Lovings v. Mathena
Filing
28
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 1/29/2013. (tvt)
ek'- : eFFl u. > e .eeur
e' ..
AT O y I e,
kk VA
J 21/ ;
l31 C
p
j
.
:
I TH E U NI
N
TED STATE S D I
STR I C O U R T
CT
FO R TH E W ESTERN D I
STR I O F VI G I I
CT
R N A
R O AN O K E DI SI N
W O
PA U L A . O VI G S,
L
N
Pett oner,
ii
M N DA LL L .M ATH ENA ,
R espondent
.
JuL .
MY1
w
DEP
RK
'
L
Ci lA c i N o.7: 2- vvi t on
1 c 00238
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
M EM O M ND U M O PI O N
NI
By:
H on.Jaclson L .K i
t
ser
Seni U ni e St t sD i t c Judge
or
t d a e s ri t
Pa A .
ul Lovi ,aVigi ai aepr e ng pr K ,fld apeii f a wrtofha s
ngs
r ni nm t oc edi
o
ie
tton or
i
bea
.
c pus purua t 28U. C.j225 compl ni abou deecsi pr - arngpr es l di
or , s nt o
S.
4,
ai ng
t f t n ehe i oc s ea ng
t an i tt i lcon c i Re ponde fl am o i t dimis a pe ii rr ponde
o nsiutona
viton. s
nt ied
ton o s s , nd ttone es
d,
m a ng t ma trrpef diposton.Afe r viwi t r cor Igr ntt m o i t dimis
ki he te i or s ii
tr e e ng he e d, a he ton o s s
be us pe ii ri note il t ha sr le .
ca e ttone s
ntted o bea ei f
1
.
On Ocobe 24, 0,ac r tona ofk e a t Re Oni Stt Prs c ge
t r 201
oreci l t r t he d on a e ion har d
pe ii rwih m a nga lwd orobs e a tt r a t rper o
ttone t ki
e
c ne c owa d no he
s n.Alhough pe ii ra gued
t
ttone r
t tde e t i pr - a i pr e e w a r nt di m i s loft c r ,t he r ng of i er
ha f c s n e he r ng oc dur s r a ed s s a
he ha ge he a i
fc
f
ound pe ii rguit oft ofe ea i
ttone ly he f ns nd mpos d a s nt nceofs ve days iolton.
e e e
e n
' s ai
Pe ii ne fl d awrtofha ascor wih t Supr m eCour ofVigi a,c
tto r ie
i
be
pus t he
e
t
r ni ompl i ng
ani
ofde ec si pr he rng pr ed e f rt Oc o r24,201 ofe e.The Supr m eCour of
f t n e- a i
oc ur s o he t be
0, f ns
e
t
V igi a di m i s d t pe ii be us ç be c pusdoesnotle i t sm a t r' Lovi v.
r ni s s e he tton ca e ç as or
ha
i n hi te .
'
nzs
W a d no t Re Onin SaePrs n No 1 2 2 , l o a 1( . . 0 2 2 (iig
r e f he d o tt io , . 1 3 9 si p. t Va Apr 2 , 01 ) ctn
p
Car lv. ohns n, Va.683,694,685S. 2d647,652(
rol J o 278
E.
2009).Peii rs e tyfld
) ttone ubsquenl ie
t s e com pl i sa
he am
a nt boutt pr - a i pr edur s i t i t tpe ii n.
he e he r ng oc
e n he ns an tto
I
I.
Re ponde fl amoton f apr e tveor rf pe ii ne ' r quessf ad isons
s
nt ied
i or ot c i de or tto rs e t or m s i
a dt p o u to o d c me t.Rue6o t eRulsGo mig j2 4Ca e r q ie la eo
n he r d cin f o u n s l f h
e ve n 25 s s e ur s e v f
c tf ra pa t t c
our o ny ry o onduc dico r No la ha be n g a e pli ifsr quessd not
t s ve y.
e ve s e r ntd, antf e t o
i
mpac t diposton oft saci a Iwilno a horzedic r Acc di y,Igr n
t he s ii
hi ton, nd
l t ut i s ove y.
or ngl
at
rs
e ponde ' moton f apr e tve or r
nts i or ot c i
de .
1
11.
lmus if uslont nee t enszet tsaeprs r us onl ha asc pus(
tçoc l he d o tr ha tt ione s e y be or or
smia sae rme iswh nt e se t iv l aet edlaino t i c n ie n - et r
i lr tt) e d e e h y e k o n ai t h t to f her o fn me t i
d
r
he
die tytr ug a ij ncinc mpeln s e irr la eo i ie tyt r u haj iil
rcl h o h n nu to o lig pe d e ee s r ndrcl h o g udca
dee mi ton t tnec s rl i i t unlwf l s oft Stt sc t ' W iki o v.
t r na i ha
es a iy mples he a u ne s he a e' usody.
' l ns n
Do s n, 4 U.. 4 81( 0 5 .Peiin rscams e e i s c sf lwo l no t e e s rl
to 5 4 S 7 , 2 0 ) t o e ' li , v n f uc e s u, ud t t c sa i
t
n
y
s ls edirr ea e'fom c t be us t pe t f t c ci wass ven da '
pel pe e el s ' r
usody ca e he naly or he onvi ton
e
ys
i ol ton, w hi h di notaf e tt dur ton ofpe ii r ss nt nc 1 Thus pe ii r s c ai s do
s ai
c d
f c he a i
ttone ' e e e.
, ttone ' l m
r lt t t dtr to ofhi c
ea e o he lai n
s onûntme ,do notlewihi çhec e ofha scor , a mus
nt
i t n ç or
t
bea pus' nd
'
t
bedim is .2 Se à.a 8 .
s s ed
ep t 1
a
I .
V
Fo t f egoi r as , gr ntr s
r he or ng e ons 1 a e ponde ' m oton f ra pr t tveor randm oto
nts i o
o eci
de
in
t dimi s and Idim ist pe ii f awrtofha ascom us Ba e upon my fndi t
o s s,
s s he tton or
i
be
. sd
i ng hat
' to g ptin ralj di teptto ta h l tg o c n uti ,h rcr etbih stapeiinrdi
Al u h eio e lee n h ei n ht eos o d o d ctmete eod salse ht t o e d
h
t
i
t
notf f i good co
or e t
nduc tm ebe us oft O c obe 24, 0,ofe e. Any cha i pe ii r sr t ofe r ng
tl
ca e he t r 201
f ns
nge n ttone ' a e a ni
goodconduc tm easar s toft i tt ina co ci doesnoti plc t apr t t lbe t i e es.See e. ,
ti
e ul he nsiuto l nviton
m iae oeced i ry ntr t
. 2.
Lu e v S ot71F.d 1 2 1 39 (t Ci.1 9 )(iigMe c u v Fa o 4 7U. 21 , 2 n8(9 6)
k n . c t, 3 9 , 9 -4 5h r 9 5 ctn a h m . n , 2 S. 5 2 9 . 1 7 ).
2Peii rscl m sm a bebr
ttone ' ai
y
ought i a alva4 U. C. 1 8 .W i - s n 5 4U.. ts .
, f t 1 i 2 S. j 9 3
,
li o , 4 S a 1
.n
k
2
peii rha no madet r quiies t nta s
ttone s t
he e st ubsa i l howi ofde a ofaco tt i lrghtas
ng
nil
nsiutona i
r q ie b 28U.. j2 5 () ac riiaeo a p aa l yi d n e .
e urd y
SC. 2 3 c , e t c t f p e lbit s e id
f
i
TheCl r i diecedt s nd aco oft sM e a l Opi on a t a ompa ng
ek s r t o e
py hi mor ndtm
ni nd he cc
nyi
Or rt peii ra cot e ofr cor f r s
de o ttone nd ms l e d or e ponde .
nt
ENTER :
Thi
w;da ofJ nua y, 3.
y a r 201
I
.
N
ni Unie Stt sDititJ
or t d a e src udge
3
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?