Davidson v. Uzma et al

Filing 14

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 4/30/12. (tvt)

tke- : OF Q: u . 04 x Qe
FI
4%

A M N l iV
T vk ,A
)
L

I TH E UM TED ST ATE S D I
N
STR I CO U R T
CT
FOR TH E W ESTERN DI
STRI OF VI NI
CT
RGI A
R O AN O K E D I I O N
V SI

F
l
t
aUL

BY:

TR AV I LE ON D A VI SO N ,
S
D
Pl ntf ,
ai i f

g/ >
o,
Q

AFR 3p 2 1
22
. ) Ex
pt

DE - ct
E
C i lA c i N o.7: 2- vvi ton
1 c 00044
M EM O R AN D UM O PI I N
N O
By:

D R .A Ll U ZM A ,etaI,
.
D ef
endant
s.

H on.Jaclson L.K i
t
ser

se orUnied st esDititJudge
ni
t at src

Tr sLeon Davi on,a V igi a i a e pr
avi
ds
r ni nm t oceedi pr K ,fl a ci lr ght com pl nt pur ua t
ng o
ied vi i s
ai , s nt o

42 U. C.j 1 3,whiea t Roa
S.
98
l t he nokeCiy J l By isOr e e e e Fe ua y 7 201 t c r a s d
t ai. t d r ntr d br r , 2, he ou t dvie
pl ntf t ta f l et updat hi m aii addr s afera tansf orr eas fom i cer i w ilr ul i
ai if ha aiur o
e s lng
es t r er el e r ncar aton l es t n
dim i aloft sacton.
s ss
hi i
The courts m ai t pl ntf hasbeen r t ned asundelver e,and t envel hast not ton,
'
l o ai if
e ur
i abl
he
ope
he a i
tRet n t Sender.A tem pt - NotKnown. Unàbl t f war ' Pl ntf f l t com pl w ih t courts
i ur o
t ed
e o or d.' ai if aied o
y t he
'

Or r rng hi t m ai ai an accur e m aii addr ,and pl ntf hasnotcont ed t cour si
der equii
m o nt n
at
lng
ess
ai if
act he
t nce
flng a moton i M ar 2012. Ther or 1fnd t pl ntf f l t com pl w ih t Febr y 7,201
ii
i n
ch
ef e, i hat ai if aied o
y t he
uar
2,

Or ra f l t pr e t t sa ton, s ntt Fe r Rul ofCi lPr ed e4lb) Ac or ngl,I
de nd ais o os cu e hi c i purua o deal e
vi oc ur ( . c di y

dimist a tonwihoutprj c Se Balr v. rs 8 F. 93,96( hCi.1 )(ttn pr K
s s he ci t
eudie. e lad Calon, 82 2d
4t r 989 saig o
ltga t aes jc t tmerquie nt a rs c f c ur ore sa dimis li a a o it snci
ii ns r ube t o i e rme s nd epe t or o t d r nd s sa s n pprprae a ton
f no c inc .Seeas Do ly v. oh - a le Sae Cor ,677F.d 339,3 41( d Ci.1 2)
or n- ompl e)
a
lo nne l J nsM nvil ls n.
2
40- 3 r 98
(e og zi adititco t y s s edim isa a tonpurua t Fe R. v.P. lb).
r c ni ng src ur ma ua pont s s n ci
s nt o d. Ci 4 ( )
The Cl k i di ed t s copi oft sM em ora
er s rect o end
es hi
ndum Opi on and t accom pa ng Or t
ni
he
nyi
der o
pl ntf.
ai if
ENTER :Thi

day ofAprl 2012.
i,
%

Se i Unied St t D it itJ
or t
a es s rc udge