Hamden v. Total Car Franchising Corporation
Filing
21
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge James C. Turk on 5/22/12. (med)
a . .:o-j:t,>u - n A qe ,
Te
A
FuAn tv
tix A
s
I T H E UN I
N
TED STATE S DI
STRI CO U R T
CT
FO R TH E W EST ER N D I
STR I T O F V I G I I
C
R N A
Roanoke Di si
vi on
MAt 22 2 1
22
JULI C,
A
D
,
c-
DEV I H A M D EN,
N
C ase No.7: cv12- 00003
Pl ntf ,
ai if
M EM OM NPUM OPI ON
NJ
V.
T O TAL C AR FM N C H I NG CO R P.
SI
,
d/ a C O LO RS O N PA M D E,
b/
By: H on.Jam es C .Turk
Se or U nie St e D i t i tJudge
ni
t d at s s r c
D ef
endant.
Thi m a t r i pr e l be or t Cour o t D e e nt s M oton t D i m i s o St
s te s es nty f e he
t n he f nda '
i o s s r ay
Lii ton a Compe Ar tai ( . 5) ThePli ifopposd t moi ( . 9)
tgai nd
l birton. DktNo. .
antf
e he ton DktNo.
a t Def ntrpled ( .No.11. The Cour he r orlar nton t moton on
nd he enda e i Dkt
)
t ad a gume
he i
M a c 2,201 a t t m o i unde a s m en t alow t pa tes t ptr ue m e a i
rh
2, nd ook he ton
r dvi e t o l he r i o ls
di ton.
M e a i w as not s e s ul a t ,t m o i i rpe f r di pos ton. For t f l w i
di ton
ucc s f nd hus he ton s i o s ii
he olo ng
r s , t D e e nt s M oton t D im i s o St y Lii a i a Com pel A r ta i i
ea ons he f nda '
i o s s r a
t g ton nd
bir ton s
D ENI .
ED
Bac ound
kgr
Pli ifDe nHn n(t- mde 'wa afa hie ofDe e ntTot Ca
antf vi mde 'la n' s rnc se
l
)
f nda
al r
Frnc sngCor Cç a1' sari i Ma 1 Totli afa s i t a omobie
a hii
p. Tot ' t tng n y 996. a s rnchior n he ut
)
l
r t a i bus ne s A spa tofa e ng t be a f a hi e H a d s gne a Li ied Fr nc s
esor ton i s .
r
gr ei o
r nc s e m en i d
m t
a hi e
Age me t(dr n hieAge me t'a aNo - mp tto a dCo fd n il yAge me t
r e n t a c s re n' nd n co ei n n n ie tai r e n
F
)
i
t
Cç compeii Agre nf'.Thetr oft Frnc s Agee twas1 ye r The
Nontton e me )
em he a hie r men
5 as.
Frnc s Agre nti l dadiput r ol i pr e epr di f ( )prvae
a hie e me ncude
s e es uton oc dur ovi ng or 1 i t
ne i i ( me ai and( bi ngabirton.( . 1 1 j 1 .TheFrnchie
gotaton, 2) diton, 3) ndi r tai DktNo. - , 2)
a s
ClFRK
.
Agr me alo i ude a c nan nott compee, nt s c i e ild ç ght a Dute of
ee nt s ncl d ove t
o
t i he e ton ntte t
Ri s nd is
Pari Upo Expia i Te m i ton orN on- ne a ,' hi h s a ed:
tes
n
r ton, r na i
Re w l' w c t t
Pos Ter C om pe ii For2 ye r f l w i t t na i n of
t m
ttona s olo ng he enni t o
t sAgreme net ryounora ofyo pa t rs or
hi e nt ihe
ny
ur rnet)
s rhol rs s lenga i o ha a fna alor
hae det) hal ge n, r ve ny nci
m a ge e i t r t die ty ori r ty e t r a a of i r
na m nt n e es , r c l
ndiec l ihe s n fce ,
pr i t ,age ,e pl e,d r c o ,s r hol r f a hi e or
opr e or
nt m oye i e t r ha e de , r nc s e
pa t r i a ot rm o l offxe pantr t r ton busne si
rne , n ny he bie i d i eso ai
i s n
t s a r m e r po ian sats i a a e i w hi h t t ni o y i
he t nda d t o lt t i tc l r a n
c he e t r s
l t
ocaed.
( . 1 1 !9) TheNo co tto Agre n pr de amor deal veri oft
DktNo. - , .
n- mpeiin e me t ovi d
e tied son he
c na nott c
ove nt o ompet Specfc ly,ipr bie co ii ûg urngt tr o t
e.
iial t ohi td mpetton çdl i he em f he
Fr nc s Agr eme 'a pr dedt t
a hie e nt' nd ovi ha :
l t Fr nc s Agr e e i t r na e be or ise r i dae,
f he a hie e m nt s e mi t d f e t xpiaton t
ori you as i ortans eryou i e e ti t Fr nc s
f
s gn r f
r nt r s n he a hi e
A g e m en , o a pe s orbusnes o ga z ton e e
r e t t ny r on
i s r ni a i xc pt
a cor ng t Se i 7oft Fr nc s Ag e nt t n You
c di o cton
he a hie r eme , he
c na ,f a pe i of2 ye r a t rt r i to t a f ror
ove nt or
rod
a s f e e m na i n, r ns e
a s gnm e ,nott e ge asa ow ne ,ope a o ,o i a
si
nt
o nga
n
r
r t r r n ny
ma ge i lca iy,n a busne se ge i t s m eor
na ra pact i ny i s nga d n he a
s m ia t pe ofa
i lr y
ppea a e t c mol i s wihi t m e r polt n
r nc e l og e t n he t o ia
s a itca ar a i whi h t Fr nc s A gr e e ' D e i t d
t ts i l e n
c he a hi e
e m nt s s gna e
M ar tng Ar ai l aed,ot rt n asa au horz fa hie
kei
e s oc t
he ha
n t ied r nc s e
ore pl e ofa he Col son Pa a f a hi e.
m oye
not r or
r de r nc s
( t No.12, 1.Net rt Fr nc s Agre ntno t NonDk.
- at ) ihe he a hie e me r he
compeii Ag e me
tton r e nt
i ude a s c i c a ni de i d tr s alhough alm ied n be oft nnsa e de d i
ncl d e ton ont i ng fne e m , t
i t um r e
r sne n
t r dt l t t Fr nc s A g ee e .
he e a s o he a hi e r m nt
The Fr nc s A g e m e expie i M a 2011 butHam de con i d w o ki a a
a hi e r e nt
rd n y
,
n tnue
r ng s
fmwhie OnN ove
r
s e.
mber30,2011 Ha n notfe Tot lt thewoul notbec i ng wih
, mde
i d a ha
d
ontnui
t
t f a hi e A fe r e vi a ca lfom Tot he c pl t l c as o r tons on Dec m be 1
he r nc s . t r ec i ng
l r
al om e e y e ed pe a i
e r ,
Ha de wihe t o n hi own d tr parbusnes bu be or doi s e n t h he
m n s d o pe s
en e i i s t f e ng o, ve houg
be i ve he w asno l
le d
ongerbot d by t Fr nc s A gr e e ta t N onm
he a hi e
e m n nd he
com pe ii
tton
Ag ee nt hec a t d To a a i or d t m ofhi i e i . Tot ldia r e wih
r me , ont c e t l nd nf me he
s ntntons
a sged t
Ha n' i e r tton t tHn de wa no bo by t Fr hieAgr eme a t Nonmde s ntm ea i ha m n s t und he anc s
e nt nd he
Com pe ii n A gr e e . Upon l mmi o H a d si e i n t s a thi own bus nes ,Tot l
tto
e m nt
e ng f m en' nt nto o t r s
i s
a
if r dHa e te wo l tkei daej dca a t nt p e e t m fo d igs
n o me md n h y u d a mme it u iil ci o rv n hi r m on o.
o
Ha de t n fl t i t nta ton.
m n he ied he ns a c i
I . St
I apdar ofRe e
d
viw
Unde Fe r lRul ofCi lPr ce e8()2) ac antne d onl c an( s t
r de a e
vi o dur a( , ompli e y onti $ hor
a
a pli sae e oft ca m s
nd an t tm nt he li howi t tt plad ri en ild t r le . W he e uai
ng ha he e e s tte o ei f'
'
n val tng
ac antunde Fedea Rul ofCi lPr ed e 1 b)6) c t mus û cc ptt ale tons
ompli
r rl e
vi oc ur 2( ( , ours tù e he lgai
a
i t co pli ta tu a dr w a1 r as bl f cuali e enc si f
n he m a n s r e, nd a 1 e ona e a t nf r e n avoroft pl i if'
he antf.'
Co e v Gi s n, 5 U. 41 4 - 6( 9 7 .Nowi tn igRul 8a ( ) teS p e Co r
nly . b o 3 5 S. , 5 4 1 5 ) t t a dn
hs
e ( )2 ,h u rme u t
ha s ciid t tpl a ngswhi h me ey ofe (lbe sa c usons'çaf mul i r ia i
s pe fe ha e di
c
r l f r ta l nd oncl i ,'t or ac ectton
oft e e nt ofa c us ofaci 'orE kedas e to de d off t rf cual
he l me s
a e
ton,' d
na
s ri ns voi
urhe a t
e nc nt'aenots fce .As r tv.I l 1 S. .1 1 (
nha eme ' r
ufiint hcof qba, 29 Ct 937, 949 2009)(ii Bel
ctng l
Ata i Cor v.Twombl 55 U. 544,555 5 (
lntc p.
v, 0 S.
- 7 2007:. Thus whieûdeaiedfcua
, l i t l at l
alega i ' a e notr qui e ç o s vi a m o i t di m i s a c pl i m us c t n s fci nt
l tons ' r
e r d, s ur ve
t
ton o s s , om a nt t on ai uf i e
f t lm a t r a e e ast ue t sa e a cl i t r le t ti pl us bl on is f c ' 1
ac ua te , cc pt d r , o t t
a m o e i f ha s a i e t a e. d.
'
1 1 Anal i
1.
ys s
Tot ' motont dimisort co labirto r ie t l lis s: 1 whehe t
als i o s s o mpe r tain as s wo ega sue ( ) t r he
pr s ons r ga di a bir ton i t Fr nchie A gr e e a t N onovi i
e r ng r t a i n he a s
e m nt nd he
com pe ii
tton
Agr me c
ee nt ompelabirton, nd( whehert sCo ts ddimist ca ea t
r tai a 2) t hi ur houl s s he s fer
3
c
ompe lng a bir ton,i t Cour r e a bir ton i r quied. Hamde r po by a g ng
li r ta i f he
t uls r ta i s e r
n es nds r ui
t tt Fr hieAgr eme doe noti udea ag e ntt a bir t t cai a is and
ha he anc s
e nt s
ncl
n r eme o r ta e he l ms t s ue
t te n i t Fr nc s A gr m e di c rt pr s nti s s t r quie e t a bir e
ha ve f he a hi e
ee nt d ove he e e s ue , he e r m nt o r tat
e r d wih t Fr nc s Ag e m e ti M a 2011.Furher or Ha de a g st tt
xpie t he a hie r e n n y
t m e, m n r ue ha he
pr vii t a bir t i ude i t Fr nc s Agr e e tdoe note e t orgo r t Nono son o r ta e ncl d n he a hie e m n
s
xtnd o
ve n he
Co pe ii A gr e e .
m tton
e m nt
The Cour tr taddr s e t i s ofwhe he t pa tesag e d t a bir t t pr e
tis
e s s he s ue
t r he r i
r e o r t a e he es nt
diput r ga di whe he Ha de ma sar hi o i e
s e e r ng
t r m n y t t s wn nd pende busne sa t stme o
nt i s t hi i r
whe he hei bo byt t ye rnon- ompe eclus a deaied i t Fr nc s Agr eme
t r s und he wo a
c
t a e s t l n he a hie e nt
andt No compeiin Agr me .Thequesi ofEl hehe apa t hasagee t abirt
he ntto
ee nt
ton swl t r ry
r d o r tae
a is i amatrofc rc i eprtton:;AJpat c nno ber uie t s tt
n sue s te onta t ntr eai g ry a t eq rd o ubmi o
a bir ton a di put whi h he hasnota e d s t s bm i.' Le n v. l s & A s oc . I .
r ta i ny s e
c
gr e o o u t'' vi A m
s s s nc ,
634F. 260, ( hCi. 1 ( i Unie Stewor r- Ameiav. aror& Gul
3d
266 4t r 201 ) quotng td e l ke-of rc W ri
s
f
Na cain Co.363U. 574,582( 960:.Nonehels , ca et Supr Co te ourges
vi to
,
S.
1
t e s be us he eme ur nc a
a l at r ga df rt f r lpolc fvo i a bir ton,' os H .
t lhy e r o he ede a iy a rng r ta i 'M es Cone M e ' Hos v.
he
m l p.
M ec yConsr Cop .460U. 1 24( ) d nydoubt c er ngt s opeofar ta e
rur
t.
,
S. , 1983 ,t
a
s onc ni he c
birbl
is ss dber s ve i f vorora bir ton, Le n,634 F. a 266.A st Fourh Cic t
s ue houl
e ol d n a
r tai ' vi
'
3d t
he
t r ui
hass i t r i aS a pr umpton'i fvo ofabirbiiy.I (uoi Peo e Sec Lie
ad,hee s : vy es i 'n a r r ta lt d. q tng pls . f
he
l . v. on ntlLiel . ,8 F. 8 81 ( hCi.1 9) W iht ssa r i
ns Co. M ume a f ns Co. 67 2d 09, 2 4t r 98 . t hi tndad n
m i t Cour e ua e t l ngua oft di pu e r s uton s ton i t Fr nc s
nd, he
t val t s he a
ge he s t e ol i ec i n he a hi e
Agr m e t de er i i i w a i e d t c rt c r ntdi put ,whi h i a di put
ee nt o t m ne f t s nt nde o ove he ur e
s e
c s s e
be w e n t f a hi ee H a den,a t f anc s ,Tot l
t e he r nc s , m
nd he r hi or a .
Se ton 1 oft Fr hieAgr e e , pe ii st t e se t tm us betke i t
c i 2 he anc s
e m nt s cte he hr e tps ha
t a n n he
e ntofa di put . St p 1 r r ng pr va e neg i ton,s ii s t he ve a c us of
ve
s e
e , ega di
i t
ota i pec f e i ne r ny a e
W
po e i lca e f dia e ntma occ wihi t Col son Pa adec muniy, hepa te
t nta us or s gr eme
y ur t n he or
r
om
t t
ris
i ve wile e i odie tc
nvol d l ntr nt rc ommuniai wihonea he . ( . 1 1, t9) I prvae
c ton t
not r' DktNo. - a . f i t
'
negoitoni uns c sul se 2die st pa te t purueme ai (d.a 1 ) l no
tai s uc esf , tp rct he ris o s
diton. l , t 0 . f
r s uton occ ls se 3 s c fe t pr dur s f rbi i a bir ton,a f l w s
e ol i
t , t p pe ii s he oce e o nd ng r t a i
r
s olo :
The pa te wile c c
r i s l a h hoos o a bir t . The t ar ta or
e ne r ta or
wo bir t s
wils ec at r Thepa te wildee m i t f u f
l el t hid.
ri s l t r ne he or m or
a bir ton. I ,how e r t pa te f i t esa i h a f 'm t
r ta i
f
ve , he ri s a l o t bls ol he
u
s a r r e ofa bir ton a s tou by t A m e i a A r t a i
t nda d ul s r t a i s e t he
r c n bir ton
As oc ai w ila y.. Thea bir to wilbe bi ng a t
s i ton l ppl ..
r ta in l
ndi nd he
de s on oft a bir t sfna .
ci i
he r t a or i l
The f r a oft ar ta i pr es i t s
o m t he bir ton oc s s hi :
Oneore h diputnts isade nd f ra bir i n t
ac s a ubm t
ma o r tato o
us W ewilas iti t s e ton ofa bir or a s r e
.
l ss n he elc i
r tat s nd e v
a c e a i sr t .
s as dm nit a or
Onc t a bir t r a e a ntd, he wilc r t
e he r ta o s r ppoi e t y l ontol he
pr ee ngs a al de s onsw ilbe tna a bi ng a
oc di
nd 1 ci i
l
i l nd ndi nd
ma befldi ac u t fc mp tn j rs ito
y ie n o r o o ee tu id ci n.
(d..
I)
Hn n a gue t tSe ton 1 wa i t nde t be a i erofie diput r s uton
mde r s ha c i 2 s n e d o
n nt - fc s e e ol i
p o e t ea dn t ne de t g v r ds u e bewe ntefa c ie a dfa hs r ( tNo
r c dl n o i tn d o o en ip ts t e h r n h s e n rnc io . Dk . .
r
9, t3) Tos r t spostonHa nr lesonaLouiinadecson,O' lv. tlCar
a . uppo thi ii
mde ei
sa
ii
Nea Toa
Frnc sncCom .27So.d 31 ( CtAp 2009 ,ha hedt tt abirtonpr sonsdi
a hii
,
3 7 La. . p. ) t t l ha he r tai ovii
d
n t o e abtain i an n c mp t b e c o c nr c c s .Toa rj cst i ag me ta d
o c mp l r i to n o -o ee r a h f o ta t ae tl ee t h s r u n n
r
r s t tt Lo s a de i i pl ce ç
ea ons ha he ui i na c s on a d t
undue e phas son t f c t tD e e ntwoul
m
i
he a t ha f nda
d
a ss i t s lci ofar tat sa s l a ac ead nitaor'( . 1 a 3)
s itn he ee ton
bir or nd e' s as mi srt . DktNo. 1, t .
ve
'
Thea bir ton clus pr de ,a not d a
r ta i a e ovi s s e bove t
, s ore h diput ts
one ac s an ubmisa
t
de a f r a bir ton t us W e w ila s s i t s e ton ofa bir t sand s r a c s
m nd o r t a i o .
l s i t n he el c i
r t a or
e ve s a e
ad nitaor' ( . 1 1 a 1 )(mpha i a d) Thercial t t Fr nc s Agre n
mi srt . DktNo. - , t 0 e
'
ss dde .
e t s o he a hie e me t
pr det tToa i r fredt a tt a /o t 't oughou t sAgr me .'( . 1ovi ha tl s eer o s twe' nd r us hr
t hi ee nt' DktNo.
1 a 1.Thus t drfi oft spr sons sst tTotlwhoi t dei pat i S '
,t )
,he a tng hi ovii ugget ha a,
s he fned ry n s
we'
a t ,' sno i e
nd t 'wa t nt ndedt bea diput ntunde t spr son.l To a wer adiput ntt y
us
o
s a
r hi ovii
f t l e s a he
woul s
d ubmi t i diput t t
t her s e o hems l , c ma sltl s ns ll e , ast Loui i na
eves whih ke ite e e. nde d
he
sa
c ts i Ches pa s gesc s To a Ca/ or onPa a a ane r ladmi sr t r nota
our a d t e s a
t
a t t l rcol s
r de s uta
nita o ,
diputnt i t t s e c empl e by t sag ee nt' O' l 27 So. a 31
s a , n he diput s' ont atd hi r me .' Nei,
3d t 9.
Addii ly,ot rpori nsoft diput r s u i s c i notdie ty a i bl t
tona l he
to
he s e e olton e ton,
r c l pplca e o
t pr e diput s
he es nt s e, ugges t s m eou c e Fis,hes ond s n e eoft diput
t he a
t om . r t t ec
e t nc
he s e
rs uto sci sae ç a e t a debyt spr edu e. ( t No.1 1 a 9)(mpha i
e ol in e ton tts ç
You gre o bi
hi oc r ' Dk .
'
- , t e ss
a d) Thed a tr c ek 'ahe t d 'i cai t tt drfe,Totldi not
dde .
r fe s hos ç rt r han t ndi tng ha he a tr a, d
you'
we'
i endt bebound by t pr son. Se O' l 27 So.d a 31 Se ond,helng ge
nt o
he ovii
e Nei,
3 t 9. c
t a ua
r ga di m e a i s a esû e w ilpr de a ls oft e s
e r ng di ton t t i
w
l ovi
i t hr e ugge t d m e a o st de lw ih t
se
di t r o a t he
stain. ( tNo.11 a 1 )( mph ssa d d .Ag i,h sd a t gs g ssToa wa t b
i to ' Dk .
u
'
- , t 0 e a i d e ) an t i rfi ug et tl s o e
n
s en a a ne r pa t t t diput r t rt n adipu a .Se O' i,27 So. a 31
e s utal ry o he s e, a he ha
s t nt e Nel
3d t 9.
Fi ly,t s Cour fnds Tot ls a g e t tO ' e pl e tundue e pha i ' on
na l hi
ti
a ' r um nt ha N al ac d d
m
s s'
To a ' r e i s l c i t a bir t sunpe s s ve.
t l s ol n e e tng he r ta or
r ua i The que ton bef e t s Co ti not
si
or hi ur s
whehe t pr es f s e tng t abir t si f i, rt rwhe he t pa te a e t
t r he oc s or elc i he r ta or s ar but ahe
t r he ris gr ed o
a bir t t di put a al. Conc r a
r ta e he s e t l
e ns boutt f ine s o t s l to pr es a e s co r
he a r s f he e ec i n oc s r e nda y
a i m a e i t t s Co ts i r Thi Cour ' r a oni whi h di c s t f c t t
nd m t ral o hi ur ' nquiy. s
ts e s ng, c s us es he a t ha
'Deenda ' agum e t ti i bou byt dipu er s ui s ton byvit ofhol ng is l ou a ame ber
f nts r
nt ha t s nd he s t e olton eci
rue
di tef t s
m
oft Col son Pa a comm uniy fist addr st s c i ss Gcus oft wor iwe'a Kus'a t i
he or
r de
t al o
es he e ton' peci
e he ds t ' nd < ' nd hus s
unpe s i
r uasve.
6
Tot li i ve i t s l ton pr e sf a bir t r ,i no aco m e on t f ine soft
a s nvol d n he eec i
oc s or r ta o s s t m nt he ar s
he
pr es ,bu r t ra s a e e aboutt m e ni o t pr vi i is f a whe he t
oc s t a he t t m nt
he a ng f he o s on t el- nd
t r he
pr s on w o d ha be n dr t d i t s m e m mm e ha i be n i t nd t co diput s
ovi i
ul ve e afe n he a
r d t e n e ed o ver s e
be we t f a hi ora f anc s e. H a t pr s on be n i e
t en he r nc s nd r hi e
d he ovi i
e nt nded t c r diput s
o ove s e
be we t f a hi ora f a hi e t s Co tfndst ti woul ha bee dr f e
t en he r nc s nd r nc s e, hi ur i
ha t
d ve n a t d
dif r ty. 2
fe en l
I . Concl on
V
usi
N ot ihs a ng t û avy pr s pto 'i f r of a bir ton, t s Cou tc nnot s
w t t ndi he t
he
e um i n' n avo
r ta i hi
r a
ay
t t ba e on t l nguage of t d s e r s uto s c i t pa te a ee t a bir t a
ha s d
he a
he i put e ol i n e ton, he ri s gr d o r t a e
dipu e bet e t fanc s a f a hie s
s t
we n he r hior nd r nc s e, uch as t c r nt diput Ac or ngl
he ure
s e.
c di y,
Def nda ' M o i n t D i m i s or St y Lii ton a Com pel A r t a i i D EN I
e nts t o o s s
a
tga i nd
bir ton s
ED. A n
a op i t or rs l i s t sda
ppr r a e de ha l s ue hi y.
ENTER:Thi 7..
s 7
-
a ofMay,201
y
2
,
' z)
pg,
'
Se
n' U nied St t s Di t i tJ e
t
a e s rc ud
2Dee tas a gue t tt cour i TotlCa Fr nchii Co n. v An esn,1 9 W L 1 3 9 ( D. C.
fndan lo r s ha he
tn a r a sng r . d ro 9 9
9 75 9 M. N.
Au , 6 1 9 ) edta teabtainca s a is eheewa v l a de oc a e Dee d n, o v r
g 2 9 9 h l h th rirto lu e tsu r s ai n nfre bl. fn a th we e,
d
micha a trzest hol ng i Ande s l Ande s t c tconsderd S he adipu er s uton pr es
s r ce i he di n
r on. n
r on he our
i e t
whet r s t e ol i oc s
cond e byt pate wihi aJ hova sW i esesCongr gai c tt esç ndi abir ton'w ihi t
uctd he ris t n e h' m s
e ton onsiut bi ng r tai
t n he
m e ng oft pa te 'fanc s a e m en . 1 W L 193 99,a 1 Theco thel Tot f ldt m e tis
ani
he ris r hie gr e t' 999
'
75 t .
ur d al aie o e t
b r e o smmayj d me ta dta teewa ads tdmaeila t st wh te teJho a ' Wi e ss
u d n n u r u g n n h t h r s ipue tra fc a o eh r h e v hs t se
n
Cong e tonpr ed ewasi ende t bebi n abirton.l ex ai ngt na u eoft diputd m aei
r gai
oc ur
nt d o
ndig r ta i n pl ni he t r
he s e
tral
f t t cou tnot d t ta l as one oft pa te m a ha bele t J hova sW ines e Congr to
ac , he r e ha t e t
he ri s y ve i ved he e h' t s s
ega i n
pr dur wast t a c r t . Thus t c ti Ande s t no poston on t s ope oft a bir ton
oce e
t r - ontac ual'
ex
'
, he our n
r on ook
ii
he c
he r t a i
a e m en orw hehe t pa tes diput wass tbl f a bir ton u rt s ton.
gr e t
t r he ri ' s e
uia e or r tai nde he eci
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?