Mustard v. New River Valley Regional Jail
Filing
4
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 03/29/2012. (rkc)
CLERK' OFFI U . , ST COURT
S
CE s DI .
AT ROANOKE,
VA
FIED
L
MA2 29 2 1
22
I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI CO URT
CT
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI O F VI NI
CT
RGI A
R O AN O K E D I ISION
V
JULI C.
A DUDL CLERK
R
BY:' U )
c
6
.<
GARY D.M USTARD
Pl ntf ,
ai if
C i lA cton N o.7: 2C V001
vi
i
1
46
V.
M EM ORANDUM OPI ON
NI
NEW R I ER V A LLEY RE GIO NA L JAIL
V
By:Sam uelG .W is
l on
U nied St esD i t ctJudge
t
at
s ri
D ef
endant
.
Thi i a a i pu s t 42U. C.j1 b pl ntf,Gar De nM usad,whoi
s s n cton ruanto
S.
983 y ai if y a
tr
s
p o e d n i o mapau rs a ans teNe Ri e ValyRe in lJ i(C
r c e i g nf r
pe i, g i t h w v r l
e go a al '
NRVRJ'algn
' le ig
)
t rel t ta trbei a r se on Fe ua y 3,2011 by a Pul s Count Vigi aofi era
e s y ha fe ng r e t d
br r
,
a ki
y, r ni tc nd
ta p re t NRVRJ a o fc ra t e al wh Musadd e n t a )t ru e 'Musad Th
rns o td o
, n fie t h j i( o tr o s o n me Co tr d' tr . e
t
Co tfndst tM usa d' c pli tf ist sa eac am a i tNRVRJand dimis shi
ur i ha
t r s om a n al o tt l i gans
s se s
c mp an p ru n t 2 U. C. 1 5 e( )B)i .
o lit u s a t o 8 S. j 91 ()2 ( (i
)
1
.
Pu s a t o28U. C. 1 5 e( ( (i, c u t h l û ta ytme' imisa i o ma
ru n t
S. j 91 ()2)B)i) a o r s alt n i 'ds s n nf r
a
pa pe i c mp an i i ûal t saeacam u nwhc rle ma b g a td. dA1u emus
u rs o lit ft' is o tt li po ih eif y e rn e ' t j dg
f
' (
t
a c pta tuea 1oft f c ua al gai nsco ane i t c
c e s r 1 he a t l le to
nt i d n he ompli .' i ks v.Pa dus 551
ant'Erc on
r ,
U. 8 9 1 S. . 97,1 L. 2d 1 ( )(iai omitd) Theco t onsnlsrr
S. 9, 4, 27 Ct21 67 Ed. 081 2007 cttons te .
ur c t e o
s co ant lbe al i
e mpli s i r ly, mposng dls srng ntsa r t n f malpl a ngsdr fed by
i çe s ti e t nda ds ha or
e di
at
lwy r . Se i (ntr lquottonmaksa ciai o te . Eve siltac antmus
a e s' e d. i ena
'
ai
r nd tton mitd)
n tl,t ompli
t
c a n s tc e f c ua m a t r a ce e astue, o l t t a cl i ofr le t ti pl us bl on is
ont i ufi i nt a t l te , c pt d r t s a e a m
e i f ha s a i e t
fce'' hcof v.q l556U. 662,1 S. .1 1 173L. 2d8 (
a .'As r t Iba,
S.
29 Ct 937, 949,
Ed. 68 2009( i Bel
quotng l
.
At. r . . mbv 5 U.. 4 , 7 ,1 S. .1 5 ,1 7L. .d9 9( 0 7 ; e as
lCo p v Two l, 50 S 5 4 5 0 27 Ct 9 5 6 Ed2 2 2 0 ) s e lo
At ronv.D. Ofi ofM a ,567F. 67 68182( C.Ci.2009)(iW hiepr s
het
C. fce
vor
3d 2, - D. r
çl l o e
c antqmus behedt ls srnge sa ar t f ma pla ngsg)... ve apr s
ompli s t
l o e s ti nt tnd ds han or l e di , e n o e
c pl i ntm us pl ad f t m a t rt tpe m ist c tt i e m or t n t m e e pos i lt
om a na
t e ac ual te ha r t he our o nf r
e ha he r
sbiiy
ofmic
s onduc.)(nt qu ai maksa ctto omitd)
t' i enml otton r nd iains te .
'
II.
Tosaeaca eofa i unde j1 apli ifmus algef t i cai t tplitf
tt us cton
r 983, antf t le acs ndi tng ha anif
ha be de i d ofrg sg a ee byt Consiu i o l oft Unie Stt sa t tt s
s en prve
i ht uar nt d he
tt ton r aws he t d a e nd ha hi
de i ton r uled fo c
prva i es t r m onductc
omm itd by ape s aci underc o ofsat l w.W ej v.
te
ron tng
ol r t e a
t
At ns 48 U. 42( ) C a g r ngb e ... nbes ddiecl und j 1 f
ki , 7 S. 1988 . ioc l oveni odis ca
ue r ty er 983 or
mo eay, e lrt r , rij n tv rle wh r . .h a t nta i alg dt b u o si to a
n tr d caao y o nu cie eif ee . te ci h t s l e o e nc n tt in l
o
e
u
i e e sore cut apolc sae e , di nc r gul i ordecson ofi al a eda
mplm nt
xe es
iy t tm nt or na e, e aton,
ii
fcily dopt nd
pr
omul t byt tbody' ofi e s'M o l v. w Yor Civ De tofSoc.Se v .436 U. 658
gaed ha
s tc r . nel Ne
'
k t p'
r s,
S. ,
690(1 . Topr t ago r ntle iy,s cha al alai,sla ef c tttona
978)
ove hat venme a ntt u s oc j li ibl or onsiui l
vi a i c m it d b ise pl e , a ntf m us s
ol tons om te y t m oye s pl i if t how t tt e iy' polc wa d he m ovi
ha he ntt s i y s t
t
ng
f c oft c tt i lvi aton. Pol Cot yv.Do on,454U. 31 326( 981. Hee
ore he onsiutona ol i ' k mt
'
ds
S. 2,
1 ) r,
M u tr fist l ka y p l yo t eNRVRJ alc lalt a o t t e e d n ' alg da t.
sad al o i n oi f h
n
c
, o a j i o ny f ha d fn a ts l e cs
,
e
Ac or ngl t c twildimist cli ag ns NRVRJunde j 1 5 f fiur t saea
c di y,he our l s s he ams ai t
r 91 A or al e o tt
c am upon whih r i ma b gr nt
li
c elef y e a ed.
111
.
Fort r a ons s a ed, he co tdim i s sM us a d' co pl ntpur ua t 1 U . C.
he e s
tt t
ur s s e
t r s m ai
s nt o 8 S.
j 1 5()2)B)i)wi u p eu iel
91 e( ( (i t t rj dc .
ho
EN TER : M ar h 29,201
c
2.
.'
,K
IXA D STATESDITRI J
J
S CT UDGE
1S cin 1 5le a ple t aIi o mapau rstlng Ina iin t c ansfldb
e to 9 () p is o 1 nf r
pe i ii s ç ddto o omplit ie y
i
prs nes.' M iha v. a lso Cou t , 4F. 7 ,7 (t Ci. 6 . Acc dngy,ti t e
io r ll' c u Ch re tn n y 43 3d 25 28 4 h r 200 )
or i l i s h
pr vehi et dimi sM usar scom pl nt
oper cl o s s
t d'
ai .
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?