Patterson v. Middle River Regional Jail
Filing
9
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 09/04/2012. (kab)
nlFRKS OFFI U. DI .COURT
CE S ST
..
A a * ,A
rx
v
FI
LED
I THE UNI STATESDI CT COURT
N
TED
STRI
s p gj 2 1
22
FO R TH E W E STERN D I
STRI T O F V I G I I
C
R N A
R O AN O K E DI SI
VI ON
%2
%U
BK
FR EDE RI H . TTER SO N ,
CK
PA
' Rg
c
E
>
K
C A SE N O .7: 2CV 00299
1
Pl ntf ,
ai if
M EM O M N D UM O PI O N
NI
VS.
M I DLE R I
D
VER R EG I NA L JA I
O
L,
By: G l n E .Conr
e
ad
C hi fU ni e St t D i t i tJudge
e
t d a es s r c
D ef
endant.
Fr de i k H. te s aVigni i aepr e di pr K , ie t scvi rg sa ton
e rc
Pa tr on, r i a nm t oc e ng o fld hi i l i ht c i
puruan t 42 U. C.j1 algi t thehasi quaea ce st me a heat te me a
s to
S.
983, le ng ha
nade t c s o ntl lh rat nt t
tej i wh r h i c ni e .Up nrv e o terc r ,h c u t idst t h a t nmu tb
h al e e e s o tn d o e iw f h e o d te o r fn ha t e ci
o s e
s m a iy di m i s
um r l s s ed.
Pat r o saeshi cli a f l :
te s n t t s am s olows
1nee t s e a ps hi t itf r m y m e a di or r . The do t c e onc a
do e
yc a r s o
nt l s de s
c or om s e
m ont b lha ye t s e hi be us t ls i t l ng. lha be he e f r 7
h ut ve t o e m ca e he it s oo o
ve en r o
m ont now a nee ps hi ti ca e f m y de us o lbipol rs hi
hs
nd d yc a r c r or
l i na - a e zophr ni
e c
ds r e .1f e ta myme ia n e sa en tb i me b t j i. .
io d r e lh t
dc l e d r o eng t y he al . .
Com pl2. The onl de e ntPate s na e i t M i e Ri rRe o lJ l A sr le ,
y f nda
tr on m s s he ddl ve gi na ai.
ei f
Patro se ta frt aVigi aDe t ntofCor to (
tes n e ks r nse o r ni parme
recins VDOC)prs f iiy t ot t
ion aclt รป ha
s
g )ca rc vepr rps hiti cae'Compl 4.
he n e ei ope yc arc r.'
.
Tosaeaca eofa tonunde j1 apli ifmus esa iht thehasbee
tt
us
ci
r 983, antf t tbls ha
n
de i ofrgh sgua a e d by t Consiuton o lwso t Unie St t sandt tt s
prved i t
r nt e
he
tt i r a f he td a e
ha hi
d prva i r ule f om co uc c m it d by a pe s a tng unde col ofs a e l w . W es
e i ton es t d r
nd t om te
r on c i
r or t t a
t
v. ki , U. 42( 988) Thec ti r rdt dimisan a tonorcam fl bya
At ns 487 S. 1 .
our s equie o s s y ci
li ied
pr s r a i ta gove m e t e iy orofi i li t c t t r i s t tt a ton orcl i
i one ga ns
m n al ntt
tc a f he our de e m ne ha he c i
am
i fi o , ai ous orf ist sae acai on whih r le m a be g a e 28U . C.
s rvol us m lci , al o t t l m
c e if y
r nt d.
S.
j 1 5 b)1 .
91 A( ( )
C algoveni bodi ... a bes die tyunde j1 f mo tr de lrt y,
toc
r ng es c n ued rcl
r 983 or nea y, caaor
o ij nci er le whee. .h a to ta i alg dt b u c n tt t n lmplme t o
r n u tv eif r . t e cin h t s le e o e n o siui a i e n s r
o
e cu esa polc sa e e , di nc r ul ton,o de i i of i i l ado e and
xe t
i y t t m nt or na e, eg a i
r c son f c aly pt d
pr m ul a e by t tbody' ofier . M one lv.Ne Yor CiyDe ofSoca Se vce ,436
o g t d ha
s fc s'
'
l
w
k t pt
il r i s
U. 6 8 6 0( 9 8 .Top o et a ag v r me tl n i , u ha al c l ali la l f r
S. 5 , 9 1 7 )
r v h t o e n na e tt s c s o a j i, s ib e o
y
c tt i nalvi a i c m m it by is e pl yee , a ntf m us s
ons iuto
ol tons o
ted t m o s pl i if
t how t tt e iy' po i y
ha he ntt s lc
w asS he m o ng f c o t c tt i na vi a i n. Pol Co y v.Dods 45 U . 31
l
t
vi or e f he ons iuto l ol to '
' k unt
on, 4 S. 2,
3 6( 9 ) P t ro f ist l kaj ip lc t a yo t alg dd prv to sa d a s c
2 1 81. at s n al o i al o iy o n f he le e e iain n s u h,
e
n
n hi a ui
fist saea a to a ecam a ans t ej i,whih i t onl def ndanti t sl ws t
al o tt n cin bl li g i t h all c s he y e
.
Th r f r,h c u t l ds s tec mpan wi o t rj dc .An a prpraeo d rwil
ee o e te o r wil imis h o lit t u p eu ie
h
p o it r e l
i s t sda
s ue hi y.
The Clr i die t t s nd c esoft sm e a um o ni n a a ompan ng
e k s r ced o e opi
hi mor nd
pi o nd cc
yi
or rt pl i if
de o antf
ENTER:Ths &- d yo Yu
i 1# a f v
'
w
-
, oj
a a.
Chi fU nie St t s Di t i tJ
e
t d a e s rc udge
1Patro salgainsas fit saea yato bl jl 3cam a i ta jiof a.
tesn' l to lo alo tt n cina e 98 li gans ny al fkil
e
Fis,Pa t s f l t alege f t i catngt hi curentment healh condii pr ent as i
rt ter on ais o l acs ndi i hat s r
al t
ton es s erous
me c nedf i dit te t nto difrn ac
dial e ormme ae rame r fee t c ommod tont tl ha rc i da t alo ta
ai ha z s eeve theji, r h t
e
of i al have ac ed wih delber t i fer
fci s
t
t
i a e ndif ence t hi needs. SeeEselev.Ga bl 429 U . 97,102
o s
tl
m e,
S.
( 9 )(i i t tt saeEiht Ame me cam,i t mus s w p io ofiilsdei rt
1 76 fndng ha o tt g h
nd nt li nmae t ho rs n fca ' l ae
be
i fee et imae ss rou me c l e ) W rg tv. lns 76 F.d 8 , 49( t Ci.1 5
ndif rnc o n t ' e i s dia ne d ; ih Coli , 6 2 41 8 4h r 98 )
(idi t a imae' ds gre nt t me c l ro ne r g r ngdig ossa c reo te t n
fn ng h t n t s ia e me wih dia pe s n l e a di a n i nd ou s f r ame t
do sno i iaet eEih hAme me ) Patro do sno alg t a h ha no i e t j i'
e t mplc t h g t
nd nt. te s n e t le e h t e s tt d he als
i
m edi saf ofany pari arment healh s pt orexpl ned i hi com pl ntwhatteat
cal t f
tcul
al t ym oms
ai n s
ai
r menthe
beive hene d .Se ond Pa tronh snoc nsiu in rg t b c nfne i a y pa t ulrj i o
le s
e s c , tes a
o ttto al ihto e o i d n n ri a al r
c
p io fclt Se Olm v. a ne on , U. 23 ,2 ( 98 )
rs n a iiy. e i W ki k a 46l S. 8 45 1 3 .
2
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?