal c nsr e ,h c mpan as alg s
n h sc lh e t. Do k t 1 . b rly o tu d t e o lit lo l e
'
e
c r i ofa l s $1m ilo a ofdoc e t r lt d t apr ousc tc ei whih
onve son t ea t
li n nd
um n s ea e o evi our as n c
Thom asw a a pl i i fl Se v cew ase f t d, a dt d fn a t fldaj it to t ds s
s a ntf . r i
f ec e n he ee d n s ie on moin o imis

p ls a tt Fe ea Rue o Ci l o e l e1 ( )1 a d( )o Ap i 1 , 01 ,( c e No. )
t u n o d r l ls f viPr c dz 2 b ( ) n 6 n rl 7 2 2 Do k t 6.
r
r
Asrquie byRos bor v.Gars n,5 F. 309( hCi.1 ) t Clr oft Cour
e rd
e o
rio 28 2d
4t r 975 ,he ek he
t
notf e Thom a t the woul ha t e t one da i whi h t f l ad tonale de e or
ii d
s ha
d ve w n yys n
c o ie dii
vi nc

1The pr vi ca e i Thomasv. Ciyo Sa no s . :0 c -0 5 7 01 WL4 0 5 ( . Va S p .
e ous s s
t f tu tn No 7 l-v0 5 3 2 1
0 78 4 W D. . e t08

2 1 ) I i n t la fo tec mplitwh td u nsTh ma s e so h w te aer ltdt hi oh rcams
0 l. ts o ce r r m h o an a oc me t o s e k r o h y r eae o s te li .

.

RK

a gtme shewihed t c tt c i rorhers ha ng hi c
r l nt
s
he our o onsde
iked vi s ompl i dim is f rf l e
ant s s ed o aiur

t pr e ut ( ke No.8.
o os c e. Doc t
)

OnM a 5 2 2 Th ma fldamoinf rd fut u g n , li ngh h dn v r
y , 01 , o s ie
to o ea lj d me t cami e a e e
r c ie t d fnd ns moi nt ds s.( c e No 1 . OnJ n 1 , 01 , a ig
e ev d he ee a t' to o imis Do k t . 5)
u e 3 2 2 h vn
r c i d no ot r s e fom Thoma ,t co to de e Thomast s
e eve
her e pons r
s he ur r r d
o how c us why hi
a e
s

compl nts dnotbedimis dpurua t t d e ns moton.( ke No.1 )
ai houl
s se s nt o he efnda t' i Doc t
8.
Thomasr ponde t t s
es
d o he how c us o d wiht fln .The frt fl o Jme 27, 2,
a e r er t wo ii gs
is, ied n t
201
agan cli d heha ne rr evedt de e
i a me
d ve ec i he f ndan s m oton t dim is aswela a a lga i
t' i o s s ,
l s n le ton

t t h cek' o fc wa e g g di aC o pr dc nrv n e'ofv rt ed fnd ns ( c t
ha t e lr s fie s n a e n s ns ie o tia c 't a o h ee a t . Do ke
c
No.1 ) Thescond,fldt ne da rque td a a iina t ryda i whiht pr vi
9.
e
ie he xt y, e se n ddto lhit ys n c o o de

t ec u t t s p lme a if nn to .( c e No. 0. Nohn mo eha sn eb e fldi
h o r wih u p e ntln o ain Do k t 2 ) t ig r s ic e n ie n
t c e.
he as

Ha ng gve t pli ifhi r que t d tme, nd t n s m e t s
vi i n he antf s e se i a he o , o how c us orr s ndt
a e e po o
t de e nt motont dimis at t pl i ifha ng f iedt do s t c tnow
he f nda s' i o s s , rd he antf vi al o
o, he our

c nsd r t ematrrp f ra j iain F rtera o sgv n b lw,h c u t l ga tte
o ie s h te i e o dudc to . o h e s n ie eo t e o r wi rn h
l
de e nt 'm oton t di m i s
f nda s
i o s s.
II.

D i si
scus on

Th d fn a t frtse ds sa o Th ma ' camsf rlc o s b e tmatr
e e e d n s is e k imis l f o ss li o a k f u jc te
j rs ito , t s a t oRu e1 ()1 .Fe ea Rueo Cii P o e u e8 a rq ie t a a
u id ci n p t u n t l 2b ( ) d r l l f v l r c d r () e ur s h t
r
pla ngm us c an <as r a pl n sae e oft g oundsu whi h t co ts
e di
t ont i t ho t nd ai t tm nt he r
pon c he ur'

j iditonde
urs ci pends' Fed.R.Ci Pr 8a .W he jlidito i baedo t di riyoft
.
'
v. o. ()
n t s cin s s n he vest he
r
pate u r28U. C.j1 t cii ns p ofa1d e nt mus bedi refom t toft
ris nde
S.
332,he tze hi l efnda s t ves r ha he

p an if S rwb i ev. ris 3Crn h2 7, U. 2 7( 8 6 .Fo dv riyp r o e ,h
litf. ta rdg Cu t , a c 6 7 S. 6 1 0 ) r ie st u p s s te
s

cii e hi ofa c or ton i de medt bet tofeve y sae i whih i i i or a e a wel
tz ns p
op ai s e
o ha
r t t n c t s nc por t d s l

a t esaewh r i h sisp icp l a eo b sn s.28U. C. 1 3 c () W h na
s h tt ee t a t rn ia plc f u ie s
S. j 3 2()1. e
d f n a tc ne dst e a 1 b ()mo int a t epan ifh sfie t alg fcsu n
e e d n o tn md r 2()1 to h t h litf a ald o l e a t po
e
whc s b e t te j rs ito c nb b s d tec u t la s met a t efcsalg di t e
ih u j c matr u idcin a e a e ,h o r wi su h t h a t l e n h
l
e
c ai aet e.Adamsv, n,697F. 1 3,1 9( h Ci.1 .
ompl nt z nz
Bai
2d 21 21 4t r 982)
Pa ag a t t oug f roft c
r r phs wo hr h ou
he ompl i ale t f l ng:
ant lge he olowi

2.Th Co r h s u id ci n Die st a dF n n il q ie n saeme.
e u t a j rs ito . v riy n i a ca Re urme t r t
3. Pl ntf i a r s de ofW e t m D it i tofV igi a
ai i f s e i nt
se
sr c
r ni .
4. D e e nti a V i g ni Cor a i n,
f nda s
r i a por to dom e tc t d i Te s e . M i ha Ba t i a
s i a e n nne s e
c el s o s

Vigni r i nt
r i a esde .

( c e No 1a ! 2 4) Th c mpan s y n t n mo ea o t h lc to o ctz ns i o
Do k t . t ! - . e o lit a s ohig r b u t e o ain r i e hp f
i
t pa te .
he r i s
A c ptng a t e t i onna i pr vi d i t c pl i , m a ha f ie t
ce i s nz he nf
ton o de n he om a nt Tho s s a l d o

p o rype ddv riyj rs ito rt i i t ectz ns i o tepat st a i d tnniai e
r pel la ie st u id cin.Fis,t s h iie hp f h ri h t s ee n tv
e
f rd ve st pum os s nott i r sde s Se Axe J
o i r iy
e , her e i nce . e
l ohns ne nc v.Car lCa o i Oi Co.
o I .
r ol r lna 1 .

l c,1 F.d6 0 6 3( t Ci 1 9 )(l laect e s p frp r o e o dv ri j rs ito
n . 45 3 6 , 6 4h r 9 8 t s tt iz n hi o u p s s f ie st u idcin
t
i
y
d p n sn to rsd n e b to n to a ctz n hp a dd miie' S c n , o sh s
e e d o n e ie c , u n ain l i e s i n o cl. e o d Th ma a
i
).
alege t tBa t i a r i ntofV igi a t s m e sa e whe e Thom a r i s Li w i e,
l d ha s o s es de
r ni , he a
tt
r
s es de . ke s
Tho a a l gest tOm i r n (i a V igi a co o a i ' ag n,t s m e s a e whe e t
m s le
ha
c o Cs
r ni p r tonr' ai he n
tt
r he

pl i ifc am sr i nc Sa ngnot ngm or ,t co pli tal gesi ufi e i o m ai
antf l i esde e. yi
hi
e he m a n le ns fcint nf r ton
t de e m i t c tze hi ofa oft pa te ;a t ki Thom as s c ai st tOm i r i a
o t r ne he ii ns p
ny he r i s nd a ng
' l m ha
c on s
V igi a c por ton a Ba t i a r s de ofV igi a t a s i pl t rc tz hi a t tof
r ni or a i nd s o s e i nt
r ni o l o m y hei ii ens p s ha

Vigi awoul rnde di riydesr d.I a cae,wihrs tt di riyj rs ci t
r ni
d e r vest toye n ny s t epec o vest u iditon,he

c
ompli f ist s tsy Rul 8' r quie e t ma a t a n sae e oft gr
a nt a l o aif
e s e r m nt o ke t i t tm nt he oundsupon
pl

whc t c u ts mid ci nd p n s' e . Ci Pr . ()
ih he o r' j s ito e e d . d R. v. o 8 a.
'F
Tot e e t tTho sag sf f rlque to j iditonunde 28U. C.j
he xtnt ha ma rue or edea sin urs ci
r
S.
1 , hi co pl nti a s de i i nt d
331 2 s m ai s l o f c e . d
unde t l f ng w e lpl de c pl i nze ...
r he ongsandi
l- ea d om a nt l

a s tç rs unde 'f der l1w ç nl whe t pl n ifssae e ofhi own c us ofa ton
ui a ies
r e a a o y
n he aitf ' t tm nt
s
a e ci

s wsta i i b s du o (e ea lwj' Va e v Dic v rBn k 5 6 U.. 9 6 ( 0 9
ho h t t s a e p n fd r la .' d n . so e n , 5 , S 4 , 0 2 0 )
'
( i Louivil & Nas leR. v.Motlv,211U. 1 1 ( 908:.Thepl ntf t
quotng s le
hvil Co.
te
S. 49, 52 1
ai if hus
be r t btr n ofa l gi f c ss f c e t e t bls t e s e e o ar gh t r i t t
a s he lde
le ng a t uf i i nt o s a i h he xit nc f i t o elef ha

t e e s rl d pe d o (h )r s lto o as bsa ta q e to o fd r la ' F a c s Ta
t c s ai e n s n t e e ou in f u tn il u sin f e ea lw. rn hie x
n
y
'
Bd.v.Cons.La er Va atonTr t463U. 1 27( 983 .
t bor s c i us,
S. , 1 )
Ha ng r vi wedt c pli t Thomasha f ie t a lgecli sorf t gi ngrs t
vi e e
he om a n ,
s al d o le
am
ac s vi ie o

fd r l u sinj rs ito Paa rp o esae çthsa to i b o g tt rd e sRih s
e ea q e t u idcin. rg a h n tts d l i cin s r u h o e r s g t
o
l
s c rdt P an ifb t eUntdS ae Co si to . ( k tNo 1)A g neaie r frn e
e u e o litf y h ie tts n tt in' Doc e . . e rlz d e ee c
u '
t t Cons iuton ora f er l1 w doesnotby is fc e t a f r lques i M c rne v.
o he
tt i
ed a a
t el r a e ede a
ton. ca t y

W e t r i a 1 6F.d7 9 7 (t Ci.1 4 )(d eer frn e t t efd r lCo siuin,
s Vicni, 5 2 3 , 41 4 h r 9 6 C r e ee c s o h e e a n t to
M
t
l w s ort e tesa m e e as e to t a f er lque to i i ve a e no s fc e tt
a , r a i nd r s ri ns hat ed a
s i n s nvol d r t ufi i n o

c n e jl s ci n'.No d Th ma ' v ro scamso i are yAfe Tr s a d o Fru ,
o fr t idito .
r
) r o o ss ai u li f s ac n tr u t n /r a d'
l
'
' s rm i tony G
t c i na i ' ç e i s ons a phys ca t ea s ' c
di
' hom nva i
nd
i l hr t , onve s on ofm one a t f o
'
ri
y, nd he t f

doc nt iaieunde t Consiui orlwsoft Unie Stts' 28U. C.j1
ume s trs
r he
ttton a
he td ae .'
S. 331.Ther
e
i sm pl no wa t t l whih ofhi f de a rg s i a y,Thoma cai ha bee vi aed.
si y
y o el c
s e r l i ht , f n
s l ms ve n ol t
111.

C oncl on
usi

2I t cvl o e se t c o n n tec mplitTh ma lsshsb ssfr uidcina dv riy ( c e
n he iic v r h e a c mpayig h o an7 o s it i ai o jrs ito s iest . Do k t
No. -.
1 1)
4

Fort er a o ,t c t i t tt c pli f ist s tsy t r quie t f
hes e s ns he our fnds ha he om ant al o a if he e r men s or

f d rls b e t te j rs it nu d rb t 2 U. C. 1 31a d 1 3 Astec u t a k
e ea u j c matr u id ci n e oh 8 S. j 3 n 3 2. h o r lc s
o
s be t t r u idcin t ed fn a t' to t d s s wi b g a td, n t c u ti s
u j c mat j rs it , h ee d n s mo in o imis l e r ne a d he o r t
e
o
l
nd
i u n c sa yt c n ie t d fn a t' to f rfi r t saeacam t e Rue1 ( )6 .
t n e e sr o o sd r he ee d n s moin o al e o tt li md r l 2 b ( )
u
An a opra e o de s lis
ppr it r r hal s ue.Thepli ifi a s dt thema a
antf s dvie ha
y ppea t sde ii
l hi c son
ptr ua t Rul 3 a 4 oft Fe r lRul ofAppela ePr e eby flng anotc o
ls nt o es nd
he de a
es
lt oc dur
ii
ie f
a
ppea wiht sc t t n 30 da oft da eofe ty oft sme or ndum opi on a t
l t hi our wihi
ys he t
nr
hi m a
ni nd he
a om pa ng or r orw ihi s h e e d pe i d a t c tm a g a plr ua t Rul
cc
nyi
de ,
t n uc xt nde r o s he our y r nt zs nt o e

4 a( )
()5 .
The Cl r i diece t s nd c rii d c esoft sm e a l opi on a t
e k s r td o e e tfe opi
hi mor ndlm
ni nd he
a com pa ng o dert t pa te .
c
nyi r o he ri s

a fs pe e, 2.
ENTER:Thi tt8 d yo- e tmb r201
s
Y
.

j( - l
. twv
chi fUnie St t s Di ti tJ ge
e
t d a e sr c ud