Demetriades et al v. Allison et al

Filing 3

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 8/17/2012. (ssm)

ctEe s OFFI u. Dl O URT
CE s. sr.
ATR- OKE,
VA
'
FI
LED

I THE UM TED STATES DI
N
STRI COURT
CT
FOR TH E W ESTERN D I
STRI OF V I W I
CT
RG A
ROAN O KE D I SI
VI ON

AL6 17 2 1
02
JUL G. UDL
EY
BK *

PETER DEM ETRI
ADES, tgk,
t
-

Pl i i f ,
a ntf s

Ci lAc i N o.7: 2CV0037
vi ton
1
4

M EM OM NDUM OPI ON
NI
By: on. l n E.
H
Ge
Conr
ad
ChifUnie St tsDititJ dg
e
td ae src u e

SAM UEL W .
ALLI
SON ,âg1,
# ,
.

De e nt .
f nda s

Pe e a M iheleDe erade , oc di pr K , ie t sa ton on Aug t1 201
t r nd c l m ti s pr ee ng o fld hi c i
us 3, 2
ag ns Sa
ai t muelW . ls Ke nFl nor and J e B.Lye. Thepl ntfsalo m o d t
Alion, vi ee ,
os ph
l
ai if s
ve o

pr e L f mapa rs purua t 28U. C.j1 5()1.Thec t l g a t
oce d q or
upei, s nto
S. 91 a()
our wil r nthe
pli if'moint pr e di fr pa rs.Howe r a trrviwi t c antt
antfs to o oc e q oma upei
ve, fe e e ng he ompli ,he

c u t o cu e ta t ea t nmu t ed s se f rlc o s be t t r u idcin p ru n
o r c n ld s h t h ci
o s b imis d o a k f u jc mat j rs ito , u s a t
e
t 2 U.. j1 5 e( )B)a dRue1 ( )3 o t F d r l lso Cii Pr c dze
o 8 SC. 91 ()2 ( n l 2 h ( ) fhe e ea Rue f v l o e l .
r
B ackground

A 1 oft pa te i t i t nta i a e c tz ns ofV i g ni A c or ng t t
l he r i s n he ns a cton r ii e
r i a. c di o he

co pli ,t pli if r sdei Rur lRer a ;Sa lAlio a Ke n Fle rr i i
m a nt he antfs e i n a te t mue ls n nd vi e no esde n
Brsol a J e Lyl r i i Abi
it ; nd os ph e esdes n ngdon.
Theaci a ie fo f r cos r pr e di i ta e a i tt pl n if 'pr pe t i
ton rs s r m o e l u e oc e ngs niit d gans he aitfs o ry n

Brsol whih waspur has fom Ali o i 200 f t prncpa s of$ , 00. To
it , c
c ed r
ls n n 3 or he i i l um
285001.
f t pur has o t pr ry, he pl i if e cu e a pr i s y no e pm s n t w hi h
und ht c e f he ope t t
a ntf s xe t d
om s or l
ua t o t

t y a e d t ma t f l ngpa nt t Alion:$5,00. on orbef eM a 7,2003;
he gr e o ke he olowi
yme s o ls
0 00
or y

RK

$44, . on o be o eN o mbe 30,2003;a $236, 0 a 7. i e e t t bepa d i
00100 r f r ve r
nd
000,0 t 00% ntr s, o
i n
239 mont yi t lme sof$1,70. 1 be nni on Jme 1,
hl nsal nt
5 1 , gi ng t
2003.
Ats epoi t r afe ,t pl i if f l be nd i t pa nt duet rt
om
nt he e tr he antfs e l hi n he yme s
mde he

pr s or no e On J 29, 0,t pl i if ga Sa
omis y t .
une 201 he antfs ve muelAlion apa
ls
ymentof$5, 00
000.
t r t a r a agea t dhi t ta a to lpa nto $ 400. wo d bemadeon
owa d he re r nd ol m ha n ddiina yme f 4, 00 ul
J y2,2 0, c woul blngt a r a ag c r n . On J y 2,201 whieon t wa t
ul
01 whih
d i he re r e ur e t
ul
0, l
he y o

ma t ba a epa m e ,hepli if r c i a wrte de
ke he l nc y nt t antfs e eved itn mand f r$ 6, 0 a ongwih
o 21 800.0, l
t
anotc ad sngt m t tt pr ry woul be s d a atu t e' s l on Augus 5,201 The
i e vi i he ha he ope t
d ol t r se s ae
t
0.
pl i tf sc e t tt y ne rr ce ve a prorwa i t tt ei pr ry w o d be
a n if ont nd ha he ve e i d ny i
m ng ha h r ope t ul

f e l e upon i pay e swe enotbr htc r nt
or cos d
f m nt r
oug ure .
Thepl ntfsaleg t tt ytld a aci i sa ec t o so t f e os e s e a
ai if l e ha he ie n ton n tt our t t p he or cl ur al, nd
t tt s l wasalowe t pr e ptr ua t a o de e t r on Se e be 1 201
ha he ae
l d o oc ed ts nt o n r r n e ed
ptm r 5, 0.
Ac di t t pli if ,Lyl,t s tt etu te, dnotwai t r c i t or ra
cor ng o he antfs e he ubsiut r se di
t o e eve he de nd
i t a s dt pr ry t Fle r t hi s bi r on Augus 5,201 Thepl i if as e t
nse d ol he ope t o e no ,he ghe t dde ,
t
0.
antfs s r
t tLyl di notha t t ndi 'a t tt f ecos r p oc e ng s d ha be n i taed
ha e d
ve t a ng' nd ha he or l u e r e di s houl ve e niit
s

b De r Br wn,h tu teie tte o ted e ofrlt ( mpla p r 1 . Th panif
y b a o te r se d ni d n h e d tt . Co . t aa 9) e litf
i
s
aloase tt tt i pr ry ç s dwa belw t make val v' ndt ttll s l s d
s sr ha her opet k ol y o he r t ue'a ha çthe ae houl
was
ha a las sa tda $350, 00. (
ve t e t tre t
000. ' Compl a paa. )
'
. t r 20.
OnAugus l 201 Lyl s htt ha t pl i if e ced.A he rngwass he ed
t 6, 0, e oug o ve he antfs vi t
ai
c dul

f Se e r1 201 a t pl i if we euli t l gi n tn d yst va t t pr ry.
or pt mbe 3, 0, nd he antfs r tma ey ve e a o cae he ope t

Ac di t t pli if , htpr pe t i now on t ma ke f $449, 00.
cor ng o he antfs t o ry s
he r t or
000.

Bas o t f e ngaleg tons t pl ntfsfld t i tnta ton a i tt
ed n he or goi l a i , he ai if ie he nsa c i gans he

de e nt o Augus 1 201
f nda s n
t 3, 2.Thepl ntfss k $41 000. i dama sfom Alion,
ai if ee
2, 00 n
ge r
ls

Fle o , n Ly ef rth fut f rco u ea dtei e a s l a dp r h s o (h il
e n r a d l o ' e a l o e l s r n h l g l ae n u c a e f t er
t
y
l
f e l edprpet '(
orcos o ry. Compl a paa. ) l t frtpaa a oft compl ntt plitfs
'
. t r 2. n he is rgrph he
ai ,he anif
i c t t tt aci i br
ndi ae ha he ton s oughtpur ua tt Se tons3755 375 a 3757 ofTil 1 oft
s n o ci
, 6, nd
te 2 he
Unied Stt sCode whih we ee ce aspa to t Si eFa l M orga For c os eAc
t
ae
, c
r na td
r f he ngl miy
t ge e l m
t

of1
994.See1 U. C.j3751 .1sq.
2 S.
,q e
St
andard ofR evi w
e

Un e 28U. C. l 5e , ihg v r sL fr p u ei p o e dn s t ec u t a a
dr
S. j 91 ( )whc o en q o ma a p rs r c e ig ,h o r h s
m a t ydut t s r n i talflng
nda or y o c ee nii ii s.ErlneCo. l h s n 4 0F.d6 8 6 6 6 7(t Ci.
ii
v, o n o , 4 3 4 , 5 - 5 4 h r
-

2 6 .S e iial,t dsrc c u t s d s s a a to ta t ec u ti d t b fioo so
00 ) p cfc l t itit o r mu t imis n cin h t h o r fn s o e rv lu r
y a
maii ort tfist saeacam. iha v. retn Co y, 4F. 7 7 ( h
lcous ha al o tt li ' c u Chalso unt 43 3d 25, 28 4t
'M
Ci.
r 2006)(ii 28U. C.j1 5()2)B).
ctng
S. 91 e( ( )
Addii ly, rua t Rul 1 h)3)oft Fe rlRulsofCi lPr e e,hec t
tonal pu s nt o e 2( (
he dea e
vi oc dur t our

t s d s s'a a to tift ec u t eemi sa a ytmet a i lc ss be tmatr
t t imis' n cin tl h o r d tr ne t n i h tt a k u j c- te
mu
r
ju s ito ' Fe R. v. 1 ( )3 .ç ol e to o s b e tmatr mi dcinma b r ie
ti dcin. d. Ci P. 2 h () d u sins f u j c- te j s ito y e as d
'
g
a a poi d i t pr ee ngsa ma ( ,moeprciey, t berie s s nt by
t ny nt urng he oc di nd y or r e s l mus) as d ua po e

t c u t'Brc wo Co ta tr.nc v Daa e Encn eig lc, 6 F.d3 5 3 0( t Ci.
he o r. ik od n rco s I . . tn t ie rn .n .3 9 3 8 , 9 4h r
'
2004)
.
D i c son
s us i

Fed r lc t aec t oflmiedjliddin.'f ypos e sonl t tpowe
e a ours r ours i t t s i o s he s s y ha
r
r
a t i e by Cons iuton a s a ut ' K okkone v. ua di n Li e l . ofAm . 511 U .
u hor z d
tt i nd t t e.
'
n G r a f ns Co.
,
S.

37 , 77( 9 4 .Ge eal, c s c nb o i ial fldi afd r l itit o r i teei
5 3 1 9 ) n rly a a e a e rgn l ie n e ea d src c u tf h r s
y

fd r l u si nj rs ito u d r28U. C. 1 31o dvest o ctz ns i j rs ci nt e
e e a q e to u idcin n e
S. j 3 r i ri f iie hp u idito md r
y
28U. C.j 1 2.
S.
33
Ha ngr vi we t pl i if 'c
vi e e d he antfs ompli , hec ti c ta ne t co l t ti
ant t our s onsr i d o ncude ha t

mus beds se f rlc o s be t te j rs ito Th plitfsha ef i dt alg a y
t imisd o a k f u j c matr u idcin. e an if v al o l e n
e
e
vo aino fd r la whihmih s p o th e ecs o j rs ito u d rj 1 31 Al u h
ilto f e ea lw c g t u p r te x rie f u id ci n n e 3 . t g
ho
t pli if ct t pori oft Si eFa l M orga For cos eAc , ha Ac a i
he a ntfs ie o tons he ngl miy
t ge e l ur t t t t pples

onl t morga t taehel byt Se rtr ofHo i a Ur nDe l
y o t ges ha r d he ceay
usng nd ba veopmen (1 'or
t$
HUD'
)
t ts c el nsoblgae byHUD.Se 1 U. C.j3751b) s eas TçM a shv. me
ha e ur oa
i td
e 2 S.
( ; e lo r rc Ho q

Se vcn Co p, 9 F. p . d8 7 8 9( D. c . 0 5 .Be a s t ep an if d n t
r iig r .3 9 Su p 2 2 , 2 E. Mih 2 0 ) c u e h litfs o o
a lget tHUD ha a i ve ntwih t i l n o t f e l ur pr ee ngsi ta e
le ha
d ny nvol me
t her oa r he or c os e oc di niit d
a i tt i pr pe t t y c nnotpur ueacli unde t Si eFa l M org eFor c osle
ga ns he r o ry, he a
s
am
r he ngl miy
tag
e l tr
A ct
.

l t abs nceofa al gai nst tmi pr deargh t r ift rf der ll t s
n he e
ny le to ha ght ovi
i t o ele mde e a aw, hi

c u t yo l e ecs s b e tmatr u idcino e t ep anif ' o an i te
o r ma ny x r ie u j c te j rs ito v r h litfs c mplit f h
rquie nt o di riyj iditonaes tsid.Alhoug t a
e r me s f vest urs ci r aife t h he mounti c r rye ee
n ontove s xc ds

$ 50 0a rq ie b j1 3 () tep anif aeu a et e tbl hta c mp eedvest o
7 ,0 s e ur d y 3 2 a,h litfs r n bl o sa i h t o lt i ri f
s
y
ctze hi e ssbe we n t pari .To t c ta y, hec
ii ns p xit t e he tes
he on r r t ompl i i c t st tt pl i if
ant ndia e ha he antfs

a dted fn a t aer sd n so Vigna Ac o dn l,h sc u ta k j rs ito t
n h e e d n s r e ie t f r ii. c r igy ti o r lc s u idcin o
c i rt pl i tf s c a m s
ons de he a n if ' l i .

4

Concl on
usi

Fort r s nssae t co twilgrntt plitfs moint pr e di f ma
he ea o ttd,he ur l a he anif' to o oc e q or

p u rs Ho v r t ec u t o cu e t a t ea to mu tb d s se f rlc o s b e t
a pei. we e ,h o r c n ld s h t h cin s e imisd o a k f u j c
matr u idcin, u s a t o2 U. C. 1 5e( )B)a dRul l ( )3 o t eFe ea Rue
te j rs ito p ru n t 8 S. j 91 ()2 ( n e 2 h ( ) f h d rl ls
o Cii Pr c d r .S c d s sa s al ewi o t rj dc .
f v l o e u e u h imisl h l b t u p eu ie
h
The Clr i die t t s nda c rii d c o t sm e o a l o ni a t
e k s r ced o e
e tfe opy f hi m r ndlm pi on nd he
a ompa ng or rt t pl i if .
cc
nyi
de o he antfs

ENTER:

.
4
- k
Thi ?a da ofAug t 2012.
s .t
y
us,
' ..-/
r
!

'

t à v, j
p sv à
zyw
,

f

.

'

ChifUnied St t DititJ
e
t
aes src udge

5