Foore v. SWVRJA-Abingdon

Filing 8

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge James C. Turk on 08/27/2012. (kab)

rLERK'AT R- U.s. ST. cotqT
S oFFl
G8
DI
l
OKE,V
A
FI
LED

I T H E UN I
N
TED STATE S DI
STR I C O U R T
CT
FO R TH E W E STER N D I
STRI T O F V I G I I
C
R N A
R O A N O K E DIVISIO N

ALs 2? 2 1
92
J
UL

BY:

. D EX CLERK
D

DEPUT CL
Y ERK

C H R ISTO PH ER A D A M FO O R E,

CA SE N O .7:
12CV 00375

Pl ntf ,
ai if

M EM O M N DU M O PI O N
NI

SW VR JA - BI D O N ,
A NG

By: Jam e C.Tur
s
k
Se or U nie St e Di t c Judge
ni
t d at s s ri t

D ef
endant.

ChrsopherAda Foor ,aVigi ai aepr ee ng pr K ,fld t scvi rght
it
m
e
r ni nm t oc di
o
ie hi i l i s

a t np ru n t 4 U. C. 1 8 , l gngt t o a j io tcasha efie t p o iehm
ci u s a t o 2 S. j 9 3 al i ha l c lal fi il v ald o r vd i
o
e
w ih ade t t e t e f de a a m e a he t pr e s Foor ha a s fl d a m oton t
t
qua e r a m nt or nt l nd nt l alh obl m .
e s l o ie
i o
a e w hi h t c tw ilg a ,t a a c ai a
m nd, c he our l r nt o dd l m boutm e c t e t e . Af e r vi w of
di al r a m nt t r e e
Foo e' com pl ntasa e d,howeve ,t c ur s m a iy dim i s st ac i wihou
r s
ai
m nde
r he o t um rl s s e he ton t t

p eudc f rfiu et saeacam .
rj ie o alr o tt li

Foor i i a c r ed a t So hwese n V igi a Re o J i Aut iy f c lt i
e s nc r e at t he ut
t r r ni gi nal a l hort a iiy n

Abn d n (tej i', u hei d sg ae frta se t teVignaDe rme to Co rcin
ig o 'h al' b t s e in td o rn fr o h r i i pa t n f re to s
s
)
(
VDOC) l t pas 1 mont ,heji de itha e rced 1 ofFoor steh.Fo e
. n he t 5
hs t al nts s xta t 3
e' e t or

c mpli ta h h so h rd n a p o lmsta c l t etxe a t ej i, c o l d e
o ans h t e a t e e tl r b e h t amo b i d t h alwhih ny o s
t he rci
00t xta tons. Fo e c
or anno a f d t buy pa ta de ur s a i now r c vi m e l
t f or o
r i l nt e nd s
e ei ng a s
c itng ofpea tbute a bea ,be a e he c l ote tt nor a i a e di tuntlhi
ons s i
nu
t r nd ns c us
am
a he m l nm t e
i s

t t aefxe Foo eas cai t tt j i' me a he t saf r f e t s ehi be a eof
eeh r i d. r lo l ms ha he als ntl alh t f eus s o e m c us
a pa tc ge t tw a ne ri s i t d.l hi m oton t a end,Foor a l gest ta t he
s har ha s ve nve tga e n s i o m
e le
ha fer

c ai dofe re i dba dizys l,' doco e mi dhi a t dhi dgj' nota
ompl ne
xpeincng t d z pels'a tr xa ne m nd ol m,tlts

s rousme ca c tona t r snot ngheca do. ( No.7. Foor t na ke t se
ei
di l ondii nd hee' hi
n ' ECF
'
)
e he s d o e

a o h rd co .Thej ime ia sa f odhm t e wo l p thm o t eç o trsls, b t
n t e o tr
al dc l tf t l i h y u d u i n h t co ' it' u
d
'
ha not'olowe t ough.'(d. Fi ly,Fooecamst tasaVDoc- sgnae i e,
ve k l d hr
f
' 1 ) nal
r li ha
de i td nmat he

i eiil t b aEr se 'u d r
s lgbe o e t u te' n e VDOC r e , u t ej isa f sno f lo n VDOC r lsa d
t
uls b t h al tf i t ol wi g
ue n
w r f ly r f e t m a hi a t us e .
ong u l e us s o ke m r t e

Th o l d fn a tFo r n me i t t W vl Abn d n'al Asr le i ti
e ny ee d n o e a s s he t uA- ig o 'j i. eif n h s
s
a ton,Foor s ksçobes t a( DOC fclt s g c nge pr rdent a me a
ci
e ee é
t ent o VI
a iiy o hel a t ope
al nd ntl
he lhc r ' (
at ae.' Compl2.
. )
1
1

Tosaeaca eofa tonunderj 1 3,apl ntf mus e tbls t thehasbe n
tt us ci
98
ai if t sa ih ha
e
de i d ofrg sgua a e byt Consiuton orlwsoft Unied St t sa t tt s
prve
i ht
r nt ed he
tt i
a
he t
a e nd ha hi
de i ton r s t fom conduc c
prva i e uled r
t ommitd by ape s a tng unde c orofsa elw .W es
te
r on c i
r ol
tt a
t

v. ki , 7U. 42 ( 988)
At ns 48 S. 1 .Thecou ti rquie t dimisan a tonorcam tldbya
r s e rd o s s y ci
li ie
pr s ne a i ta gove nm e ale iy orof i i li t c t t nni t tt a ton orc ai
i o r ga ns
r nt ntt
fc a f he our de e nes ha he c i
lm
i fi ous m a i i , f l t sa e a c a m on w hi r i m a be g a e 28 U . C.
s r vol , lc ous or ais o t t l i
ch elef y
r nt d.
S.

j 1 5 b)1.
91 A( ( )
tloc lgo r ngbodis. . a bes ddiecl unde j 1 frmoneay,de lrtr
tv a veni
e . c n ue r ty
r 983 o
tr caaoy,

o ij tverle wher ...hea tont ti al edt beunc tt i li e nt or
r nunci eif
e t ci ha s leg o
onsiutona mplme s
exe ut sapolcy sae e ,or na ,r gul i orde so o tc al a e a
c e
i t tm nt di nce e aton,
cii n fi i ly dopt d nd
pr m ul t by t tbod s ofk e s. M one lv. e Yor Civ D e .ofSoc a Se vi e , 6
o ga ed
ha
y' t r '
'
l N w
k t pt
i l r e s 43

U. 6 8 6 0 (9 ) Topr v t tag v n na e tt s c a alc l al i la l f r
S. 5 , 9 1 78 .
o e ha o e une tl ni u h s o a j i,s ibe o
y,
consiutonalvi atons com m it by isem pl
tt i
ol i
ted
t
oyees,pl ntf m us s
ai if
t how t t entt spolcy
hat he iy' i
w as lt m ovi f ce oft cons iutonalvi aton.' Pol Count v.D ods 454 U . 31
the
ng or
he
tt i
ol i ' k
v
on,
S. 2,

3 6( 9 1.F o efist lr aji p lc t a yo tealg dd p iains Ac od n l,
2 1 8 ) o r al o il al oiy o n f h l e e rv t . c r i gy
k
e
o
pli iffist saeacai u whihr le ma begrntda ns t j l1a dt c t
antf al o tt l m pon c eif y
a e gai t he ai, n he our
wildimist c antwiho prj c Ana o it or rwilis t sda
l s s he ompli t ut eudie. ppr prae de l sue hi y.
The Cl r i di e t t s nd c e oft sm e or ndum o ni n and a com pa ng
e k s r c ed o e opi s hi m a
pi o
c
nyi
or rt pl i if
de o a ntf .
%

'

ENTER:Th s peJ a o Au u t 2 2
i , Aj y f g s, 01 .
/
.

'é z zc>
t ..

,<n
.

Se orUnied St t sD i ti tJ
ni
t
a e sr c ud

1FO r ' alg ton alofit saea yaton bl j1 cam a ans a yj iofiil Fis,
oeS le ai s s alo tt n ci a e 983 li g i t n al fca. rt
Foor f l t alege f ct i ca i t tany ofhi medial dent ,orment healh condii pr e a
e ais o l a s ndi tng ha
s
c , al
al t
tons es nt

sro me ia n e f i dit tet n ordfee ta c
eius dc l e d ormme ae rame t ifrn commo to ta h ha rc ie a teji,
dain h t e s e ev d th al
ort of i al have ac ed wih delber e i f e encet hi needs. See Eselev.
hat fci s
t
t i at ndif r
o s
t l Gam bl 429 U. 97,
e,
S.

1 2 ( 97 )(i i t a t saeEi t Ame dme tcam,ima emus s o prs n o fca' d lb rt
0 1 6 fndng h t o tt ghh
n n li n t t h w io fiils eie ae
idif rnc t i t ' s rou me c ln e ) W ra tv. l , 66F.d 8 ,8 ( t Ci.1 )
n fe e e o nma es ei s dia e d ; ih Coli 7 2 41 49 4h r 985
ns
(idigt ti t ' dia r e ntwihme c l ron l e a dngdign i a c ureofte t n
fn n ha nmaes s g e me t dia pes ne r g r i a oss nd o s r ame t
d sno i iaet Eih hAme me t. S c nd j iofiil'f iu et c mpl wiht VDOC
oe t mplc t he g t
nd n) e o , al fcas alr o o y t he
p io r guai sr g r i ei bii f tu tesau do sn saeaj 1 3cam.W elrv. - 'o
rs n e lton e a dng lgi lt or r se tts e ot tt
y
98 li
le De t f
p

S ca S r ie, 0 F.d3 7 3 2(t Ci. 9 0 (idn ta voain o saelw b saeofcas
o il evc s9 1 2 8 , 9 4h r 1 9 ) fn ig h t ilt s f tt a y tt fiil
o

dono p o d b ssf c siu in camsun rj 1 3) Fi ly, or ha n c ttton lrg tt
t r vie a i or on tt to al li
de 98 . nal Fo e s o onslu i a ih o

bec fn d i an pa t ulr a l rp ionf cly.Se Ol v. a ne o , lU. 23 2 ( 98 .
on ie n y ri a j i o rs a ii
c
t e i W ki k na 46 S. 8, 45 1 3)
m