Dodson v. United States District Court
Filing
4
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge James C. Turk on 08/31/2012. (kab)
*
a wwm oFnc: t.s. sm
l Dl
AT ROANOKE,
VA
Fl ED
t
I TH E UN I
N
TED STATES DI
STR I C O U R T
CT
FO R TH E W E STER N D I
STRI T O F VI G I I
C
R N A
R O A N OK E DI SI N
VI O
R ALEIG H D O D SO N ,
s 2i 2 1
EP
22
JUL
I
BK
D DL -N , CL
L
.
CA SE N O .7:
12CV 00361
C EM
Pett oner,
ii
M EM O M N DU M O PIN I N
O
U NITED STA TES DISTRIC T CO UR T,
By: Jam es C.Turk
Se or Uni e St t sD i t c Judge
ni
t d a e s ri t
R es
pondent
.
Raei Dods a Vigi ai t pr ee ng p o K ,fld t spe ii f awrtof
l gh
on, r ni nma e oc di r
ie hi tton or i
ha scor ,purua t 28U. C.j225 algi t tVigi aa ho iisrf et c y
bea pus s nt o
S.
4, le ng ha r ni ut rte eus o ompl
wi afd rlc u t u g n o d rn t t d o ' f d rl rmia sn e c s u drn
t e ea o rj d me t r eig ha Do s n s e ea c i n l e tn e ho l u
h
c ur e l w ih hi s a e c ts nt nc U po r vi w oft r or t c tsz m a iy
onc r nty t s t t our e e e.
n e e
he ec d, he our lm rl
di m i s st pe ii w iho pr l di e.1
s s e he tton t ut e- c
u
l
Rali h Dods wa c cedon f de a dnl c r a s t nce i M a c 1 t
eg
on s onvi t
e r l g ha ges nd en e d n r h 995 o
240mont i prs Se Unie Sttsv. o Cas No.7:4CR401 ( . Va.1 .
hs n ion. e td ae Dods n, e
9
06 W D. 995)
Ont J me Or r atrsai t tr ofi ionme i e t j ea dt
he udg nt de , fe ttng he e m mprs nt mposd,he udg dde he
f l w i c to .
olo ng ondii n'
De enda ' t r ofi prs
f nts e m
m iomne s l r n c ure l wih any prs n
nt hal u onc r nty t
io
t r i pos d by t c m onwea t ofV igi a whi h i ba e on a c
em m e
he om
lh
r ni
e s sd
onvi to i
ci n n
t c r tc toft Ciy ofD a vil , Vi g ni on t 5t da ofM a 1 , nd
he icui our
he t
n le r i a he h y
y, 994 a
f rwhih t Comm onwe t ofVigi ahastld ade aner
o
c he
a1h
r ni
ie
ti .
A fera c r a ni t am ountofs a e tm e t def nda m us s r e on
t s e t i ng he
t t i he e nt
t ev
t s a e c ge t Bur au ofPr s s l r l as t de e ntt t c t
he t t har , he
e
i ons ha l e e e he f nda o he us ody
oft Com m onw e lh ofVi gi a t ta ou oftm e prort t co pl t o of
he
at
r ni ha m nt i
i o he m e i n
t i t sent
he ns ant ence so t t sf alsent
hat hi eder
ence w ilbe com pl ed i t cusody
l
et n he t
1 Un rRue4 b)oft RulsGo n ig j225 Ca e ,h c ur ma s
de l (
he e ve an
4 s s te o t y umma i d s s a
rl imis
y
j2 5 mo inE ifi pai ya e r fo t ep ttona a y alc ede bist ttepeii e i no
25 to t q t l nl pp a s r m h eii nd n ta h xhi t ha h tton r s t
l
entted t r i i t diti tcour.'
il o elef n he s rc
t'
oft Com monwe t ofVigi aa wilbec
he
a1h
r ni nd l
omplt d by r mi c ur e ty
ee
ur ng onc r n l
wih hi sa e s nt nc
t s tt e e e.
( No.12, 1 .W he fdea a horte r l sdDods t Vigi aa horte ,he
ECF
- p. )
n e rl ut iis eeae
on o r ni ut iis
e
xpec e t the w oul be pr es ed and r l as I t ad, l r d t tV igi a a horte
t d ha
d
oc s
e e ed. ns e he ea ne ha r ni ut ii s
wo d r quiehi t s r hi s ve yea sae s nt nc i t Vigi aDe rm e tof
ul e r m o e ve s e n- r t t e e e n he r ni pa t n
Co rcin (;
re to s 6
VDOC' .Do o wr t t VDOC o fcas akigwhyhi s ne e h dn t u
' ds n o e o
)
fiil, s n
s e tnc s a o r n
c ur e l asor e a r ei d t sr pl
onc r nty
der d, nd ec ve hi e y:
Plms bead s d t tt s ntncei pos d i Da le Cic tCour wasor r d
e e
vie ha he e e
m e n nvil r ui
t
de e
t r c e tve t t s n e i pos d i t f de a c ts t . W hie i i
o un ons cu i o he e t nce m e n he e r l our ys em
l ts
no edt tyourf de als ntncewa o de edt rm c ure t yourVigi a
t ha
e r e e
s r r o t onc r nt o
r ni
sntnc youweenoti t c t y oft (
e e e,
r
n he usod he VDOC; youweei t c t of
I
r n he usody
t f r laut ii a s r d t ts nt nc pr o t be nni t s r c of
he ede a hortes nd e ve ha e e e i r o gi ng he e vi e
t s nt nc i
he e e e mpos i Da vil Cic tCour.
ed n n le r ui
t
( No.12,p. )
ECF
- 2.
Dods riest cli i hi j2254peii .
on as wo ams n s
tton'
Pe ii rpl ded g ly bas d on f l e i or a i f om hi l w ye a l
ttone ea
uit
e
a s nf m ton r
s a r td
t Diti tAto ne t thi f de a tmewoul r c ure l wih hi
he src t r y ha s e r l i
d un onc r nty t s
s a e s nt nce a
t t e e ; nd
2.
V igi a au hortesa kno l dget tt f de a cou ti pos is
r ni t ii c w e
ha he e r l r m ed t
s nt nc t r n conc r nty w ih t s a e s nt nce buthave t ke no
e e eo u
ur e l t he t t e e ,
a n
ac i n t a r st st ton.
to o dd es he iua i
D ods a s r st the l a ed a tt s nt nc notr mzng co u r nty onl afe hi
on s e t ha
em
bou he e e es
u i
nc r e l
y tr s
t a f rt t VD OC. A s r le i t s a to D ods n as t co tt die tt VD OC t r n
r ns e o he
e i f n hi c i n,
o ks he ur o r c he
o u
t saetmeco rntwiht fdealsntnc ort rviihi fdeals ntnc 'ot t( j
he tt i
ncure t he e r e e e o e st s e r e e e ç ha he
s
c nc eebohs ntnc a t smetme. ( No.1 p.1 )
a omplt t e e es the a i ' ECF
'
, 4.
11
Unde 28U. C.j225449,afdealc t nno grntaha aspeii unls t
r
S.
1 e r our ca t a
be tton e s he
pe ii rha e
ttone s xhaus e t r m edi a ia e i t cou t oft s a e i whi h he w a
t d he e
es va l bl n he r s he t t n
c
s
c ce Thee
onvi td.
xhausi r uie ti s ts i by s e ngr e oft c am s t oug
ton eq r men s a ifed
e ki eviw
he l i ,hr hout
t saeco ts t t t hihetsaec twihj idito t c iert cli .Se
he tt ur ysem,o he g s tt our t urs cin o onsd he ams e
O' lva v. r l 526U. 8 845( 999 .Afe hi opporuniyf die a a o hi
Suli n Boecke,
S. 38,
1 ) tr s
t t or rd ppe l f s
c c i ha pas e t de e ntssae c tr me e i Vigi ai l flnga sae
onviton s s d,he f nda ' t t our e dis n r ni ncude ii
tt
ha aspe ii n wih t Cic tCour whe e he w asc c e w ih a a a ofa a r e
be
tto t he r ui
t r
onvi t d, t n ppe l n dve s
de ii t t SuprmeCour ofVigi a,Va.
cson o he e
t r ni
CodeAnn.j8. - 4()1,j1 1411 ori
0165 a( ) 7.- , n
'
t ale ai flngasaehabe speii die tywiht Supr meCou ofVigi a j8. he tm tve, ii
tt
a tton r cl t he e
rt r ni. 01
654()1 .W hihe rr ehef l i exha tngsaec ur rme e ,adef ntmus
a( )
c ve out olows n usi tt o te dis
enda
t
uli a e y pr e hi c ai st t Supr m e Co tofV igi a be or a f der ldit i tc tc n
tm t l es nt s l m o he
e
ur
r ni f e e a s rc our a
c i rt meisofhi camsunde j2254.
onsde he rt
s li
r
Dods al gest thi tilc
on le ha s ra ouns lpr de i c a ei or ton a
e ovi d nac ur t nf ma i boutt
he
s t nc ngbe ftDods woul r c i i e ha f hi g ly plat t sae c r a
en e i
ne i
on
d e eve n xc nge or s uit e o he t t ha ges nd
t tt VD O C i i pr pe l ca a i hi t r ofc i m e . Dods s a e on t f ce of
ha he
s m o ry kul tng s e m
ontne nt
on t t s he a
hi peii t thedi notpur ueadiec a a i saec ta t theha no fl d a o he
s tton ha
d
s
r t ppe l n tt our nd ha
s t ie ny t r
pos co c i pe ii n o m oto c e ni i a s a e co t St t c tr c ds a ia e
t nvi ton tto r
i n onc r ng n ny t t ur . a e our e or va l bl
o i alo i caet tDo on hasnotpurue a pos c c i r m e i saeco t
nlne s ndi t ha ds
s d ny t onviton e dy n t t ur.
A lhoug D ods s o
t
h
on' pporuniy t pu s a di e ta a ha e r D ods c
t t o r ue r c ppe l s xpied,
on an
pr s thi c am salegi t i ope e c i ofhi Vigi as nt e i apeii f rawrt
e en s l i
l ng he mpr r xe uton
s r ni e enc n
tton o
i
ofha a c us i t D a le Co y Cic tCour , ih a s e
be s om
n he nvil unt r ui
t w t ubs quen a ala ia e i t
t ppe va l bl n he
Supr m eCour ofVigni l t a tm a i Dods c pr e hi cl msi a ha a c pus
e
t
r i a. n he le tve,
on an es nt s ai n
be s or
petton fld diecl i t Supr m eCour ofVigi a2
ii ie r ty n he
e
t
r ni .
Be us D ods sc r ntpe ii i ca e t the m a ha a l bl s a e cou t
ca e
on' ur e
tton ndi t s ha
y ve vaia e t t
r
r m e e a t stm e t scour mus dimishi j225 peii wi
e di s t hi i , hi
t t s s s
4 tton t prj c 3 sç
hout eudie. ç
Slvonv.Smih, U. 53,54( 971 (i ngt tj2 4ha a peii mus bedimis
at
t 404 S.
1 ) tndi ha 25 be s tton t s sed
wih u p eu iei p tto e h sn t r sn e hscamst tea pr p it saec u t n
t o t rj dc f ei n r a o p e e td i li o h p o rae tt o r a d
i
coul sildos .Ana o it or rwilis t sd y.
d tl o)
ppr prae de l sue hi a
Fo t er a o sae t ec u t imis sDo s n' peiinwih u p eu ie Th
r h e s ns ttd,h o r ds se d o s t o t o t rj dc . e
t
Cl r i diec e t s nd c e oft s m e o andu o ni a ac om pa ng o de t
e k s r t d o e opi s hi m r
m pi on nd c
nyi r r o
pe ii ne .
tto r
ENTER:Th s A/ vd yo Au u t2 2
i j a a f g s, 01 .
''
'
'
z,. . , .u'@- 4 - .
..
'c
rU nied St t s Di t i J
t
a e sr c udge
2 Thi courtsfndi t tDods may ha avaia e sa ecour r edi doesnotconsiut a
s
' i ng ha
on
ve
lbl t t
t em es
tt e
fndi t tt ale i i hi cur entpetton sat any habeascor cl m on w hi he i entted t
i ng ha he lgatons n s r
ii t e
pus ai
ch s il o
r if.I t Danvil Cicui Cour i pos iss e t r cons utvet t f als e i
ele f he
le r t
t m ed t ent nce o un
ec i o he eder ent nce, t
appea st Vigi aaut ii ar executng Dods ssa e s ence i accor ncew ih t sat
r hat r ni hortes e
i
on' tt ent
n
da
t he t e
s enci or r.
ent ng de
3 S ci 2 4 p o de ar me yt p ron c nfne u e saec rj g nsi vi ain
e ton 25 r vi s e d o e s s o i d nd r tt ou tud me t n olto
oft Cons iuton orlw soft Unied St t . Ther or t t ext ntt Dods wi t chalenge
he
tt i
a
he t
a es
ef e, o he e hat
on shes o
l
hi f d r l e e c a i e ,h c n tp o e du e j2 4.
s e e a s ntn e s mpos d e a no r c e nd r 25
4
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?