Thomas v. Omicron Development Corp. et al
Filing
21
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 9/11/2012. (lab)
ILERKS OFFI U. DI COURT
CE S. ST.
AT R- OKE, ,
VA
FIED
L
sEP 112 1
92
I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FO R TH E W ESTERN DI
STRI O F V I I I
CT
RG N A
ROAN OK E DI I ON
V SI
).
E
y
J A , Dk
ULI
R
B w
W I AM W .
LLI
THO M A S,J ,
R.
Ci lA c i N o. 11 cvvi ton
7: - 00588
Pl n if
ai t f ,
M EM O R AN DU M O PI O N
M
OM I
CRON DEVELOPM EN T COU OM TI
ON
a MI
nd CHEAEL BASTO,
By:Gln E.Con a
e
rd
Chi fUnie Stt sDititJ
e
t d a e src udge
D e e nt .
f nda s
1
.
Pr e
oc duralBac ound
kgr
W ila W . o s(tho s' rt eé litf ', pan ifp o e dn p os ,ie a
l m Th ma df ma'o h s anif ) a litf r c e ig r e fld
i
p
c pl i i t U nie St t s Di t i tCour f t W e t r D it i tofVi gi a o D e m be
om a nt n he t d a e sr c
t or he s e n s rc
r ni n ce r
1 , 01 .( c e No 1) Th c mplit me Omir nDe eo me tCop(i co ' a
4 2 1 Do k t . . e o an nn s co v lp n r d
omir n' nd
)
isPrsd n Mih e Ba t (% so' a d fn a t.Th ma alg sawiev reyo p tn il
t e ie t c a l so t t ' s ee d n s o s l e
Ba )
e
d ait f oe ta
c am s i udi ûla ce Afe Tr s a o Fr udr'ç s i na i 'a t ei sons
l i ,ncl ng tar ny tr u t nd/ r a 'çdicrmi ton, nd f
'
hom nva i
a dp y ia tr as' ( c e No. ! 6) Li eal c nsr e ,h c mpan as alg s
n h sc lh e t. Do k t 1 . b rly o tu d t e o lit lo l e
'
e
c r i ofa l s $1m ilo a ofdoc e t r lt d t apr ousc tc ei whih
onve son t ea t
li n nd
um n s ea e o evi our as n c
Thom asw a a pl i i fl Se v cew ase f t d, a dt d fn a t fldaj it to t ds s
s a ntf . r i
f ec e n he ee d n s ie on moin o imis
p ls a tt Fe ea Rue o Ci l o e l e1 ( )1 a d( )o Ap i 1 , 01 ,( c e No. )
t u n o d r l ls f viPr c dz 2 b ( ) n 6 n rl 7 2 2 Do k t 6.
r
r
Asrquie byRos bor v.Gars n,5 F. 309( hCi.1 ) t Clr oft Cour
e rd
e o
rio 28 2d
4t r 975 ,he ek he
t
notf e Thom a t the woul ha t e t one da i whi h t f l ad tonale de e or
ii d
s ha
d ve w n yys n
c o ie dii
vi nc
1The pr vi ca e i Thomasv. Ciyo Sa no s . :0 c -0 5 7 01 WL4 0 5 ( . Va S p .
e ous s s
t f tu tn No 7 l-v0 5 3 2 1
0 78 4 W D. . e t08
2 1 ) I i n t la fo tec mplitwh td u nsTh ma s e so h w te aer ltdt hi oh rcams
0 l. ts o ce r r m h o an a oc me t o s e k r o h y r eae o s te li .
.
RK
a gtme shewihed t c tt c i rorhers ha ng hi c
r l nt
s
he our o onsde
iked vi s ompl i dim is f rf l e
ant s s ed o aiur
t pr e ut ( ke No.8.
o os c e. Doc t
)
OnM a 5 2 2 Th ma fldamoinf rd fut u g n , li ngh h dn v r
y , 01 , o s ie
to o ea lj d me t cami e a e e
r c ie t d fnd ns moi nt ds s.( c e No 1 . OnJ n 1 , 01 , a ig
e ev d he ee a t' to o imis Do k t . 5)
u e 3 2 2 h vn
r c i d no ot r s e fom Thoma ,t co to de e Thomast s
e eve
her e pons r
s he ur r r d
o how c us why hi
a e
s
compl nts dnotbedimis dpurua t t d e ns moton.( ke No.1 )
ai houl
s se s nt o he efnda t' i Doc t
8.
Thomasr ponde t t s
es
d o he how c us o d wiht fln .The frt fl o Jme 27, 2,
a e r er t wo ii gs
is, ied n t
201
agan cli d heha ne rr evedt de e
i a me
d ve ec i he f ndan s m oton t dim is aswela a a lga i
t' i o s s ,
l s n le ton
t t h cek' o fc wa e g g di aC o pr dc nrv n e'ofv rt ed fnd ns ( c t
ha t e lr s fie s n a e n s ns ie o tia c 't a o h ee a t . Do ke
c
No.1 ) Thescond,fldt ne da rque td a a iina t ryda i whiht pr vi
9.
e
ie he xt y, e se n ddto lhit ys n c o o de
t ec u t t s p lme a if nn to .( c e No. 0. Nohn mo eha sn eb e fldi
h o r wih u p e ntln o ain Do k t 2 ) t ig r s ic e n ie n
t c e.
he as
Ha ng gve t pli ifhi r que t d tme, nd t n s m e t s
vi i n he antf s e se i a he o , o how c us orr s ndt
a e e po o
t de e nt motont dimis at t pl i ifha ng f iedt do s t c tnow
he f nda s' i o s s , rd he antf vi al o
o, he our
c nsd r t ematrrp f ra j iain F rtera o sgv n b lw,h c u t l ga tte
o ie s h te i e o dudc to . o h e s n ie eo t e o r wi rn h
l
de e nt 'm oton t di m i s
f nda s
i o s s.
II.
D i si
scus on
Th d fn a t frtse ds sa o Th ma ' camsf rlc o s b e tmatr
e e e d n s is e k imis l f o ss li o a k f u jc te
j rs ito , t s a t oRu e1 ()1 .Fe ea Rueo Cii P o e u e8 a rq ie t a a
u id ci n p t u n t l 2b ( ) d r l l f v l r c d r () e ur s h t
r
pla ngm us c an
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?