Howard v. Statzer et al
Filing
19
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 06/12/2012. (kab)
r FRK' OFFI U. DI CoUr
;
:
CE S. SX
AT ROANOKE,
VA
f lit?
' '.
.
'
I TH E U NI
N
TED STA TES DI
STR I T C O U R T
C
FO R TH E W ESTERN DI
STR I O F VI G I I
CT
R N A
ROANOKE DI SI
VI ON
R O B ER T PH A RO AH H O W A R D ,
J
UN 2 2 1
92
JULI
A
BY:
D
k ?ërCL
. '
ERK
U
CLERK
CA SE N O .7: 2C V00079
1
Pl ntif
ai f ,
M EM O R AN D UM O PI I N
N O
V S.
J.STATZER,c AL.
,
By:Gln E.Conr
e
ad
C hi fU nied St e D i t i tJudge
e
t
at s s r c
Dee
fndants.
t)
Pr K pl n if Robe t r h Howa d, ie t scvi rg sa ton ptr ua t 42
o
aitf,
r Pha oa
r fld hi i l i ht c i ls nt o
U. C.j 1 algi t tofiil a Re Oni Stt Prs vi aedhi c tt i lrght
S.
983, le ng ha fcas t d on ae ion olt s onsiutona i s
by de ng hi e ge m e c te ment usng e s i f cea ns hi a i ere i
nyi m mer ncy dial r at
, i xce sve or gai t m, nd nt f rng
wih hi a lt t pr c i hi r i ousdi a ybele s De e nt havewave s r i e,
t s biiy o a tce s elgi
etr
i f . f nda s
i d e v c but
ha notyetr pondedt t c
ve
es
o he ompli t Howa d i no confne a W al nsRi St t Prs n
an .
r s w
i d t le
dge ae i o
a dh smo df re ty o atmp rr r srii go d ro p r n n ijmcin dr cig
n a ve o nr f e o ay etan n r e r ema e t n t to , ie tn
prs ofk i l nott t a f hi ba k t R e Oni Upon r vi w oft r or t c t
i on t a s
o r ns er m c o d
on.
e e
he ec d, he our
d n e Ho r ' mo inf ritro uo yijmcier l f
e is wa d s to o nel c tr nt tv ei .
e
Howa d f a st ti hewe eta f redba k t Red Oni ofk i st r wo d brng
r e r ha f
r r nse r
c o
on, f al he e ul i
f l e di c plnar cha ges a i tHow a d t r t i e aga ns hi f f lng t s l s ta a
as s i i y r
ga ns
r o e alat
i t m or ii hi aw ui nd
pr vi lws t Ass
e ous a ui.
uppo tf t sas e ton ofpot ta r t la i Howa d r f st hi
r or hi s ri
en i l e a iton,
r e er o s
unde l ngcl m i t sa to t tRe Oni ofk il f l iid r c dsr a e t hi r lgi
ryi ai n hi c i n ha d on t a s a sfe e or elt d o s ei ous
dit c usng hi t ber m ove fom t di t
e, a i m o
e
d r hat e .
Asapr i nay ij tontmporrl a fr a e r di r r medyprort tilt
elmi r nunci e a iy fods n xtaor nay e
i o ra,he
pat s e i gt ep ei n r ijmcin mu t e n taet a: 1 t i lk l t s c e o
ry e k n h r lmi ay nt to s d mo srt h t ( ) t s iey o uc e d n
he
t meis'( G i lkeyt s frirpa a eha m i t a e eofpr lmi rle , ()
he rt, 2) t s i l o ufe re r bl r n he bsnc
' he
ei nmy eif' 3
'
ûhebaa c o e ute tp i h sfv r'a d( )ç n ij ncin i i t p bi itr s. Se
t ln e f q iis is n i a o , n 4 l nu to s n he u lc n ee t' e
t
'
a
'
W i trv. tla Re olc sDee eCo n i.nc, 5 U. 7 1 S. . 6 , 7 ( 0 ) A
ne Nat l s t e fns u cl I .5 5 S. , 29 Ct 3 5 3 4 2 08 .
r
r
s i ofa ts r ng pos i lt ' hn i i uf i i nt be aus t s a r r r a s
how ng
tt o
s biiy' of nn s ns f c e , c e he t nda d equies howi
ng
t thar i çlkel ' l Ea h oft ef f t smus be s tsi be or i eroc or
ha m s ti y.' d. c
hes our acor
t a ifed f e nt l ut y
tt
ijmci rle i war ne l RealTrzh A boutO bam a. I c v.
nt tve eif s ra td.
n . FEC, 7 F.d3 , 4 ( t
5 5 3 42 3 7 4h
Ci.2009) va t bv.rma d bv-c r.aantd,1 S.Ct 2371( 0) rafime i pa t
r
, caed e nde
e t r e 30
.
201 , e fr d n r.
rma dbv, F. 355( hCi. 0)
e nde
607 3d
4t r 201 .
H ow a d' m oton f is on t fr ta s c f t st de W i e . Fis , ow a d
r s i al
he i s nd e ond ac or m r nt r r t H
r
cn
nnotde ons r t a lkelhood ofs e s o t m e isofhi t a f rcl i . l a eshave
m
ta e ny i i
ucc s n he rt
s r ns e a m nm t
nopr t c e lbe t i er s i bengc i d i a pa iul rt ofprs e n whe
o e t d i ry nt e t n i onfne n ny rtc a ype
ion, ve
n
c tons i one pr s n a e m o e r ti tve orha s t n c tons i o he pr s . M e hum
ondii n
io r
r esr c i
r h ha ondii n t r i ons
ac
v.Fano,427U. 215, ( 976) Olm v.W a ne ,461U. 238,247- (983 .Be us
S. 224 1 ; i
ki kona
S.
48 1 ) ca e
How a d ha no c tt i lr g nott be t a f r d bac t Red Oni he ca
r s
ons iutona i ht
o r ns er e
ko
on,
nnots
how
lke i
i lhood ofs c son a t ryi c ai r r ng t a f r Se ond,How a d f ist
uc es
n mde l ng l m ega di r ns e . c
r al o
de onsr t t twihouti e l ut y r lef he i lkey t s f rir pa a eha m . Howa d
m ta e ha t
nt roc or e i , s i l o ufe re r bl r
r
sa esno f c s s es i t the i lke y t be ta f r e t Red Oni i t ne r f lr
tt
a t ugg tng ha
si l o
r ns e r d o
on n he a utze.
M o e v r Ho r sa srin ta h wo l b s b e t ortlai nb Re On o o t il i
ro e , wad' se t s h t e ud e u j c t eaito y d in f as s
o
k
m e e s cul ton. Thus H ow a d f l t dem ons r t t the i lke y t s f ri r pa a e ha m
r pe a i
,
r ais o
t a e ha
s i l o uf e r e r bl r
i t a e e oft r que t r le .Fort sa e r s ns t c tc udest tHowa d'
n he bs nc
he e sed ei f
he tt d ea o , he our oncl
ha
r s
motonf i el ut yij tver i t prve hi ta frmus bede ed.An a oprae
i or ntroc or n unci elef o e nt s rnse
t
ni
ppr it
or rw ili s t sday.
de l s ue hi
1 Tempor y r t i i g or sar i s onl r el , when t movantpr
ar esran n der e s ued y ar y
he
ovest the wils f
ha
l ufer
ij r i r ifi n tg a tdbe o et ea ves pa t c l b n iida d h v op ru t t r s nd.
n u y f ele s o r ne f r h d r e ry oud e otfe n a e po tni o e po
y
S eF d R. v P. 5 S c a od r udo l ls u t s c t a ah aigo ap ei n y
e e . Ci. 6 . u h n re wo l ny at ni u h i s e rn n rl a
l
me
mi
ij ncin c ul b ar ng d.Asi i ce rfo t o te t tHo r i no e ildt apr lml r
n u to o d e ra e
t s la r m he u st ha wa d s t ntte o ei nay
ij ncin, h c u t idsn b ssu nwhiht g a hm atmp ayr sr i n or e .
n u to t e o r fn o a i po
c o rnt i e orr e tanig d r
2
TheClr i die t d t s ndcopi oft sm e andum opi on a a compa ng
ek s r ce o e
es hi mor
ni nd c
nyi
or rt pl i if
de o a ntf .
ENTER: Thi IR& da ofJ
s t
y une, 2.
201
Chi fU nie St t s D it i tJ
e
t d a e s rc udge
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?