Goodman v. McCoy et al
Filing
13
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge James C. Turk on 07/13/2012. (kab)
r.FRKSOFFI I. DI COUA
l
C: .S, ST.
/
AT HOA?G E VA
tJKE,
Fl 87
L :7
I TH E UN I
N
TED STATES DI
STR I C O U R T
CT
FO R TH E W E STER N D I
STRI O F VI G I I
CT
R N A
R O A N O K E DIVISIO N
JUL 13 2 1
92
If
!;
?
TH O M A S L.G O O D M A N ,
.
'
'
CA SE N O .7:
12CV 00186
Pl ntf ,
ai if
M EM O R AN D U M O PI IO N
N
V S.
M AJOR K.M CCOY,c AL.
,
By: Jam es C.Turk
Seni Uni ed Stat D i ri Judge
or
t
es st ct
Dee
fndants.
t)
Thom a L.G ood a a V i g ni i a e pr e ng pr K , ie t s c vi rght a ton
s
m n, r i a nm t oce di
o f l d hi i l i s c i
purua t 42U. C.j 1 algi t tt dee ntprs ofi al a RedOni Stt
s nt o
S.
983, le ng ha he fnda ion fci s t
on ae
Prs vi ae hi c tt i lrg si s vea r pe t.Unde 28U. C.j1 5A( ( )
ion oltd s onsiutona iht n e rl es cs
r
S.
91 b)1,
w he a pr s rs s gove nm e of i al , he c tm us s r en a s m a iy di m i sa s
n
i one ue
r nt fci s t our
t c e nd um rl s s s oon
aspr c i bl a s torpor i t r t ti f i ous m a i i , f l t s a e a c a m .
a tca e ny ui
ton he eof ha s rvol , lc ous or ais o t t l i
Ahe rviw oft r or t c ts
re e
he ec d,he our umma iydimis cli ( )and( unde
rl s ses ams 1
4) r
j1 5A( ( ) de e Goodma sde ndf atmporr r tani or ,a or r sr ie
91 b)1, nis
n' ma or e ay esri ng der nd des e vc
oft r m a ni c ai s
he e i ng l m .
I hi compl ntGoodma alge furcli f rle :( )onAprl22,2011 Ofier
n s
ai ,
n le s o ams or eif 1
i
, fc
Belne ie l ij e Goodman' fng whieope nghi c ldoor ( onAug t1 2011
l glg nty nurd
s i er l ni s el
; 2)
us 0, ,
Of i e Loone yanke G oodm a sa m t oug t ta s oti hi c ldoorw iho
fc r
y
d
n' r hr h he r y l n s el
t ut
pr voc ton, usngij yt hi am;( OfiesStnlya M ccoyplce Goodma i
o ai ca i n ur o s r 3) fc r a e nd
a d
nn
am bul t y r s r i s f r 27 hotr w iho ba hr
a or e t a nt o
ts t ut t oom br a ,c usng Goodm a t d e a e a
e ks a i
n o ef c t nd
urnaeonhi ef a ( NurePhi deaye c ryi outad t ' or rf Good nt
it
ms l; nd 4) s pps l d ar ng
ocors de or
ma o
ha x-a ofhi a m . Asr le i t sa ton,Good a s ksa tempor r r sr i ng o de ,
ve r ys
sr
e if n hi c i
m n ee
s
t
a y e tani r r
$50,000. (nd)pema nt rnse fom t sr i ,l
.
00 a
r ne ta fr r hi egon.,
I o d rt saeacam i a yfd rlcvla to t ep an ifsita t a alg t ns
n r e o tt li n n e ea ii cin,h litf t l cu l le ai
g
o
m us be e
t nough t r i e a r ghtt r lefa
o a s i o e i bove t s c a i l ve , t one t ti d a i e o
he pe ul tve e l' o
'
ha s i usbl n
pl
isf c ' r t t n m e el ç
t a e, a her ha
'
r y l e va e. Bel At . p. Tw om bl 550 U . 544,570
conc i bl '
' l l Cor v.
v,
S.
( 07 .The eor,aplitf mus ç le f t s fce t saealheelme sof(hel
20 ) r f e anif t ç lge acs ufiint o tt 1t e nt t
a
cai ' Bas v.E.. pontdeNe
l m.
' s l Du
mour & Co.324F.d761 765( h Ci.
s
,
3
,
4t r 2003)
.
Tosaeac us ofa tont rj1 apli ifmus esa iht theha bee
tt a e ci mde 983, antf t tbls ha
s n
de i d ofrght guar nt d by t Consiuto orlwsoft Unie St t sa t tt s
prve
i s
a ee
he
tt i n a
he t d a e nd ha hi
de i ton r s t d f o c
pr va i e ule r m onductc m it d by a pe s ac i unde c o ofs a e l w . W e t
om te
r on tng
r ol r t t a
s
v. ki ,487U. 42( 988 .TheEiht Ame me pr ecsprs r fom c ue a
At ns
S. 1 )
g h
nd nt ot t iones r r l nd
unus llvi c to .Rho v. pma 45 U. 337( 981 . Topr aco tt ina
ua i ng ondiins
des Cha n, 2 S. 1 )
ove nsiuto l
cam rltdt a u s f j i c n iin panifmu ts o ta ted fnd n p io o fca
li eae o n n ae al o dto , litf s h w h t h ee a t rs n fiil
a tdwihd l e aeid fee c - h th o s ek e s be tv l,h c n iinp e e tda
ce t ei rt n ifrn e t a e r h n w, u j ciey t e o dto r sne
b
s t nta r s ofs r ousha m a ne t l s f ie t t d e o e m e ur ' t alevi t
ubs a i l i k
ei
r nd verhe es a l d o ake û as nabl as es' o l a e
r
i.Fame v.Brnnan,511U. 8 8 37( 99 .Si ene i ncebyofi as i f lngt
t r r e
S. 25, 35- 1 4) mpl glge
fcil,n aii o
p e it h t p e eo prs ne up n mih c us a imaeph sc lnu y smpl d e n t
r dc t a a ic f io q ime t g t a e n n t y ia ij r , i y o s o
gi rs t a co tt i lcam aci bl unde j 1
ve ie o ny nsiutona li tona e r 983. See e. ,
, c.Count ofSaca nt
y
rme o
v. wi,523U. 8 8 ( )(ûT1 Consiutondoe no guaa e duec r o t pat
Le s
S. 33, 49 1998 d( he
tt i
s t rnte
ae n he r
1 Th c r noest a Go ma sd ma d f atmpo ayr sr i ngor r(
e ou t t h t od n' e n or e rr e tani de TRO)mus b
te
deni Goodm an' alegatonsaboutpas event do notdemonsr et thewils f any i medi e,
ed.
s l i
t
s
tat ha
l ufer
m
at
ir paa l h r wh to ve i t a e c o t erq se ij c i r le .Se Fe R. v. 65 b
re r be a m a s e r n he bs n e f h e ue td nun tve eif e d. Ci P. ( )
(uhorzngTRO o y wh nt emov n pr est thewils fe i ne ,ir p r bl ij yi
a t ii
nl e h
a t ov ha
l u fr mmi nt re a a e nur f
ij nci r le i no g a td b f r t a e s p ry c dben tfe a r s nd .
nu tve eif s t r ne e o e he dv re a t oul
o iid nd e po )
ofsae ofii l;la lt f ne i nty i lc e ha i c t gorc ly be t t t es d'of
t t fc as ibiiy or glge l nfit d nn s a e i a l neah he hr hol '
co tt ina pr eci )
nsiuto l ot tons.
l cai ( ) Goodma alge t to Aprl22, 1 OfierBeli nedg
n l m 1,
n le s ha n i 20l , fc l s
ope Goodma s
n'l
c ldoorne i ntyta ng ( s rghtpi yfng rbewe nt doora dlwi
el
glge l rppi hil i nk i e t e he
nl ndow fa
rme
c usn ad e c ti (i)fng r' Co l2.Go d na s rst a t eij r c u e hi p i
a ig e p u n h s i e. mp .
'
o ma s et h t h nu y a s d m an
a s f rng a l sof s ns ton,a s sBel f ç lge .' O n t f c oft c pl i ,
nd uf e i nd os
e a i nd ue
l or s i nce '
neg
he a e he om a nt
t scl i f ist r s t c tt i lpr
hi a m a l o i e o ons iutona opori . Goo an hi s fc l Be ls a tonsm e e
tons
dm
m el als l ' c i
r
ç glge e,' nd a o f c a ' ne i nc doe notv ol t t i a e' c tt i na rght ,
û i nc ' a n f i i ls glge e s
ne
i a e he nm t s ons iuto l i s
e e whe ic u e ij r .AsGo d nfist alg a yfcss g sigta Bel ce wih
v n n t a ss nuy
o ma al o l e n a t ug e tn h t l a td t
e
d lb r t i ifrnc t ak o rs t a h wo l c u eGo d ns ro sp y ia ij r b
eie ae ndfee e o n wn ik h t e ud a s o ma e iu h sc l nu y y
o ni hi c ldoor G oodm a scl i a i tBel m us be s m a iy di m i s d,pur ua t
pe ng s el
,
n' a m ga ns
l t um rl s s e
s nt o
j1915 b)1,a lgalyfi ous
A( () s e l rvol .
O nl a pr s ofi i ' de i r t i f e e e t a i a e' s r ous m e c lnee
y
i on t c als lbe a e ndif r nc o n nm t s e i
di a
d
viltst eEih hAme me t S eEsel v Ga l, 2 U. 9 1 2 ( 9 ) A s fiin l
oae h g t
nd n . e tle . mbe 4 9 S. 7, 0 1 76 . u fce ty
s r ousm e c ne i t t tha bee di gnos d by a phys c a a m a tng t e t e tor
ei
di al ed s t ha s n a
one
e
i i n s nda i r a m n
one t ti s obvi t te a l pe s w oul e s l r cogni t ne es iy f r a doc or s
ha s o
ous ha ven ay r on
d a iy e
ze he c st o
t '
at ton,'kov.Shrve,535F. 225,24l( hCi. ) a aprs ofi i i t i rtl
teni 'I
e
3d
4t r 2008 , nd ion tcal s û beaey
del
i fee 'o yi het
ndifrnt' nl f t
knowsofa dir r grr pondsunr s bl t a e e svers
nd segads o es
ea ona y o1 n xc s i ik
t i t he lhors ft 'Fame v. ema 511U. 8 8 ( 994)
o nmae at aey.' r r Brl n,
S. 25, 37 1 .
l cam ( ) Go d nalg st a alrh sam wa ij r di ata so icd n o
n li 4 , o ma le e h t fe i r s n u e n ry lt n ie t n
Aug t8 2011 a doc oror r d t tGoodm a s a' be x- a d,c usng hi t s f rpa n a
us ,
,
t
de e ha
n' l
m
r ye a i
m o uf e i nd
s f ng and t l e range ofm ot on.G oodm an as erst N ur Phi t coverup t f
uf eri
o os
i
s t hat se pps, o
he act
t tRed Oni di notha a X - a t hni i n on saf f s e tm e del ye f f m ont
ha
on d
ve n r y ec c a
t f or om i , a d or our
hs
be or m a ng a r nge e sf Good a t ha hi a m x-a d.Goodm a sal to
f e ki r a m nt or
m n o ve s r r ye
n' legai ns
sm pl do nots at s fci fact t supportal el ent ofa constt i
i y
t e uf i ent s o
1 em s
iutonalcl m r di t
ai egar ng he
del y i ge tng x-ays Goodm a doe no a l ge t tt doc oror r d a i m e a e x- a
a n ti
r .
n s t le ha he t
de e n m di t r y
afe t Augus 2011 i i nta doesnotdes rbe a s pt s f om w hi h Phi woul
t r he
t
nc de nd
c i ny ym om r
c
pps
d
ha kno n t tG oodm a ha a s rous m ed c lnee f a i m e a e x-ay. M or ove ,
ve w ha
n d ei
ia
d or n m di t r
e r
Goodm a doesnotalege a f c ss w i t tt d a i obt i ng t x- a pr ve t d t
n
l
ny a t ho ng ha he el y n a ni he r ys e n e he
me ia saffo p o i igt l a da p o raete t n frt eij r t h sa m.Be a e
dc l tf r m r v dn i y n p r p it rame t o h nu y o i r
me
c us
G oodm a s a l ga i nsf l s r ofs a i t ne es a y e e e sofa Ei h A m e m e
n' le to a l ho t t tng he c s r l m nt
n ght
nd nt
c a m r r ng de i r t i f e e e t a s r ousm e c lne d, he co ts m a iy di m i s
l i ega di
lbe a e ndif r nc o e i
di a e t
ur um r l s s es
cam ( ,puruantt j 1 5A( (1.Ana o it ode wile e t sda dimisngcai
li 4) s
o 91 b) )
pprprae r r l ntr hi y, s si l ms
( )a ( ,a dieci t cekt atmptsr ieofpr e sast Goodma sr mai ng
1 nd 4) nd r tng he lr o te e vc
oc s o
n' e ni
cl m s2
ai .
The Cl r i die t d t s nd c esoft sm e o a um opi on a ac om pa ng
e k s r c e o e opi
hi m r nd
ni nd c
nyi
or rt pl i i f
de o a ntf .
EX TER : Thi
s
/ dp a o J l, 2012.
g- d y f uy
Se ' rU nie St t s Di t i t dge
t d a e s rc
2 Thec r fndst a Go ma salg to i cams( a ( )s fiin l s pp the
ou t i h t od n' le ains n li 2) nd 3 u fce ty u or t
ee nt o p sbl c tt to l olton a to bl un rj 1 3 s a t s r i s r e ngu e
lme s f osi e onsiu ina vi ai s cina e de 98 , o s o u vve ce ni nd r
j l 5 b ( ) Se Hu o v. c ila ,50 U. 1 8( 99 )(idi ta whe imaecli ofie
91 A( ) 1. e ds n M M lin 3 S. , 1 3 fn ng h t n n t ams fc r
us exces vef ce agai thi i r i whet ofi tac ed wih a s fci l c pabl sae of
ed
si or
ns m, nquiy s
her fcer ç t
t ufi enty ul e t t
mi a d E t e jt al ge wr ng oi wa obe tv l hamf e g t e tbls ac nsiu i a
nd n wheh r he l d o d ng s j ciey r ul nou h o sa ih o tt ton l
e
vilton' (ne n q tto maksomitd .
oai ' itr al uo ain r
)
te )
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?