Howard v. Statzer et al

Filing 80

ORDER granting 40 Motion for Discovery; granting 42 Motion to Compel; denying 50 Motion for Protective Order; granting 52 Motion to Produce; dismissing as moot 58 Prisoner Miscellaneous Motion; granted in part and taking under advisement in part 60 Motion for Summary Judgment; denying 67 Motion for Protective Order; granting 68 Motion to Dismiss; granting 72 Motion for Discovery; denying 74 Prisoner Miscellaneous Motion; denying 75 Motion for Protective Order; granting 24 Motion for Summary Judgment; denying 31 Motion for Summary Judgment. Plaintiff is directed to submit his final response to defendants' motions for summary judgment on or before January 14, 2013. Defendants are directed to certify to the cou rt, in camera,that they have shown discovery materials to plaintiff within twenty (20) days from entry of this order. Defendants are to respond in some fashion to the interrogatories in DE 42 as stated in this order within twenty (20) days from entry of this order. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 12/13/2012. (kab)

edKRKY OFFI U,. SX COUU '
CE S D4
ATRQANOKE!
VA
) kjk
> yq

I TH E UN I
N
TED STA TES DI
STR I T CO U R T
C
FO R TH E W ESTER N DI
STRI O F W R G I I
CT
N A
R O A N O K E D I ISI N
V O

ROBERT PHAROAH H OW ARD,

BEC 1i 2 1
92
a u c. - ,LR
ui . , C E K
m 1
nv;

DeP

LERK

CASE NO.7: 2CV00079
1

Pl ntff
ai i ,
O R D ER
V S.

J. TATZER, & ,
S
c

By: Gln E. nr d
e Co a
Chi U nied St es Di tri Judge
ef t
at
s ct

D e e nt .
f nda s
I a c da e w ih t ac m pa ng m e or nd opi on,i i he e
n c or nc t he co nyi
m a um
ni t s r by
A DJUD G ED AN D O R DER ED

a f l '
s olows
.

Plitf smoi nf rd fut u g n a an tDee d n S az r( No. 4 i
an if to o ea lj d me t g is fn a t tte ECF 7 ) s
D EN IED ;
2.

Plitf moint d s s ( No 6 ) whc tec u t o sr e a amo inf r
an ifs to o imis ECF . 8 , ih h o r c n tu s s to o
vol a ydim is lofCl m 1, sGRANTED;Cli 1i DISM I
untr s s a
ai i
am s
SSED W I OUT
TH
PREJUD I ; he cl r s l t r i t D e e nt Loone a M uli aspa test t
CE t
e k ha l e m na e f nda s
y nd
lns
r i o he

a to a dplitf' mo inf rd futr ltdt Cli 1( No. )i DI M I SED
cin; n anifs to o ea l eae o am ECF 58 s S S
asm oot
;

3.

Totee tn ta pani c mpan s e sijmci erle o d rn ta h b
h xe t h t litt o lit e k nt tv eif r e ig h t e e
rs
t a f r e t co pl nti D I I
r ns e r d, he m ai s SM SSED asm oo , s d on pl ntf st a f rt
t ba e
ai i f r ns e o
a t rf c lt afe t c
no he a iiy tr he ompli twa fl
a n s ied;

4.

Dee a t Php s mo inf rs mmayj g n ( No. 4 i GRANTED o t e
fnd n V. ip ' to o u r ud me t ECF 2 ) s
nh
g ound ofquaii d i l t a t c e k wilt r naeV . ppsasapa t t t s
r
lfe mmlniy, nd he l r l e mi t Phi
ry o hi
a ton;
ci

Th moinf rsl r j d me t ie b tes c rt d fn ns( No 6 )i
e to o l
mmay u g n fld y h e u iy ee da t ECF . 0 s
G R AN TED I PA R T A N D TA K EN U ND ER AD V I
N
SEM EN T I PAR T , f l s
N
as olow :

a
.

De e a t' to f rs mmayj d me t( No 6 )i GRANTED
fnd n s mo in o u r u g n ECF . 0 s
o t gr mdofquaii i
n he ot
lfed mmuniyast pli ifsCl m ( agans
t o antf' ai 2) i t
De e nt Stt er M cGowa a La
f nda s az ,
n, nd mber r r ng pl i ifs
q ega di
antf '
em e
rgency gr evance on O ct
i
ober21,2011,and t cl k w ilt i e
he er l erm nat
Def nda sStt er M cGowa a La
e nt a z ,
n, nd mber aspa test t sa ton;a
t
ri o hi c i nd

b.

Th moinf rsl r u g n i TAKEN UNDER ADVI ENT
e to o l
mmayj d me t s
SEM
a t pl ntf sCli () algi us ofe e svef ceonNo mbe 7,
s o ai if am 3 , le ng e xc si or
ve r
2011 pe ngco plton o dico y;
, ndi
m e i f s ver

6.

Plitf moi nf rsl r j g n ( No. )i DENI
an ifs to o l
mmay ud me t ECF 31 s
ED;
Defnda s moi f pr eci or r( Nos 50,67,& 75)aeDENI a
e nt' tons or ot tve de ECF .
r
ED; nd

8.

Pli ifsdic r moi ( No. 42,5 & 72)aeGRANTED t t e e
antf s ovey tons ECF 40, 2,
r
o he xtnt
t tde e nt a eDI
ha f nda s r RECTED :

()
a

Toc riyt t ec u t ti t ny( 0 d ysfo e tyo t sod r h t
e t o h o r wi n we t 2 ) a r m n r f hi r e t a
f
h
pli ifhasbee pr dedopporuniy t viw a la l e s ve lanc
antf
n ovi
t t o e 1 vaiabl ur il e
c m e af a c or rf t ,a silphot a r a e t t
n r oot ge, nmc de oo age nd tl
ogr phs elt d o he
Nove be 7,2011 i i nta i s i Cli 3,a t tcopi ofal s h
m r
, ncde t s ue n am
nd ha
es
l uc

ie ha bee s te t t c tt c mea;a
tms ve n ubmitd o he our,q a r nd

()
b

9.

Tors o di s mefs i nwi i t ny( 0 d y fo e tyo ti
e p n n o a h o t n we t 2 ) a s r m nr f h s
h

o dert t i e r t re i ECF N o. 42 o y a f l w s 1 De e nt
r o he ntr oga o i s n
nl s olo : f nda
Tae,I t rog. .1 4,5,7,8,9;De e ntL. Phi ,I e r Nos
t n e r Nos ,
f nda
B. pps ntr og. .
1 5;Def nda Fi l ,I erog. 2' f nda W hie mt no and
e nt eds nt r No. , e nt s nht , ne;
De
Defnda He none; nd
e nt ad,
a

Pl ntf i DI
ai if s RECTED t s i hi fnalr pons t def nt 'm o i f s
o ubm t s i es e o enda s tons or ummar
y

j d me to o beo eJ n a y 1 , 3
u g n n r f r a u r 4 201 .
EN TER : Thi l <
s 3
.

d y o De e r 2 2
a f c mbe, 01 .

ChifUnied St t Diti tJ
e
t
aes src udge

The courtconsruespl ntf squesi f t def ndant i ECF No.42 asi e r oresas
t
ai if
tons or he e
sn
nt r ogat i
aut ied underRul 33 oft Feder Rul ofCi lPr
horz
e
he
al es
vi ocedur The c tw ilnotr r def nda s
e.
our l
equie e nt
t r pond t i erogat i t a e a gum ent i orot wie notpr l f amed underRul 33,t
o es
o nt r ores hat r r
atve
her s
opery r
e
hat
r at t cl m sno l
el e o ai
ongerbef e t cour,ort tar notr onabl cal a ed t l t r evant
or he
t ha e
eas
y cult o ead o el
evi
dence.

2