Nofsinger v. Virginia Commonwealth University et al

Filing 37

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 03/28/2012. (rkc) (Main Document 37 replaced on 3/28/2012) (rkc).

clEM s OFFI Et,s. ST. URT
C ) DI O
AT ROANOKE.VA
FIED
L

MA2 22 2 1
92
I TH E U N I
N
TED STA TES D I
STR I T CO U R T
C
FO R TH E W ESTER N D I
STR I T O F V I G I I
C
R N A
R O A N O K E D I ISIO N
V
SY LV I E . O FSI G ER ,
A N
N

J LAG DUD CL RK
UI
R
E

BY;

C i lA c i N o.7: v00030
vi t on
12c

Pl nt f
ai i f,

M EM O R AND U M O PI O N
NI

V.

V I G I I C O M M O N W E AL TH
R N A
U N I ER SI ,e al,
V
TY t .
D efendant
s.

By:Sam ue G .W is
l
l on
Unied St e Di t i Judge
t
at s s r ct

Thi i a a i bypli ifSyl aNofi e pu s ntt 42U. C.j 1 3a ns
s s n cton
antf vi sng r rua o
S.
98 gai t

d fn a t ( r i aCo n at Un v riy(( '; u lsBo dno ,
ee d n s Vigni mmo we 1h i est 6
VCU' Do ga u i tVCU De no
)
a f
Gr dua e St e ;Ce lD r i VCU Dea ofA li d He t Pr e s o ;a Tho a M a w ,
a t udi s ci a n,
n
le
a1h of s i ns nd
m s yhe

VCU Ph sc l rp De rme t ar f rd ma e a dij n tv rle t r d e ste
y ia Thea y pat n Ch i) o a g s n nu cie eif o e r s h
de e nt 'al ge vi a i ofNofi r sc tt tonalrg st duepr s a e l
f nda s le d ol ton
snge ' onsiu i
iht o
oce s nd qua

p oe t n.No sn e as a srsacam p rua tt t c u tss p e na j rs ito
r tci
o
fi g r lo se t li u s n o he o r' u plme tl u idcin
aga ns U .S.Phys c lThe a f br c ofc r c unde a t r pa t be t c ar t or l The
i t
ia
r py or ea h
ont a t
r hid- ry ne i i y he y.

matri c r l bef et c to t dee nt'28U. C.j1 a moto t ta frt s
te s urenty or he our n he fnda s
S. 404() in o rnse hi
ac i t t Eas e n Di t i tofV igi a, i hm ond D i s on. H a ng c i r d t
ton o he t r s rc
r ni R c
vi i
vi ons de e he
co ni nc oft pa tesa t i w ine s a ot rr l va f c or ,t c tfndst tt
nve e e he r i nd he r t s es nd he e e nt a t s he our i
ha he
Eas e n Di ti tofV igi a i t a opra e f u a w ilgr ntt de enda s m oton t
t r sr c
r ni s he ppr i t or m nd l a he f
nt ' i o
ta f r
r ns e .
lVCU i l t i t Easer DititofVigi a, a ea h i vi de e nta t pl ntf hes f
s ocaed n he t n src
r ni nd c ndi dual f nda nd he ai if rel
r i i t Ea tr Ditit U . Ph i lThe a i he dquatr d i Ho t Te a ha l tonsi
esde n he sen src . S. ysca
r py s a
re e n uson, xas nd s ocai n

Ch niy, c mo d Milt a a dCh ita s ug Vigna ( fl to Ag eme t7 l , C. No 9 1)
a tl Rih n , dohin, n rsin b r , rii. Afiain re n , 6 E. F. . - .
l
i
Thecour hasna ed t de e t a or ng t Nof i r' amende c pl nt N of i r sorgi l
t
m he f ndan s cc di o snge s
d om ai . s nge ' i na
c pl nti ude t oaddii VCU pr e s s butNof i rhasvolntrl dim is t m .Theamende
om ai ncl d w
tonal
ofs or,
snge
u a iy s s ed he
d
c pl nta s aba
om ai l o ndonst br ac ofcon r c c a m sa ns VCU .
wo e h
t a t l i gai t

,

-

Z, y
#c/
'

1
.

I 2006,N of i re oled i t D oc orofPhysca The a pr a a t Sc
n
s nge nr l n he
t
i l r py ogr m t he hoolof

Ali He t Pr e sonsa VCU i Rihm o Vigi a I t s
led a1h of s i
t
n c nd, r ni . n he ummerof2009,a t
fer
c pl i m or t n ei y c e t hotr ofco s w o k a V CU , of i rbega a r quied
om etng
e ha ght r di- ls
ur e r t
N s nge
n e r
of - m pusc i c c s a U . Phys c The a i Cl s i ns ur Vi gi a V CU pl ce
fca
lni al our e t S.
i al r py n ui ta b g, r ni .
a d

do or lca da esa U. Physc lThe a by vit ofan d fiiton ag e m e 'be we n
ct a ndi t t S.
ia
r py
rue
t fla i
a
r e nt' t e
VCU a U . Physc lThe a Nof i raleg t tt c s i tuc o ,Te r Fe rer
nd S.
ia
r py. snge l es ha he our e nsr t r ri ri ,
pr vi d i deq t i t u ton a t tNo snge decde t ha aco r a i wih Fe re
o de na uae nsr c i nd ha f i r i d o ve nve s ton t r ir
a tc s e
bou our e xpec a i . W hie t c r um s a esoft te ount ra e f rf om c e r i
t tons
l he ic t nc
ha nc
e r a r
la,t
alege y r s t i V CU di m i s ng N o s nge f om t phys ca -he a pr r m f a l k o
l dl e uled n
s si
f i r r he
i lt r py og a or ac f
ai ha fe s s i
snge , t low d r o ri i t n
pr es i ls . V CU cl m st ta t rdi m i sng N of i r i a l e he t pa tc pa e i a
of s ona i m 2
tde i r t m uliter d pr es t ta l
ç lbe a e, t-i e oc s ha lowed Pl i i ft op t t t pr e he a gum e s
a ntf he poruniy o es nt r r
nt

agans ...hedimis . ( s'Br Supp. otDimis15, C. No.31) Ac or ngt t
i t t s sal' Def. .
'
M . s s E. F.
. c di o he
def nda t , hi pr es t plc i t Ea t m Dititandt de son m a r i ved
e n s t s oc s ook a e n he se
src
he cii
ke s nvol
cure l r s de t r
r nty e i he e.
N o snge tl t sac i i t Ci c tCour f M o gom e y Co y,Vi gi a a
f i r i ed hi ton n he r ui
t or nt
r
unt
r ni , nd

defnda sr movedt aci t t sco ta move t ta frve purua t 28U. C.j
e nt e
he ton o hi ur nd
d o rnse nue s nt o
S.

1 a . N ofi rcli st t i dimisnghe,VCU vi ae he c tt i rght t
404()3 snge a m ha , n s si r
oltd r onsiutonal i s o
pr ed aldue pr s and e lpr t c i oft l w . She a s c a m st tU . Ph i a
oc ur
oce s
qua o e ton he a
l o l i ha S. ys c l

2VCU as tl Nofi e (ndid e VCU c niu soalg )ta a a e crao sfr dpat fh
lo od sng r a n e d
o tn e t le e h t c d mi e s n ome r o te
ba i f Nof i r' dim i s l
s s or snge s s s a .

3No sn e o ii al fld aj 1 3 a to i t eU. . src Co r f rt eEa tr Ditit fVig nao
fi g r rg n l i
y e
98 ci n n h S Ditit u t o h se n src o r i i n
Au ut 2 1 Afe e c u trn tu idito a is e'(eae t VCU' r fslowav s v rini nt
g s2, 01 . tr n o neig j rs cin lsu s rltd o
'
S eu a t ie o eeg mmu iy
a ad fn et No sng rsb e c o c n r c camsa an t h u i riy , f ig rvou trl d s s e h r
s ee s o f i e ' r a h f o ta t li g is t e nvest ) No sn e ln a i imis d e
y
lws i a dr fldt ec s i t eCic i Co r f rM o t o r Co ny Vign ao No e e l , l ( p.
a ut n e i h a e n h r ut u t o n g me y u t , r ii n v mb r 5 201 . Op
e
M o . a se 3 5 E. F. .1 .
t Tr n fr , , C. No 7 )

The a b e che isia flaton ag ee nt' t VCU a i la et Nof i ron at r
r py r a d t tfii i
r me 'wih
nd s i bl o
snge
hidpary be f c a' t or
t ne i i l he y.
y
lI
.

N of i r a guest tt c t houl notta f rt c s bec us he c ce off r m
snge r
ha he our s d
r ns e he a e a e r hoi
ou
i e tte t de er nc s w a lvi i t W eser D i ti tofV igi a w he t e nt gi ng
s n il d o f e e, he s i ng n he
t n s rc
r ni
n he ve s vi
r s t t sa ton oc r d,a Te r Fe r e a o he pot nta w ines e lve he e asw e l The
i e o hi c i
cur e nd r i r i r nd t r e i l t s s i
r,
l.
cot ' tnds how e r t tt Ri hm o D i s o oft Unie St t D i ti tCo tf rt
ut i ,
ve , ha he c nd vi i n he t d a es s r c ur o he
Eas e n Di ti tofV i g ni i a m or a opr a e, nve e f um a w ilta f rt c s
t r sr c
r i a, s
e ppr i t co ni nt or
nd l r ns e he a e
t
here.

S ci n 1 4() o ie ta tto tec n e in eo pate a dwi e ss i te
e to 40 a pr vd s h tûl r h o v ne c f ris n t se ,n h
l
n

itrs o j sie ad src c u t yta fra ycvla t nt a yohe dsrc o dv so
n eet f u tc , itit o r ma rnse n ii ci o n t r itit r iiin
o
whe e i m i have be n br
r t ght
e ough .
t'
'The Supr m e Cour ha he d t tt s m e f c o sr l va
e
t s l ha he a
a t r e e nt

t f m nonc
o onl
onveninsdee nai s das beus di e uai motonsunde j1
e tnui tons houl lo
e n val tng i
r 404,
na l ( )t pli ifsc c off u ( t rltveea eofa ce st s ur sofpr of (
mey: 1 he antf hoie or m;2) he eai s c s o o ce
o ;3)

tea albl yo c mpu s r p o e sf ratn a c o u wil win se ; 4 tec s o
h v ia it f o lo y r c s o te d n e f n lng t e s s ( ) h o t f
i
i
obt ni atnda ofwilngwine ss ( t pos i lt ofviwi prmies i a ia e
ai ng te nce
li t se ' 5) he sbiiy e ng e s ,f pplc bl'
,
,
( a1ot rprcialpr e t tma ti ofac eeay,e dii ,a i xpensve a
6) l he a tc oblms ha ke ral
as s xpe tous nd ne
i ' nd
,
( fco sofpublci ees,ncudi t rltvec esi ofc t ckesa ap eee e
7) a tr
i ntr ti l ng he eai ong ton our do t nd r frnc
f hol ng a t i li t c m uniy m os af e t d. Se Fos e v. yi J . nc , o. 06c 9,
or di
r a n he om
t
t fce
e t r Fl na . I . N 7: v45

2 0 W L 1 31 9 a * ( . Va J n ay 1 , 0 7 , e as Ter v W ak r 36 F. u p. d
07
9 6 , t 1 W D. . a u r 9 2 0 ) s e lo ry . le , 9 S p 2
.
81 8 ( . Va 2005)(ii Gul OiCo p. Gibet 33 U. 501 508 (947:.
8, 22 W D. .
ctng f 1 r v. l r, 0 S. , -09 1
W ih t e f t s i m i t cour tndst tt a f ri pr . Thoug N of i e '
t hos ac or n nd, he
ti
ha r ns e s oper
h
s ng r s
c c off um des ve de e enc a s e r l va e nt oc ur e i t W e t r Di t i tof
hoi e or
er s f r e nd om e e nt ve s c r d n he s e n sr c

Vigni anum be off ct spoi t t Ri hmond Di so oft Unied St t sDititCour
r i a,
r a or nt o he c
vii n he t
a e src
t
f t Easer Di t i tofV igi a a a m or a o i t ,c
or he t n s rc
r ni s
e ppr pr a e onve e f um t n t W e t r
ni nt or ha he s e n

Diti tofVigi a Fis,VCU i i Rihmond,a t i vi de e nt a Nofi e
src
r ni . rt
sn c
nd he ndi dual f nda s nd
sng r
r sdei t Rihm o a e i t Ea tr Ditit Sec
e i n he c nd r a n he se n src . ond, hede son t dimisNof i r
t
cii o s s
snge
a t he rngst tf l d a loc ured t r 4 Thid, i w a i Ri hm ond t tV CU a U .
nd he a i ha olowe 1 c r he e.
r t sn c
ha
nd S.
Phys c lThe a en e ed i o t C fla i n ag ee e ' t tf m s t ba i ofN of i r s
ia
r py t r nt he l ii t o r m nt' ha or he s s
af
s nge '
t r pa t be i i r c a m ,a t a r e e ts a e t ti i pe f m a e i He i o Cot y,
hid- ry nefc a y l i nd he g e m n t t s ha t s r or bl n nr c
mt

i t Easem DititofVigi a.( flai Agr me 9-1 E. F. 1. Andf t a
n he t
src
r ni Afiiton ee nt 0, C. 9- )
ourh, ny

ij n tv r le ac u t rn swo l h v i efc i Rih n Th c u th r f r tn sta
n u cie eif o r g a t ud a e t fe t n c mo d. e o r te eo e i d h t
s
t Ea t r D it i ofV igi a Ri hm ond Di s on,i t m os a opr a e f um .
he s e n s rct
r ni , c
vi i s he
t ppr i t or
1
11.

Thoug N of i rha c e t W e t r D it i ta he f m ,N of i rc plt d
h
snge s hos n he s e n s rc s r onz
snge om e e
ne ry a lofhe Phys ca t r py educ ton a V CU i Ri hm ond,t i vi ldef nd t a e
al l
r
i l he a
ai t
n c
he ndi dua
e an s z

e oy by VCU i Ri hm o Nof i rlve i t Rihm ond a e a t de ii n t
mpl ed
n c nd, snge i s n he c
r a, nd he c so o
dimishe a t he rngst tf l d a1oc ure t r Unde t cic sa e ,t
s s r nd he a i ha olowe l c r d he e.
r he r um t nc s he
Ri m o D i s o oft Ea t r D it i tofVi gi a i a m o e a oprat c
ch nd vii n he s e n s rc
r ni s
r ppr i e, onve e f r m
ni nt o u
t n t W eser D i ti tofVi gi a. A c r ngl t c tg a t t de e nt 'm o i t
ha he
t n sr c
r ni
co di y, he our r n s he f nda s ton o
t ans er
r f .

EN TER :Thi 28t day ofM a c 201
s h
r h, 2.
r7
C:
,- '
.-'
.

'A

A I STATES DI CT J
TED
STRI UDGE
4Durng or a g
i al r umenton t smoton, c elf U. Physc The a not t tN ofi rsï nonhi
i ouns or S.
ial r py ed ha
snge ' f
key
pa t w i es,' ese nD iti r i ntTe r Fe re , i cae herwilngne st ta lt t Easer D itit
ry m s'W tr srct esde
r i rir has ndi td
li s o r ve o he t n src
a nee d.
s de