Brown v. Clark

Filing 26

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge James C. Turk on 02/15/2013. (kab)

o p- s OFFI U. Dl COURT
a
CE s. sT.
AT ROANOKE,V
A
FIED
L

I TH E UN I
N
TED STA TES D I
STR I CO U R T
CT
FO R TH E W ESTERN D I
STR I T O F V I G I I
C
R N A
ROAN OK E DI SI
VI ON

NI OLAUS LAI BROW N,
CK
N

CASE NO . 1
7: 2CV00185

J I5 2 1
AN
23
JUL G. DL ,
D
CLERK
BY:
E W CL
ERK

Pe ii ner
tt o ,

#.

M EM OM NDUM OPI ON
NI

ol
REcToR DEPARTM ENT

oFc
oRuE l xs
èT o ,

B :Jme C. uk
y a s Tr
Se or U nie St e D i t c Judge
ni
t d at s s ri t

R e ponde .
s
nt
Pe ii r a i at pr e ng pr K ,fl t s pe ii f ra wrtofha s c pus
ttone , n nm e oce di
o
ied hi tton o
i
bea or ,

pm s ntt 28U. C.j2254,c le i t vai t ofhi c
ua o
S.
halngng he ldiy s onfne ntf muli e
me or tpl
c c i unde Vigni l w.Upon r viw oft pm i 's
onvitons
r ri a a
e e
he
es ubmis o a saeco tr co ds
s i ns nd tt ur t r
fom t Cic tCour ofM on g r Co mt t Co ltofAppe l ofVigni a t
r he r ui
t
t ome y t y, he tr
as
r i a, nd he
Supr m eCour ofVigi a, heco tc ude t tt r ponden ' m oton t dim ist
e
t
r ni t
ur oncl s ha he es
ts i o s s he

peii m us begr nt d.
tton
t
a e

Afe aj yti i t Cic tCo tofMont meyCot y o J nuay8,2004,
tr ur raln he r ui ur
go r mt n a r
Ni kolusLan Br
c a
i own wa c c e ofa tm pt r bbe y,us ofafr a i a a tmpt d
s onvit d te ed o r e
ie nn n n te e

r bbey,atmptdca tlmur r a us ofafram i a at edc pia mur r( e
o r te e pia
de, nd e
ie r n n tempt a tl de Cas

Nos 03- 03- 03- 1 & 03- 0,es tvey) Thee de eoferda ti wast t
. 943, 945, 1 76,
118 r peci l .
vi nc f e t ral ha
o M ay 6,
n
2003,Br
own e e e t Te coHa M a ti Chrsins zg, nt afr r a
nt r d he xa
ndy r n ita blr poi ed iea m t
s o e e pl e R e on Y a s a de a
t r m oye
m
s a nd m nded m one a pule t ti rs ve a tm e ,
y, nd l d he r gge e r l i s

at ht gundi no fr The ea et convitonst tBr c le si hi j225
lhoug he
d t ie. s r he
ci ha own halnge n s
4

peiin (çheChrsins gc ci ' .
tto t
t
ita bur onvitons'
)

O n J nua y 21 2004,Br zw a t i d be o e t Cou ton dif r nti c m e sa w as
a r ,
om
s r e f r he
r
f e e ndi t nt nd

f u dg it o t c t so u eo afr am i r b eya dt c t so r b r ( s No .
o n u l f wo omt f s f ie r n o b r n wo omt f o bey Ca e s
y
03- 3,0 8 03- 65,& 03- r s ci l) Thee de ofeedatt stilwast ton
86 3-64, 8
866, epe tvey .
vi nce fr
hi ra
ha
M a 6,2003,Br
y
own e er d acon ninc sor i Bl ks g,g a d sor e pl
nt e
ve e e t e n ac bur r bbe t e m oyeeM r
.
Cha y a poi e wha a a edt beapit athi , man a r evedm oneyfom
udar nd nt d
t ppe r o
sol m de ded nd ec i
r
t r gi t r a fed.
he e s e , nd l

The Cou ts he e t Blc bur r r a fr ar sc c i a Chrsins g
r c dul d he a ks g obbe y nd ie m onvitons nd ita bur
c ci nsf s nt ncng, on Aprl1 ,2004,e e e a sngl s nt nc ng o de a es i
onvi to or e e i and
i 9
nt r d i e e e i r r ddr sng
a 1oft e convi tons s a i a f l
1 hes
c i , t tng s olows;

I a ce a i wih t Vigi aDe rme ofCore tonsf rt t r of 1ye r
nc r r ton t he r ni pa t nt
r c i o he e m :
a
f ATTEM PTED ROBBERY,30 ye sf ATTEM PTED CAPI
or
ar or
TAL

M URDER, yeasf e c USEOF FI
3 r or a h
REARM I ATTEM PTED MURDER (
N
3
ye r i t mandaor mi mum f t schage,25ye r f ea hROBBERY,
a s s he
t y ni
or hi r )
a s or c
a 5 yea s f ea h USE O F FI
nd
r or c
REA RM I A TTEM PTED ROBBERY . The
N
RO BBERY s t nce r c ur e w ih ea h ot a c ur e w ih
en e s un onc r nt t c her nd onc r nt t
ATTEM PTED ROBBERY a ATTEM PTED CAPI
nd
TAL M URDER. Thet t l
oa
s nt e i pos d i 56 yea s
e enc m e s
r.

Br
own, hr
t ough c
ouns ,fl anotc ofa a ,lsi Ca eN os 03 11 t o
el ied
i e ppe l itng s
. - 76 hr ugh

1 8 , 3 9 3tr ug 9 (h Ch ita s l gc n ito ) a d0 - 61tr u h 8 6(
1 2 0 - 4 h o h 45 t e rsin bz o v cins, n 3 8 h o g 6 t
r
he

Blc s ur c n ito ) Co n e as o ti e ata s rp o t ej r til nte
a k b g o vcins. u s l lo ban d rn cit f h u y ra o h
Chrsins g ofe e . Br wn sa est tc
ita bur f ns s o
tt ha ouns li or hi by lte t tpe ii nsf
e nf med m
e tr ha tto or
a alwoul be fld.Ther or oft Cour ofAppe sofVigi a,howe r i udea
ppe
d ie
ec ds he
t
al
r ni
ve , ncl

p tto fra p a o l a t Br wn' Blc s u gof n e ( c r No 1 3 - 4 0 ) wh c wa
ei n o p e l ny s o o s a k b r fe s s Re o d . 0 2 0 - 3 , ih s
i
uli t l dimis d by or rda e M a c 23,2005.
tma ey s s e
de t d r h
Br
own, hr
t ough c
ouns l a al d t di m i s lofRec d N o.1
e , ppe e he s s a
or
032- 4- t t
0 03 o he

Supr meCo tofVigi a( codNo.
e
ur
r ni Re r
05078 .Br sSuprmeCour peii f a l
4) own'
e
t tton or ppea
a es e t s fce oft e de ea t t Bl ks g a t Cl si ns zg ofe es as
ddr s s he ufi incy he vi nc s o he ac bur nd he ui ta blr f ns ,

um r de t
pt m r
doest r s
he e ponde ' m o i t di m i s t a a . By s m a y or r da ed Se e be 8,
nts ton o s s he ppe li

2005, ed o r viw oft pa te 'a gl t ,t Supr m eCour ofVigni r us d t
bas n e e
he ris r lmen s he
e
t
r i a ef e he
pe ii f a
tton or ppea .Nope ii f awrtofce to a ion Br
l
tton or
i
ri r r
own' be l wasfld i t Unie
s ha f
ie n he td
St t s Su e e Cou t
a e pr m
r.

On Febnlr 1 201 Br
a y 0, 0, own fl d ape ii f awrtofhabe sc pusi t Cic t
ie
tton or
i
a or n he r ui

Cour o M ont meyCount ( s No.1 67 ) al ngc ter s pr ec ora
tf
go r
y Ca e
0- 49 , legi our ror, os ut il
m ic
s onduc ,i ufk i nte de e,a i fe tve a ssa e o cot ela ti la on a
t ns t e vi nc nd ne f c i s it nc f ms t ra nd
ppea .
l
Ther s
e ponde move f dim is lofBr
nt
d or s s a
own' pe ii ast i ey fld t rt a i bl
s tton mtm l ie mde he pplca e

saueo l tto f rh be speiins eVigni Co eAn j8. - 4 A)2 ( n aig
tt t f i ains o a a t o .Se r i a d n. 0165 ( ( ) ma d tn
mi
t
t t h b a p tto c aln igaci n l u g n befldwi i t y asfo fn l
ha a a e s eiin h le gn rmi a j d me t i
e t n wo e r r m ia
h
j
udgme i t tilc toroneye fo c ei ofdie a a o e piai oftmef
nt n he ra our
ar rm omplton rct ppe l r x rton i or
slng s ha a, c ve i ltr.l t moto t dimis t r s
i uc ppe lwhihe r s ae) n he in o s s,he eponde a s redt tt
nt s et ha he
Co tofAppe l ofVigi aha no r or ofBr
ur
as
r ni d
ec d
own' a a oft Chrsins g c c i .
s ppe l he ita bur onvitons
Aferr c vi t moton t dim is Br wn fl d ai otont va t 'hi ha as
t e ei ng he i o s s , o ie ç i o cae' s be
m

p tto wi o tp eu c s h c uda p a.Thecrui c u t e idt smoin a d
eiin t u rj die o e o l p e l
h
ic t o r d n e hi to n ,
uli ael dimis d Br
tm t y, s s e own' ha aspe ii by or rda e Aprl7, 1.Br t n
s be
tton
de t d i 201
own he

a pe ldt eha e sr ln t t Su e Co r o Vign a( c r No. 1 4 4 , c
p ae h b a uig o he prme u t f r ii Re o d 1 1 3 ) whih
r f ed hi pe ii f a a by or rda ed D e e be 6,2011.
e us
s tton or ppe l
de t
cm r

OnAp i 1 , 01 , o sg e h sh n wrte j2 4p tto a maldit ti
rl 6 2 2 Br wn in d i a d itn 25 eiin nd ie t o h s
c twhe e i wasr e ve on Aprl19 201 Br
our, r t
ec i d
i , 2. own al ge t f l ng gr mdsf r le ;
le s he olowi
ot
or e if

( )Th til u g a u e d srto wh na wei jlo q sins ( )Coms l s
1 e ra j d e b s d icein e ns rng t r ueto ; 2 t e wa
r
i fe tvei f ii t ob e tt t c tsa eofdicei r r ngt j orquesin;(
nef ci n alng o j c o he our' bus
srton egadi he ur
to 3)
1 Br pr e sa l t da ed J 1 2005 i whi c eli or sBr , SYoura
own es nt eter t une 4
n ch ouns nf m
own ç
ppeal

ha b e s n t t Su e Couf't lte do sno ls a y c s nu e s ( No. - ,a 1 )
s e n e t o he prme r ;he etr e t it n a e mb r. ECF 2 1 t 7.

Th p os c trma emila igrmak t j r r; 4 Th c u tmp o e l al we t e
e r e uo d se dn e r s o u o s ( ) e o r i r p ry lo d h
m os uint prs ntde nsrtvee de e;( Thee de wa i uf in t s
tc to o e e mo tai vi nc 5)
vi nce s ns fce t o uppor
t
Br
own' c
s onvi tonsf r a t m pt d c pia m ur r a us ofa fr r dur ng t tof e e;a
ci
o te e a t l de nd e
iea m
i ha f ns nd

( )Co ns l sief ciei ()fiigt p e r f rtil ( )fiigt r q e t a o a l
6 u e wa n fe tv n a aln o rpae o ra; b aln o e u s fv r be
e ie ef rt d fns ; c f ingt rieo j cins ( )f ingt r n w mo in a dp e ev
vd nc o he ee e () al o as b e to ; d al o e e
i
i
to s n rs r e

t e fra p a ; nd()fii t p o ryfl adie ta p a fo t ej dg n a trp tto e
h m o p e la e al o r pel ie rc p e l r m h u me t fe ei n r
ng
i
es
ie
i o s s r ng ha he
ake c e t dos 2 Ther pondentfl d am oton t dim is, agui t tt j2254
s d ounsl o o.

p tt nwa u tmeyfldu d r2 U. C. 2 4 *, n Br wnr s o d d ma i t ematr
eii
o s n i l ie n e 8 S. j 2 44 a d o e p n e , kng h te
rpef co i r ton.Br
i or nsde a i
own a s s
lo ubmitd apladi t thee ild: S o i f Be aed
te
e ng ha
ntte t ton or l t
M
A ppea .
l'
'
11

Ha a p tto sfld u de j 2 5 aes be to ao ey a pei do lmi to .2
be s ei n ie n r 2 4 r u j c t n - e r ro f i t in 8
i
a
U. C. 2 4 ( )1 .Ge e al u e j2 4 ( )1( ,h fd rl ii p ro b gnst r n
S. 1 2 4 d ( ) n r l nd r 2 4 d ( )A) t e e e a fl e id e i o u
y,
ng
fo t d t o wh c t j d me t f c n ito b c me fn l wh n p tto rn ln e
r m he ae n ih he u g n o o v cin e o s i a - e eiine o o g r
hasa a l bl a nue f r die tr vi w , he t tm e f f lng a pe ii f w rtofc ri r r
n vaia e ve
o r c e e w n he i or ii
tton or i
e to a i

i t Unied St t Supr m eCour ha expie ort Supr me Cour ha de ed c ri a ifo
n he t
aes
e
t s
r d, he
e
t s ni e tor r r m

tehg etsaec u tsd n a o dr c a p a.S eClvv. ie Stts 5 7U. 5 2( 0 3 .
h ih s tt o r' e il n ie t p e l e a Untd ae , 3 S. 2 2 0 )
Fo pur esoft saut oflm ia i a l i onl t c twilpr umewihout
r pos
he t t e i t tons nayss y, he our l es
t
fndi t tt Supr m eCour ofVigi aadd e s Br
i ng ha he
e
t
r ni
r s ed own' a pe oft Chrsi ns g
s p al he ita bur

2 Br
own fl a a ended pe ii on M ay 30, 201 r sng t sa ecl i si a t writ
ied n m
tton
2, aii hese m am n ype ten

me r nd m I No.7 .
mo a u EcF
)
4

ofe e on t m e isi r f i hi pe ii f appe lby o de da e Se t
f ns s he rt n e usng s tton or
a
r r t d p embe 8 2005.
r ,
3
W he Br
n own di notpur ue apeii n f rawrtofc ri a it t Unied Stt Supr me Co t
d
s
tto o
i
e tor r o he t
aes
e
ur
wihi 90 dayst r a tr on De mbe 7,
t n
he e fe ,
ce r 2005, own' c c i be me fna u r
Br
s onvitons ca i l nde

j2 4 d ( )A)4 A tt tpoi , Br wn' o ey a p ro t fl atmeyj2 5 p tto b g n
2 4() l( . ha nt o s n - e r eid o ie i l 2 4 eiin e a
r nni a e rdonDe e r7,
u ng nd xpie
c mbe 2006.Br di notfl hi j225 peii untlAp i 1
own d ie s
4 tton i rl 6,

20 2, ttee ris, r t ntv y ast olt t e j2 4 d ()A)
1 a h ale tmo e ha s e e r o ae md r 2 4()1( .
Br alodoesno algef csonwhiha ofhi j225 cai c dbede me
own s
t le a t
c ny
s
4 l ms oul
e d

tmeyu d rj2 4 ( )1( , a e o t ermo a o a i e i nto j2 4 ( )1( , a e
i l n e 2 4 d ( )B) b s d n h e v l f n mp dme , r 2 4 d ( )C) b s d
on ane r toaci Supr me Cour de son.
w, er tve
e
t cii

Br ase t t thi j2254cli s dbede me tmeyunde j2244( ( )D)
own s rs ha s
ams houl
e di l
r
d)1( ,

bae o hi ds o eyi M a 2 0(r m temo int d s s fldi t esaeh b a
s d n s ic v r n y 01 fo h to o imis ie n h tt a e s
pr e di )t tco e hadne rpef t ana aloft Chrsi bur ofe es5 'us
oc e ngs ha uns l
ve reced ppe
he itans g f ns . y

ag me th sn me i.S b e to 2 4 ( )1( alwsc luaino aha e sp tto e '
r u n a o rt u s cin 2 4 d ( )D) lo ac lt f b a eiin rs
o
f de alilng pe i fo t dae o whi heco d frtha dic r çlr
e r i
rod r m he t n ch
ul is ve s ove ed, çlough t e r s
t
he xe cie

ofd dii nce't fcsne esayt hi j2254cams Att tmeoft til Br wnkne
ue lge r'he a t c s r o s
li . he i
he ra, o
w
t f t ne s a yt a 1ofhi ha ascam s e pthi a lga i a
he acs ce s r o l
s be li , xce s le tons boutc
ouns lsf ii
e ' alngs
d i t die ta alpr s .Be ivi t thi a alha gonet t Cou tofAppe l a
urng he r c ppe oce s le ng ha s ppe
d
o he
r
a s nd

3 Ther pondentar
es
guest t tm elnessofBr
hat he i i
own' petton s d becacult ast
s ii houl
l a ed hough
he fld no appealoft Chritans g ofens Thi a gumenti est f tt t Supr eCour
ie
he
si bur f es. s r
gnor he ac hat he
em
t
ofV igi a consde ed t pari ar
r ni
i r he tes' gument ast t Chrsi bur a Bl bur ofensesa
s o he itans g nd acks g f
nd
s marl r us t a al appar l on t mert
um
iy ef ed he ppe ,
enty
he is.
4 Se H ilv. axt , 27 F. 701 7 ( t Ci. 02 CE nopeii f rawrt fc rir r i
e l Br on 7 3d , 04 4h r 20 ) l
f
tton o
i o e to a i s
fl i t Unie Stt Supr e Cour,t t lm ia i pe od begi r ng whe t tm e f
ied n he t d a es
em
t hen he i t ton ri
ns unni
n he i or

d ng s - 90d ys- ha ea e ' .
oi o
a
s lps d.)
'
5 Br
own ass rst tuntlher ved t moton t di sshi s ae petton, hebele t thi
e t ha i ecei he i o smi s t t ii
ived ha s
a
ppealoft Chrsi bur ofens ha gonet t Supr Cour ofVigi a i Rec dN o.050784,
he itans g f es d
o he
eme
t
r ni n or
ast Supr e Cour' r d appear t i ca e.
he
em
ts ecor
s o ndi t

t n t t Supr m e Co tofVigi a whe ei wasdim is o Se e be 8,2005,
he o he
e
ur
r ni , r t
s s ed n pt m r
ne rhe e s Br
ve t l s , own wat d f t a ahafyea s t i Fe a y 1 201 t fl hi ha a
ie otr nd
l r , mtl bnlr 0, 0, o ie s be s
pe ii n i t c r ui cou t I Br
tto n he i c t r . f own had fl d a tm e y s a eha aspe ii ast Cl i s 1
ie i l t t be
tton o a m

t ough5a 6( t ough( ,bas o fcsara kno t hi hec dha dic r
hr
nd a) hr
d) ed n a t le dy wn o m, oul ve s oveed
muc e rirt pr e swih hi a alan coul ha a s re tmel sa eha ascai son
h a le he oblm
t s ppe
d
d ve s e td i y tt be l m
t si s aswe l Be aus Br f ist saeany f c son whih t cour c d fnd t the
hi s ue
l. c e own al o t t
at
c he
t oul i ha
a t d wih duedii ncei dicove i t ç w'f t a
ce t
lge
n s rng he i ' acs boutt a a ,t cou tc notfnd
ne
he ppe l he r nn i

ta a yo h sj2 5 camsaetmeyfldu d rj2 4 ( )1( .
h t n f i 2 4 li r i l i n e 2 4 d ( )D)
e
Unde 28U. C.j2244( ( ,t oneye tlngpei i t l whieali t s
r
S.
d)2) he - ar ii rod s oled l r nmae'
ç ope l fl a i a i f St t pos - onvi ton orot rcola e alr vi w ' i pe ng.
s
pr r y ied pplc ton or a e tc
ci
he
l t r e e ' s ndi

Be a s sauo yt lmiso saepeiin aeç o dto s t fln , a u t l sae
c u e ttt r i i t n tt t o s r ç n iinlj o iig' n ni y tt
me
t
c
'
me
p tto i no C r p ryfld'o p r o e o tligt e j2 4 d () Aru v Be n t, 31
ei n s tl o e l ie 'f r u p s s f o l md r 2 4()2 . tz . n et 5
i
p
n
U. 4,11(
S.
2000)
.
Br
own di notfl hi s aehabe pe ii l i l a trhi f de a flng pe i
d
ie s t t
as tton mtl ong fe s e r l ii
rod

e r d. The e or ,t pe ncy oft saeha aspr ee ngsc nnott lt f de a
xpie
r f e he nde
he t t be
oc di
n
ol he e r l
lm iai perod.M or ove , a et cr ui c tdim is Br wn' sae ha aspe ii
i t tons i
e r bec us he ic t our s s ed o s t t be
tton
a untm e y fl a t Supr e Cour sl m a iy di m i s d hi ha s a
s i l ied nd he
em
t lm r l s s e s bea ppea ,Br n' s a e
l ow s t t

p tto wa n tt r p ry Eld'f r r o e o t ligu d rj2 4 ( )2 .Aru , 31U. a
ei n s o ç o el e 'o pu p s s f oln n e 2 4 d ( ) tz 5 S. t
i
p
11 Ac or ngl Br
. c di y, own i no e ild t a sa u o y t lng oft f de a flngperod t r
s t ntte o ny tt t r oli
he e r l ii
i mde

j2 4 ( )2 , n h sf d rl eiini ce ryuni l u d rj2 4 d ( )
2 4 d ( ) a d i e ea p tto s lal tmey n e 2 4( )1.
Equia et lngi a ia ei fdealha swheet peii rs :( )hepu s d
tbl oli s valbl n e r bea
r he ttone hows 1
rue
hi rght wihr s na edii nc a ( s e r r naycrumsa eprve edhi
s i s t ea o bl lge e; nd 2) ome xtao di r ic tnc e nt m
fo tmel flng hi ha spe ii Se Hola v. orda
r m i y ii s bea tton. e l nd Fl i

6

-

U.
S.
-

,

1 S.Ct 25 2562
30
. 49,

( 01 ) On yi t s ç aeisa c swh r -d t cru tn e e tma t t p ry' o
2 0 . l n ho e ç r n tn e e e ue o ic msa c s k e lo he a t s wn
r
c
onduc -i woul beunc c o bl t e or et lmia i pe i a i tt pa t a gr s
t t
d
ons i na e o nf c he i tton rod gans he ry nd os

ij siewo l r s l'se utbet ligwa rn e .Gr e v J hn o 5 5F.d2 0 3 4(t
n u tc u d e ut i q ia l oln ra td e n . o s n, 1 3 9 , 0 4h
'
Ci. ) Ge r iy,a i t spr K sausa i a oft lw aeno s t e t
r 2008 . ne al n nmae' o tt nd gnornce he a r t ufkin

g o n st j siye utbetlig Uni dSae v. s s 6 F.d5 7 51 (t Ci. 0 4 .
r u d o u tf q ia l oln . t tts So a 3 4 3 0 , 2 4h r 2 0 )
e
Br
own' va a lga i a
s gue le tons boutprs n ta f r ,lw lbr r i qua es a l k of
io r ns e s a i a y nade ci , nd ac
l ltani dono s fc t mee t hea e de it bur n r quie t wa r nte t bl
ega r i ng
t ufie o
t he vy vi nta. de e r d o ra quia e
y

t lng oft f de a flng pe i f mor t n f l ye s The e or t c r c l st t
oli
he e r l ii
rod or e ha otr ar . r f e, he ou t onc ude ha
Br
own i no e il d t e t bl t lng t a l c i r ton ofhi ha asc am son t
s t ntte o quia e oli o low onsde a i
s be l i
he
m ert
is.
II
I

Fort r a o sae t c tgr nt t m otont dimi sa dim is Br
he e s ns t td, he our a s he i o s s nd s s es own'
s

p tto a u tmeyfldu d rj2 4 ( Th c u t lod ne Br wn' sp rt moin fra
eiin s ni l e n e 2 4 *. e o r as e is o s e a ae to o
bel t d a
a e ppea i t sa e cours a t sm oton m e e y r i es a t runtm e y ha s c a m on
l n he t t
t , s hi
i
r l a s no he
i l bqa l i

whc r le i t - ar du d rj2 4 4 .Ana p o raeo d rwil ne t i d y
ih eif s i b re n e 2 4 *
me
p r p it r e le tr hs a .

Fo t er a o sae t ec u t imis sBr wn' p tto wih u p eu iea u tmey
r h e s ns ttd,h o r ds se o s eiin to t rj dc s ni l
tl d.The Clr i di t d t s nd c pi oft sm e a um o ni n a a compa ng o de
ie
e k s mc e o e o es hi mor nd
pi o nd c
nyi r r
t pe ii r
o ttone .
EN TER:

Thi J5 da ofJ nua y 2013.
s * y a r,
J
Se Unie St t sDititJ e
nl
t d a e src u