Springer v. Mathena et al

Filing 77

ORDER ADOPTING REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS 70 ; denying 42 Motion for Preliminary Injunction; Springer's Objections 73 are OVERRULED. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 10/10/12. (tvt)

eL ( c', :.;,? ti c cour ;
EAK: ., ., , ls'
t .
-

/ lï .. .
1 '.
:

.'
.

î ;. .
u.

0CT 1 1 Ll2
*1
i
I TH E U N I D STA TE S D I
N
TE
STR I T C O U R T
C
FO R TH E W ESTER N DISTR I T O F V I G I I
C
R N A
R O A N O K E D I ISI N
V O
LE VI G A R Y SPRIN G E R ,

J(u:h # - ,. r u x
At
J?
! . ,..s
' y ujx
BY'
.
DE JI u
-

C i lA ct on N o.7:
vi
i
12cv00074

Pl ntf ,
ai i f
O RD ER AD O PTI G RE PO R T
N
A N D R EC O M M EN DA TI N
O
RA N D A L M A TH EN A et al,
.
D ef
endant
s.

By:Sam ue G .W is
l
l on
Uni St esD i t ctJudge
ted at
s ri

LeviG a y Sprnger a V igi a i a e pr ee ngrrps ,brngs t s a ton pur ua tt
r
i , r ni nm t oc di
t e i hi c i
s n o

42U. C.j 1 cami t dee nt,s vealRe Oni Stt Prs empl s itreed
S.
983, li ng he fnda s e r d on ae ion
oyee ,nefr
wih Spr nge ' a ce st t c t ,i lc e crz la unus lpuni hm en on hi ,a
t
i r s c s o he our s nfi t d te nd
ua
s
t
m nd

diplye delbe ae i fe e et hi m e c lne ds Theco thasr e r t m at rt
s a d i r t ndif r nc o s di a e .
ur
ef red he te o
Unie Stt sM agita eJ e Pamel M e Sa ge tf aRe tand Re
td ae
sr t udg
a ade r n or
por
commendai n
to

purua tt 28U. C.j636( ( )B) TheMagitaeJ eha is dar por a l ng
s n o
S.
b)1( .
srt udg s sue e t nayzi
Sprnge ' rques f ij tver i a rco ndi t co tde Sprnge ' rque ton
i rs e t or nunci elef nd e mme ng he ur ny i rs e s

t g o ndt a S rng rh se tr l f i dt s cf t n tr o t ij cierle h i
he r u h t p i e a niey al o pe iy he au e f he nun tv eif e s
e
se n .S rng rh stldat r ep g o j cint t eRe r a dRe o nd to t t
e kig p i e a ie h e - a e b e to o h po t n c mme ain ha
r ier t hi pr vi a gum e sbutof e sno m or s c fc t t n a of Sprng ' ea le
e t a es s e ous r
nt
fr
e pe i i iy ha ny
i er s ri r

tln s Th c u t a r v e dterc r d n v i lg t fS ig rso j cin a da o t
ii g . e o r h s e iwe h e o d e o o n ih o prn e ' b e to s n d p s
t M a sr t J
he gitae udge' Re t Re
s por and commendai n.Ac or ngl i i her by ORDERED a
to
c di y, t s e
nd

ADJUDGED t tSprnge ' obe ins( No.73)aeOVERRULED,heM a srt
ha i rs jcto ECF
r
t
gitae
J ' Re r a Re ommendai ( No. )i ADOPTED,a Sprnge ' rque tf
udges po t nd c
ton ECF 70 s
nd i rs e s or

ijmci rle i DENI
nt tve eif s
ED.

The Clr i DI
e k s RECTED t s nd ac oft sor rt t pl ntf.
o e
opy hi de o he ai if
EN TER :O c ober 1 201
t
0, 2.

UN I
TED STA TES D I
STRI JUD G E
CT

2