Rigole v. VA Doc Sussex I State Prison

Filing 5

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 05/29/2012. (kab)

CL S OFFI U. . ST COURT
ERK'
CE S DI .
AT ROANOKE,
VA
FI
LED

MAï 18 2 1
22

FNT HEWEEES ATS RITOFVI URT
I T U TT RNDITDI R CTCO NI
OR HE NISD T ES CT I RGI A
S

JULI
Dt
R
B'A C. 4 .
Y

RO AN O K E D I I O N
V SI
M I AEL A .R I O LE,
CH
G

CA SE N O .7: 2C V 00
1
230

Pett oner,
ii

M EM OR ANDUM OPI ON
NI
V A D O C SU SSEX I STA TE PRI N ,
SO

By: Gl n E.C o
e
nrad
Chi f Unie St e Di t c Judge
e
t d at s s ri t

R es
pondent
.

M iha A.li e,aVigi ai t pr e ng pr K , ie t spe ii n f awrtof
c el tgol
r ni nma e oc edi
o fld hi tto or
i

ha ascopuspurua t 28U. C.j2254.Ii e, sa c ce offrtde e
be r
s nt o
S.
tgol who tnds onvitd is gre
m tr ra s nt nc t lf i pr s c le
zde nd e e ed o ie n i on, ha l ngest va i t ofhi c i m e . Upon r vi
he ldiy
s onf ne nt
e ew

oft r or t co tc ude t tt pe ii m us besl ma iy dim is wihout
he ec d, he ur oncl s ha he tton
t l
m rl s s ed t

p eu ief rfiu et e h u tsaec t'r me is
rj dc o alr o x a s tt out e de .
Ri e sa e t thepl de guit i t Cic tCour f W as ngt Count t a
gol tt s ha
ea d ly n he r ui
t or
hi on
y o
c r offr tde e mtr r a on J 25,201 t Cour s ntnc d Ri et alf
ha ge is gr e lde , nd
une
0, he
t e e e gol o ie
s nt nc Ri ealo saest thedi no a ala ha notpr vi l tl d a ot pe ii n
e e e. gol s t t ha
d t ppe nd s
e ousy i e ny her tto
c le ng hi c
ha l ngi
s onvi to o s nt nc
c i n r e e e.

Riol sgne a dae t i tntj2254peii onMa 22,201 a t c t
g e i d nd td he nsa
tton
y
2, nd he our
r ceve a doc t d i on M a 24,201
e i d nd ke e t
y
2.Li r ly c t u d,t go e' s
be a l onsr e li l s ubmisonsa lget
si
le he

f l ngg ot f r i :()t e de wasi ufi e t s ppo tRi esc ci f
olowi r mds or elef a he vi nce
ns fcint o u r gol' onviton or
frtdege mtr rbe aus hewasi oxiatd'()co elwasi fe tvei fii t pr
is re zde c e
nt c e , 2 uns
nefci n alng o ove

RK

ta Ches e eo t eicd n wm i fc ( g l'jpa eo r sd n e' ndi fii t rq e t
h t t c n f h n ie t s n a t Ri oes lc f e i e c 'a n al o e u s
t
ng
l

atepa si t cin;a ( c e pr de i feci asit er r ngt guit pla.
rs s nsnzto nd 3) ouns l ovi d nef tve ssanc egadi he ly e
Unde 28U. C.j2254(9,afdea co tc nnotgr taha a peiinunl st
r
S.
1 e rl ur n
an be s tto es he
peii ha e used t r m e esa l l i t c t oft sae i whih he was
ttonez s xha t he e di vaiab e n he ours he ' t n c
t
co ced, o gi t sat c ur t fr topporuniy t a r shi c tt i lcai To
nvit t ve he t e o t he is
t t o dd es s onsiutona l ms.
s ts yt e usi r quie nt peii rmus s e r viw ofhi c am si t hi he tsa e
ai f he xha ton e r me , ttone
t ek e e
s l i n he g s t t

c u t t u id ci no e s c cams Se O' u l a v. ec l 5 U.. 3 , 4 ( 9 9 .
o r wihj rs ito v r u h li . e S li n Bo rke, 26 S 8 8 8 5 1 9 )
v
l Vigi a a trt tm ef diec a alt t Cour ofAppeasofVigi ahase r d,a
n r ni , fe he i or r t ppe o he
t
l
r ni
xpie n
i a e c n e us hi s a e c tr e esi one oft o w a Fis ,he ca tl a sa e habe
nm t a xha t s t t our em di n
w
ys. r t
n ie tt
as

pe ii wih t Cic tCour whe ehewasc c e wih anap alofa a s de son t
tton t he r ui
t r
onvit d, t
pe
n dver e cii o

t Supr meCo tofVigi a.Va.
he e
ur
r ni
CodeAnn.j8. - 4( ( ) j1 1411 I t atr tve,
0165 a)1; 7.- . n he lenai
heca fl asaeha speii dr tywiht SuprmeCo tofVigi a j8. - a( )
n ie tt bea tton iecl t he e
ur
r ni. 01654()1 .
W hi he rr ut he f l s he m us uli a e y pr s nthi cl i st t Supr m e Cour of
c ve o e olow ,
t tm t l e e
s a m o he
e
t

Vigi a a r ceve ar lng fo t tCo t f eaf r ldititc tc n c i rt
r ni nd e i
ui r m ha ur be or ede a src our a onsde he

meisofhi cai unde j2254.
rt
s l ms r
Ri e' s i sonsc e ry i c t t the hasnotpur ue s a e c tr m e es
gol s ubm s i
l a l ndi a e ha
s d t t our e di .

Ri ei caest thedi no e us saeco t e di bec us heûg )no be nabl t
gol ndi t ha
d t xha t tt ur r me es a e Ehas t e e o
ge a o it c e t a s e( qi flngc rcl ' Be aus ofRi e' f l et exha t
t ppr prae ouns l o sur he s ii ore ty.' c e
gol s aiur o
us
s a e c t e e e ,t s c t nno a es hi c ai s on t m e isa m us di m i shi
t t our r m di s hi our ca t ddr s s l m
he rt nd
t s s s

1 Aln wi t j225 peiinfr Ri l sbmisan rofatc nsa moi
o y t he
h
4 tto om, goe u t umbe tahme t nd tons
bearng t headt $1 Tl E SUPREM E COURT OF THE STATE 0F VI
i he
' tN '
ng:
l
RGm I .' The cour
A'
t
lber l consr d t e s
i aly
tue hes ubmi sonsasmotonsi ended f t scour. I m a be,however t Ri e
si
i nt
or hi
t t y
, hat gol

itnd dt s bmi t s do ume st t S prmeCo t Vigi a I t itr s o j sie t c r
ne e o u t he e c nt o he u e
ur of r ni. n he ne e t f u tc ,he ou t

wi drc teceksot t rtr Rioes r ia s b sin t hm,ota h ma sb th m t
l ieth lr ' f o eun g l' oi n l u miso s o i s h t e y u mite o
l
ke
j
t a oprat courq i hes desr Pettonerl advied t t tmet fl ape ii f a wrtof
he ppr i e
f o ies. ii
s s hat he i o ie tton or
i

ha e sc r st t Su e Co r ofVigi ai lmie b saue.S eVa Cod Ann. 8. b a o pu o he prme u t r ni s i td y tt t e . e
j 01
6 4( ( )
5 A)2 .

j2 5 p tto wih u p eu ie S eS a t nv Smi 40 U. 5 , 4( 9 )(i dn t a
2 4 ei n t o t rj dc . e lyo . t 4 S. 3 5 1 71 fn ig h t
i
h,
j2 5 h b a peiinmus beds s e wih u p eu iei peiin rha no p e e tdhs
2 4 aes t o
t
t imis d t o t rj d c f tto e s t rs n e i
camst t a opraesaec t.
li o he ppr it tt our)
Riol s te wihhi j225 peii ado l ntsyldasaC rtofCorm Nobi.
g e ubmitd t s
4 tton ctme t e
i i
W
a
s'
'

Fe ea c u t lc j rs ci nt atrtej d me t ft saetil o rsb wa o c rm
d rl o rs a k u idito o le h u g n o he tt ra c u t y y f o n
nobi Se Tho sv.Cunni m,335F. 67,69( hCi.1 (û r corm
s. e ma
ncha
2d
4t r 964) t or a
Er

n b s. . a no is u d rteisa t r c e ig. . o tej g n sa en ti tec u t
o i . c n t sue n e h n tn p o e dn . f r h ud me t r o n h o r
whihThoma ha peii d. Theef e,hec t l dimisRi e' r ques f co a
c
s s ttone '
). r or t our wil s s gol s e t or r m

n bsrle wi u prj d c .An a p o raeo d rwil su t i d y
o i eif t t eu ie
ho
p r p it r e lis e hs a .
The Clr i diecedt s nd c pi oft sme o a ' opi on a ac ompa ng
e k s r t o e o es hi m r ndlm ni nd c
nyi
or rt t pe ii ne .
de o he tto r

sxTsR:Ths A4Md yo y 2 2.
i
a fva , 01
Chi fUnie St t s Di t i tJ
e
t d a e s rc udge

3