Hockman v. Hobbs et al

Filing 8

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 8/10/2012. (tvt)

clEv s OFFI U.. DI COUR
CE S SX
AT ROANOKE,
VA
FI S
' O
LF

I THE UNI STATESDI
N
TED
STRI COURT
CT
FO R T H E W ESTE RN D I RICT O F V I G I I
ST
R N A
R O A N O K E D IV ISIO N
D O N NA A R EE D Y H O CK M A N ,

At' 12 2 1
l
22
JULA c, L
I D'
BK
DE

,

C i lA cti N o.7:
vi
on
12cv00312

Pl nt f
ai i f,
M EM O M N D U M O PINIO N

W EN D Y H O BB S & M A R SH A G A R ST,
C OM M ONW EALTH' A TTORNEY,
S
D ef
endant
s.

By:Sam uelG .W ison
l
U nied St es D i ri Judge
t
at
st ct

Pl ntf Dor a J Re y Hoc a a Vi gi a i a e pr e ngrr s ,orgi l
ai if m . ed
km n, r ni nm t oce di
/ e i naly

b o g tti a to f rd ma e a ij n tv r l fa ans W e d Ho b ,hef r rwad n
r u h h s cin o a g s nd nu cie ei g i t n y b s t o me r e
e
ofFl nna Cor ec i lFac lt f W om e a M a s Ga s , he Com m onwea t sAtonw y
uvn
r tona
iiy or
n, nd r ha r t t
lh' t
f Roc ng m Count t r e s a l ge vi a i ofhe Fi s ,Four h,Si h,Ei h,a
or ki ha
y, o edr s le d ol tons
r rt
t xt ght nd
Foure t Am e
t en h
ndm e r ght , w e lasvi a i nsofç der land St t W a r nt La s ' nd
nt i s as l
ol to
t
Fe a
a e ra y w 'a

t Ameia wihDia ltesAc,42U. C.j1 01e s q.Amongot t ngs Hoc n
he rc ns t sbiii t
S. 21 t e
her hi , kma
a l ge t tt def ndant i e f r d w ih herl w s t 'i lc e c ela unus lpuni hm e ;
le d ha he e
s nt r e e t
a uis nf i t d nz nd
,
ua
s nt

s b e tdh rt u r a o a l lvngc n i o s o fn e h rfe d msofs e c e p e so
u j ce e o n e s n b e ii o dt n ; fe d d e r e o
i
p e h, x rs in,
a c c ;f s l ac us d he ofr l s vi a i ns dicrm i t a ns he ;a i pos d t x
nd hoi e al e y c e r u e ol to ; s i na ed gai t r nd m e d
e

p s fcoj d me t'
ot at u g n .
'
On J y 1 201 t c te e ed a m e or ndum o ni and or rdi m i s ng
ul 7, 2, he our nt r
m a
pi on
de s s i

Ho k n' camswih u prj diefrfiigt pe ds fiin f csi t ers p r.OnJ l
c ma s li
t o t eu c o aln o la u fce t a t n h i u po t
uy
25 h, oc a s n a l te t t c ts ki pe s i n t a f t ls
t H km n e t e t r o he our ee ng nui s o o dd ac ua uppor t he c a m s
to r li
and r s i he c pl i . The c tc t ue Hockm a s l te a a m o i n t n e
e ubm t r om a nt
our ons r s
n' e t r s
t o o m nd

purua t Fedea Rul ofCi lPr ed e59() Nohi i t c tsJ y 1 hopi onwas
s nt o
rl e
vi oc ur e . t ng n he our' ul 7t ni

cL RK

i e d t pr ven Hoc a fom flng ane c
ntnde o e t km n r ii
w ompli tc ani c e f c ua s ppo t
a n ont i ng oher nt a t l u r
f e c ofherc ai s butH oc a hasof e ed no a tona f t he e a t co tt r o e
or a h
lm ,
km n
fr
ddii l ac s r , nd he ur he ef r

dic r noba i f grntnghe Rul 59()motont n nda t stme.Ac or ngl t
sens
ss or a i r e e
i o me t hi i
c di y,he
courtdeni H ockm an, m oton.1
es
s
i

The Cl r i di e t d t s nd a co oft s m e o a
ek s r ce o e
py hi m r ndum o ni n a t a co pa ng
pi o nd he c m nyi

or rt t pli if
de o he antf .
EN TER : ugus 1 201
A
t 0, 2.

r

UN I
TED STATES D I
STRI J D GE
CT U

' c uetec u t imisdHo k n' c mpan wi u peudc ,h i fe a a ytmet ra py
Bea s h o r ds se c ma s o lit t t rj ie se s re t n i o e p l
ho
fri omapa pe i sausa dfl an w c mplit l h v r Ho k nwih st fl an w c mplit se
o nf r
u rs tt n i e o an. t owe e, c ma s e o ie e o an, h
e
l
m us ale ie
t lge çnough f t t sat acai t r i t i plusbl on isf e. Giraanov. ol on,52lF.
acs o t e l m o elef hat s a i e t ac ' ar t
'
J ms
3d

2 8 3 2(t Ci. 0 )( u tn Bel lCop. Two l, 5 U. 5 4, 7 ( 0 ).A c u t s, ta
9 , 0 4h r2 08 q oig lAt. r v. mby 5 0 S. 4 5 0 20 7) o r mu ta

mii m, ea et dsenfo tec mplith jatsb igse adt alg dc n uto whihec cam
nmu b bl o icr rm h o an te ri en ud n he lee o d c n c ah li
e

rss Th sa d r d ma d g nea c hee c , n ld e n trq r c t' toc nueu q eto sn v r
et. e tn ad e n s e rl o rn e a d t o s o e uie out ç o j r p u sin e e
st
suaeypee tdt t m. Be u etv Ci o Ha tn 7 5F.d1 7 ,1 78(t Ci. 9 5.Dititc u tae
q rl r sne o he ' a d t . w f mpo , 7 2 2 4 2 4h r 1 8 ) src o rs r
'
r r dt r ew prs rc pli sf c pla ew iht bascr l ofpladi a i doi s t cou t
equie o evi
ione om ant or om inc t he i ues
e ng, nd,n ng o,he r
mus eihertde iy c z ecai ordimist c
t t ç ntf ogniabl l ms
i
s s he omplit...ft compli ... al t saeacli u n
an
i he
ant f is o tt
am po

whc rle ma bega td' 2 U. C. 1 5 b)
ih eif y rne . 8 S. j 91 A( .
'