Howard v. Statzer et al

Filing 172

ORDER ADOPTING REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS ; granting in part and denying in part 60 Motion for Summary Judgment; granting 91 Motion for Summary Judgment; denying 104 Motion to Compel; denying 106 Prisoner Miscellaneous Motion; adopting Rep ort and Recommendations re 160 Report and Recommendations. Due to Defendant Head's death, Plaintiff is directed to motion within 20 days from entry of this order to substitute an appropriate individual by name as a defendant in Head's p lace or the claim against Head will be dismissed; or in the atlernative, plaintiff may move for voluntary dismissal of his claim regarding Head. All claims against Defendant Payne are dismissed as frivolous. All remaining claims against remaining defendants shall be scheduled for trial in the Big Stone Gap Courthouse. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 09/20/2013. (kab)

rLERK:OFFI U.S. ST COURT
CE
Dt .
ATRQANQKE,VA
F1. 3
81
q

sE? 2g 2 1
23
I TH E UN I
N
TED STA TES DI
STR I C O U R T
CT
FO R TH E W ESTER N D I
STRI O F V I G I I
CT
R N A
ROANOKE DI I ON
V SI
R O BER T PH A R O A H H O W AR D ,

J
ULi DtDLE
BY; A C. J Y,CLERK

kb

DEPUTY CLERK

CA SE N O .7: 2CV 0007
1
9

Pl ntf ,
ai if
O R DE R
V.

( o i Re r a Re o nda in
Ad ptng po t nd c mme to )

J STATZER, K ,
.
c

By:GlnE. nr d
e Co a
C hi fU ni e St t s Di t i tJudge
e
t d a e sr c

D ef
endant .
s

l a or nce w ih t a om pa i m em or ndtm o ni i i he e
n cc da
t he cc
ny ng
a l pi on, t s r by
A D JU DG ED A N D O R D ERE D
a f l w s:
s olo

Afe t c ts X novo rviw of t pe tne pori of t rcor pli ifs
tr he our'
ee
he ri nt tons he e d, antf
o jcinst t ema itaej dg ' rp r a d rc mme ai na eOVERRULED, n
be t o h g srt u e s e o t n e o nd to r
o
ad
terpo t n r c mme d to ( No 1 0 i ADOPTED i ise trt .
h e r a d e o n ain ECF . 6 ) s
n t n iey 1
2.

3.

Plitf smo in s e igsl r u g n ( No .1 4& 1 6 aeDENI
an if to s e kn l
mmayj d me t ECF s 0
0)r
ED.
De e d n Mah nasmo in f rs mma yj d me t( No 91 i GRANTED,a d
fn a t t e ' to o u r u g n ECF . ) s
n
t clr wiltr naeM a he asapa t t t sa ton.
he e k l e mi t
t na
ry o hi c i

4
.

Th mo in f rs mmay j g n fld b t e s c rt d fnd ns ( No 6 )i
e to o u r ud me t ie y h e u i ee a t ECF . 0 s
y
G R AN TED I PA R T AN D DEN I I PAR T , f l s
N
ED N
as olow :

a
.

Them o i n i GRANTED a t a lc am sag ns De e ntTa e a t
to s
s o l li
ai t f nda
t , nd he
c er w ilt r i t Def nda sTa e a a pa t t t sac i a
l k l e m na e
e nt t s
ry o hi ton; nd

b.

Th mo in i DENI a t p an ifs Cli ( ) algn u e o
e to s
ED s o litf' am 3 , le ig s f
e es i f c on N ovem be 7,2011 by D e e
xc s ve or e
r
f ndan s M e s r W hi e mt
t
se ,
s nht ,
a Fi l .
nd eds

lThema itae ud eas is darp r a drc mme d to o S pe e 11201 ,e adig
gsrtj g lo sue e o t n e o n ain n e tmb r , 3 rg r n
plitœ smoin frp ei n r ij n tv rl ttldAu u t1 a d2 , 01 , n d fn a t r s nssteeo.
ani
to s o rlmiay nu cie ei lie g s 3 n 3 2 3 a d ee d n s epo e h rt
e
Th c u t lis easp rt o no a do d ra d esn teS ptmbe 1 rp r a a yo jcins
e o r wi su e aae piin n r e d rsig h e e r l e o t nd n be to .
l

5.

Bec us t r c d now i caest tDef ntHe hasdi d a t wa vi s r ce of
a e he e or
ndi t ha
enda
ad
e fer i ng e vi

pr s ,i pli ifwihe t puruehi j1 cam f mo t y dnma ba e on
oce s f antf s s o s s 983 li or near
ges s d
Dee a tHe d' alg da to s p ru n t Fe R. v P. 5 a , ei DI
fnd n a s le e ci n , u s a t o d. Ci. 2 () h s RECTED t
o
m a a m o i wihi 20 da fom e r of t s or r t s tt t a a opra e
ke
ton t n
ys r
nty
hi de o ubsiu e n ppr it
i vi lby nn e a adef nda i He splce ort cli r r ng Hea salege
ndi dua
m s
e nt n ad' a , he a m ega di
d' l d

a to s wilb d s se wih p eu ie I te atm ai ,Ho r ma mo e fr
ci n l e imis d t rj dc . n h le t
ve wad y v o
vo t ay d s is lofhi cli r ga dng He d.
lmtz im s a
s am e r i
a
6.

Pts a toterp ra drc mme d to a a o tdb tec u ta1camsa anta y
l u n t h e ot n e o n ain s d ye y h o r, 1 li g is n
r
def ntnnmed Pay i c
enda
ne n onne ton wih t i l nto Nove be 7,2011, e
ci
t he nc de n
m r
ar

sl rl DI M I ED t e 2 U. C. 1 5 e( )a fi lu .
l
mmai S SS md r 8 S. j 91 A()2 s rvoo s
y
7.

Ast t cai sr mai ng a i tDe e nt M e s r W hie
o he l m e ni gans f nda s s e , s nhunt a Fi ds t sca e
, nd el , hi s

SHAIL BE SCHEDULED f r ra b f r as v n me e j r i t Uni dS ae
,
o til eo e e e - mb r u y n he t tts
e
Courhous i Bi St Ga V i g ni a t c tse r i tconve e .
t e n g one p, r i a, t he our ' a les
ni nce
EN TER : Tu s

t' d yo e tmb r 2013.
a rs p e e ,

ChifUnied St t sDititJ
e
t
a e src udge

2