Blount v. Collins et al

Filing 104

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 04/24/2014. (kab)

e **P: QFFOK U, DI r l
d
I
6. 8X n r
AT ROAN(KE,
. VA
7
F2 .
'

I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FO R TH E W ESTER N D I
STR I T O F V I G I I
C
R N A
R O AN O K E DI SI N
VI O

APk 2j 2 1
F 'f gj
?
s
JULG J

B
Y;

z / -i. ZRK
j .z CL
Y
/

DEP l CLERK

DONELL J.
BLOUNT, ,
SR.

CASE NO .7: 26+ 00476
1

Pl ntf ,
ai if

M EM O M N DU M O PI O N
NI

SGT.LARRY RO SS COLLI ETAL ,
NS,

By: Gl n E.Conr
e
ad
Chi fU ni e St esD i t i tJudge
e
t d at
sr c

Dee
fndants.
t)
DONELL J.BLOUNT,SR.
,

CASE NO .7: 3CV00505
1

Pl ntf ,
ai if

M EM O M N DU M O PI O N
NI

SG T.LA RR Y RO SS C O LLI S,
N

By: G l n E .Conr
e
ad
Chi U ni St esD i t ctJudge
ef ted at
s ri

Dee
f ndant
.

Th sp io e cv lrg t a to u d r42U. C.j1 8 i c re ty b f r tec u to
i rs n r ii ih s cin n e
S.
9 3 s u rn l eo e h o r n
moin fritro uo y ij nci rle fld b p o s p an if Do elJ Blu t S .Untd
to s o n elc t r nu tve eif ie y r e litf, n l . o n , r ie
St t s M a sr t J
ae
gita e udge Pnme a M e de Sar nt ptruan t a r e e or r unde 28 U. C.
l
a
ge , ls t o ef r nce de
r
S.

j6 6 b ( )B) c n u td a e d n ir h a ig a d ha fld a r p r r c mme dn t t
3 ( )1( , o d ce n vie tay e rn n s ie
e o t e o n ig ha
Bl ' motons be de le Fr r viw of t r c d,t c t c l s t t Bl '
ounts
i
ri d. om e e
he e or he our onc ude ha ounts

o j ci n mu tb o e ze ,te rpo ta d r c mme d to mu tb a o td a d Blu ts
b e to s s e v m ld h e r n e o n ai n s e d pe , n o n '
moin f ritro u o yij n tv r le mu tb d ne
to s o ne lc t r nu cie eif s e e id.
1

Bl ' i ta j 1 co ai ( eNo.7:2CV00476)al ed t tfurof r a
ounts niil 983 mpl nt Cas
1
leg ha o fces t

Re Ono S ae P io usd e e sv fre a an thm o t o c so si 2 2 (t e2 2
d in tt rs n e xc sie o c g is i n wo c a in n 01 th 01
l

lws f). Th c u td n e t e d fn a t'mo in frsl r j d me t a d te matri
a ui
e o r e id h ee d n s to o l
mmay u g n , n h te s

n w sh d e f raj r tili M a 2 4. l Oco e 2 3 Blu tfld moinss e i
o c e uld o u y ra n y 01 n t b r 01 , o n i
e t
o e kng
itro u oy ij n tv r l f b s do alg to ta o eo ted fn a t,S t Coln , d
ne lc t l nu cie ei a e n l ains h t n f h ee d n s g . lis ha
e
e
m a ve baltleas a us d e s i f c agans Bl ti r t la i f t 201 lws t
de r lr t nd e xce sve or e i t oun n e a iton or he 2 a ui.

The c tc tonaly tld t e moi as a ne a spaae ci l acin ( e No.
our ondii l ie hes tons
w nd e rt vi to Cas
7:3CV00505) CG 201 lws f',and Bl fld a a
1
t
he 3 a ui )
ount ie n mende c ai ,t whih t
d ompl nt o c he
de enda fl a a we .Theco tt n s tt 201 l ws tf tilwih t 201 lws ton
f nt ied n ns r
ur he e he 3 a ui or ra t he 2 a ui
M a 1 1 201
y 5- 6, 4.

Bl mtsm oto f i e l t y r le t alvit t alege da ert tSgt Coli
ot '
i ns or nt rocu or e if o le a e he l d ng ha
. lns

wo l rtl t a ans Bl u tb fr tilwee r fre t t ema itaej d e Blu tsld
ud eai e g i t o n eo e ra r ee rd o h g sr t u g . o n e
a
tmey o j cin t t er p r' c n lso sa d r c mme d d d s o i o ,ma ig t ematr
i l be to s o h e o ts o cu in n e o n e ip st n kn h te
i
rpe f diposto
i or s ii n.
1
1

Be a s itro uo y ij n tv rle i a e ta r i r rme y t ep ry s e i t e
c u e n elc t r n u ci e eif s n x ro dnay e d , h a t e kng h
p ei n r ijmcinmu tma eace rs wi t 1 t a h i l l t s c e d o teme is
r l ay nt to s k la ho ng t ) h t e s i y o u c e n h rt;
mi
(
ke
( hei lk l t s frirp rbl h r i t ea e c o p ei n r r le ; 3 ta teb ln e
21 s iey o ufe re aa e n m n h bsn e f r l a y eif ( ) h t h aa c
mi

o e ui e tpsi h sf v r a d ()a ij n to i i t p bi itrs. Re lTnl Ab u
f q t s i n i a o ; n 4 n nu cin s n he u lc n ee t' a t o t
i
'
h
Ob ma I c v.
a . n . FEC, 75F.d3 2 3 6 4 ( t Ci. 0 9 , a ae o o h rao n b 5 9U.
5 3 4 , 4 - 7 4h r 2 0 ) v c td n t e r u ds v 5 S.
1 9 ( 0 , ensae i rlv n p r b 6 7F.d3 5 35 (t Ci. 01 ) Ea ho t e efu
08 201 ) ri ttd n ee a t a t v 0 3 5 , 5 4 h r 2 0 . c f h s o r
f t sm us be s ts i d. I a 347.
ac or
t a i fe d. t

Tosaeaprmaf i j 1 cam ofr tlai a i t mus ofe fcss ngt t
tt i ace 983 li
eaiton, n nmae t fr a t howi ha
hi e r i e ofhi cons iutona r ghtw a a s t i f c or m otva i t r t i t y a ton.
s xe c s
s
tt i l i
s ubsnntal a t
i tng he e ala or c i

Se ec. Ameia Ci lLi ris Unin v.W i mi Cot y,999 F. 780,785 ( h Ci.
e. . , rc n vi be te
o
co co mt
2d
4t r
2

1 )(ii Mt Heatw Civ Sc DititBoadofEd ai v.Doyl 429U. 27 28
993 ctng . ll t hool src
r
uc ton
ç,
S. 4, 7

( 9 7 (e urngplitf t s o : c us lr lto s i b t e te p oe td e p e so a d
1 7 ) r q ii an if o h w ç a a eain h p ewe n h r tce x r sin n
a
t e rtl t r a to ' Us o f re b p io o fcasvoae t e Eih h Ame d n o y
h eai o y ci n). e f o c y rs n fiil ilts h g t
a
n me t nl
whe a id ç lc ousy a s ditcal f t ve y pur e ofca i hn m.' Huds v.
n pple i ii l nd a si ly or he r
ma
pos
usng r '
on

M c lin 5 3 U. 1 6 ( 9 2 . Fo c a p id ln a g o -at ef r t manan o rso e
Mila , 0 S. , 1 9 ) re p le t o d fi fo t o iti r et r
i
h
dicplne' o t ot rha i notInc tt i l l
s i i ,' n he he nd, s
l onsiutona . d.
11
I

Th ma itaej g ' rp r p o ie aln h sl r o t etsi n p e e tdb
e g sr t ud es e o t r vd s e gty l
mma y f h e tmo y r sn e y
t pa te wines e a t e de i r he rng a a sl a y of a vi r c di of Sgt
he ris' t s s t he vi nta y a i nd lmm r
deo e or ng
.

Col 'u eo OC s ry a an tBlu to Oco e 8 2 3 i e pa t h so j ce t te
lns s f
i
p a g is o n n t b r , 01 .Net r ry a b e td o h
h
a c a y of t s sl ma y or a s td t t a wine s t sii d dif r nty t r pored.
c ur c
hi lm r
s ere ha ny t s e tfe fe e l han e t
Acc di y, hec ta st f c ua s
or ngl t our dopt he a t l umm a y oft r t
r
he epor.

Blu to j cst t erpo tsc n l in t a ih e d n ep ru d st ec u t h tte
o n b e t o h e r' o cuso h t t e vie c e s a e h o r t a h
t
us of f c w a not e es i unr a ona e or r a i t y,butr t r w a us d i a e f tt
e
or e s
xc s ve, e s bl
et la or
a he
s e n n f or o

man an imae ds iln . ( No 51 p. . On t i g o n ,t ema itaej d efn s
iti n t icp ie' ECF . , 21)
'
hs r u d h gsrt u g i d
t ha Bl
l t ountha f ie t s
t
s a ld o how alkelhood ofs e son hi r t la i cli 'a r omm e
i i
ucc s
s e a iton a m' nd ec
nds

d na o G i rq e tf rprl n r ij n tv r l f' (d. Blt a s rst a i r a high r
e il f t s e u s o ei a y nu cie ei . I ) omt se t h t n e c n e
h
mi
e'
fn ig a d c n l ins te ma itae j d e fie t c n ie s me o h s e ie e a d
i dn s n o cuso , h
gsrt u g ald o o sd r o
f i v d nc n
i ope l ga mor we g t c ran ofk e s t si ony a
mpr ry ve
e i ht o e t i t r ' e tm
boutSgt Coli 'g ne alte t e
. lns e r r am nt
ofi a e .
nm t s

Th c u tfn s n mei t Blt ' o j cins Th ma itaej d e a p o itl
e o r i d o rt o omts b e to . e gsrt u g p rpraey
dec i d t de i f om conta c or e de
lne o c de '
r
r di t y vi nce w he he Bl
t r ount t e t ne Coli or Coli
hr a e d
lns
lns

tle tn dBlu t Th is eb f r t ec u t t h s t tr i n twh t e S t Coln ' cin
l ae e o n . e su e o e h o r a t i jmct e s o eh r g . l s a to s
r
l
i

aga ns Bl
i t ountw e e r t i or or e s i f c i vi aton ofhi c tt t o lr ght Thes
r e alat y
xce sve or e n ol i
s ons iu i na i s.
e

q e t nswil er s le b t ej r a til
u si
o
l b e ov d y h u y tra.
The c r n i uiy i whe he Bl ts e de de onsr t t ne f pr lmi r
ur e t nq r s
t r oun ' vi nce m taes he ed or ei na y

ijmcierle t e t ehi s ft t it til Th a we i n Theu d s u e e i e c i
nt tv eif o nsl s a ey mtlhe ra. e ns r s o.
r
n ip td v d n e s
t t Sg Coli us OC s ay agans Bl mtonl a r s e ng m e c la ova a onl
ha t
lns ed
pr
i t ot
y he e ki
di a ppr l nd y

a tr Bl mtr peae y r us d t compl wih die tor r . Alo undipu e i t e de e
fe ot e t dl ef e o
y t r c de s
s
s t d s he vi nc
t ta t Coli s aye Bl t ,t i ae r f e de a i ton and r quie no m e c l
ha fer lns pr d o mt he nm t e us d contm na i
e rd
di a

c r . Ba e o te e f cs t e c u ta re wi te ma itaej d e ta Bl t ha n t
ae
s d n h s a t, h o r g e s t h
h
gsrt u g h t omt s o
de onsr t d a lke i
m ta e
i lhood ofs es i pr ng t tSgt Coli 'a tons s tsi t r quiie
ucc s n ovi ha
. lns c i
a ifed he e st
consiutonalsa r f r t la i or e e sve f c I ot r wor ,fom t e de e
tt i
t nda ds or e aiton
xc s i or e. n he
ds r
he vi nc

p ee td, ti n mo e l l ta n tta jzo swi fn i fvo o Blt o t e ecams
r s ne i s o r i y h n o h t l r l i d n a r f omt n h s li .
ke
r
l
Ass h,Bl
uc
ountha f ie t esa ih a s t nta lkei
s a ld o t bls ubsa il i lhood ofs ce son t m e is whih i
uc s
he rt , c s

o e o tef u ee nsr q ie t warn t ee ta r ia yrme y o p ei n r ij n tv
n f h o r lme t e urd o ra t h xr o dn r e d f r lmia y nu cie
r le . Re lTrzh,5 F. a 346ei f
a t 75 3d t
t
47.
I
AJ

Fo t e r a o s sae , t c u t o e r ls Blu ts o j cin t te rp r a d
r h e s n ttd he o r v rue o n ' b e to s o h e o t n
rc
e omm e ton,ado s t r por i ise ie y,a de esBl mts m o i f pr lmi r
nda i
pt he e t n t ntr t nd ni
ot ' tons or ei na y

ijmcier l f An a pr p it o d rwil su ti d y.
nt tv ei . p o rae r e l is e h s a
e
The Cl k i diece t s c es of t s me or ndum opi on a ac ompa ng
er s r td o end opi
hi m a
ni nd c
nyi
or rt pl ntf .
de o ai i f

E R:T i %V dyo Api 2 1 .
NTE hs
a f rl 0 4
,
Chi Unie Stt Diti tJ
ef t d aes src udge

4