Rigole v. VA Doc Sussex I State Prison
Filing
5
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 05/29/2012. (kab)
CL S OFFI U. . ST COURT
ERK'
CE S DI .
AT ROANOKE,
VA
FI
LED
MAï 18 2 1
22
FNT HEWEEES ATS RITOFVI URT
I T U TT RNDITDI R CTCO NI
OR HE NISD T ES CT I RGI A
S
JULI
Dt
R
B'A C. 4 .
Y
RO AN O K E D I I O N
V SI
M I AEL A .R I O LE,
CH
G
CA SE N O .7: 2C V 00
1
230
Pett oner,
ii
M EM OR ANDUM OPI ON
NI
V A D O C SU SSEX I STA TE PRI N ,
SO
By: Gl n E.C o
e
nrad
Chi f Unie St e Di t c Judge
e
t d at s s ri t
R es
pondent
.
M iha A.li e,aVigi ai t pr e ng pr K , ie t spe ii n f awrtof
c el tgol
r ni nma e oc edi
o fld hi tto or
i
ha ascopuspurua t 28U. C.j2254.Ii e, sa c ce offrtde e
be r
s nt o
S.
tgol who tnds onvitd is gre
m tr ra s nt nc t lf i pr s c le
zde nd e e ed o ie n i on, ha l ngest va i t ofhi c i m e . Upon r vi
he ldiy
s onf ne nt
e ew
oft r or t co tc ude t tt pe ii m us besl ma iy dim is wihout
he ec d, he ur oncl s ha he tton
t l
m rl s s ed t
p eu ief rfiu et e h u tsaec t'r me is
rj dc o alr o x a s tt out e de .
Ri e sa e t thepl de guit i t Cic tCour f W as ngt Count t a
gol tt s ha
ea d ly n he r ui
t or
hi on
y o
c r offr tde e mtr r a on J 25,201 t Cour s ntnc d Ri et alf
ha ge is gr e lde , nd
une
0, he
t e e e gol o ie
s nt nc Ri ealo saest thedi no a ala ha notpr vi l tl d a ot pe ii n
e e e. gol s t t ha
d t ppe nd s
e ousy i e ny her tto
c le ng hi c
ha l ngi
s onvi to o s nt nc
c i n r e e e.
Riol sgne a dae t i tntj2254peii onMa 22,201 a t c t
g e i d nd td he nsa
tton
y
2, nd he our
r ceve a doc t d i on M a 24,201
e i d nd ke e t
y
2.Li r ly c t u d,t go e' s
be a l onsr e li l s ubmisonsa lget
si
le he
f l ngg ot f r i :()t e de wasi ufi e t s ppo tRi esc ci f
olowi r mds or elef a he vi nce
ns fcint o u r gol' onviton or
frtdege mtr rbe aus hewasi oxiatd'()co elwasi fe tvei fii t pr
is re zde c e
nt c e , 2 uns
nefci n alng o ove
RK
ta Ches e eo t eicd n wm i fc ( g l'jpa eo r sd n e' ndi fii t rq e t
h t t c n f h n ie t s n a t Ri oes lc f e i e c 'a n al o e u s
t
ng
l
atepa si t cin;a ( c e pr de i feci asit er r ngt guit pla.
rs s nsnzto nd 3) ouns l ovi d nef tve ssanc egadi he ly e
Unde 28U. C.j2254(9,afdea co tc nnotgr taha a peiinunl st
r
S.
1 e rl ur n
an be s tto es he
peii ha e used t r m e esa l l i t c t oft sae i whih he was
ttonez s xha t he e di vaiab e n he ours he ' t n c
t
co ced, o gi t sat c ur t fr topporuniy t a r shi c tt i lcai To
nvit t ve he t e o t he is
t t o dd es s onsiutona l ms.
s ts yt e usi r quie nt peii rmus s e r viw ofhi c am si t hi he tsa e
ai f he xha ton e r me , ttone
t ek e e
s l i n he g s t t
c u t t u id ci no e s c cams Se O' u l a v. ec l 5 U.. 3 , 4 ( 9 9 .
o r wihj rs ito v r u h li . e S li n Bo rke, 26 S 8 8 8 5 1 9 )
v
l Vigi a a trt tm ef diec a alt t Cour ofAppeasofVigi ahase r d,a
n r ni , fe he i or r t ppe o he
t
l
r ni
xpie n
i a e c n e us hi s a e c tr e esi one oft o w a Fis ,he ca tl a sa e habe
nm t a xha t s t t our em di n
w
ys. r t
n ie tt
as
pe ii wih t Cic tCour whe ehewasc c e wih anap alofa a s de son t
tton t he r ui
t r
onvit d, t
pe
n dver e cii o
t Supr meCo tofVigi a.Va.
he e
ur
r ni
CodeAnn.j8. - 4( ( ) j1 1411 I t atr tve,
0165 a)1; 7.- . n he lenai
heca fl asaeha speii dr tywiht SuprmeCo tofVigi a j8. - a( )
n ie tt bea tton iecl t he e
ur
r ni. 01654()1 .
W hi he rr ut he f l s he m us uli a e y pr s nthi cl i st t Supr m e Cour of
c ve o e olow ,
t tm t l e e
s a m o he
e
t
Vigi a a r ceve ar lng fo t tCo t f eaf r ldititc tc n c i rt
r ni nd e i
ui r m ha ur be or ede a src our a onsde he
meisofhi cai unde j2254.
rt
s l ms r
Ri e' s i sonsc e ry i c t t the hasnotpur ue s a e c tr m e es
gol s ubm s i
l a l ndi a e ha
s d t t our e di .
Ri ei caest thedi no e us saeco t e di bec us heûg )no be nabl t
gol ndi t ha
d t xha t tt ur r me es a e Ehas t e e o
ge a o it c e t a s e( qi flngc rcl ' Be aus ofRi e' f l et exha t
t ppr prae ouns l o sur he s ii ore ty.' c e
gol s aiur o
us
s a e c t e e e ,t s c t nno a es hi c ai s on t m e isa m us di m i shi
t t our r m di s hi our ca t ddr s s l m
he rt nd
t s s s
1 Aln wi t j225 peiinfr Ri l sbmisan rofatc nsa moi
o y t he
h
4 tto om, goe u t umbe tahme t nd tons
bearng t headt $1 Tl E SUPREM E COURT OF THE STATE 0F VI
i he
' tN '
ng:
l
RGm I .' The cour
A'
t
lber l consr d t e s
i aly
tue hes ubmi sonsasmotonsi ended f t scour. I m a be,however t Ri e
si
i nt
or hi
t t y
, hat gol
itnd dt s bmi t s do ume st t S prmeCo t Vigi a I t itr s o j sie t c r
ne e o u t he e c nt o he u e
ur of r ni. n he ne e t f u tc ,he ou t
wi drc teceksot t rtr Rioes r ia s b sin t hm,ota h ma sb th m t
l ieth lr ' f o eun g l' oi n l u miso s o i s h t e y u mite o
l
ke
j
t a oprat courq i hes desr Pettonerl advied t t tmet fl ape ii f a wrtof
he ppr i e
f o ies. ii
s s hat he i o ie tton or
i
ha e sc r st t Su e Co r ofVigi ai lmie b saue.S eVa Cod Ann. 8. b a o pu o he prme u t r ni s i td y tt t e . e
j 01
6 4( ( )
5 A)2 .
j2 5 p tto wih u p eu ie S eS a t nv Smi 40 U. 5 , 4( 9 )(i dn t a
2 4 ei n t o t rj dc . e lyo . t 4 S. 3 5 1 71 fn ig h t
i
h,
j2 5 h b a peiinmus beds s e wih u p eu iei peiin rha no p e e tdhs
2 4 aes t o
t
t imis d t o t rj d c f tto e s t rs n e i
camst t a opraesaec t.
li o he ppr it tt our)
Riol s te wihhi j225 peii ado l ntsyldasaC rtofCorm Nobi.
g e ubmitd t s
4 tton ctme t e
i i
W
a
s'
'
Fe ea c u t lc j rs ci nt atrtej d me t ft saetil o rsb wa o c rm
d rl o rs a k u idito o le h u g n o he tt ra c u t y y f o n
nobi Se Tho sv.Cunni m,335F. 67,69( hCi.1 (û r corm
s. e ma
ncha
2d
4t r 964) t or a
Er
n b s. . a no is u d rteisa t r c e ig. . o tej g n sa en ti tec u t
o i . c n t sue n e h n tn p o e dn . f r h ud me t r o n h o r
whihThoma ha peii d. Theef e,hec t l dimisRi e' r ques f co a
c
s s ttone '
). r or t our wil s s gol s e t or r m
n bsrle wi u prj d c .An a p o raeo d rwil su t i d y
o i eif t t eu ie
ho
p r p it r e lis e hs a .
The Clr i diecedt s nd c pi oft sme o a ' opi on a ac ompa ng
e k s r t o e o es hi m r ndlm ni nd c
nyi
or rt t pe ii ne .
de o he tto r
sxTsR:Ths A4Md yo y 2 2.
i
a fva , 01
Chi fUnie St t s Di t i tJ
e
t d a e s rc udge
3
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?