Howard v. Statzer et al

Filing 19

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 06/12/2012. (kab)

r FRK' OFFI U. DI CoUr
;
:
CE S. SX
AT ROANOKE,
VA
f lit?
' '.
.
'

I TH E U NI
N
TED STA TES DI
STR I T C O U R T
C
FO R TH E W ESTERN DI
STR I O F VI G I I
CT
R N A
ROANOKE DI SI
VI ON
R O B ER T PH A RO AH H O W A R D ,

J
UN 2 2 1
92
JULI
A
BY:
D

k ?ërCL
. '
ERK
U

CLERK

CA SE N O .7: 2C V00079
1

Pl ntif
ai f ,

M EM O R AN D UM O PI I N
N O
V S.

J.STATZER,c AL.
,

By:Gln E.Conr
e
ad
C hi fU nied St e D i t i tJudge
e
t
at s s r c

Dee
fndants.
t)
Pr K pl n if Robe t r h Howa d, ie t scvi rg sa ton ptr ua t 42
o
aitf,
r Pha oa
r fld hi i l i ht c i ls nt o

U. C.j 1 algi t tofiil a Re Oni Stt Prs vi aedhi c tt i lrght
S.
983, le ng ha fcas t d on ae ion olt s onsiutona i s
by de ng hi e ge m e c te ment usng e s i f cea ns hi a i ere i
nyi m mer ncy dial r at
, i xce sve or gai t m, nd nt f rng
wih hi a lt t pr c i hi r i ousdi a ybele s De e nt havewave s r i e,
t s biiy o a tce s elgi
etr
i f . f nda s
i d e v c but
ha notyetr pondedt t c
ve
es
o he ompli t Howa d i no confne a W al nsRi St t Prs n
an .
r s w
i d t le
dge ae i o

a dh smo df re ty o atmp rr r srii go d ro p r n n ijmcin dr cig
n a ve o nr f e o ay etan n r e r ema e t n t to , ie tn
prs ofk i l nott t a f hi ba k t R e Oni Upon r vi w oft r or t c t
i on t a s
o r ns er m c o d
on.
e e
he ec d, he our

d n e Ho r ' mo inf ritro uo yijmcier l f
e is wa d s to o nel c tr nt tv ei .
e
Howa d f a st ti hewe eta f redba k t Red Oni ofk i st r wo d brng
r e r ha f
r r nse r
c o
on, f al he e ul i
f l e di c plnar cha ges a i tHow a d t r t i e aga ns hi f f lng t s l s ta a
as s i i y r
ga ns
r o e alat
i t m or ii hi aw ui nd

pr vi lws t Ass
e ous a ui.
uppo tf t sas e ton ofpot ta r t la i Howa d r f st hi
r or hi s ri
en i l e a iton,
r e er o s
unde l ngcl m i t sa to t tRe Oni ofk il f l iid r c dsr a e t hi r lgi
ryi ai n hi c i n ha d on t a s a sfe e or elt d o s ei ous
dit c usng hi t ber m ove fom t di t
e, a i m o
e
d r hat e .

Asapr i nay ij tontmporrl a fr a e r di r r medyprort tilt
elmi r nunci e a iy fods n xtaor nay e
i o ra,he

pat s e i gt ep ei n r ijmcin mu t e n taet a: 1 t i lk l t s c e o
ry e k n h r lmi ay nt to s d mo srt h t ( ) t s iey o uc e d n
he
t meis'( G i lkeyt s frirpa a eha m i t a e eofpr lmi rle , ()
he rt, 2) t s i l o ufe re r bl r n he bsnc
' he
ei nmy eif' 3
'

ûhebaa c o e ute tp i h sfv r'a d( )ç n ij ncin i i t p bi itr s. Se
t ln e f q iis is n i a o , n 4 l nu to s n he u lc n ee t' e
t
'
a
'
W i trv. tla Re olc sDee eCo n i.nc, 5 U. 7 1 S. . 6 , 7 ( 0 ) A
ne Nat l s t e fns u cl I .5 5 S. , 29 Ct 3 5 3 4 2 08 .
r
r
s i ofa ts r ng pos i lt ' hn i i uf i i nt be aus t s a r r r a s
how ng
tt o
s biiy' of nn s ns f c e , c e he t nda d equies howi
ng

t thar i çlkel ' l Ea h oft ef f t smus be s tsi be or i eroc or
ha m s ti y.' d. c
hes our acor
t a ifed f e nt l ut y
tt
ijmci rle i war ne l RealTrzh A boutO bam a. I c v.
nt tve eif s ra td.
n . FEC, 7 F.d3 , 4 ( t
5 5 3 42 3 7 4h

Ci.2009) va t bv.rma d bv-c r.aantd,1 S.Ct 2371( 0) rafime i pa t
r
, caed e nde
e t r e 30
.
201 , e fr d n r.
rma dbv, F. 355( hCi. 0)
e nde
607 3d
4t r 201 .
H ow a d' m oton f is on t fr ta s c f t st de W i e . Fis , ow a d
r s i al
he i s nd e ond ac or m r nt r r t H
r
cn
nnotde ons r t a lkelhood ofs e s o t m e isofhi t a f rcl i . l a eshave
m
ta e ny i i
ucc s n he rt
s r ns e a m nm t

nopr t c e lbe t i er s i bengc i d i a pa iul rt ofprs e n whe
o e t d i ry nt e t n i onfne n ny rtc a ype
ion, ve
n
c tons i one pr s n a e m o e r ti tve orha s t n c tons i o he pr s . M e hum
ondii n
io r
r esr c i
r h ha ondii n t r i ons
ac

v.Fano,427U. 215, ( 976) Olm v.W a ne ,461U. 238,247- (983 .Be us
S. 224 1 ; i
ki kona
S.
48 1 ) ca e
How a d ha no c tt i lr g nott be t a f r d bac t Red Oni he ca
r s
ons iutona i ht
o r ns er e
ko
on,
nnots
how
lke i
i lhood ofs c son a t ryi c ai r r ng t a f r Se ond,How a d f ist
uc es
n mde l ng l m ega di r ns e . c
r al o

de onsr t t twihouti e l ut y r lef he i lkey t s f rir pa a eha m . Howa d
m ta e ha t
nt roc or e i , s i l o ufe re r bl r
r
sa esno f c s s es i t the i lke y t be ta f r e t Red Oni i t ne r f lr
tt
a t ugg tng ha
si l o
r ns e r d o
on n he a utze.

M o e v r Ho r sa srin ta h wo l b s b e t ortlai nb Re On o o t il i
ro e , wad' se t s h t e ud e u j c t eaito y d in f as s
o
k
m e e s cul ton. Thus H ow a d f l t dem ons r t t the i lke y t s f ri r pa a e ha m
r pe a i
,
r ais o
t a e ha
s i l o uf e r e r bl r

i t a e e oft r que t r le .Fort sa e r s ns t c tc udest tHowa d'
n he bs nc
he e sed ei f
he tt d ea o , he our oncl
ha
r s

motonf i el ut yij tver i t prve hi ta frmus bede ed.An a oprae
i or ntroc or n unci elef o e nt s rnse
t
ni
ppr it
or rw ili s t sday.
de l s ue hi
1 Tempor y r t i i g or sar i s onl r el , when t movantpr
ar esran n der e s ued y ar y
he
ovest the wils f
ha
l ufer

ij r i r ifi n tg a tdbe o et ea ves pa t c l b n iida d h v op ru t t r s nd.
n u y f ele s o r ne f r h d r e ry oud e otfe n a e po tni o e po
y

S eF d R. v P. 5 S c a od r udo l ls u t s c t a ah aigo ap ei n y
e e . Ci. 6 . u h n re wo l ny at ni u h i s e rn n rl a
l
me
mi

ij ncin c ul b ar ng d.Asi i ce rfo t o te t tHo r i no e ildt apr lml r
n u to o d e ra e
t s la r m he u st ha wa d s t ntte o ei nay
ij ncin, h c u t idsn b ssu nwhiht g a hm atmp ayr sr i n or e .
n u to t e o r fn o a i po
c o rnt i e orr e tanig d r
2

TheClr i die t d t s ndcopi oft sm e andum opi on a a compa ng
ek s r ce o e
es hi mor
ni nd c
nyi
or rt pl i if
de o a ntf .

ENTER: Thi IR& da ofJ
s t
y une, 2.
201
Chi fU nie St t s D it i tJ
e
t d a e s rc udge