Blount v. Collins et al
Filing
104
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 04/24/2014. (kab)
e **P: QFFOK U, DI r l
d
I
6. 8X n r
AT ROAN(KE,
. VA
7
F2 .
'
I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FO R TH E W ESTER N D I
STR I T O F V I G I I
C
R N A
R O AN O K E DI SI N
VI O
APk 2j 2 1
F 'f gj
?
s
JULG J
B
Y;
z / -i. ZRK
j .z CL
Y
/
DEP l CLERK
DONELL J.
BLOUNT, ,
SR.
CASE NO .7: 26+ 00476
1
Pl ntf ,
ai if
M EM O M N DU M O PI O N
NI
SGT.LARRY RO SS COLLI ETAL ,
NS,
By: Gl n E.Conr
e
ad
Chi fU ni e St esD i t i tJudge
e
t d at
sr c
Dee
fndants.
t)
DONELL J.BLOUNT,SR.
,
CASE NO .7: 3CV00505
1
Pl ntf ,
ai if
M EM O M N DU M O PI O N
NI
SG T.LA RR Y RO SS C O LLI S,
N
By: G l n E .Conr
e
ad
Chi U ni St esD i t ctJudge
ef ted at
s ri
Dee
f ndant
.
Th sp io e cv lrg t a to u d r42U. C.j1 8 i c re ty b f r tec u to
i rs n r ii ih s cin n e
S.
9 3 s u rn l eo e h o r n
moin fritro uo y ij nci rle fld b p o s p an if Do elJ Blu t S .Untd
to s o n elc t r nu tve eif ie y r e litf, n l . o n , r ie
St t s M a sr t J
ae
gita e udge Pnme a M e de Sar nt ptruan t a r e e or r unde 28 U. C.
l
a
ge , ls t o ef r nce de
r
S.
j6 6 b ( )B) c n u td a e d n ir h a ig a d ha fld a r p r r c mme dn t t
3 ( )1( , o d ce n vie tay e rn n s ie
e o t e o n ig ha
Bl ' motons be de le Fr r viw of t r c d,t c t c l s t t Bl '
ounts
i
ri d. om e e
he e or he our onc ude ha ounts
o j ci n mu tb o e ze ,te rpo ta d r c mme d to mu tb a o td a d Blu ts
b e to s s e v m ld h e r n e o n ai n s e d pe , n o n '
moin f ritro u o yij n tv r le mu tb d ne
to s o ne lc t r nu cie eif s e e id.
1
Bl ' i ta j 1 co ai ( eNo.7:2CV00476)al ed t tfurof r a
ounts niil 983 mpl nt Cas
1
leg ha o fces t
Re Ono S ae P io usd e e sv fre a an thm o t o c so si 2 2 (t e2 2
d in tt rs n e xc sie o c g is i n wo c a in n 01 th 01
l
lws f). Th c u td n e t e d fn a t'mo in frsl r j d me t a d te matri
a ui
e o r e id h ee d n s to o l
mmay u g n , n h te s
n w sh d e f raj r tili M a 2 4. l Oco e 2 3 Blu tfld moinss e i
o c e uld o u y ra n y 01 n t b r 01 , o n i
e t
o e kng
itro u oy ij n tv r l f b s do alg to ta o eo ted fn a t,S t Coln , d
ne lc t l nu cie ei a e n l ains h t n f h ee d n s g . lis ha
e
e
m a ve baltleas a us d e s i f c agans Bl ti r t la i f t 201 lws t
de r lr t nd e xce sve or e i t oun n e a iton or he 2 a ui.
The c tc tonaly tld t e moi as a ne a spaae ci l acin ( e No.
our ondii l ie hes tons
w nd e rt vi to Cas
7:3CV00505) CG 201 lws f',and Bl fld a a
1
t
he 3 a ui )
ount ie n mende c ai ,t whih t
d ompl nt o c he
de enda fl a a we .Theco tt n s tt 201 l ws tf tilwih t 201 lws ton
f nt ied n ns r
ur he e he 3 a ui or ra t he 2 a ui
M a 1 1 201
y 5- 6, 4.
Bl mtsm oto f i e l t y r le t alvit t alege da ert tSgt Coli
ot '
i ns or nt rocu or e if o le a e he l d ng ha
. lns
wo l rtl t a ans Bl u tb fr tilwee r fre t t ema itaej d e Blu tsld
ud eai e g i t o n eo e ra r ee rd o h g sr t u g . o n e
a
tmey o j cin t t er p r' c n lso sa d r c mme d d d s o i o ,ma ig t ematr
i l be to s o h e o ts o cu in n e o n e ip st n kn h te
i
rpe f diposto
i or s ii n.
1
1
Be a s itro uo y ij n tv rle i a e ta r i r rme y t ep ry s e i t e
c u e n elc t r n u ci e eif s n x ro dnay e d , h a t e kng h
p ei n r ijmcinmu tma eace rs wi t 1 t a h i l l t s c e d o teme is
r l ay nt to s k la ho ng t ) h t e s i y o u c e n h rt;
mi
(
ke
( hei lk l t s frirp rbl h r i t ea e c o p ei n r r le ; 3 ta teb ln e
21 s iey o ufe re aa e n m n h bsn e f r l a y eif ( ) h t h aa c
mi
o e ui e tpsi h sf v r a d ()a ij n to i i t p bi itrs. Re lTnl Ab u
f q t s i n i a o ; n 4 n nu cin s n he u lc n ee t' a t o t
i
'
h
Ob ma I c v.
a . n . FEC, 75F.d3 2 3 6 4 ( t Ci. 0 9 , a ae o o h rao n b 5 9U.
5 3 4 , 4 - 7 4h r 2 0 ) v c td n t e r u ds v 5 S.
1 9 ( 0 , ensae i rlv n p r b 6 7F.d3 5 35 (t Ci. 01 ) Ea ho t e efu
08 201 ) ri ttd n ee a t a t v 0 3 5 , 5 4 h r 2 0 . c f h s o r
f t sm us be s ts i d. I a 347.
ac or
t a i fe d. t
Tosaeaprmaf i j 1 cam ofr tlai a i t mus ofe fcss ngt t
tt i ace 983 li
eaiton, n nmae t fr a t howi ha
hi e r i e ofhi cons iutona r ghtw a a s t i f c or m otva i t r t i t y a ton.
s xe c s
s
tt i l i
s ubsnntal a t
i tng he e ala or c i
Se ec. Ameia Ci lLi ris Unin v.W i mi Cot y,999 F. 780,785 ( h Ci.
e. . , rc n vi be te
o
co co mt
2d
4t r
2
1 )(ii Mt Heatw Civ Sc DititBoadofEd ai v.Doyl 429U. 27 28
993 ctng . ll t hool src
r
uc ton
ç,
S. 4, 7
( 9 7 (e urngplitf t s o : c us lr lto s i b t e te p oe td e p e so a d
1 7 ) r q ii an if o h w ç a a eain h p ewe n h r tce x r sin n
a
t e rtl t r a to ' Us o f re b p io o fcasvoae t e Eih h Ame d n o y
h eai o y ci n). e f o c y rs n fiil ilts h g t
a
n me t nl
whe a id ç lc ousy a s ditcal f t ve y pur e ofca i hn m.' Huds v.
n pple i ii l nd a si ly or he r
ma
pos
usng r '
on
M c lin 5 3 U. 1 6 ( 9 2 . Fo c a p id ln a g o -at ef r t manan o rso e
Mila , 0 S. , 1 9 ) re p le t o d fi fo t o iti r et r
i
h
dicplne' o t ot rha i notInc tt i l l
s i i ,' n he he nd, s
l onsiutona . d.
11
I
Th ma itaej g ' rp r p o ie aln h sl r o t etsi n p e e tdb
e g sr t ud es e o t r vd s e gty l
mma y f h e tmo y r sn e y
t pa te wines e a t e de i r he rng a a sl a y of a vi r c di of Sgt
he ris' t s s t he vi nta y a i nd lmm r
deo e or ng
.
Col 'u eo OC s ry a an tBlu to Oco e 8 2 3 i e pa t h so j ce t te
lns s f
i
p a g is o n n t b r , 01 .Net r ry a b e td o h
h
a c a y of t s sl ma y or a s td t t a wine s t sii d dif r nty t r pored.
c ur c
hi lm r
s ere ha ny t s e tfe fe e l han e t
Acc di y, hec ta st f c ua s
or ngl t our dopt he a t l umm a y oft r t
r
he epor.
Blu to j cst t erpo tsc n l in t a ih e d n ep ru d st ec u t h tte
o n b e t o h e r' o cuso h t t e vie c e s a e h o r t a h
t
us of f c w a not e es i unr a ona e or r a i t y,butr t r w a us d i a e f tt
e
or e s
xc s ve, e s bl
et la or
a he
s e n n f or o
man an imae ds iln . ( No 51 p. . On t i g o n ,t ema itaej d efn s
iti n t icp ie' ECF . , 21)
'
hs r u d h gsrt u g i d
t ha Bl
l t ountha f ie t s
t
s a ld o how alkelhood ofs e son hi r t la i cli 'a r omm e
i i
ucc s
s e a iton a m' nd ec
nds
d na o G i rq e tf rprl n r ij n tv r l f' (d. Blt a s rst a i r a high r
e il f t s e u s o ei a y nu cie ei . I ) omt se t h t n e c n e
h
mi
e'
fn ig a d c n l ins te ma itae j d e fie t c n ie s me o h s e ie e a d
i dn s n o cuso , h
gsrt u g ald o o sd r o
f i v d nc n
i ope l ga mor we g t c ran ofk e s t si ony a
mpr ry ve
e i ht o e t i t r ' e tm
boutSgt Coli 'g ne alte t e
. lns e r r am nt
ofi a e .
nm t s
Th c u tfn s n mei t Blt ' o j cins Th ma itaej d e a p o itl
e o r i d o rt o omts b e to . e gsrt u g p rpraey
dec i d t de i f om conta c or e de
lne o c de '
r
r di t y vi nce w he he Bl
t r ount t e t ne Coli or Coli
hr a e d
lns
lns
tle tn dBlu t Th is eb f r t ec u t t h s t tr i n twh t e S t Coln ' cin
l ae e o n . e su e o e h o r a t i jmct e s o eh r g . l s a to s
r
l
i
aga ns Bl
i t ountw e e r t i or or e s i f c i vi aton ofhi c tt t o lr ght Thes
r e alat y
xce sve or e n ol i
s ons iu i na i s.
e
q e t nswil er s le b t ej r a til
u si
o
l b e ov d y h u y tra.
The c r n i uiy i whe he Bl ts e de de onsr t t ne f pr lmi r
ur e t nq r s
t r oun ' vi nce m taes he ed or ei na y
ijmcierle t e t ehi s ft t it til Th a we i n Theu d s u e e i e c i
nt tv eif o nsl s a ey mtlhe ra. e ns r s o.
r
n ip td v d n e s
t t Sg Coli us OC s ay agans Bl mtonl a r s e ng m e c la ova a onl
ha t
lns ed
pr
i t ot
y he e ki
di a ppr l nd y
a tr Bl mtr peae y r us d t compl wih die tor r . Alo undipu e i t e de e
fe ot e t dl ef e o
y t r c de s
s
s t d s he vi nc
t ta t Coli s aye Bl t ,t i ae r f e de a i ton and r quie no m e c l
ha fer lns pr d o mt he nm t e us d contm na i
e rd
di a
c r . Ba e o te e f cs t e c u ta re wi te ma itaej d e ta Bl t ha n t
ae
s d n h s a t, h o r g e s t h
h
gsrt u g h t omt s o
de onsr t d a lke i
m ta e
i lhood ofs es i pr ng t tSgt Coli 'a tons s tsi t r quiie
ucc s n ovi ha
. lns c i
a ifed he e st
consiutonalsa r f r t la i or e e sve f c I ot r wor ,fom t e de e
tt i
t nda ds or e aiton
xc s i or e. n he
ds r
he vi nc
p ee td, ti n mo e l l ta n tta jzo swi fn i fvo o Blt o t e ecams
r s ne i s o r i y h n o h t l r l i d n a r f omt n h s li .
ke
r
l
Ass h,Bl
uc
ountha f ie t esa ih a s t nta lkei
s a ld o t bls ubsa il i lhood ofs ce son t m e is whih i
uc s
he rt , c s
o e o tef u ee nsr q ie t warn t ee ta r ia yrme y o p ei n r ij n tv
n f h o r lme t e urd o ra t h xr o dn r e d f r lmia y nu cie
r le . Re lTrzh,5 F. a 346ei f
a t 75 3d t
t
47.
I
AJ
Fo t e r a o s sae , t c u t o e r ls Blu ts o j cin t te rp r a d
r h e s n ttd he o r v rue o n ' b e to s o h e o t n
rc
e omm e ton,ado s t r por i ise ie y,a de esBl mts m o i f pr lmi r
nda i
pt he e t n t ntr t nd ni
ot ' tons or ei na y
ijmcier l f An a pr p it o d rwil su ti d y.
nt tv ei . p o rae r e l is e h s a
e
The Cl k i diece t s c es of t s me or ndum opi on a ac ompa ng
er s r td o end opi
hi m a
ni nd c
nyi
or rt pl ntf .
de o ai i f
E R:T i %V dyo Api 2 1 .
NTE hs
a f rl 0 4
,
Chi Unie Stt Diti tJ
ef t d aes src udge
4
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?