Sons et al v. Trompeter et al

Filing 8

OPINION. Signed by Judge James P. Jones on 6/27/12. (eot)

Download PDF
CL ERKS OFFI U,. ST COURT CE S Di . AT ROANOKE, VA FjED L J 2ï 2 : UN 22 JULI C. A I TH E U N ITED ST A TES D ISTR IC T C O U R T N FO R TH E W E STER N D I STR ICT O F V IR G I IA BK DE N R O A N O K E DIV ISI N O , CLERK C!FRK . . M A R TY A .SO N S,ET A L . , Pl ntf s, ai if Cas N o.7: e 12CV 00264 O PI IO N N PH ILIP T R O M PE TER ,ET A L. , By: J esP.Jones am U nied St esD it i J t at sr ct udge D ef endant s. l t spr s a ton unde 4 U. C. j 1 3 ( e t2003) t pli if n hi o e ci r 2 S. A. 98 W s , he antfs see t pr k o oceed i f m a paupe s. B as on t afi t fl by t pl nt f s i n or ri ed he tdavis ied he ai if n t s cas I w ilalow t Com pl ntt be fl w ihout paym ent oft flng f hi e, l l he ai o ied t he ii ee, purua tt 28U. C. j 1 5( ( )( es 2006) Howe r upone mi tonof s n o S. A. 91 a)1 W t . ve , xa nai t Complit 1fnd t ti i wihoutmei a wildimisi. 28 U. C. j he an , i ha t s t rt nd l s s t S. A. 1 5()2)B)i)( es 2006 . 91 e ( ( (i W t ) To sae a cam und r j 1 3,apli ifmus alge ( )t vi ai ofa tt li e 98 antf t le 1 he olton c tt tonalrght( by ad ron'aci unde c o o saelw. 42 U. C. onsiu i i 2) ç s ' tng pe r olr f tt a S. A. j1 983. Thepl ntfs camsa i tt de e nt f i f va i r a ons 28 ai if ' li gans he fnda s al or rous e s . U. C. j 1 5( )2)B)i)(ttng t tt c ts ldimisa a to fld i S. A. 91 e ( ( (i sai ha he our hal s s n cin e n f m a paupe i at any tm e i t cour det m i t t ac i f l t s a e a or rs i f he t er nes hat he t on ais o t t cli on whihr i m a begrntd) am c elef y a e . Fis,t pl ntfs camsa i tt sae co tj rt he ai if ' li gans he tt ur udge mus be dimis d t s se bec us çud a e a ol ey i a e j ges r bs utl mmune f rla lt fom da ge a ii outof o ibiiy r ma s rsng t i j cila tons' M ur y v.Gof Ci lAci No.6:0-vher udi a ci . ' ph f i vi ton 1 c 00026,201 W L 0 22921 a *2- ( . Va. une 7,201 )(ii Chu v f h,771F. 79,81 30, t 3 W D. J 0 ctng .Gr ht 2d ( h Ci.1 ).TheCompli alge nof cst two dove co t do ti 4t r 985 ) ant le s a t ha ul r me he crne ofj ca i niy.M uph 201 W L 229 1 a *3 ( i t tt do ti udiil mmu t r y, 0 2 30, t notng ha he crne ofj ca i udiil mmuniy ca beo r omeo y whe aj ge' a tonsa eno tke i t n ve c nl n ud s ci r t a n n hi j cil c pact or whe t y a e tke i t c ee a e e of a1 s udi a a iy n he r a n n he omplt bs nc 1 j iditon) urs ci . The cl m s agai t pl ntf M art A .Sons' courta ai ns ai if y - ppoi ed ator y m us nt t ne t f lbecause a prva e per ai i t son,s as a couruch tappoi ed at or nt t ney,doesnotac unde t r c orofsae lw a i ge r ly uns c ptbl t a cam br ol tt a nd s ne al us e i e o li oughtunde j 1 3. r 98 1 a * s e alo Hal v.Quiln,6 F. 11 11 56,n.2- ( t Ci.1 d. t 4; e s l le 31 2d 54, 553 4h r 980) (oncl ng t tc ta ntd c uns ldoe no a tu rt c o ofsae lw c udi ha our-ppoi e o e s t c nde he olr tt a f j 1 3 p pos s . or 98 ur e ) The cl m s agai tt Com m onw ealh of V i gi a and t Roanoke Count ai ns he t r ni he y D epart ent of Soci Ser ces m us be di m i ed becaus t e entt es ar not m al vi t s ss e hes ii e c i r d ç r o ' wihi t mea ng of j 1 onsde e ç s ns' t n he ni pe 983. Se Wilv.M i De ' o e l ch. p t f St e Polce 491U. 58,64 ( 989) s alo Doev.M uli ,No.2:0CV00 7, at i , S. 1 ; ee s lns 1 01 201 W L 2950385,a *1( . Va.J y 22,201 .I a to t camsmus 0 t W D. ul 0) n ddiin, he li t - 2- be di m i s becaus t e e ii ar i m une f s s ed e hes nttes e m rom an acton f dam ages under i or t El he event A m endm ent 1d. h . Fi l t cl m s agai t R oa naly, he ai ns noke Count al m us be dim i s y so t s s ed. A s a mu cpaiy,Roa nii lt nokeCou y c dbela eunde j 1 i t t o tttonal nt oul ibl r 983 f he t nsiui ly c ofe i a t of(ount e o sa e tke i f rhe a e ofs me munii l fnsve cs c yj mplyee r a n n u t r nc o cpa i iy orc t '' M ilgan v polc usom.' li .C# o wpor Nc 7 F. 227,229 ( h fNe t z 43 2d ww, 4t Ci.1 4)( i M onelv De 'o .Se s,436 U. 65 694 ( 978 ) A r 98 quotng l . p t fsoc rv. S. 8, 1 ). pli ifma esa ih t e se e ofapoiy orc t i s ve a wa : t 1 antf y tbls he xitnc lc usom n e r l ys t ) ( t ough a e e spolc s h asa wrte o di nc o r gulton;( t r h hr n xpr s iy, uc itn r na e r e ai 2) h oug t de ii of a pe s wih fna iyma ng a hort ( t o h a he csons ron t i lpolc ki ut iy; 3) hr ug n omison,s h a a f l e t pr ry tai ofi e s t tt nie ts dei rt s i uc s aiur o ope l r n fc r, ha ma f sll lbeae i fe e et t rght ofctze ' or( t ough apr tc t ti s ( r itnt ndif rnc o he i s ii ns; 4) hr acie ha s o pe sse and w i pr des ead'as t cons iut a ç t or us w ih t f ce of l .' Lyte o tt e cus om age t he or aw '' l v.Do e,3 F. 463,471 ( h Ci.200 ( i Carerv M o rs 1 4 F.d yl 26 3d 4t r 3) quotng t . r i, 6 3 21 21 ( t Ci. 1 ) Alho t Co ai c ans algai t t 5, 7 4h r 999). t ugh he mpl nt onti le tons ha R oa noke Count polci and pr y i es ocedur caused var ous vi atons of Sons' es i ol i cons iutonal r ght t e ar s m pl l tt i i s, hes e i y egal concl ons pr usi esent as f t . The ed ac s alegatons do not cont n any act f s s fci t s a e a pl us bl cl m f l i ai ual act uf i ent o t t a i e ai or r le .Se Ewig v.Sivou No.117683, 2 W L 1 92, t*1( h Ci.J eif e n li s, 201 9788 a 4t r une 4,201 ( 2) unpubls )( tngAs r.tv I al 5 U. 662,678( ihed cii hc o . qb , 56 S. f 2009). ) - 3- For t r he easons s at above,l w ildi m i s a1 of t f al consiutonal t ed l s s 1 he eder tt i cams ase td by t pli if. Purua t 28 U. C. j 1 c ( ( e t li s re he antfs s nt o S. A. 367( )3) W s 200 ,Iwilde lnet e r ie s pplme a j idito ove t pl ntfs sae 6) l ci o xe cs u e ntl urs cin r he ai if' tt 1 w cl m s and t act on w ilbe di m i s a ai he i l s s ed. A s at or w ilbe ent ed f hw ih. epar e der l er ort t D A TED : J 27,201 une 2 / / J es P.J s am ones U nied St t D i t i Judge t a es s r ct - 4-

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?