Strickland v. Militana et al

Filing 35

ORDER ADOPTING REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS ; adopting Report and Recommendations re 33 Report and Recommendations ; denying 2 Motion for Preliminary Injunction; granting in part and denying in part 22 Motion to Amend/Correct; granting in part an d denying in part 24 Motion to Amend/Correct; granting in part and denying in part 25 Motion to Amend/Correct; granting in part and denying in part 26 Motion to Amend/Correct; granting in part and denying in part 28 Motion to Amend/Correct; overruled objections to the R&R 34 ; defendants added. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 6/15/2012. (tvt)

c n oF lEts Ds c e
œ rs Fc l lm ou
.
ATR k k,A
oAt v
oK
Fsno
u

J 15 2 1
UN
22
IN TH E U N I
TED STATE S DISTRIC T C O U R T
FO R TH E W ESTER N D I
STR I T O F VIR G INIA
C
R O AN O K E DIVISIO N

H A R O LD E .STR I LA ND ,
CK
Pl ntif
ai f ,
V.

D R . A R K M I TA N A , aI,
M
LI
e/ .
D ef
endants
.

)
)
)
)
)
)
)

JULI C. U EX C RK
A
BY:

C

Ci lA ct on N o.7: v00005
vi
i
12c

O R DER A D O PTI G R EPO RT
N
AN D RE CO M M EN D A TIO N
By:Sa ue G .W is
m l
l on
U ni St esD i t ctJudge
ted at
s ri

H a ol E.S rc a a V igi a i a e pr e ng pr s f l d a m oton f pr lm i r
rd
t i kl nd,
r ni nm t oc edi
o e, ie
i or e i na y

ij n tv rle ( c e No. )a d s v r lmoi n t a n ( c e No .2 , 4, 5 2 a d
nu cie eif Do k t 2 n e ea to s o me d Do k t s 2 2 2 , 6, n
28) Byprviusode,t c trfre t matrt Unied Stt M agitaeJ RobetS.
.
e o r r he our ee rd he te o t aes
srt udge
r
Balu f aRe ta Re mme tonpurua t 28U. C.j636( ( )B) TheM a srt
lo or por nd co ndai
s nt o
S.
b)1( .
gitae
J e t l d a r por , r com m e ng t t t c tgr nt i pa tand de i pa t St i kl nd'
udg i e
e t e
ndi ha he our a n r
ny n r rc a s

mo in t a n a d t tt ec u td n Src lnd smoin f rp ei nay ijmci r l f
to s o me d n ha h o r e y tika ' to o r l r nt t ei .
mi
ve e
S rc ln fld o jci n t te Re o ta d Re o n ain a i c n en t M a itae
tika d i be to s o h p r n c mme d to s t o c r s he gsrt
e
J d esr c mme d to t d ny Src ln ' rq e tf rp ei n r ij n tv r l f lr ey
u g ' e o n ain o e tika d s e u s o r l a y nu cie ei , a g l
mi
e
r ie a i a g e s m ade i hi e r i r pl a ngs H a ng r vi w e t Re t a
e t r tng r um nt
n s a le
e di .
vi
e e d he
por nd

Re o n ain te o j ci n t eeo a d p rie t p rins o t e rc r d n v i
c mme d to , h be to s h rt , n e t n o to f h e od e o o n
n
a o d nc wih j636( ( ) t cou ta ee wiht M a sr t Judge' rco ndain.
cc r a e t
b)1 ,he r gr s t he gitae
s e mme to
Thi a ton c er St i a sm e ca t e t e whie he w ashous a M e e r
s c i onc ns rckl nd' di l r a m nt l
ed t ckl nbe g
Cor e tona Ce e ,D e p M e do s Co r tona Ce e ,a Powha a Cor ec i na Ce t r a 1
r c i l nt r e
a w
r ec i l nt r nd
tn
r to l n e , l
l a ed i t W e t m D it i t of V igi a. St i kl nd i no hous d a l a Cr ek
oc t n he
se
s rc
r ni
rc a
s w
e t ndi n e
Cor e tonal Ce e , l t d i t Ea t r Di ti t of V igi a. A s r le f hi m o i f
rci
nt r oca e n he s e n sr c
r ni
e i f or s ton or

p ei n r ij nci n Stika a k t e c u tt od rt e d fn a t t p o i e hm wi
r l ay nu to , rc lnd s s h o r o r e h e e d n s o r v d i t
mi
h
a qua e m e c lt e t enta ta 1 r i ue l tbe di t a or r d by t doc or' To t
de t
di a r a m
nd d ow es d /ow i r e s de e
he t .
'
he

e tn Src ln s e p ei n r ij ncie r l f a ans te d fn a t h n me i t s
x e t tik a d e ks rlmiay nu tv ei g i t h e e d ns e a s n hi
e
elef rc a e ks
t
e r d es rbe nd/ r
a ton, hi cl i i m oot1 The r i Stiklnd s e m us be r nde e , pr c i d, a o
ci
s am s
.
or r by a m e c lpr e s onalw ho i cur e ty tea i hi . N one of t de e nt t t s
de ed
di a of s i
s r n l r tng m
he f nda s o hi
ac i n a e c r nty t e tng St i kl nd' m e c ne ds
to r ur e l r a i
r c a s di al e .
Sti a nam est f l i def nda st t s a ton:
rckl nd
he olow ng e nt o hi c i

A)Fr M e klnbeg Core tonalCe e (C CC' :Dr M iia Nure Gayl Ha s R.
om c e r
r ci
ntr t
M ' . ltna, s
)
e ni,
Sute f e d,N ur e G r or a W a de Po on;
tri l
s eg y, nd r n nt

B) Fr De p M e
om e
adows Coreci l Ce e (û CC' : Dr Clr , Food Sevies
r tona ntr û
DM ' . ake
I
rc
Di e t rM s Cl
r co
. oud,a W a de Di '
nd r n ggs
,

C) Fr Powhaa Co rci lCe e (TCC' :Dr Ohai Dr To Sg .W hie Nure
om
tn re tona ntr ( ' . , . ny, t
)
t, s
Pr i,M s.C ar
oft
son,and N ur /1;
se /

D) Ot es Omb s n W hte
h r:
ud ma
i n,Omb s n Br n ,Ombu s n Da s Omb d ma
t
ud ma ya t
d ma vi,
us n
Ta or Ombuds a Se y,He 1h Se vce Die t oft VDOC,ChifM e c lOfi e
yl ,
m n a
a t r i s r c or he
e
di a fc r
of t V D O C, D iec or of t V DO C Ha ol Cl r , A s i t nt A tor y G e r l J
he
r t
he
r d a ke
ssa
t ne
ne a .
M i ha lPar o , t V D O C,a t Com m onw e 1h ofV igi a.
c e
s ns he
nd he
at
r ni 2
The de e nt f o M CC ,DM CC ,a PCC a e u bl t pr de t m e ca t e t e ordi t
f nda s r m
nd
r na e o ovi he di l r a m nt
e
t Sti kl nd s e bec e St i kl nd i no l eri t rc r .
hat rc a e ks aus rc a s ong n hei a e
The fve Om buds a de e nt ,H a ol Cl r J. i ha lPa s ,t V DO C,a t
i
m n f nda s r d a ke, M c e r ons he
nd he
Com m onwea t ofV igi a a e notm edi alde e nt . The e or t e de e n sa e nota e
1h
r ni r
c
f nda s
r f e, hes f nda t r
bl

t p e cie o o d rS rc lnd sme ia c r wi u tepr fs in l ud me to ame ia
o rs rb r r e tika ' dc l a e t t h o e so a j g n f
ho
dc l
pr es i
of s onalwho i cur e l t e tng Sti kl
s r nty r a i
r c and.

1 sc u t x rse n o iina t wh te Src a dma h v acam frp ei nayijncierle a an t
Thi o r e pe ss o pno s o eh r tikln y a e li o rlmi r nu t eif g is
v
deenda sa hi cu r tf lt H owe r any s cl m mus ber s d i t Unied SttsDititCour frt
f nt t s ren aciiy.
ve ,
uch ai
t aie n he t
ae src
t o he
Ea tr D ititofV igi aa t Sti a ha exha td a1avalbl a i sr tver e es
se n src
r ni fer rcklnd s
use l ia e dm nitai em di .
2The cou wilr e w hehe ea h oft defndant ar appr i ey na ed a defnda t t t sacin by
rt l eviw
t r c
he e
s e
opratl m
s e n s o hi to
s pa a e opi on a or .
e r t ni nd der
2

Fi ly,at
nal lhough t He t Se vies Die t a t Chif M edi lOfier ma be
he a1h r c
r c or nd he
e
ca fc
y
m e c lpr e s ona s t r i no evi nc t teihe i c r nty t e tng,orhase rpe s ly
di a of s i l , he e s
de e ha t r s ur e l r a i
ve r ona l
tea e St i kl nd. Thus a a lt t e def nda s woul ha t pr de m e ca t e t e
r t d, rc a
, ny biiy hes
e nt
d ve o ovi
di l r a m nt
or a s c a di t w oul c e t oug t m e c pr es i l a I an Cr e Cor ec i l
pe i l e
d om hr h he di al of sona s t ndi
ek
r tona
Ce e ,whe e Sti a i c r t y hous a i c r nty be ng tea ed.
nt r
r rckl nd s ur en l
ed nd s ur e l i r t

Ac or ngl i i he e ORDERED a ADJUDGED t t
c di y, t s r by
nd
ha :

1 Src ln s o j cins t t e Re o t a d Re o n ain ( k t No. 3 ) ae
) tika d' b e to o h
pr n
c mme d to Doc e
4 r
O V ER RU LED ;

2 t M a itae J g ' Re o ta d Re o n ain ( c tNo.3 )i ADOPTED i
) he g srt ud es p r n c mme d to Do ke
3 s
n
is entret ,
t i y'

3) Stiklnd' motonst a nd ( ke Nos 2 2 25,26,a 28 a eGRANTED i
rc a s i o me Doc t . 2, 4,
nd ) r
n
part and D ENI
ED i par ;t s m otons a e gr nt t t ext t Sti kl nd s e t
n
t he e
i
r a ed o he en r c a e ks o
a ne def ndan s D r Tony,Sg . hie,Dr Oha , tr e Pr i ,M s Ca s a N ur e
dd w
e
t .
tW t
. i N ls ott . r on, nd
s
#1 a f c s i s
nd a t n uppor of hi cl i s aga ns t e ne de e nt ' how e r t e
t
s am
i t hes
w f nda s
,
ve , hes
m otons ar de e t t ext nt he s e t add ne de enda s N lr e /2 a Dr
i
e ni d o he e
e ks o
w f
nt z s / nd .
Ca pbe la f t i s
m
l nd ac s n uppor ofhi cl i saga ns t s t o def nda s
t
s am
i t he e w
e nt ;

4 Src ln smoi nf rp ei n r ij ncierle ( c e No 2 i DENI
) tika d' to o rlmiay n u tv eif Do k t . ) s
ED;
5 The Clr i DI
)
ek s RECTED t ADD Dr Tony,Sgt W hie,Dr Oha,NurePr i,M s
o
.
. t . i s ott .
Ca s n,a N ur e /1 asdef nda st t sa ton.
r o nd
s /
e nt o hi c i
The Cl r oft Cour i r t t s nd c e t s Or r t t pa
e k he
t sdiec ed o e opi sof hi de o he

sx-su,vhs/bfb oln 2 1.
r
i ' . tue 0 2
,

ied St t Di t i tJ e
t
a es s rc udg

3