Goodman v. McCoy et al

Filing 13

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge James C. Turk on 07/13/2012. (kab)

r.FRKSOFFI I. DI COUA
l
C: .S, ST.
/
AT HOA?G E VA
tJKE,
Fl 87
L :7

I TH E UN I
N
TED STATES DI
STR I C O U R T
CT
FO R TH E W E STER N D I
STRI O F VI G I I
CT
R N A
R O A N O K E DIVISIO N

JUL 13 2 1
92
If
!;
?

TH O M A S L.G O O D M A N ,

.
'
'

CA SE N O .7:
12CV 00186

Pl ntf ,
ai if

M EM O R AN D U M O PI IO N
N
V S.

M AJOR K.M CCOY,c AL.
,

By: Jam es C.Turk
Seni Uni ed Stat D i ri Judge
or
t
es st ct

Dee
fndants.
t)
Thom a L.G ood a a V i g ni i a e pr e ng pr K , ie t s c vi rght a ton
s
m n, r i a nm t oce di
o f l d hi i l i s c i

purua t 42U. C.j 1 algi t tt dee ntprs ofi al a RedOni Stt
s nt o
S.
983, le ng ha he fnda ion fci s t
on ae

Prs vi ae hi c tt i lrg si s vea r pe t.Unde 28U. C.j1 5A( ( )
ion oltd s onsiutona iht n e rl es cs
r
S.
91 b)1,
w he a pr s rs s gove nm e of i al , he c tm us s r en a s m a iy di m i sa s
n
i one ue
r nt fci s t our
t c e nd um rl s s s oon
aspr c i bl a s torpor i t r t ti f i ous m a i i , f l t s a e a c a m .
a tca e ny ui
ton he eof ha s rvol , lc ous or ais o t t l i

Ahe rviw oft r or t c ts
re e
he ec d,he our umma iydimis cli ( )and( unde
rl s ses ams 1
4) r
j1 5A( ( ) de e Goodma sde ndf atmporr r tani or ,a or r sr ie
91 b)1, nis
n' ma or e ay esri ng der nd des e vc
oft r m a ni c ai s
he e i ng l m .

I hi compl ntGoodma alge furcli f rle :( )onAprl22,2011 Ofier
n s
ai ,
n le s o ams or eif 1
i
, fc
Belne ie l ij e Goodman' fng whieope nghi c ldoor ( onAug t1 2011
l glg nty nurd
s i er l ni s el
; 2)
us 0, ,
Of i e Loone yanke G oodm a sa m t oug t ta s oti hi c ldoorw iho
fc r
y
d
n' r hr h he r y l n s el
t ut

pr voc ton, usngij yt hi am;( OfiesStnlya M ccoyplce Goodma i
o ai ca i n ur o s r 3) fc r a e nd
a d
nn
am bul t y r s r i s f r 27 hotr w iho ba hr
a or e t a nt o
ts t ut t oom br a ,c usng Goodm a t d e a e a
e ks a i
n o ef c t nd

urnaeonhi ef a ( NurePhi deaye c ryi outad t ' or rf Good nt
it
ms l; nd 4) s pps l d ar ng
ocors de or
ma o

ha x-a ofhi a m . Asr le i t sa ton,Good a s ksa tempor r r sr i ng o de ,
ve r ys
sr
e if n hi c i
m n ee
s
t
a y e tani r r

$50,000. (nd)pema nt rnse fom t sr i ,l
.
00 a
r ne ta fr r hi egon.,

I o d rt saeacam i a yfd rlcvla to t ep an ifsita t a alg t ns
n r e o tt li n n e ea ii cin,h litf t l cu l le ai
g
o
m us be e
t nough t r i e a r ghtt r lefa
o a s i o e i bove t s c a i l ve , t one t ti d a i e o
he pe ul tve e l' o
'
ha s i usbl n
pl
isf c ' r t t n m e el ç
t a e, a her ha
'
r y l e va e. Bel At . p. Tw om bl 550 U . 544,570
conc i bl '
' l l Cor v.
v,
S.

( 07 .The eor,aplitf mus ç le f t s fce t saealheelme sof(hel
20 ) r f e anif t ç lge acs ufiint o tt 1t e nt t
a
cai ' Bas v.E.. pontdeNe
l m.
' s l Du
mour & Co.324F.d761 765( h Ci.
s
,
3
,
4t r 2003)
.

Tosaeac us ofa tont rj1 apli ifmus esa iht theha bee
tt a e ci mde 983, antf t tbls ha
s n
de i d ofrght guar nt d by t Consiuto orlwsoft Unie St t sa t tt s
prve
i s
a ee
he
tt i n a
he t d a e nd ha hi
de i ton r s t d f o c
pr va i e ule r m onductc m it d by a pe s ac i unde c o ofs a e l w . W e t
om te
r on tng
r ol r t t a
s

v. ki ,487U. 42( 988 .TheEiht Ame me pr ecsprs r fom c ue a
At ns
S. 1 )
g h
nd nt ot t iones r r l nd
unus llvi c to .Rho v. pma 45 U. 337( 981 . Topr aco tt ina
ua i ng ondiins
des Cha n, 2 S. 1 )
ove nsiuto l

cam rltdt a u s f j i c n iin panifmu ts o ta ted fnd n p io o fca
li eae o n n ae al o dto , litf s h w h t h ee a t rs n fiil
a tdwihd l e aeid fee c - h th o s ek e s be tv l,h c n iinp e e tda
ce t ei rt n ifrn e t a e r h n w, u j ciey t e o dto r sne
b
s t nta r s ofs r ousha m a ne t l s f ie t t d e o e m e ur ' t alevi t
ubs a i l i k
ei
r nd verhe es a l d o ake û as nabl as es' o l a e
r

i.Fame v.Brnnan,511U. 8 8 37( 99 .Si ene i ncebyofi as i f lngt
t r r e
S. 25, 35- 1 4) mpl glge
fcil,n aii o

p e it h t p e eo prs ne up n mih c us a imaeph sc lnu y smpl d e n t
r dc t a a ic f io q ime t g t a e n n t y ia ij r , i y o s o
gi rs t a co tt i lcam aci bl unde j 1
ve ie o ny nsiutona li tona e r 983. See e. ,
, c.Count ofSaca nt
y
rme o
v. wi,523U. 8 8 ( )(ûT1 Consiutondoe no guaa e duec r o t pat
Le s
S. 33, 49 1998 d( he
tt i
s t rnte
ae n he r

1 Th c r noest a Go ma sd ma d f atmpo ayr sr i ngor r(
e ou t t h t od n' e n or e rr e tani de TRO)mus b
te
deni Goodm an' alegatonsaboutpas event do notdemonsr et thewils f any i medi e,
ed.
s l i
t
s
tat ha
l ufer
m
at

ir paa l h r wh to ve i t a e c o t erq se ij c i r le .Se Fe R. v. 65 b
re r be a m a s e r n he bs n e f h e ue td nun tve eif e d. Ci P. ( )
(uhorzngTRO o y wh nt emov n pr est thewils fe i ne ,ir p r bl ij yi
a t ii
nl e h
a t ov ha
l u fr mmi nt re a a e nur f
ij nci r le i no g a td b f r t a e s p ry c dben tfe a r s nd .
nu tve eif s t r ne e o e he dv re a t oul
o iid nd e po )

ofsae ofii l;la lt f ne i nty i lc e ha i c t gorc ly be t t t es d'of
t t fc as ibiiy or glge l nfit d nn s a e i a l neah he hr hol '

co tt ina pr eci )
nsiuto l ot tons.

l cai ( ) Goodma alge t to Aprl22, 1 OfierBeli nedg
n l m 1,
n le s ha n i 20l , fc l s
ope Goodma s
n'l
c ldoorne i ntyta ng ( s rghtpi yfng rbewe nt doora dlwi
el
glge l rppi hil i nk i e t e he
nl ndow fa
rme

c usn ad e c ti (i)fng r' Co l2.Go d na s rst a t eij r c u e hi p i
a ig e p u n h s i e. mp .
'
o ma s et h t h nu y a s d m an
a s f rng a l sof s ns ton,a s sBel f ç lge .' O n t f c oft c pl i ,
nd uf e i nd os
e a i nd ue
l or s i nce '
neg
he a e he om a nt
t scl i f ist r s t c tt i lpr
hi a m a l o i e o ons iutona opori . Goo an hi s fc l Be ls a tonsm e e
tons
dm
m el als l ' c i
r
ç glge e,' nd a o f c a ' ne i nc doe notv ol t t i a e' c tt i na rght ,
û i nc ' a n f i i ls glge e s
ne
i a e he nm t s ons iuto l i s

e e whe ic u e ij r .AsGo d nfist alg a yfcss g sigta Bel ce wih
v n n t a ss nuy
o ma al o l e n a t ug e tn h t l a td t
e
d lb r t i ifrnc t ak o rs t a h wo l c u eGo d ns ro sp y ia ij r b
eie ae ndfee e o n wn ik h t e ud a s o ma e iu h sc l nu y y
o ni hi c ldoor G oodm a scl i a i tBel m us be s m a iy di m i s d,pur ua t
pe ng s el
,
n' a m ga ns
l t um rl s s e
s nt o

j1915 b)1,a lgalyfi ous
A( () s e l rvol .
O nl a pr s ofi i ' de i r t i f e e e t a i a e' s r ous m e c lnee
y
i on t c als lbe a e ndif r nc o n nm t s e i
di a
d

viltst eEih hAme me t S eEsel v Ga l, 2 U. 9 1 2 ( 9 ) A s fiin l
oae h g t
nd n . e tle . mbe 4 9 S. 7, 0 1 76 . u fce ty
s r ousm e c ne i t t tha bee di gnos d by a phys c a a m a tng t e t e tor
ei
di al ed s t ha s n a
one
e
i i n s nda i r a m n
one t ti s obvi t te a l pe s w oul e s l r cogni t ne es iy f r a doc or s
ha s o
ous ha ven ay r on
d a iy e
ze he c st o
t '

at ton,'kov.Shrve,535F. 225,24l( hCi. ) a aprs ofi i i t i rtl
teni 'I
e
3d
4t r 2008 , nd ion tcal s û beaey
del
i fee 'o yi het
ndifrnt' nl f t
knowsofa dir r grr pondsunr s bl t a e e svers
nd segads o es
ea ona y o1 n xc s i ik
t i t he lhors ft 'Fame v. ema 511U. 8 8 ( 994)
o nmae at aey.' r r Brl n,
S. 25, 37 1 .

l cam ( ) Go d nalg st a alrh sam wa ij r di ata so icd n o
n li 4 , o ma le e h t fe i r s n u e n ry lt n ie t n
Aug t8 2011 a doc oror r d t tGoodm a s a' be x- a d,c usng hi t s f rpa n a
us ,
,
t
de e ha
n' l
m
r ye a i
m o uf e i nd
s f ng and t l e range ofm ot on.G oodm an as erst N ur Phi t coverup t f
uf eri
o os
i
s t hat se pps, o
he act

t tRed Oni di notha a X - a t hni i n on saf f s e tm e del ye f f m ont
ha
on d
ve n r y ec c a
t f or om i , a d or our
hs

be or m a ng a r nge e sf Good a t ha hi a m x-a d.Goodm a sal to
f e ki r a m nt or
m n o ve s r r ye
n' legai ns
sm pl do nots at s fci fact t supportal el ent ofa constt i
i y
t e uf i ent s o
1 em s
iutonalcl m r di t
ai egar ng he

del y i ge tng x-ays Goodm a doe no a l ge t tt doc oror r d a i m e a e x- a
a n ti
r .
n s t le ha he t
de e n m di t r y
afe t Augus 2011 i i nta doesnotdes rbe a s pt s f om w hi h Phi woul
t r he
t
nc de nd
c i ny ym om r
c
pps
d
ha kno n t tG oodm a ha a s rous m ed c lnee f a i m e a e x-ay. M or ove ,
ve w ha
n d ei
ia
d or n m di t r
e r
Goodm a doesnotalege a f c ss w i t tt d a i obt i ng t x- a pr ve t d t
n
l
ny a t ho ng ha he el y n a ni he r ys e n e he

me ia saffo p o i igt l a da p o raete t n frt eij r t h sa m.Be a e
dc l tf r m r v dn i y n p r p it rame t o h nu y o i r
me
c us
G oodm a s a l ga i nsf l s r ofs a i t ne es a y e e e sofa Ei h A m e m e
n' le to a l ho t t tng he c s r l m nt
n ght
nd nt
c a m r r ng de i r t i f e e e t a s r ousm e c lne d, he co ts m a iy di m i s
l i ega di
lbe a e ndif r nc o e i
di a e t
ur um r l s s es

cam ( ,puruantt j 1 5A( (1.Ana o it ode wile e t sda dimisngcai
li 4) s
o 91 b) )
pprprae r r l ntr hi y, s si l ms
( )a ( ,a dieci t cekt atmptsr ieofpr e sast Goodma sr mai ng
1 nd 4) nd r tng he lr o te e vc
oc s o
n' e ni
cl m s2
ai .

The Cl r i die t d t s nd c esoft sm e o a um opi on a ac om pa ng
e k s r c e o e opi
hi m r nd
ni nd c
nyi
or rt pl i i f
de o a ntf .
EX TER : Thi
s

/ dp a o J l, 2012.
g- d y f uy
Se ' rU nie St t s Di t i t dge
t d a e s rc

2 Thec r fndst a Go ma salg to i cams( a ( )s fiin l s pp the
ou t i h t od n' le ains n li 2) nd 3 u fce ty u or t
ee nt o p sbl c tt to l olton a to bl un rj 1 3 s a t s r i s r e ngu e
lme s f osi e onsiu ina vi ai s cina e de 98 , o s o u vve ce ni nd r
j l 5 b ( ) Se Hu o v. c ila ,50 U. 1 8( 99 )(idi ta whe imaecli ofie
91 A( ) 1. e ds n M M lin 3 S. , 1 3 fn ng h t n n t ams fc r
us exces vef ce agai thi i r i whet ofi tac ed wih a s fci l c pabl sae of
ed
si or
ns m, nquiy s
her fcer ç t
t ufi enty ul e t t

mi a d E t e jt al ge wr ng oi wa obe tv l hamf e g t e tbls ac nsiu i a
nd n wheh r he l d o d ng s j ciey r ul nou h o sa ih o tt ton l
e
vilton' (ne n q tto maksomitd .
oai ' itr al uo ain r
)
te )