Karavias v. Commonwealth Of Virginia et al

Filing 13

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 10/11/12. (tvt)

ctenx' orFl u s Dl cour
s
cE
sm
,

,

A D N l iy
T l vt s
k

.

IN TH E UN ITED STA TES D ISTR ICT C O UR T
FO R TH E W ESTE RN D I
STRI O F V I G I I
CT
R N A
RO AN O K E D IVISIO N
JA SO N S.I M VIA S,I
G
I,
Pl ntf
ai if,

COM M ONW EALTH OF
V IR G I IA,etal,
N
.
Defendant
s.

)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)

soo. >
kc

0CT 1 1 2 1
22
dUL C. DL CL RK
D EX
-,
DEPUW CL

4.

Ci lA cton No.7: cvvi
i
12- 00326
M EM O R AN D UM O PI IO N
N
By:

H on.Jacks L.K i
on
ser
Se or Uni e St t s Di t i Judge
ni
t d a e sr d

J on S. a a a ,1 ,a V i g ni i a e pr ee ng pr K ,f l a c vi r ght Com pl i t
as
K r vi s I
r i a nm t oc di
o
ied i l i s
an
a r que t l ave t pr ee w iho pr pa e oft t lng f e,pur ua t 28 U . C .
nd e s ed e
o oc d t ut e ym nt he i i e
s nt o
S.

j1915()2) ByOr re eedonAugus 2, 2,heco tdiecedpl ntf t fl c rii
a( .
de ntr
t 201 t ur r t ai if o ie e tfed
i t tus ac ountr cor f t sx- ont pe i be or J y 201 wihi ffee da .
mna e r t c
e ds or he i m h r od f e ul
2 t n i t n ys

Pl i ifs e nty fl d aM oton t Compe a Or rfom t Cour,as ng t co tt
antf ubs que l ie
i o
l n de r he
t ki he ur o
or runknow n pr s of i i l a t Re Oni St t Pr s n,W a l nsRi St t Prs n, nd
de
i on fc a s t he d
on a e i o
le
dge a e i o a

Powha a Coreci lCe e t tl pli ifsfna i ldaaon hi be fbe us pl itf f t
t n r tona nt r o ie antf i nc a t
s hal ca e an if el
t pr e sw ast s r s f and bur ns e. The M agi ta e J
he oc s
oo t e s ul
de om
s r t udge lbe a l c t u d t
i r ly ons r e he

r ques a an e e i oftm et compl wih t Augus 2,201 Or rand gr nt d pli tf
e t s xt nson i o
y t he
t
2, de
a e a n if
t ry a tonalda Pli ifç ppea s' h M a sr t J
hit ddii
ys. a ntf t
a
l't e gita e udge' Or rf m et r viw .
s de or
o e e

A Ditit ud ema ûe o sd ra p era matrgeer dt ama itaej d e
src J g y ' c n ie ny r til te rfre o
r
gsrt u g l
wh r ih sb e s o t a t . .L gsr t j d es o d ri ce rye r n o so c nrr t
ee t a e n h wn h t he . ma itae u g ') r e s lal ro e u r o tay o
lw. 28U. C.5636( ( )A) Pli ifa g t tma nghi pr det fna ildaa
a '
'
S.
b)1( . antf r ues ha ki m ovi he i nca t
e us l ue s r s ' a he r a onst tt co ti r s
a es l
und t es ,' nd
es
ha he ur s e pons bl f rr c rng t da a f om
i e o e ove i he t r
t s a ount ofic r be us i i t e c t notpl i tf , ho w a st i or a i . Pl i if
nl t cc
s t e s ca e t s h our ,
a n if w
nt he nf m ton a ntf

a s be ivesi i unf i f t c t o c gehi $350 f a cvi aci a t n m a hi
lo le t s a r or he our t har m
or i l ton nd he
ke m

pa f c esa posa t r ove a fl t fna i lda a.Pl ntf f t fl d as c md
y or opi nd tge o ec r nd ie he i nc a t
ai if urher ie e c
M oton t Com pe a O r rf om t Cou tt r cove t fna a da a f om s a e of i i l f
i o
l n de r he
r o e
r he i nci l t r
t t fc a s or
t s er
he am easonsnot i t Sappeal'
ed n he t
.'

Pl i iff l t e t bls t tt M ag s r t J
a ntf ais o s a i h ha he
i t a e udge' or rw a c e r y e r ous or
s de s l a l r one
c r r t l w . The M agit a e J
ont a y o a
s r t udge' or rm er l gr nt d pl i i ft ry a tona d t
s de
e y a e a ntf hi t ddii l ays o
rc
e overt r qui ie fna a do e s Furhe m or t s a ut a l w i pl ntf t
he e s t i nci l cum nt . t r e, he t t e lo ng ai if he

prvie ofpr edi wihoutprpa ngt $350fer uiesai ioner...gojs ta
i lge oce ng t
e yi he
e eq r t s
pr
t ubmi
c r ii c oft tus f a ountsa e e ... ort prs rf t 6- ont pe i
e tfed opy he r t und cc
t t m nt f he i one or he m h r od

i me ael pr e ng t tlngoft c pli ornotc ofa al obt i d fo t
m di t y e edi he ii
he om ant
i e ppe , ane r m he
a opra e ofi i ofea h pr s a w hi h t pr s r i o wasconfned.' 28 U . C.
ppr i t t c al
c i on t c he i one s r
i '
S.

j1 5 a ( (mpha i a )
91 A()2) e
ss dded .Thus i i pli ifsoblgai t tl t ne sa yfna il
,t s antf' i ton o ie he ce sr i nca
doc nt , t c t a pl i ifm a pa t e ie $350 flng f e whe flng aco ant
ume s not he our, nd antf y y he ntr
ii e
n ii
mpli
i he tnds i t s r s ulor b de om e t r c r tna i ld um e sf om pr s n ofi i l .
f i
t oo tes f
ur ns
o e ove i nc a oc nt r
i o tc a s
A c di y,pl ntf ' û ppe ' a M o i t Com pel whi h r ie a e t a gum e t no e i
cor ngl ai if s t al' nd tons o
a
, c e t r t he r
ns td n
t dappeal' ar deni
he d
,' e
ed.

M o et 45 da ha elps d,a pli ifha notr q sedm or tm eorc
r han
ys ve a e nd antf s
e ue t
ei
omple
id
w ih t Augus 2,201 O r r w hi wa ne t ta f l e t c pl w oul r s ti di m i s l
t he
t
2, de , ch r d ha aiur o om y
d e ul n s s a

o ti a t nwih u p eu c . Ac o di l , 1 imist ea to wi o tp eu iea d srke
f h s ci t o t rj die1 c r ng y d s s h ci n t u rj d c n ti
o
h
t c e f om t a i doc oft c t Pl i ifm a r ie t c ai si a s pa a e a ton
he as r he ctve ket he our . a ntf y efl he l m n e r t c i

oncepli ifi pr pa e t pa t $350 flng f eortl t ne s a y doc e st pr ee
a ntf s e r d o y he
ii e ie he ce s r
um nt o oc d
w ihoutpr
t
epayi t flng f
ng he ii ee.

1Pl ntf tld unc tfe c esofi aetus ac untsatm e sfom M a c ,A prl M a J
ai if se
eriid opi
nm t r t co t e nt r
rh
i, y, une,J y,
ul and
A ugus 201
t 2.

The Cl r i die t d t s nd a co oft sM e or ndum Opi on a a om pan ng
ek s rce o e
py hi m a
ni nd cc
yi
Or ert pl ntf .
d o ai i f

E E T i l'# dyo- tb r2 1.
NT R: hs l x a foco e, 02
'
#
F

e r Unied St t sD i t i tJ
ni
t
a e s rc udge