Southern Coal Sales Corporation v. Xcoal Energy & Resources et al

Filing 38

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge James C. Turk on 10/26/12. (med)

a

s OFFI u. . sT. URT
CR s Dl K
ATROANOKE,
VA
FI
LED

I TH E U N I
N
TED STA TES D I
STRI T C O UR T
C
FO R TH E W ESTERN DI
STRI O F V I G I I
CT
R N A
R O AN O K E D I ISIO N
V

2CT 25 2 1
92
J A .U
ULI
BY;

,CL
ERK
L
ERK

SOUTHERN COAL SALES CORP.
,
Pl ntf/
ai ifcount - e
erdefndant
,

)
)
)

Cas N o. 7: 2- ve : 1 c 00265JCT
M em orandum O pi on
ni

X CO A L EN ERG Y & R ESO U R CES,
By:H on. m esC .Tur
Ja
k
Se or Unied St e D i t i tJudg
ni
t
at s s r c
e

De e
f ndantc ount r pl ntf ,
/
e - ai if
and X C O AL EN ER G Y & RESO U R CES,LLC,
and ER M E TH R ASH ER ,

De e
f ndant.
s

)
)
)

Thi m a t r i be or t Cour on De e nt 'M oto t D i m i sCount 1 a l loft
s te s f e he
t
f nda s
in o s s
s 1 nd I
he
Com pl nt ECF N o.1 Pl ntf tl d a r s
ai .
9. ai if i e
e pons a De e nt ha r ple ECF N o. 29.
e nd f nda s ve e i d.
27,

TheCour he d a gument on t m o i o Ocobe 22,201 a i i now rpef de son.
t ar r
s he ton n t r
2, nd t s
i or cii
De e nt m ove t di m i st fa c ai i Count1 on t o gr
f nda s
o s s he r ud l m n
1 w
ounds Fi s , he a g
. r t t y r ue

t tPli iffie t plad fa wih t patculrt rquie by Rul 9( ,Fed.R.Ci P.
ha antf ald o e r ud t he ri aiy e rd
e b)
v. .
Sec
ond,t y c e t tPl i t f hasf l t pl d a a tona e f a
he ont nd ha a n if
aied o ea n c i bl r udul nts a e e be aus
e t t m nt c e
t aleg m i r pr e a i m a by Def nd nt Thr he a e no s a e e s of exi tng
he l ed s e es nt tons de
e a
as r r
t t t m nt
si
m a e i l f c s but i t a a e e t r t a t l or puf e y or pe t n o y t D e e nt '
t ra a t
ns e d, r ihe r de a k
fr
rai nl o f nda s
i e i t pe f m t c r t A c r ngl Def nda t a gue t t t s a e e s c
nt ntons o r or he ontac . co di y, e n s r
ha he t t m nt anno
t

s
uppor afa cl m underV igi a lw.
t r ud ai
r ni a
D e e nt a s m o t di m i s Pl i if s dur s c a m on t gr
f nda s l o ve o s s a ntf '
es l i
he ounds t t i ha not
ha t s
bee ade t y pl d a t t d e s c nnotbe a s r e as a i pe ntcl i ,pa tc a l i
n
qua el e nd ha ur s n
s e td
n nde nde
am
r i ul ry n
t a e e ofany r ques f r i i t f m oft voi ng of a co r ct Fi ly,Def nda s
he bs nc
e
t or elef n he or
he di
nt a . na l
e nt

m ove t dim is or srke Pl i ifs cai f at ne 'f s on t gr
o s s
ti
antf l m or tor ys ee
he ounds t t i ha not
ha t s
i ii any excepton t t r e t each part s d pay f is own atorneys'f so ast
dentfed
i o he ul hat
y houl
or t
t
ees,
o

entte i t r ove isf s
il t o ec r t ee .

Asdic s i de a lbel t Cour GRANTS I PART a DENI I PART t
s us ed n t i ow, he
t
N
nd
ES N
he
M oton t Di m i s Count 1 a 1 1 a diec s Pl i tf t fl an a e
i o s s
s 1 nd 1 , nd r t a n if o ie
m nded Com pl i no l t r
a nt t a e
t n f t n da a t e r oft s Or .
ha ouree ys fer nt y hi der
1
.

FA C TUA L BA CK G R O U ND

Ac e i t wel- e f c si t Co anta tu a t sCo tm us when r i o
c ptng he lpld a t n he mpli s r e, s hi ur
t
ulng n

a moto t dimis s Giraa v.J on,521F. 298,302 ( h Ci.2008) t fcsof
in o s s, ee ar tno ohns
3d
4t r
, he a t

t c e ae as f l : Pl ntf Sout r Coa ls Coporto (t ' i a Dea r
he as r
olows ai if hen lSae r ain ;
SCS' s
)
lwae
cor r ton wih is prnci lpl ce of bus ne s i Roa
po a i
t t i pa a
i s n
noke,V igi a,a i i t bus ne s of
r ni nd s n he
i s

mi nga s li c .Xc lEnegy & Re o c s(t oa1' a Xc Ene g & Res c ,
ni nd elng oal oa
r
s ur e d
Xc ' nd oal r y
)
oures

LLC (ole tvey t t l Defnda s' a e a Penns va a lmie pa t rhi a a
c lci l he t
xcoa
e nt' r
)
yl ni i td rnes p nd
Pems va a lm ie la lt c
l yl ni i td ibiiy ompa
ny,r pe tvey,a bot ha t i prncpalplc of
es c i l nd h ve her i i
ae
busnes i Pe yl ni Er e Thr he i a cii n a r i ntof Fl i a a prncpal
i s n nns va a. ni
as r s
tze nd esde
orda nd
i i
ow ne oft X c D e e nt aswel a X c lLLC ' m a gi pa t r he oal f nda s
l s oa
s na ng rner l
I Mac a J
n
r h nd une 2011 SC S a Xcoa e e e i o a s r e of pur ha e or r ,
,
nd
l nt r d nt
eis
c s de s
pur ua tt whi h X c la e d t pu c s c ofva i s c t c tonsi c r a n am ount a
s n o
c
oa gr e o r ha e oal
rous pe ii a i n e t i
s nd
a a c r a n pr c U nder t pur s or r , Xc was o i t d t pur has fom SC S
t e t i i e.
he
cha e de s
oal
blga e o
c e r

a oxi ael 3. m ilon t ofc a t pa SCS o r$560 milon f t c l wih a
ppr m t y 91 li ons oal nd o y
ve
li or he oa , t

1 S Pr e l ivok s t s Co tss be tma trj rs cin u e 28 U. C.j 1 2 be a e t e
CS op ry n e hi ur' u j c te u idito nd r
S.
33 c us h
pa t sa e c tz n ofdif r tsa e a d t eamo ti c n r e s e e dst e s of$7 0 0.
ri r ii e s
e
fe en t t s n h
un n o tov r y xc e h um
5, 0 ECF No
.

1 a !5. fnd n sd n tc ts t sCou ts urs ito ECFNo. , t!3.
, t Dee a t o o one t hi r' j idcin.
21 a

de i r pe i e ng M ar h 201 X c ,how e r r utne y r us d t a ce delve y oft
lve y rod ndi
c
2. oal
ve , o i l ef e o c pt i r
he
c r c ualy de i na e vol es oft c lunde t pur has or r .2 A s oft f lng oft
ont a t l s g t d um
he oa
r he c e de s
he ii
he
Com pl i ,SCS ha de i r t X c la t a ofa oxi a el 450, 45 t of c l whi h
a nt
d lve ed o oa ot l ppr m t y
856. ons
oa , c

wa al of t coa or r by Xcoa durng t t pe i Xc l wa oblgae t pa
s 1
he
l de ed
l i ha rod. oa
s i td o y

a oxi ael $45 m ilon f t co ,buthasonl pai a oxi a ey $ m ilon,a sil
ppr m t y
li or hat al
y d ppr m t l 20 li nd tl
owe a oxi ael $24. m ilon f c a r a de i r d.CountIas e t a br a h ofc r t
s ppr m t y
5 li or oal le dy lve e
s rs e c
ontac
c a m bas on t s f l es a a i i t d f iur st pe f by X c l
li
ed
he e aiur nd ntc pa e a l e o ronu
oa .
SCS f t r a l ge t tX c ls f l e t pe f r unde t c r c s a is co i ng
ur he le s ha oa ' aiur o r o m
r he ont a t nd t ntnui

( s a e a pr s ofpero ma e' ld SCS t a e t a nd t pur ha e or r i
s ur nc nd omies
as
f r nc ' e
o gr e o me he c s de s n
Fe ua y 201 a t e e Xc ls pe f ma
br r
2 nd o xt nd oa ' ror nce de dlne a oxi t l one ye r untl
a i s ppr ma ey
a, i
M a c 201 I Coun 1 1 tted i es , SCS a l gest tis own ç conom i s v vala t t
rh
3. n
t 1 , il s
Dur s '
'
le
ha t
s
e
c ur i
nd ha

ofisa fla e de nde hea l upon Xc lswilng st a ce t a o sofc t ti
t fiit s pe d viy
oa ' li nes o c pt he m unt
oal ha t
c r c e f undert pur has or r and t Am e d POs't tXco kne t s a t t
onta t d or
he c e de s
he
nde
, ha
'
al w hi , nd ha
X c lf t r kne t t is br c w e e c i dur s t SCS.SC S a l ges t ti a e d t
oa urhe
w ha t ea hes r ausng e s o
le
ha t gr e o
t e e i n oftm e f pe f m a e undert pur has or r and a ee t t A m e
he xt ns o
i or r or nc
he c e de s
gr d o he
nded POs

onl a ar ul oft sdur s ECFNo.1a !!5 5
y s es t hi es.
t 2- 7.
Co 1 oft Com pl i a l s a f a c ai .l t t c a m ,SCS a l ge t t d i
unt 1 he
a nt lege
r ud l m n ha l i
le s ha , ur ng
t neg i tons be w e n SCS a Xeoa r r ng t pos i e s l ofc , a heri r d as
he ota i
t e
nd
l ega di he sbl a e oal Thr s nquie
t how m any t of m e a l gi ala s t c ng c l SCS had a ia e f s l a t t
o
ons
t lur c nd of oki oa
va l bl or a e nd ha

Tlr s rr pr en e ç coul s l al of SCS' av lbl m ealur c la s tc ng c .'
ta he e es t d i
he
d el 1
S aia e t l gi a nd of oki oal'

2 I is Ans r and Count cl m f damages, Xcoalcont
n t
we
er ai or
ends t s
hat ome of t coaldelver di not
he
i ed d

me tt qu lt s ct to a s tf rh i te p r h s o d r a tus ha t b rj ce Xc l
e he aiy pe i ins s e o t n h u c a e r e s nd h
ka
d o e ee td. oa
f t alegest tSCS di nottm el delveratl sts oft coalor ed.
urher l
ha
d
i y i
ea ome he
der

ECF No 1 Co .a ! 1 - 1 S as alg st a Th a h rma e t e a dto a f rh r
. , mpl t ! 0 1 . CS lo le e h t rs e d h d iin l u te
r pr e a i '
e es nt tons
.
i l rs
. n e pons t SCS' a ki Th as r how m a t X c
e o
S s ng r he
ny ons oal
c d a wa e t pur has ,Thr he r po d t tXc
oul nd nt d o c e
as r es nde ha oal
c d ha e a qua iy pr duce by SCS, be us a
oul
ndl ny
ntt o
d
ca e s
Thr he s a e tl c n bu i a 1 be a e l ha a u i ie
as r t t d, i a
y t 1 c us
ve n nlm t d
m a ke pl ce'
r t a ';

i. ta Xc a h d wa (ijamao pa e i a dh d asg iia t
i h t o l a s sc
j r ly r n n a in fc n
a oun oft c ls e busne si Ko ea J pa a Chi
m t he oa als i s n r , a n nd na
ted up;and
i

ii ta h h d j t rtr e fo Asa a d h d c n rcs f r
i. h t e a us eu n d ' m i n a o ta t o
r
de i r a t r f e he c d pa SC S f r is c l pr
lve y nd he e or
oul y
o t oa oduc
t
t s a ed pr c s whi h be am e pa tof t pur s or r
he t t
ie
c c
r
he cha e de s

J.a ! 1 TheCo antalgest tt r prs nai weefle a t tDee nsma
. t 2.
I
mpli le ha he e e e ttons r as nd ha fnda t de

t e i od rt i d c S Srla c te e po t a S j si a l r l du o t m, n t t
h m n r e o n u e CS' ein e h r u n,h t CS u tt by ei p n he a d ha
i
e
SCShasbe ha
en nneda ar ul.J a ! 46s es t . t ! 49.
Z
I.
I

LEG A L STA N DA R D S
The pa tes do notdi put t a i a e l ga s a r .To s vi a m o i n t di m i s
ri
s e he pplc bl e l t nda ds
ur ve
to o s s ,

t pl i if s a l ga i m us d t t a c a m t r i f t ti pl us bl on is f e. A s r tv.
he a ntf ' le tons
t i a e l i o ele ha s a i e
s
t ac ' hc of
'

I l 556 U. 66 678 ( ) çtr uie t plitf t a tc ae fcs whe a e e a
gba,
S. 2,
2009 .i eq rs he anif o riult a t, n cc ptd s
l
tu t t$how't tt pl i ifhassaed acai e ilng hi t r le ,ie.t i a i lt of
r e, ha s
ha he antf
tt
l m ntti m o ei f . , he plusbiiy

e il ntt r i .'Fr ncsv.Gic li 588F. 18 1 (t Ci.2009 ( i I l
ntteme o elef'' a i
a omel,
3d 6, 93 4h r
) quotng qba,

556 U. a 678 .Addiinal Rul 9( rquies a pat t çsae wih pa tc aiy t
S. t )
to ly, e b) e r
ry o ttt t riulrt he
cr tnc co tt i fa ... Fed. Ci P. b)
icumsa es nsiutng rud '
'
R. v. 9( .

4

11
1.

ANALYSI
S

A . M oton t D i m i s as t C ount11
i o s s
o

A lho h t Pur has O r r i c t d t tt y a e t be gover d by N e Yor l w ,3
t ug he c e de s ndi a e ha he r o
ne
w
k a

t pa te a e t tVigi a l w gove nst fa cli ,snce Vigi a i t plce oft
he ri s gr e ha r ni a
r he r ud am i
r ni s he a
he
al ge wr
le d ong.The pa te alo a art a r et tVigi a1 w woul gove n t dur s c am ,
ris s ppe o g e ha r ni a
d
r he e s l i
and s t Cour w ila s a y Vi gi a 1 w t i,a w e l
o he
t l l o ppl r ni a o t s l.
A s not D e e nt of e t i pe n g ounds f di m i s ofCount1 ,t fa
ed, f nda s f r wo nde nde t r
or s s al
l he r ud

cai .Fis,Def nda s c e t t SCS has f ie t pl d t fa c
l m rt
e nt ontnd ha
a ld o ea he r ud ount wih s fce
t ufi int

patc aiy.Se Fe R.Ci P.9( ;Hars v.W e tnc eSa l Ri rCo. 1 F.d
riulrt e d.
v. b) rion
si hous vamah ve , 76 3
776,78 & n. ( h Ci.1
4
5 4t r 999)(dopi rquie ntt tt tcr t e ' rfr nc d i
a tng e rme ha he kicumsanc s' ee e e n
Rul 9( t taerquie t bepld wihpa tc aiya eûhetme,pl e,a co e soft
e b) ha r e r d o
e t riulrt r ç i
t
ac nd ntnt he
f s r pr e ai , wel a t i ntt oft pe s n m a ng t m ir pr e a i a wha
ale e es nt tons as l s he de iy he r o
ki he se es nt ton nd
t

he obti d t e '.The Compli hee ientfe Thr her a t pe s maki t
ane herby'
)
ant r d iis as
s he ron
ng he
mirpr s ttonsa f t rs ii whatheobt ne (n be fofXc )by ma ngt m.
se eenai nd urhe pectes
ai d o hal
oal
ki he
A s t t r m a ni r r m e s t Co pl i c t i a ge r l tm e f a e i whi h t
o he e i ng equie nt , he m a nt on a ns
ne a i - r m n
c he
f s r pr s nt to we e m a bu nota s cik d e,a i udesno r f r nc t t t a e'
ale e e e a i ns r
de, t
pe t at nd ncl
e e e e o he i c '
pl

oft rpr snttons I maybet tt fcspl a es fce t c y wih Rul 9( ,f
he e ee ai . t
ha he a t ed r ufiint o ompl t e b) or

pur e ofs r vi a moton t dimis Cf Hars n,1 F. a 784 (( c r s d
pos s u vi ng
i o s s. . rio 76 3d t
( ou t houl
A
hestt t dimisac antunde Rul 9( i t c ti stsid ( )t tt dee ntha
iae o s s ompli
r e b) f he our s aife 1 ha he fnda s
be n m a a a e oft pa tc a cic s a e f whi h s w ilhave t pr pa e a def e a
e
de w r
he r i ul r r um t nc s or c he l
o e r
ens t
3 See ECF No. 2la Ex bt A- (on anig tr nns a d Con to o Pu c a e, ic r ortd b
t hiis G c t i n t e
n
diins f r h s ' n o p ae y
'

r frnc it e c Purha e Or r) Baed on t s i s e lk y t brac ofc nta tcai a d
ee e e n o a h c s des . s
hi, t e ms iel he e h
o rc l m n
count cl m wilbe gover by N e Yor l Ast e ar cl m sar notchalenged i t pendi
er ai
l
ned
w
k aw. hos e ai
e
l
n he
ng
moton,t Cour ne notm ake t tde e m i i now .
i he
t ed
ha t r naton

tiland( t tpli ifha s tnta pr dic r e de oft efcs';Sc t GM AC
ra, 2) ha antf s ubsa il e s ovey vi nce hos a t.) otv.
'
M orc. LLC,No.3:0- 24,201 W L 33 8 a *8 ( . Va Aug.25,201 ( nyi
t.
1 cv0
4051 , t W D. .
0) de ng
m o i t di m i sw he e t f a alega i ns f ie t m e tt s cii r qui e e s s tf r h i
ton o s s
r he r ud l to a l d o e he pe fc e r m nt e o t n

Ha s butwe e nonehels s fce t pe m i t de e ntt r ie a de e e t t fa
ni on
r
t e s ufi int o r t he f nda o a s
f ns o he r ud

cli .Asumi t ar not howe r t Cour wilgi t Pl ntf an opporuniy t
am) s ng hey e ,
ve, he
t l ve he ai if
t t o
nm e is Com pl nt t be m or s cii i is f a a l ga i .A c di l t Cour g a s
nd t
ai o
e pe fc n t r ud le tons cor ng y, he
t r nt

t moint ds s Co n I, u ds se teCo n wih u p eu iet Plitf sa it t
he to o imis u t 1 b t imis s h u t t o t rj d c o an if bl y o
i
r iet cli a pla iwihmor pa tc aiy.SeeFe R. v.P.l (oursçs dfe y
efl he am nd e d t t
e riulrt
d. Ci
5 c t ûhoul rel

gv la e g a n )wh nj tc s rq ie .
ie e v t me d e usie o e ur s'
o
).
De e nt co e howe r t ta e
f nda s nt nd,
ve , ha m ndme wo d be f ie be us e n i t fa
nt ul
utl ca e ve f he r ud
cl i had be n pl d w ih m or pa tc art t a l ge m ir pr e a i do no g ve r s t a
am
e e t
e r i ul iy, he le d s e es nt tons
t i ie o
f a c a m unde V i gi a l w .
r ud l i
r r ni a They r l on Vigi a ca est tditngui h be w e l ulil d
ey
r ni s ha s i s t en i
unf fle
pr i es ors a e ent a t f ur e nt s'whi h t c l do not c tt t m a e i lf c s t t
om s
t t m s s o ut e ve s'
c ypi aly
ons iu e t r a a t ha

wils ppor afaud c am ,a t e e o pr e si f c s' whi h ca be a tonabl .
l u
t r
l i nd d s nt r e xitng a t ,
pr
' c n
ci
e.ECF No.

20a 6- (ii c es.The postt tt alege yfa e sae nt heefl i t fr r
t 7 ctng as ) y i ha he l dl rudulnt ttme s r al n he ome
cat y.
egor

The Cour diagr es wih De e nt ' c r c e i ton of t a lgedl fa e
t s e
t
f nda s ha a t rzai
he le y r udulnt
s a e e s Cont a y t D e e nt 'a s ri ,nota loft s a e e s a e s a e e sr a di
t t m nt .
r r o f nda s s e tons
l he t t m nt r t t m nt eg r ng
a i e of f ur pe f m a e,or m er C r de t l 'or S f r ' I t ad,a l s one of t
n nt nt ut e r or nc
e t a a k' s e y.' ns e
t
puf
t ea t
he

alge mir prs nttons M r Thr he ' sae n t thetha j trt ne fom Asaa
le d se e e ai - . as rs ttme t ha t d us eur d r
i nd
ha c r t f de i r a t r o e he c d pa SCS f is coa pr
d ontac s or lve y nd he ef r
oul y
or t
l oduc t s a e prce
t he t t d i s
whi h be n e pa tof t pur ha e or r ' i a sa e e of a pr s t m a e i l f c .A s t
c
cm
r
he
c s de s' s t t m nt
e en
t ra a t
he
Fourh Cic tha e a ne V i g ni 1 w Editnguihe be w ee a s a em e t t i f l e w he
t r ui s xpl i d, r i a a i s i s s t n t t nt ha s a s
n
6

m a a a pr s t tbe om e f s onl whe t pr m iorlt rf ist ke p hi wor The
de nd
omie ha c s ale y
n he o s ae a l o e s d.
f r e i f a t l te i br a h of co r c .' Ciy of R i hm ond v.M a s n M gm t Gm .
o m r s r ud, he a t r s e c
nt a t'' t
c
di o
.
,

I . 91 F. 438,447 ( h Ci.1 )( ai omitd) W hiei ma ha i e SCS t
nc, 8 2d
4t r 990 quotton te . l t y ve nduc d
o
e e i o t c r c s w ih Def nda s a w hie i m a have l d t m t bele t t
nt r nt he ont a t
t
e nt , nd
l t y
e he o
i ve ha

Def nt ha t ca biiyt meesispr s unde t c r t t sa e e by Thr he
enda s d he pa lt o
t t omies
r he ontac, he tt m nt
as r

t theç a c rcsf dei r 'i asae ntt t( alege wa û as whenmad ' Se
ha t d onta t or lvey' s ttme ha as l d) s ç le
h
f
e.4 e
'
tt l i notonet tonl be a flewhe t pr s fie t kee hi wor l fle,i
ts t s
.
ha y c me as
n he omior ald o p s d. f as t
coul s ppor a c a m f f a ul nt i e en . A c or ngl t Cour de e nes t t
d u
t l i or r ud e nduc m t
c di y, he
t t nni
ha

a ndm e woul no bef ie,a t tPli ifwilbepe te t a e isCom pli tast
me
nt
d t utl nd ha antf l
nnit d o m nd t
an
o
isfa c am .
t r ud l i
I s t Pli ifha al ged a sae e t tc d s
n hor, a ntf s le
t tm nt ha oul uppor a c am f r fa at h
t l i o r ud, lhoug
Pl i ifwilbe gr nt d l a t a e i o de t ad addii ldet ls tce t m e tt
antf l
a e e ve o m nd n r r o d
tona ai ufi int o e he

de ndsofRul 9( ,asstf t i Ha s n,s a.TheCour t dimis CountI- t
ma
e b) e orh n ni o upr
t hus s ses
l he

fa d cam wi u prj d c t Plitf a ii t fl a n n d Co lit wihn
ru li
t t eu ie o an ifs b ly o i n me de
ho
t
e
mpan t i
f t n da a trt e r oft s Or r
ouree ys fe he nt y hi de .
B. M oton t D i m i s ast C ountI l
i o s s
o
I

I Count 11 Pl i if as e t a ca m of d es ,aleg ng t t De e
n
1, antf s rs li
ur s l i ha
f ndant i pr pe l
s m o ry
e t d dur s i or r t g t SCS t a r e t a end t Pur s O r r . l t r w rten
xere
e s n de o e
o ge o m
he
cha e de s n hei i t

moton,De e nt co e
i
f nda s nt nded t tt Compl n f ld t a lge f c s s fcintt s ppo ta
ha he
ait aie o le a t ufi e o u r

d rs cam a tu ta i i s b e t od s sa. tby h we e ,h t c s su o whc
u e s li nd h s h t t s u j c t imislNo a l, o v r t e wo a e p n ih
De e d n srl weeb t d cd d a tes mmayj d me tsa e n to amoin t d s s.
fn a t ey r o h e i e t h u r u g n tg , o n
t o imis
o
4 The Cour alo concl s contar t Def
t s
ude ,
r y o
endant ar ent t t Pl ntf has adequat y
s' gum s, ha ai if
el

alg dta temirpr s n ainswe efle. No.1 Comp . t!48.
le e h t h se e e tto
r as ECF
,
la

S eKigv Do n e l c, 4 F. p 2 7 6 7 ( . Va 2 0 )( imisn d rs cam
e n . n k mws n .8 Su p. d 3 , 38 W D. . 0 0 d s s ig u e s li
purua t Rul 56) Ce e h Gp .l v.Ger cwa Co.LLC,32F. x673,a * ( h
s nt o e ; ntc
.nc. tonis nc .
App'
t 2 4t

Ci. 0 2 ( n bih d .I Ce tc tec u t fime t eg a to s mmayj d me ta ans
r 2 0 ) u pu ls e ) n ne h,h o r a fr d h rn f u r u g n g i t
a dur s c ai be a e a s m pl t hr a ' t dico i pe f m a e di not co tt e ç he
e s l m c us
i e t e t' o s ntnue r or nc d
t
nsiut t
t

coe cvecic sanc nec s ar f a c am ofe onomi dur s. 32 F.App' 673,a * The
r i r um t es e s y or l i
c
c es '
'
x
t 2.

c ur frh rn td ta t fo d r s t e s u d rVign a lw,to o l mu ta tra b
o t u te o e h t ç jr u e s o xit n e r ii a n t ny s h e t e
l
i pr r buti m us l ve t agg i ve pa t wihou an r as
m ope ,
t t ea he r e d ry t t y e onabl ale natv t t as e
e t r i e han o s nt

t t ec nr c.' I . q o igKi , 4 F S p 2 a 7 9 (mp ssi Ce tc ) l t i c s ,
o h o ta t à d ( u tn ng 8 . u p. d t 3 ) e ha i n n e h . n hs a e
'
w he he or notSCS ha a t ea ona e a t r tve 'ot r t n as e i t t a e e s t
t r
d ny t s bl le na i ' he ha s ntng o he m ndm nt o
r
t pt c s or r c nnotpr ry be de e ne a t di m i s l s a ,butt tas c oft
he t ha e de s a
r
ope l
t nui d t he s s a t ge
ha pe t he

cam h sb e p e S e Co l a ! 5 - 6 (le ig ta Plitf' G c n mi s r ia a d
li a e n ld. e mp . t ! 4 5 algn h t an ifs t o o c u vv l n
e
t t ofis a flaes'E pende he viy upon' or En l r pa tupon' Xcoa ' w ilng s t
ha
t fii t ' d
de
d a l
' t a ge r
i
'
ls li ne s o

a e t a
cc pt he mount ofcoa t ti c rce f 'a ist ompla ewihisoblgains' The
s
l ha t onta td or' nd t l
c inc t t i to .
).
Cour hasca e uly r vi d t Co pl nta t ar um e soft pa te a deer i st t
t
r f l e ewe he m ai nd he g nt
he ri s nd t m ne ha
t du es c am i a quatl pld a s vvesDe e nt moton t dim is
he r s l i s de e y e nd ur i
f nda s' i o s s .
De e nt r s d a a tona a gume f t fr ttm e a t he rng,a g ng t t
f nda s aie n ddii l r
nt or he is i t he a i
r ui ha
t ca l t onl r le t t c n be af o de a a r s t of a dur s cl i i t vo di of a
ypi ly, he y e i f ha a
f r d s e ul
es a m s he i ng

c r t( r,pr s bl t twoul bet voii oft a nd nt t t purhas or r,
ontac hee e uma y ha
d he dng he me me s o he c e des
whih we e t co rcs alege t ha be n e ue a a rs tofdur s.Defnda t
c r he nta t l d o ve e xec td s e ul
es) e ns
c r c l not howeve , t t Cou 1 1 doe no r que t r i i t f
or e ty
e,
r ha
nt l
s t e s elef n he onn of voi ng t
di he
Am e e s t t Pur s O r r , bu i t ad s e co pe a or da age . Be a e t s
ndm nt o he
cha e de s t nse e ks m ns t y m s c us hi

is wa not r ie i De e an s'wrte m o i ho ve ,a Pl ntf has no ha t
s ue s
a s d n f nd t
it n ton, we r nd ai if
t d he
opport t t r pond t i i m itng,t Courtdeclnes t grantr i on t s gr
uniy o es
o tn
i he
i o
elef
hi ound.Pl ntf
ai if
8

m a wih t co i r Def nda s a g e s whe dr fi is Ame
y s o nsde
e nt ' r um nt
n a tng t
nded Compl nt a t
ai , nd he
Cour wil e e t i a s e nt m oton t dim i s on t s g ound, s d t A m e d
t l nt r a n
ubs que
i o s s
hi r
houl he
nde
Com pl i s k r le on a dur s c a m o he t n a voi ng oft a endm e s
a nt ee e i f
e s l i t r ha
di
he m
nt .
C . M ot on t D i i s or St ke R eques f A t orneys'Fees
i o sm s
ri
t or t

Lasl De e
ty, f ndan s move t tt Pl n ifsr s f at ne 'f esbe src n fom
t
ha he aitf ' eque t or tor ys e
tike r
t Com pli t a gui t tPli ifha noti entfe a e pton t t Ame ia Rul t t
he
a n , r ng ha antf s
d ii d ny xce i o he
rc n e ha
w oul e il i t r c
d ntte t o e over is a t ne f e .ECF N o.20 a 11 I t ad,t û m erc Rul ,'
t tor ys' e s
t . ns e
he '
A
i an
e'
f l
olowed i V igi a, o dest tE tor y' f e a e no r cove a e by a pr ii ltga i
n r ni pr vi ha s t ne s e s r t e
a
r bl
eva lng ii nt n
t a e e ofa s c fc c r c ua o s a ut r pr s on t t c r r ' Rvde v.Pe r a 41
he bs nc
pe ii ont a t l r t t o y ovi i o he onta y.
'
r
te , 6

S. 2d 686,688 ( 1 ( tton omit .Si fc nty,Pli ifha notrs ndedt t s
E.
Va. 992) ciai
ted) gniia l antf s
epo
o hi
por i oft m oton t di m i sand no pa t r i e i a or la gum e .M or ove ,t Cour has
ton he
i o s s
ry as d t t a r
nt
e r he
t
r vi wed t a ho ii s c t by D e e nt a ag e t tt r ques f a t ne 'f e i t s
e e
he ut r te ied
f nda s nd r e ha he e
t or tor ys e s n hi
a ton i i pr r Se e. , C. Rit r Lum be Co. I v. Cons i ton Coal Co. N o.
c i s m ope . e. g. L. te
r
. nc.
olda i
,

1: 1
1 CV0001 2011W L 49631 ( . Va Oc.1 2011 ( s si r s f at ne '
9,
95 W D. . t 9,
) dimisng equet or tor ys

fesunde Rul 1 b)6);J Ta I v.W hia r No.2: v1 2007 W L 21
e
r e 2( ( ) TH x. nc.
tke ,
07c 70,
26300( D.
E.

Va J y 1 ,2 0 )(ti ig r q et fr atme 'fe u d rRue 1 ( .Ac odigy te
. ul 6 0 7 srkn e u ss o to ys e s n e l 2 9) c r n l, h
Cour G RAN TS t Def nda s m oto i of r a i s e t dim i s lofPl i if sr
t
he
e nt ' i n ns a s t e ks he s s a
a ntf ' eque tf r
s o
at r
to neys f s
' ee .

9

l
V.

C O NC LU SI N
O
Fort r s s 1f t a
he ea ons e or h bove, he Cour GR AN TS I PA RT a D EN I I PART t
t
t
N
nd
ES N
he

M oin t Dimis l i GM NTED wi u p eu ie a t Co n 1 a d GRANTED a t
to o s s . t s
t t rj dc s o u t 1 n
ho
so
Pl n ifs r que t f a t ne ' f es a i DENI a t Count 11 Pl ntf s l ha
aitf' e s or tor ys e , nd s
ED s o
1. ai if ha l ve
f t e da f om t e r oft s Or rt fl an Am e ed Com pl nt
our e n ys r he nt y hi de o ie
nd
ai .
An a pr pr a e or r s li s t sda
p o i t de hal s ue hi y.

ENTER:Thi f&
s
z

da ofOc o r 201
y
t be , 2.
u

n.J e C.Tur
s
k
Se o Unied St t Diti tJ
ni r t
aes src udge

10