Rainey v. Zych

Filing 2

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 05/08/2012. (kab)

eœv soF eeu: Dimeoue
Fl
.

A R A il,A
T os v
Flr:
r l

I TH E U M TE D STA TES D I
N
STW CT CO UR T
FO R TH E W E STER N DI RI O F V I I I
ST CT
RG N A
ROANOKE DI I ON
V SI

MA 28 2 1
t
22
J A- (
ULI
:
)
BY;
D TY CLE K

C A SE N O . 1 V 00200
7: 2C

JO SEPH L .R M N EY ,
Pettoner,
ii

M E M O R AND U M O PI I N
N O
VS.

W A RD EN ZY CH ,

By: G l E .Conr
en
ad
C hi U ni ed Stat D i tri Judge
ef t
es s ct

R espondent
.

J e L.Rane af r i epr e ngpr K ,fl dt spe ii f a wrtof
os ph
i y, ede al nmat oce di
o
ie hi tton or
i

ha asc pus purua t 28U. C.j2241 Rane whoi i aceae i t Unie Stt
be or , s nt o
S.
. i y,
s nc r rtd n he td aes
Pe t nta y LeeCount i J s le, r ni ,c lnge t valdiy ofhi confne e unde
nie i r
y n one vil Vigi a hale s he i t
s
i m nt
r
c i i s nt esi pos d by a f r lc t n M i s i pon r vi w oft r c d, he cour
rm nal e enc m
e
ede a our i
s our .U
e e
he e or t
t

s ma iy dim is st pe ii be us Rane f ist de onsr t a e ilm e t r i
um rl s s e he tton ca e i y a l o m ta e n ntte nt o elef

unde j2241.
r
I

Rai y' pe ii a cour r co dsonlnepr det r lva pr dur hit y. I
ne s tton nd
te r
i ovi he ee nt oce al sor n
De mbe 2007,t Unied St t Diti tCour f rt W e t r Diti tofM is lie er d
ce r
he t
aes src
t o he se n src
s otr nt e

j d me ta an tRan y c n cighm o c n p rc t dsrbuec c i eb s , itiu in o
u g n g is i e , o vitn i f o s ia y o iti t o an a e dsrb to f
c ai bas a pos e s on w ih i e t di ti ut co i ba e, s e i hi t lf
oc ne e, nd s s i
t nt nt o sr b e ca ne s and ent nc ng m o ie

i io nt Unie SGt v. ne Cas No.6: c mprs nme . td es Rai v, e
06-r03079- - ( . M o.De 6,
DW 1 W D.
c.
2007) Rane ' die ta asa j2255moto we et uc esf ll
. i y s rc ppe l nd
in r ms c s u.
I Ra ne s c r ntpe ii he a s r st thi c i m en i unco tt i
n i y' ur e
tton, s e t ha s onf ne t s
ns iutonalbe us i
ca e n
lgh oft U nie St t Supr m e Cour ' de s on i Bl t v.Unied St t s
i t he t d a es
e
ts ci i n oa e
t
ae ,

U.
S.

,130

1 Se Unied St t v. Ran y, F.d581( t Ci. a 21 201 ) c r. nid 1 S. . 2
e t a es
ie 605 3
8h r M y , 0 , e tde e , 31 Ct43

( t 1 ,2 0) p t r h. e e ,l S. . (a 1 ,2011; ie v. td S ae ,Ca eNo.1
Oc. 0 01 , e . e d nid 3l Ct989 J n. 0
) Ran y Unie tt s s
034 - S- ( . M o. r 1 201 )
67 CV- DW W D. Ap . 4, 1 .

S.Ct 1 ( a .8, 0)t tilc t olt Rane srght unde t Spe Tra Ac
. 345 M r 201 ,he ra our vi aed i y' i s r he edy il t
d i t i lpr e ngsi 2007. On t sgr
ur ng r a oce di
n
hi ound,Rai y as e t t the i e il d t habe
ne s r s ha
s ntte o
as

r i unde j22 .
elef r 41
1
1

A dititcour ma note e ti aj2241pettonatmptngt i ldaeasntnceor
src
t y
ntran
ii te i o nvai t e e

c ci t es amotonptruan t j2255i ti de t ori fe tvet t tt lgalt of
onviton ml s
i ls t o
s tna quae nef ci o es he e iy
l i t s dee i ' Swanv.Pr se 43 U. 372,381( 977) A pr edtrl
an nmae'l tnton.
'
i
esly, 0 S.
1 .
oc la
i di ntt j2255r if s ha t saut oflmiai ort r l ag ns s ce sve
mpe me o
ele, uc s he tt e i ttons he ue ai t uc si
peiins doesnotrnde j2255r e çi de t 'o ûnefci ' Se I r Vi ,11 F.
tto ,
e r
eviw ûna quae' r G fe tve.' e n e al 5 3d
i
11 11 n. ( h Ci.1 .TheUnie Stt Cour ofAppeasf t FourhCicuiha
92, 94 5 4t r 997)
td aes
t
l or he t r t s
f
oundt tj2255i i de t a i feci t ts t lgalt ofa i t sc ci
ha
s na quae nd nef tve o et he e iy n nmae' onviton
when t i a e s ts i a t e pa ts a r by s
he nm t a i fes hr e- r t nda d
howi t t
ng ha :

( )a t tmeofc cin stldlw oft scrui o t SuprmeCour
1 t he i
onvito e te a
hi ic t r he e
t
esa ihedt lgaiyoft co ci ( s e ntt t prs rsdie t
tbls he e lt he nviton; 2) ubs que o he ione ' r c
a a andfrtj2255moton,hes tntvelw c ngeds t tt c
ppe l is
i t ubsa i a ha
uch ha he onduc
t
ofwhiht prs wa c ce i dee dnott beci na;a ()t
c he ioner s onvitd s me
o rmi l nd 3 he
prs ne c nno s tsyt gae pi pr sonsofj2255bec us t new r l
io r n t aif he tkee ng ovii
a e he
ue
i notone ofc tt i ll w .
s
ons iutona a

Se l r J ne ,226F. 328,333- (t Ci.2000 .
eneo s
3d
34 4h r
)
Rane c dha r s hi c rnts e tilcl msona lori hi j2255
i y oul ve aied s ure pe dy ra ai
ppea n s

pr e di .Rane sj2241peii doe no poi t a r e c ngeofs tntvelw
oc e ngs i y'
tton s t nt o ny ec nt ha
ubsa i a
ma ng i lga t c piet ta t i c i ba eort diti eorpos e st dr g wih
ki t e l o ons r o r fk n ocane s
o srbut
s s he u t
i e t dit i e a t co ti nota a e ofa s h pr e ntors a ut y n e
nt nt o s rbut , nd he ur s
w r
ny uc ec de
t t or m ndm e .
nt2

Theef e, ne f l t me tt J sa r t s t tj2255i i quaeor
r or Rai y ais o e he ones tndad o how ha
s nade t
2 Cerai y,Rai y' r i on Bl e i mipl , ast sdecii doesnotdecrm i i t
t nl
ne s elance
oat s s aced
hi
son
i nalze he

a t f whih Rai y wa c nvce 1 S. .1 45(idigt t i grntdt apa t t prpa e
cs or c ne s o itd. 30 Ct 3 fn n ha tme a e o ry o e r
pr ralmotonsi a crm i cas i notaut a ialy e udabl f om t Speedy TralActs 70-day
eti
i n i nal e s
om tc l xcl
e r he
i
'

tmelmi)
i i t.

i fci t t tt lgalt ofhi c ci hi camsc nnotbeaddrs e unde j2241 a
nefe tve o es he e iy s onviton, s li a
esd
r
, nd
t spe ii m us be di m i s
hi tton
t
s s ed.
II
I

Fort ras sae t c tdimis sRaney' j2241peii be a ehef l t
he e ons ttd,he our s se i s
tton c us ais o
de
monsr t t the i e il d t t r i r se An a opra eor rwilentrt sda
ta e ha
s ntte o he elef eque t d.
ppr i t de l e hi y.
The Cl r i die t d t s c esoft s m e or ndum o ni and a om pa ng
e k s r c e o end opi
hi m a
pi on
cc
nyi
or rt pe ii .
de o ttoner

ENTER:Ths V d yof y, 2012.
i
a Ma
Chi fU nie St t D i ti tJ
e
t d a es s r c udge