Strickland v. Militana et al

Filing 191

ORDER granting 63 Motion for Summary Judgment; granting 70 Motion for Summary Judgment; granting 73 Motion for Summary Judgment; granting 148 Motion for Summary Judgment; adopting Report and Recommendations re 181 Report and Recommendations; granting 186 motion for extension of time. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 5/9/2013. (tvt)

r ppm OFFI U. Dl n l
a
CE S. Smr r
AT ROANOKE,
VA
FI
LED

MA 2S 2 1
t
03
IN TH E U N ITE D STA T ES D ISTR ICT CO U R T
FO R T H E W E STER N D I
STR I O F V I G I I
CT
R N A
ROANO KE DI I ON
V SI
H A R O LD E.ST RICK LA N D

JULI .
A

BY;
DEPUW C

Ci lA cti N o.7:
vi
on
12cv00005

Pl nt f ,
ai i f
M E M O M N DU M O PI I N A N D
N O
O R D ER AD O PTIN G R EPO R T
AN D RE C O M M EN D A TI N
O

V.

D R .M A R K M I TA N A et#
LI
1,
D efendants.

By:Sam uelG .W is
l on
Uni St esD i ri Judge
ted at
st ct

Ha ol E.Stikl nd,aVigi ai t pr e ngrr s ,brngst sa ton ptr ua t
r d
rc a
r ni nma e oce di
o e i hi c i zs nt o

42U. C.j1 a i tvai e oye a De pM e w Coreci lCe e a
S.
983 gans rous mpl es t e ado
r tona ntr nd
M e kl
c enbur Core tona Ce e ,of i sfo t Vigi a De rm e ofCo r c i
g r c i l nt r fcal ' m he r ni pa t nt
r
r e tons

(&
ç
VDOC' ,
' VDOC is f t Co
)
tel,he mmonweat ofVigi a, ndAsitntAtor Genea J m
lh
r ni a
ssa t ney
rl ol
Par o .1 Stikl nd c am st tofi i l de ed hi a qua em e ca te t nta apr
s ns rc a l i ha fc as ni m de t di l r a me nd oper
ditf hi Cr sdie e. Def nda sJ. ihae Pa s ,M a k M iia Gayl Ha s R.
e or s ohn' s as
e nt M c l r ons r lt na,
e ni ,
Sute fe d,F.Sc li S.W hit n, a ol Cl r H .
tr i l
hilng,
te H r d a ke, Pont n, D O C,a t Com m onwea t
o V
nd he
1h

o Vign a tldmoinsf rsl r u g n ( No . 3 7 , 3 1 8 , n t c u t
f r ii,ie to o l
mmayj d me t ECF s 6 , 0 7 , 4 ) a d he o r
r f r e t ma trt Unied St t sM ag sr t J
e e r d he te o t
ae
ita e udgePa aM . r ntf aRe ta
mel
Sa ge or
por nd
Re m enda i plr ua t 28 U .S. j6 6b ()B)2
com
ton zs nt o
C. 3 ()1 ( .
The M a sr e J
gi tat udge tl a t ough r por r com m endi t tt c tg a t
ied hor
e te
ng ha he our r nt he

d f n a t' to f rs mmayj g n o alo S rc ln scams Src ln afe u n
e e d n s moin o u r ud me t n l f tik a d' li . tika d rq e t
1By Se e
ptmber28, 2 2 od rtec u t imisdeg t fted fn a t.( No. 8)ByNo e e
01 , re,h o r ds se ih o h ee d ns ECF 5 .
v mb r
1 201 od r t c u t imisdt moed fn ns ( No.1 3)An b Mac 28 2 3 oa od r te
4, 2, r e,he o r ds se wo r ee da t. ECF
1 . d y rh , 01 , rl re,h
c u t s se tremoed fn ns ( No 1 3)
o rdimisd h e r ee da t. ECF . 8 .
2The c t t t ta oft dae oft sor r oneouttndi deenda ,Dr H. e ns Chif
our noes ha s he t hi de ,
sa ng f nt . St phe , e
M edialOfk e ofVD OC, syett r pond t Stiklnd' c pli a ns hi sa t c te e e de a t
c
t r
ha
o es
o rc a s om ant gai t m nd he our ntr d f ul
a ns anot rdefnda Nure S ly Gr gor
gai t he e nt s hel e y.

nc t or ii
ounde c ai s, nn i nond lm
ltga i t f de alc t3 who hasa pe han f f lng unf
ii nt n he e r ours
m ng
4

e s nil a t s a dl c saiymutp yn p o e dng- di n ttl atmeyo jcin t
se ta p ri , n mne e srl lil ig r c e i s- d o ie i l be t o
e
o

teRe o t ndRe o nd to b tat o g u tmey t ec u t a c nsd rdt eo j ci n
h p ra
c mme ain, u lh u h n i l,h o r h s o iee h be to s
S rc a dfld.Th s o j cinslr eyr ieaeteagl n sma ei h sp e d n s
tikln ie
o e be t ag l etrt h r l t d n i la i g .
o
me
Ha ngrviwe t Re r a Re
vi e e d he po t nd comme ton,Stiklnd' ob e tons a pe tne
ndai rc a s j ci , nd ri nt

po to o t rc r d n v i a c r a c wi j63 ( )1 ,hec u t g e swihte
rins f he e o d e o o n c o d n e t
h 6 b () t o r a r e t h
M a sr t J
gita e udge' r omm e ton.
s ec
nda i
Ac r ngl i i he eby ORDERED a ADJUDGED t tSti klnd' m o i f a
co di y,t s r
nd
ha rc a s ton or n
e e i oftm e i G R AN TED ,t M agit a e J
xt nson i s
he
s r t udge' Re t nd Re m m enda i i
s por a
co
ton s

ADOPTED i ise t ey, ndt ed fn a t' to sf rs mmayj dg n aeGRANTED.
n t ni t a h ee d n s moi n o u r u me t r
r
EN TER : a 9,201
M y
3.

UN I
TED STA TES D I
STRI J D GE
CT U

3cure l, Src a haspe ng i t sc ttr c s nami at aloft nt s n de e nt.
rnty tiklnd
ndi n hi our h ee a es
ng ot
we p eve f nda s

4Src ln so jcin weed o Ap i 1 , 01 ; eddn tfl a o j cint iAp i 1 , 01 .
tika d' beto s r ue n rl 2 2 3 h i o i n be to mtl rl 6 2 3
e
( No l 9)
ECF . 8 .