Bane v. Virginia Department Of Corrections et al

Filing 9

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge James C. Turk on 05/31/2012. (kab)

cLFM s OFFI U, DI COUA
CE S. ST. '
AT RCANOKE,
VA
F1ED
u
'

I TH E U NI
N
TED STATES DI
STR I CO UR T
CT
FO R TH E W ESTER N D I
STRI O F V I G I I
CT
R N A
R O A NO K E DIVISIO N
R O BERT ALLEN BAN E ,

MA 3 l 2 1
t
22
' J A C ''- N rN ERK
ULL - !' ' L
BK

CA SE N O .7: 2CV 00159
1

Pl ntf ,
ai if

M EM O M N DU M O PINIO N
VS.

By: Jam e C.Turk
s
Seni U ni ed St
or
t
atesD i ri Judge
st ct

VI NI DEPT. CORR.c AL.
RGI A
OF
,
,
Defndants.
e
t)

Robe tA le Ba t pr s pl i i fi t spr s
r l n ne, he o e a ntf n hi ionerc vi r g sac i pur uantt 42
i l i ht ton s
o

U. C.j1 a t Ameia wihDia ltesAc (
S. 983 nd he rc ns t s biii t ADA) movest c tfraprlmi r
,
he our o ei nay

ij n to t a wo l ç r hbt p io o fcas fo f ri gplitf t k e l rci se s
n u cin h t ud s o iil rs n fiill r m o cn an if o n e o l tp ,
p
mb
a r uiegjdefnda st al pli iffl a une umbee us ofawheec r i l ng
nd eq r e e nt o low antf ul nd nc
rd e
lhai,ncudi
t a pora i on a vehi l w ih a AD A c pla whee c i lf ' U pon r vi w oft r co d,
r ns tton
ce t n
om i nt
l ha r i e.
'
e e
he e r
t c tde e t m oton.
he our ni s he
i
1

Ba as e t t the w e r rgi br e o bot l gsand m us us a û na a Cr t h' t
ne s r s ha
a s i d ac s n h e
t e t
ca di n u c ' o

wak, e a s o n r ed ma ea dj i t ie s afci h slg .l t i cvla to , n
l b c u e f e v a g n on d sa e fe t i e s n h s ii cin Ba e
ng
cli t tofi asa Poc ho a Stt Cor to Ce e (
ams ha fcil t a nts ae recinal ntr PSCC)ha be nr usngt
ve e ef i o
pr de t r ques e di a lt a com m oda i ofhi phys c lpr e s d pie bei die t d
ovi he e
t d s biiy c
tons
s
i a obl m , es t
ng r c e

t dos byVigi aDe rme ofCoreci (
o o
r ni pa t nt
r tons VDOC)ofi asa VDOC polcy.Ba
fcil nd
i
ne
ale t tt V D O C D i e t r ofHea t Se vi s a s gne Ba a m e ca cl s ik a i t
l ges ha he
rco
lh r ce s i d ne
di l a s t ton (
F

Code'whih t ohi t hil , t r o ohe ba re s'i l ng se us d t a c sva a
,' c t
pr bis ls sais r t r rir ,'nc udi t ps e o c es ns nd
bus . D e pie hi F Code c a s fc ton,Ba a l ge ,PSCC of i a st a a hi c ut h f
es
s t s
l s ii a i
ne le s
fci l ook w y s r c or
l0 daysw hie he w asi i aton and r used hi reques st us a wheel ri t
l
n sol i
ef
s
t o e
chai ns ead. W hie he
l

wa i iolton,ofi al alo f c d Ba t kne d i c rai pr edur ,whih c us d
s n s ai
fci s s or e
ne o el urng e t n oc es
c a e
Ba s ve e pa n. B a a gue t td t rbari r ' i l
ne e r i
ne r s ha ' he
o
r e s' nc udest kne i r uie en t the
he elng eq r m t ha
c l ng a a s r st tVD O C of i i l ha e m p e hi f om t spr e e i t pa t
hale es nd s e t ha
fc a s ve xe t d m r hi oc dur n he s .

Ba pr pad t $35 00 flng f ef t sci laci n whe hefl d i i Aprl201
ne e i he 0. ii e or hi vi to
n ie t n i 2.
Def nda sw a ved s l ce ofpr es o M a 17, 2,a a e s he e t f l r s nsve
e nt i
e wi
oc s n y
201 nd r c dul d o ie e po i
pl adi i e r y J y 201
e ngs n a l ul
2.
1
1

Asap ei i ayij n to tlpo ai a fr sa e ta r iayr l d p irt tilte
rll n r n u ci n en r rl fo d n xr o dn r ene y ro o ra,h
n
y
p rys e ngt ep ei n r ij n to mus d mo taeta : 1 û ei lk l t s c e do
a t e ki h r l ay nu cin t e nsrt h t ( ) t s i ey o u c e n
mi
h
t meis'( ç i lkeyt s frirpa a eham i t a e eofpr i nayrle,' 3
he rt,'2) t s i l o ufe re r bl r n he bsnc
he
elmi r eif'( )

'h b ln eo e ute tp i h sf v r'a d ()' nij n to i i t ep b i itrs. S e
û e aa c f q iis is n i a o , n 4 k nu cin s n h u lc n ee t' e
t
'
a
'
W i e v. t a Re o c Dee eCouncll ,555U. 7, 1 S.Ct 365,374( ) A
ntr Naurl s ur es fns
i, nc.
S. 29
.
2008 .
s i ofa dsr ng pos i lt ' ha m i i uf i e , ca e t s a r r r s a s i
how ng
st o
s biiy' of r s ns fci nt be us he t nda d equie how ng

t tha m i ( i l ' l Ea h oft e f urf c or m us bes tsi be or it ro or
ha r s d ke y.' d. c
l
hes o a t s t a ited f e n e l cut y

ij ncier l fi wa rn e .Re lTr t Ab u Ob ma l c v.
nu tv ei s ra td a uh o t a . n . FEC, 7 F.d3 2 3 (t
e
5 5 3 4 , 47 4 h
Ci.
r 2009) va ae bv,ema dby.c r.ca e 1 S. . 71( 0 ,r fi di pa'.
, c td r nde
e t rntd, 30 Ct23 201 ) eafnne n l
t
rma dbv,607F.d 355(t Ci. 0) Be a et prmaypur eofij tverle i
e nde
3
4h r 201 . c us he i r pos nunci eif s

t p e ev t sausq op ndn ars lto o t emeis itro uo yij n tv r l f
o rs r e he tt u e ig e ou in n h rt,nel c tr nu cie ei
e
whi h c ngest s a usquo pe ng t i i lm ie t c s sw he e C he e g i soft
c ha
he t t
ndi ral s i t d o a e
r t xi enc e
t
he
st ton de a s h r le ' nd c l otbe ta ie oft s ur a pi e ea ti .' W e z v.
iua i
m nd uc e i f a a m
ç va l d o ec e ec m l ral'
t el

Vdwa ds 635F. 283,286(t Ci.198 .
r ,
2d
4h r 0)
U po r e oft r cor t c tc l s t tBa s m oton f i eroc o y
n evi w
he e d, he our onc ude ha ne'
i or nt l ut r

i unci rle mus bede e rt Ba smoi s e t c nget sausquo-oa hive
nj tve eif t
nid.Fis, ne' ton e ks o ha he tt
t c e
2

c tor er d a om m oda i ofhi a l ge p i a di a ltes i udi r quie c ng t
our - d e cc
tons
s le d, hys c l s biii , ncl ng e r d ha es o
pr s r gul tonsr gar ng r t a ntpr dur s a whe c rus a pur ha e ofa ve cl
i on e a i
e di esr i oce e nd
el hai e, nd c s
hi e
w ih a whe c i lf , lofw hi prs n of i a sha pr vi l r f e t pr de f Ba s
t
el ha r it al
ch i o fci l ve e ous y e us d o ovi or ne'
pur e . Ra he t n m a nt i ng t s a usquo be w e n t pa tes gr ntng t r que t d
pos s t r ha
i a ni he t t
t e he ri , a i he e s e

r ifwoul r quieprs ofi il t e nd s tnta e f ta r our esa woul
ele
d e r ion tca s o xpe ubsa il for nd es c nd
d
c r um ve e t bls d V D OC pr ed e on t e m a t s D e enda ss d notbe pu t
ic
nt s a ihe
oc ur s hes
ter . f
nt houl
to
t s bur nsbef r ha ng a c nc t de l t i s t ough t nor allt g ton
he e de
o e vi
ha e o ve op he s ues hr
he m ii a i
pr es e . l
oc s s d.
M or ve ,i or rt fnd t tt S xi e i ' ofBa s st ton w a r nti m e a e
eo r n de o i ha he d g nc es'
e
ne' iua i
r a m di t
c ti e ve i des t t e f ton t s a us q t c t oul ha t de i t ve y
our nt r nton pie he f ec
he t t uo, he our w d ve o c de he r
l ga que to Ba r i esi hi c pl i unde t Ei h A m e
e l s i ns ne a s n s om a nt
r he ght
ndm e a t A D A bef e
nt nd he
or
de e nt ha ha oppo t t t r s nd. D e di i s i t spi e e lf s on i hi hl
f nda s ve d
r uniy o e po
ci ng s ues n hi ec m a a hi s g y
di c a d. 1
s our ge d.
M os i pora l Ba i c r nty u ert c e ofm e c pe s
t m t nty, ne s ur e l nd he ar
di al r onne a PSCC a
lt
nd
doe no a l ge f c sde ons r tng t the w ils f rir pa a e har i t a enc oft
s t le a t m t a i ha
l uf e r e r bl
m n he bs e he
i m e a e r le he r ques s Ba doe nota l t the i c r nty i i ol ton,t s a usi
m di t e i f e
t . ne s
lege ha
s ur e l n s a i he t t n
whi h he w a a ke t kne l M or ve , ne a is i hi c pl i t twhe he doe not
c
s s do
e.
eo r Ba dm t n s om a nt ha
n
s
ha hi c ut h t w a k ora w he l ha rt us a m us na ga e s a r , i on ofi i l c r y hi
ve s r c o l
e c i o e nd
t vi t t i s pr s
fca s a r m

whe ehene t go. W hieBa c
r
eds o
l ne ompl i t tt sale na i a omm odai n i pr bie
ans ha hi tr tve cc
to s ohi t d
by l w , doesno de ons r t t tbe ng ca e hasc us d hi ir pa a e ha o i lke y t
a he
t m t a e ha i
ni d
a e m r e r bl nn r s i l o
c us hi ha m i t f tr . Fo t s r as ,Ba sow n a l ga i pr cl a tndi t t
a e m r n he utte r he e e ons ne'
le tons e ude i ng ha
he i lkel t s f ir abl hanu w ihouta courtor pr bii t kneelng r r ent
s i y o uf er r epar e
t
der ohi tng he
i equiem
orr rng t he be pr ded w heelchai accessas r
equii hat
ovi
r
eques ed. A s Bane t cannots ify
t
hus
ats

o eo t ef u n c s ayee n st wa rn itro u oyij n tv r l f nd rW itr hs
n f h o r e e s r lme t o ra t n elc tr n u ci e ei u e n e, i
e
m oton f s h r le m us be de e Re Tr t 575 F. a 347. An a opra e or rw il
i or uc e i f
t
ni d. al u h,
3d t
ppr i t de l
i s t s da
s ue hi y.
The Cl r i die t d t s c e oft s m e o and opi on a a om pa ng
e k s r c e o end opi s hi m r um
ni nd cc
nyi
o dert pl i if
r o a ntf .

ENTER:Thi %
s

a o Ma 2 2.
y f y, 01
ly
wxv
Se '

ù2

nie St t s D it i tJ
t d a e s rc

e