Vazzana v. CitiMortgage, Inc. et al

Filing 26

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 6/4/2013. (lab)

cL s OFFI U . . ST.
ERK'
CE S DI COURT
AT ROANOKE.
VA
FIED
L

I THE U N I
N
TED STATES DI
STRI CO U RT
CT
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF VI NI
CT
RGI A
ROAN OK E D I I ON
V SI

J 2i 2 1
UN
23
J I .
ULA

L C
EY,

DO RO TH Y L V AZZA N A ,

Ci lA c i N o.7: 2CV 00
vi ton
1
497

Pl i if
antf,
M EM O R AN DU M O PI I N
N O

By:Ho Gl E.
n. en Conr d
a
Chi fU nie St t s Di t i tJ
e
t d a e sr c udge

CI M ORTGA G E,I C.
TI
N ,
De e nt
f nda .

Thi c e i pr enty bef r t co ton a m oto t di m i sfl d by Cii o t ge, nc.
s as s es l
o e he ur
i n o s s ie
tM r ga I

(t tM o t ge' a Fe r lHomeLoa M o tageCor ai (s e eMac'( l tvel
' i rga ' nd de a
ci
)
n rg
porton k ddi
Fr
' coleci y,
)
t fnda s'. Fort ras stf t bel t moto wilbega e i pa4a d edi
û e nt'
de
)
he e ons e orh ow,he in l rntd n l nd eni n
Part
.
Backeround

On A ugus 22,2005,D or t L. a za obt i d a hom e m orgage l n f o ABN
t
o hy V z na a ne
t
oa r m

Amr M o t geGr l ($ ' f pr rylcaedat1 Dit Br nc La ,Pel
o rga
oup, nc.:
ABN' or ope t o t
)
70 to a h ne rhook,
Vi gi a. The l w ase de ed by a not a s c e by a dee oft us . The not wasl t r
r ni
oan
vi nc
e nd e ur d
d r t
e
ae
a s gne t C ii orgage t c r ntnot hol r
s i d o tM t , he ur e
e de .
Ats e poi ,Vaz a f l be nd on he m or ga pa e s. On Aprl9,201
om
nt
z na e l hi
r
t ge ym nt
i
0,
Cii o t ge s nthe a pr a c e a i w n ni notc The notc a s d V a a t ther
tM r ga e
r e- c el r ton r ng i e.
i e dvi e
zz na ha

morg wa i de a t a t ts wa r quie t pa $5, 9 00 i or rt brng he l n
tage s n f ul, nd ha he s e r d o y 1 4. n de o i
r oa
c r nt Thenotc w a ne t tf l e t pa t t a a o due a ow i w ihi 30 da m a
ur e .
i e r d ha aiur o y he ot l m unt
nd
ng t n
ys y
r ul i accel aton oft l and a s equentf ecl ur s e oft pr
es t n
er i
he oan
ubs
or os e al
he opert
y.

Afe Va a f ie t pa t s m de a
tr zz na a ld o y he u
m ndedi t pr a ee ai notc Cii o t ge
n he e- cc lr ton i e, tM rga

a ntdW itt tTil & Es r Compa LLC (k ittdt' a s tt et se f t
ppoi e tsad te
cow
ny,
i tsa ' s ubsiut nzte or he
W
)
pur e ofi ta i f ecos epr e ngs On J y 29 201 W itt notfedVaz a on
pos
niitng or l ur oc edi .
ul , 0, tsadt ii
z na,
be fofCii o t ge, ha t orgi lnot c d notbepr
hal
tM rga t t he i na e oul
oduce a t t i f ure n da ,
d, nd ha ,n o te ys
Cii orga w oul bem a ng a r s t tt s tt et us e s lt pr r y pur ua t t
tM t ge
d
ki
eque t ha he ubsiut r t e el he ope t
s nt o he
t r s oft de oft us .
em
he ed r t
On Se e ber 1 201 t pr r y w ass d a a f r l ur s l t Fr ddi M a
pt m
4, 0, he ope t
ol t o ec os e a e o e e c.
Freddi M ac s equenty ptr
e
ubs
l lsued an unl f det neracton agai tV azzana i t Gener
aw ul ai
i
ns
n he
al

D i ti tCour ofFr nkln Count Fr eM a obt ne aj
s rc
t
a i
y. eddi c ai d udgme i isf
nt n t avora Va za
nd z na
wasevi t d f om t pr r y.
c e r he ope t

On Augus 27,201 Va za fl d t i t nta ton i t Cic tCou tofFr nkln
t
2, z na ie he nsa c i n he r ui
r
a i
Count Cii orga a Fr e M a r m ove t c s t t s c t a t n m ove t
y. tM t ge nd eddi
c e
d he a e o hi our, nd he
do

dimist c antpurua t Rul 1 b)6)oft Fedea RulsofCi lPr e e.
s s he ompli
s nt o e 2( (
he
rl e
vi oc dur
The c thel ahea i on t de e nt 'm o i on M ar h 1 201 Folowi t
our d
rng he f nda s ton
c 2, 3.
l ng he
he rng,t c t nt r a or rt ki t m oton unde a s me pe ngt flng ofa
a i he our e e ed n de a ng he i
r dvie nt ndi he ii
n
a e d co pl nt
m nde m ai .
V a za f l d he a ende c pl i o M a c 26,
z na ie r m
d om a nt n r h
2013. I Coun O ne oft a e d
n
t
he m nde
c pl n ,Vaz ana a l ge t tCii o t ge br a hed t not and t de d oft us b pr di
om ai t
z
le s ha tM r ga
ec
he e
he e
r t y ovi ng
a detc e pr a ce e a i no i e. I CountTwo,V a za ale t tC ii orgage br ac d
i i nt e- c l r ton tc
n
z na l ges ha tM t
e he
t de d oftus by pr di a de i i tl tnot l te a afi vi. l C o Thr e, az a
he e
r t
ovi ng
t c en os
e e t r nd fda t n unt e V z na
ass ' a cl m f br
ert
s ai or each oft i pled covenantofgood f t and fai dealng. I CountFour
he m i
aih
r
i
n
,

Vaz anaase t acam f de lrt yj me . Shese c
z
srs li or ca aor udg nt
e ks ompe aor d gesa a or r
nst y ama nd n de
qui i tte t t pr
etng il o he opert i herf .
yn
avor

Folow i t tlng oft a e d co pl nt t de e nt fl d as e e a b i fi
l ng he i i
he m nde m ai , he f nda s ie uppl m nt l r e n
s
uppor oft rm o i t dim i s The m oto ha bee f l br e e a i rpe f r vi w .
t hei ton o s s .
i n s n uly i f d nd s i or e e
St
andard ofR evi
ew

t-hepur eo aRul 1 b)6)motoni t t tt s fce yofac ant'
ûl
pos f
e 2( (
i s o es he ufiinc
ompli .
'
Edwa dsv. t ofGol bor 178F. 231 243( hCi.1 . Towihsa amoto t
r Ciy
ds o,
3d , 4t r 999)
t tnd
in o
di m i sf l d pur ua t t sr l ,( co pl i m us c t i s t c e f t lm a t r a c pt d a
s s ie
s nt o hi u e d m a nt t on a n ufi i nt ac ua te , c e e s
a
t ue t S t t acl i f r i ft ti pl us bl on isf c '' A s r tv.l l 556 U . 66 678
r , o s a e a m or ele ha s a i e t a e.'
hc of qba ,
S. 2,

(
2009)( i BelAt.Co . Twombl 55 U. 5 5 (
quotng l l p v.
y, 0 S. 44, 70 2007). fl ea r r ctl of
) ç- dbae e ias
-hr
t e e nt ofac us ofac in,s
he l me s
a e
to upporedbym e eco us r sae e s do nots fc ' 1
t
r ncl o y t tm nt,
ufi e. d.
'

l c i rngaRul 1 b)6)moton,t co tma pr ryc i re bisat he t t
n onsdei
e 2( (
i he ur y opel onsde xhi t tac d o he
c pl n i a ton t t c pl i is l . Fa te le I t sv.
om ai t n ddii o he om a nt t e f
ye t vil nvesor Com m e ci lBuide s I .
r a
l r . nc ,

936F. 1 1 ( h Ci.1 )
2d 462, 465 4t r 991.
D icussi
s
on

C ount O ne:Breach oft N ot and Deed ofT rus
he
e
t

l Co tOne, a za c a m st tCii o t gebr a hed t not a t de d oft u tby
n un
V z na l i ha tM r ga
ec
he e nd he e
rs
pr di a de i i ntpr a c e a i notc Unde V igi a l w , he es e i lel m e sofa
ovi ng
fce
e- c el r ton i e.
r r ni a t
s nta e nt

c eofaci f brac ofc r taea f l :t 1 al lye orea eobi tonofa
aus
ton or e h ontac r s olows i ) egal nf c bl lgai
(

d fn a tt apan if ( )ted fnd n ' vilto o b e c o t a o iain; nd( )ijzyo
ee d n o litf; 2 h ee a ts oain r r a h f h t bl to a 3 n t r
g
r
da
maget t pl ntf c e by t br ac ofo i a i ' Fia v. r 594 S. 2d61 61
o he ai if aus d he e h blg ton. lk Geo ge,
'
E.
0, 4

( 2004)
Va.
.
Havi revi ed t alegatonsi t am ended com pl nt t courtconcl
ng
ew
he l i n he
ai , he
udest Count
hat

One as e t a pl usbl c a m f rbr c ofcon r c . Seel ,556 U . a 678. l i undiput d
s rs a i e l i o ea h
ta t
qbal
S. t
ts
s e

t tVa za wasc r t lye il t noiebeor t l nwa ac elrtd. ( ea !6( ;
ha z na
ontacual ntted o tc f e he oa s c e ae Not t ( C)

Dee ofTr ta !22. Va za hass fce l aleg t tCii orgagebrac dt noi
d
us t ) z na ufiinty l ed ha tM t
e he he tce
pr s onsoft no e a t de oft us by o s a i t a oun i a r a s W he ea t
ovi i
he t nd he ed r t
ver t tng he m
t n re r .
r s he

pr - c e a i notc lsedt t a a ountduea owi a $5, 94. Va za cli st t
e ac elr ton ie it he ot l m
nd ng s 1 00, z na am ha

ds wa ,i f tonl $ 537.4 i ara s' ( Co . t!1 )
the s n ac, y 2, 7 n re r . Am. mpla 4.
'
V a za hasal o s f c e l pl d t ts w a ha m ed by t a l ged br a h. V a a
z na
s uf i i nty e ha he s r
he le
ec
zz na
cl i st ti t no i ha a ur t y s a ed t a oun i a r r ,s û oul ha bee a e t
a m ha f he tce d cc a el t t he m
t n rea s he i d ve n bl o
w

pa s ha
y uc mount'a t ,a d a ceeai a f ecos e (d.a 1 ) Spe iialy,
' nd,hus voied c lrton nd or l ur. I t 5.
cfc l
Va za alege t ti Cii orga k dce bl t e tne ( lwiha eeai a
z na l s ha f tM t ge t rdi y hrae d her t cc lrton nd
ha
f e os eunl ss pa d $ 5 7 wihi 30 da , z nac d ha r ie $2, 74t pay
or cl ur es he i 2,37.4 t n
ys Va za oul ve as d 537. o
Cii orgag w ihi s h 30 da by a co bi ton ofhe t n ava l bl f
tM t e t n uc
ys
m na i
r he
ia e unds a bo r w i
nd r o ng

f fo fmiy. (d. Vaz naf t ral st ts t dno atmp t r s t muc
unds rm a l ' I )
'
za urhe lege ha he i
di t te t o aie he h
hi he a
g r mountof$5, 94. ...be a es kne t ts wasbei t e t nedw ih f e os r
1 00
c us he w ha he
ng hr a e
t or cl u e
bas d on a g os l i l t s a e e ofw ha w asi area s a ... a e s di no be i ve
e
r s y nfa ed t t m nt
t
n r r ; nd
bec us he d t le

s ha t a lt t rie$5,94,0t pa Cii tagewihi 30da . (d. Asumi t
he d he biiy o as 1 0 o y tMorg
tn
ys' l ) s ng he
'
t u h ofVaz ana' a l tons t c tc l
rt
z s lega i , he our onc udest tCountOne s a e a pl us bl cl i f
ha
t t s a i e a m or

br a oft no eand de d oftus. A c or ngl , t de e nt 'moto t dim ist sc nt
e ch he t
e
r t1
c di y he f nda s
in o s s hi ou
w ilbe de e
l
ni d.
1l t rs ement r y bref tedee da t ur t c r t rj c Va z na s l gainsrg r n
n hei uppl
al epl i , h f n ns ge he ou t o ee t z a ' al to e a dig
e
herabiiy t pay on t basst tt y ar diec l contadit by an Aprl26, 0 ltert Cii orga
lt o
he i ha he e r ty
r ced
i 201 e t o tM t ge,
whi wa atache asa e bi t t amended compl nt Upon r e oft l t and t alegatons
ch s t d n xhi t o he
ai .
eviw
he eter
he l i
i t a ended com pl nt t c ti unper uaded by t def
n he m
ai , he our s
s
he endant 'ar
s gument W hie coursar not
.
l
t e
r r t a
equied o cceptk
û
concl or alegatons i t compl ntt tar contadi ed by t atachm ent ,'
us y l i n he
ai ha e
r ct
he t
s'

J fr yM . o As o ,nc v. c vil To Ct.l .7F. p' 1 7, 02( hCi. 01, z a '
e fe Br wn s c.l . Ro k le wn r.nc, Ap x 9 2 4t r 20 ) Va z nas
alegatonsr di herabiiy t pay ar notbar orc us y. M or r,t l t doesnotwholy
l i egar ng
lt o
e
e oncl or
eove he eter
l

c nr dit ral gains oro h r s i e ry e tbls )ta s c l no ha r nsae t l n
o ta c he l to , t e wie d a l sa ihg h t he oud t ve ei ttd he oa
e
cl
wihi 3 da , ( f . Su Re yBr a 2. W hiet elte idiae t a Va z naha oban d
t n 0 ys' Des' pp. pl . t )
'
l h etr n c td h t z a
d tie
e o n a ta s ea tcpae b ig a et e l e u mo y fo h rne o t p yt
mplyme t nd h t h nii td en bl o a' no gh ne r m e wj b o a he
n
r ai ng l n bal e i si mont ,V a
em ni oa
anc n x
hs zzana di nots
d
ugges t ts had no ot rs cesoff ,or
t ha he
he our
unds
t i woul be i pos i ef he t pay t a ounti arear i a mor tmel f hi
hat t
d m sbl or r o
he m
n r sn
e i y as on.

I
l.

CountTw o:Br ac oft D e ofTrus
e h
he ed
t

I CountTw o oft a e d co pl nt V a za ale t tCii orgag br a d
n
he m nde m ai , z na l ges ha tM t e e che
par gr ph 2 oft de oft us by f e l i o t pr ry w ihou c pl ng w ih
a a 2 he ed r t or c osng n he ope t t t om yi
t

j55- 18)oft CodeofVigi a. Paa a 22pr dest ti adea ti notcur byt
59.(
he
r ni
rgrph
ovi ha f ful s
ed he
dat s cii i t pr - cc e a i no i ,t l nde S a i
e pe fed n he e a el r ton tce he e r k y nvoke t pow e ofs l a a
m
he
r a e nd ny

ot rrme esper te byApplc bl La ' ( dofTr ta !22. Thetr t ia e
he e di
mitd
ia e w. Dee
'
us t )
em t c bl
Appl
Law ' i udesr l va V i gi a sa ut .
' ncl
e e nt r ni t t es
The V igi a s a u e cied b V a a pr de i peri n pa ta f l s
r ni t t t t y zz na ovi s n tne t r s olow :
I a no e orot re denc ofi t dnes s tr d by a de d oft us i l torf r
f
t
he vi e ndeb e
s ec le
e
r t s os
o
any r s c nno be pr
ea on a t
oduce a t be i i . s ist t tusee a
d nd he netc a y ubm t o he r t n
r
afi vi t t tefe t tuseema none hees pr e t s l ,pr vi d t
fda t o ha f d, he r t
y
t l s oc ed o a e o de he
bene i a y hasgi n wr te notce t t pe s r uie t pay t i t um e
fci r
ve
it n i o he r on eq r d o
he ns r nt
t tt i t u e i una ia e and a r que tf s l w ilbe m a oft t s e
ha he nsr m nt s va l bl
e s or a e l
de he nlt e
upon e r ton of 1 da fom t da e ofm aii oft notc The no i e s l
xpia i
4 ys r he t
lng he i e.
t c ha l
be s ntby c r ii d m ai,r t n r e ptr quese t t l s know n a e s oft
e
e tt e
l e ur ec i e
t d, o he a t
ddr s
he
pe s r quie t pa t i t u e asr f e t d i t r c ds oft be f c a y
r on e r d o y he ns r m nt e l c e n he e or
he ne i i r
and s li l t na e a m a lng a e soft t s e ....I t t us e
hal nc ude he m nd ii ddr s
he nzt e
f he r t e
pr e t s l ,t f tt tt i t um e i l to c nnotbe pr
oce ds o a e he ac ha he ns r nt s os r a
oduc d s l no
e ha l t
af e tt au hort oft tus ee t s l ort va i t oft s l .
f c he t iy he r t o e l he ldiy he a e

Va.
Codej55- 1B)
59.( .
Va za cli st tCii orgagebr c pa agr ph22 oft de oft t tbyi tt i
z na am ha tM t
ea hed r a
he ed rl
s
nsiutng

f e os epr ee ngswiho s nghe al tnoelte t tcompledwih j55 5 1B)
orcl ur oc di
t ut endi r os t etr ha
i t
- 9.( .
Va za co e t tt l tnot lte s t he on J y 29,201 wa i ld,bec us i di
z na nt nds ha he os e et r ent o r ul
0 s nva i
a et d
nots cii ly i ntf W it t ta t s tt e t u t e. H a ng r vi w e t l te a t
pe fca l de iy tsad s he ubs iut r s e
vi e e d he e t r nd he
s a u e, e r t cour a e w ih t de enda t t tt l t e c ai no a tona e
t t t how ve , he
t gr es t he f
n s ha he e t r ont ns
c i bl

ir ulrt Se ton j55- 9.( rquiest tt l tnot lte (ncudet na a maii
reg aiy. ci
5 1B) e r ha he os e etr d l he me nd lng
i
addr oft t t 'r
ess he rus ee' espons bl f i iutng f ecl e pr
i e or nstt i or osur oceedi
ngs. l accor
n
dance w ih
t

t s r quiem e ,t l tnot l tc i l d t c a ti or a i f W itt dt t s bs iut
hi e r nt he os e e t r nc ude he ont c nf m ton or ts a , he u tt e

tuse a nt d f t pu pos ofco
r te ppoi e or he r e
nduci t f e l ur s l R iet lte doesnot
tng he or c os e a e.
l he et r
s ii a l r f t W itt a t s tt t tuse t c ti c nce t tt lte
pecfc ly e er o tsadt s he ubsiu e r te, he our s onvi d ha he e tr
com plesw ih t st ut
i
t he at e.

I a e ,j55- 1f t rpr de ,insrihtor r a une voc llng ,
n ny vent
59. urhe ovi s ' tag f wa d nd qui a a uage
i

t t(talr t c mp ywihter q rme t o n tc c nan di t i s cin s al o afc
ha ( iu e o o l t h e uie ns f oie o ti e n hs e to h ln t fe t
l
t vai t oft s l ....' Prnci lRei nta M orc.v.O' a1 55Va. r 250, (
he ldiy he ae
'' i na sde il t
Ne ,
Ci. 251 Va.

Ci. . )( i Va.
r Ct2001 quotng Codej55- 1C). Thus eve i t l tnot lte wa defce ,i
59.( )
, n f he os e etr s iint t
w oul notr
d
ende t s l i ld unde t a i a e l w . A c or ng y, a za s a l ga i
r he a e nva i
r he pplc bl a
c di l V z na' le tons
r ga di t l tnot l te f i t s a e a cl i upo w hi r le m ay be gr nt d.
e r ng he os e e t r a l o t t
am
n
ch e i f
a e
V a za al o c ai st tCii o t ge i tt ed f ec os e pr ee ngsw iho
z na s l m ha tM r ga ns iut or l ur oc di
t ut

pr di al tnot afda tasrquiedby j55- 1. ( Compl!53. Asstf t a
ovi ng os e fi vi e r
59. Am.
. )
e orh bove,
j5559. pr dest ti anot i l torohewieuna ia e t tuse ma nonehees
- 1 ovi ha f
e s os t r s valbl,he r te y
t ls
pr ee t s ei dhebenei ays bmist t tuseea atdavit t tef t' Va Codej
oc d o al f s
t
fcir u t o he r t n fi t o ha fec.
' .

55- 18)(mpha i a ) Thesaut û ont nsnor uie ntt tt l tnot afd t
59.4 e
ss dded .
tt e t ai
c
eq rme ha he os e fiavi
t tm us be gi n t t t us e alo be g ve t Pl i i f' V a v. C H o e Loan Ser c nc
ha
t
ve o he r t e s
i n o a ntf .
' n BA
m
vi i

LP,No.4:0c 201 U. Dit LEXI 1 21 a *1 ( D. Se . 201 ) W hie
1 v73, 0 S. s.
S 45 6, t 0 E. Va. pt23, 0 .
l
V a za as e t ,i a c us y f hi n, ha Cii orga f l t pr de a d ope l tnot
z na s r s n oncl or as o t t tM t ge aied o ovi
t
pr r os e
afi vi' t t tus ee he nm e d co pl i c ai no a l tonst ts
f da t' o he r t , r
nde m a nt ont ns
lega i ha uppor t s c ai .
t hi l m

Be us ls ke aseringj de dof'urhe fcua e
ca e ina d s to s' voi f t r a t l nhanc me ''aei ufiintt
e nt' r ns fce o
wihsand amoton t dim is t c twilgr n t de e nt 'm o i n wih r s c t t s
t t
i o s s ,he our l a t he f nda s to t e pe t o hi

c . Se lbal556U. a 678( i Twombl 550U. a 5 .
ount e q ,
S. t
quotng
y,
S. t 57)
11
1.

C ountT hree:Breach oft l pled C ovenantofG ood Fai and Fai D ealne
he m i
th
r
i

l hert rd count V azzana cl m st Cii orgage br
n
hi
,
ai hat tM t
eached t i pled covenantof
he m i

g f t and f rde i co ane i t not andt de oftu t Fo t f l ngr s ,
ood aih
ai alng nt i d n he e
he ed r s . r he olowi ea ons

t ec u t o cu e ta ti cam i as s b e t ods sa.
h o r c n ld s h t h s li s lo u j c t imis l
The Unied St t Cour ofAppe sf t Fourh Cic tha he d t tc r c sgove ne
t
a es
t
al or he
t r ui s l ha ont a t
r d
by V igi a l w c ai a i ple c na ofgood f t a f i de lng. Se W ol v.
r ni a ont n n m i d ove nt
aih nd a r a i
e
f Fed. a .
N t

Mor As ' No.11241 201 U. App.LEXI 4300,a * ( hCi. b.28,201 (ii
c. sn,
- 9, 3 S.
S
t 20 4t r Fe
3) ctng

Enomot v.Spa Adve ur .Lt , F.Supp.2d4 45 ( D. .2009);Va. r c ie
o
ce
nt es d.624
43, 0 E. Va
) Ve miult.
Lt v. . Grce& Co. 1 F. 535,5414 ( h Ci.1 . Howe r i i iddut
d. W R. a
s 56 3d
-2 4t r 988)
ve,t mple y
no
ars sw ih r pe tt ac i t g r d by e e s c nt a t t r s ' Skil t r ,I v. e
i e t es c o tviy ove ne
xpr s o r c ual e m .'
ls o m nc. El c,

DaaSvs.LLC,666F.Supp. 61 620( D. 2009)(ii W ad' Egui .I v. w
t .
2d 0, E. Va.
ctng r s p. nc. Ne
Hola N. n.49 S. 2d51 5 ( 1
lnd AJ , 3 E. 6, 20 Va. 997:. Thus l npa te t aco r c ce t vai
,f
whe ris o nta t rae ld
and bi ng r g s a i pled c na of g f t a f rde lng i i pplc bl t t e
ndi i ht , n m i ove nt ood aih nd ai a i s na i a e o hos
rght . W a d' Ecui , nc ,493 S. 2d a 520. A sex a ne by t Fourh Cic t û lhough
i s'
'
r s l p. l .
E. t
pl i d
he
t r ui, t t
a
t dut ofgood f t doesnotpr nta pa t f om e r i i ise i i co r c ua r gh s a
he y
aih
eve
ry r
xe c s ng t xplc t nt a t l i t ,
pa t m a no e r s co r c ua di c e i n i ba f ih, ve whe s h di c e i i vesed
r y y t xe ci e nt a t l s r t o n d a t e n
n uc s r ton s t
s e y i t tpa t ' Va, e m i ult Lt ,1 F. d a 542.
ol l n ha r y.'
V r c ie. d. 56 3 t

l t sca e Va za r i on t s m ea lga i unde l ng he cai sf br ac of
n hi s , z na eles he a
le tons
ryi
r l m or e h
c r ti t pr vi c
ontac n he e ous ount t s
s o uppor he cl i f rbr a h oft i pled c na tofgood
t r am o e c
he m i ove n

fiha f id ai . Se Am . mpla !6 (va z n r -vest f csstfrhi Co n On
at nd ar e l
ng e
Co . t 6 ' z a a ea r he a t e o t n u t e
ç
a CountTwo ....) Asstfrha
nd
'.
'
e o t bove,hos al to pe ti s el t Cii t ge'
t e legains ran ol y o tMorga s
e r i e ofisc r c ua r g t a e e a e pa m e a f r l e on t pr pe t afe V a za
xe c s
t ont a t l i ht o cc l r t y nt nd o ec os
he o ry t r z na
def t on he m o t ge. Be aus a pa t doesnotbr a h t i ple dut ofgood f ih a
auled
r r ga
c e
ry
e c he m i d y
a t nd
f i de i w he i e r s s e e sr g sunde a c r t a snc t a e d c pl i
a r alng
n t xe ci e xpr s i ht
r ontac , nd i e he m nde om a nt

i udesnoal ai whihplusbl s es t tCii t geç xecs dqc rdua
ncl
leg tons e a i y ugg t ha tMorga k riel onta l
e

dic e i i badf ih,' ri pe ntcli f br a h oft i pledco na ofgo f iha
s r ton n
at 'he nde nde am or e c
he m i
ve nt
od at nd
f i dea i m us be dim i s d. V a. e c t .Lt ,1 F. a 5 ,s al o Re i v.
a r lng
t
s se
V nni ule d. 56 3d t 42. çe s hbe n

Cii orca l , 2:3CV65, 3U. DitLEXI 491 4,a *21( D. Apr 4, 3)
tM t ge.nc.No. 1
201 S. s.
S 0 t E. Va. . 201 '
,
Be tv. nkofAm,N. ,3:2CV34, 2U. DitLEXI 54725, t* ( D. Apr 1
nnet Ba
, A. 1
201 S. s.
S
a 30 E. Va. . 8,

201 .
2)
1V .

C ountI :D ecl orv Judzm ent
V
arat

l Coun 1 Vaz nas e ade lrt yj me sai t ts i notr s i ef
n
t V, za e ks caaor udg nt ttng ha he s eponsbl or
f r c os e- e a e cos si ur e by Cii or ga
o e l ur r l t d t nc r d
tM t ge. She con e t tCii orga w asnot
t nds ha tM t ge

e il t a s hc t t he rmani l no i tons ûblc et pur tdf e os e
ntted o dd uc oss o r e i ng oa blgai ,s e aus he pore orcl ur
l
wasvoi .... ( Compla !76.
d ' Am.
'
.t )
Thecou ta ee wih t de e nt t tVa z naha nots fcenty saed ac am f ra
r gr s t he f nda s ha z a
s
ufi i l t t
li o

d ca ao yj d me t k Dl caao yj d me t aed sg e t d ca erg t s t tp risc n
e lr tr u g n . t e lrt r u g n s r e in d o e lr ih s o ha a t a
g
e
conf t i c
onn he r onduc t avoi f ur ltga i ' Ta av. t d St t Ba N . . 718F.
to
d m e ii ton.
' pi Unie a es nks A ,
Supp.

2d689,695( D.Va.201 ) isuc r i i unavalbl whee... amsa rght ase td
E.
0 . i h elef s
ia e r cli nd i s sre
ha f l m a ur d,a t a l d wr
ve uly t e nd he lege ongsha a r a bee s f e ' G a l ntv. e s he
ve l e dy n uf er d.
' la
D ut c

Ba Na'Tr tCo.766F.Supp. 71 71 ( . Va. 1 (ntma cttona quotton
nk tl us ,
2d 4, 9 W D. 201 ) i e l iai nd ai
maksomitd)
r
te .
l t s c e, he f e os e s e w a c
n hi as t or cl ur al s onduc e ne ry t e yea s a i Se e be of
t d a l hr e r go n pt m r
201 Be us t a l ge w r o ques i bl c
0. ca e he le d ong r
tona e onduc hasale oc ur e t co ta e
t
r ady c r d, he ur gr es
w ih t def nda st tdec a a or r le i i ppr pr a e a t tCountI m us be di m i s
t he e nt ha
l r t y e i f s na o i t nd ha
V
t
s s ed.
Sçç Bagl v.W elsFargo Balk,N . . N o.3: CV ey
l
z
A,
12- 617,2013 U . D it.LEX I 11880,at*22
S. s
S

( D. .J n. 201 ( s si a i ntc lcl m f de lrt yr le Esr lav.W els
E. Va a 29, 3) dimisng n de ia ai or caaor eig; tel
l

8

FagoBa N. ,No.2: 1 41 2011U. DitLEXI 1
r
nks A.
1 cv 4,
S. s.
S 48778, *17 8( D.Va De 28,
at -1 E. . c.
2011 (a )
) sme .
V.

Pl ntf' O ui tTil Cl m
ai ifs e te ai

I Cou s 1 I , nd I1 o t a e d c pl i ,Va zana c am s t ts i e il d t a
n
nt , 1 a I f he m nde om a nt z
l i ha he s ntt e o n
o de qui tng ttet t pr r y i he f vor l V ig ni ,E l a ton t q e tte i ba e on t
r r e i il o he ope t n r a . n r i a s l c i o ui t il s s d he
a

p e s t tap ro wi g o ttet c ranra o p ro l r p rys o l n t es b e tdt
r mie ha es n t o d i o e ti e l r es na p o e t h ud o b u jce o
h
l
vai f ur camsa i tt ttte. M anev. ms 672 S. 2d 8 866( .2009 . A
rous ut e li gans ha il ' i Ada ,
'
E. 62, Va
)
pl ntf as i a qui tte cl m m us pr t s hasrght super ort ot as i an
ai if sertng
et il ai
t ove hat he
i s
i o hers sertng

i e es i t pr pe t G a l nt 766 F.Supp. a 71 Ta a 71 F.Supp. a 700.
nt r t n he o ry. la ,
2d t 9; pi , 8
2d t
A c r ngl f er lc t i V igi a ha r i l di m i s d qui ttte c a m si s m ia c es
co di y, ed a our s n r ni ve outne y s s e
e il l i n i l r as ,
w he e pl i if f ie t aleg t tt y ha s ts i d t i oblga i unde t not a de d of
r a ntf s a l d o l e ha he d a i f e he r i tons
r he e nd e
tus . Se e. ,Ta a 71 F.Supp. a 700;M a ut v. d. o e Loa M o t Cor , o.
r t
e, c. pi , 8
2d t
b ol Fe H m
n r g. p. N

2:2c
1 v406,201 U. DitLEXI 42685,a *1 ( D. .M a.25,201 ;Towns ndv. nni
3 S. s.
S
t 3 E. Va r
3)
e
Fn e
M a No.3:2-ve,
1 c 00045, 3U. Dit LEXI l
201 S. s.
S 8588, t* ( . Va. b.1 201 ;Blckv.
a 35 W D. Fe 2, 3) i

W el Fa g Bal N. ,No.3: 1c 00081 201 U. Dit LEXI 41 6,a *1 ( . Va.
ls r o rk, A.
1 -v, 2 S. s.
S 26 t 4 W D.
M a . 201 .
r 27, 2)
I t s c s ,t f c spl d i V a za s a e d c pl i d no pl usbl s es t t
n hi a e he a t e n z na' m nde om a nt o t a i y ugg t ha
s ha s i tt e t t pr pe t a i s
he s uperor il o he o ry t s ue. I i undi put d t tV a z de a t d o he
ts
s e ha z ana f ule n r
m o t ge a s doesnotale t ts hass ts i d he l n oblga i ort tt unde l ng
r ga , nd he
l ge ha he
a i fe r oa
i tons ha he
ryi
de hasbe n pa d,f gi n,o ca ele Co eque ty, o t e e V a za a t m p st br ng
bt
e i or ve r nc l d. ns
n l t he xt nt z na te t o i
a qui tte cl m i
et il ai ndependentofherot cl m s,t cour concl
her ai
he
t
udest such cl m m ustbe
hat
ai

dim i s d.
s se

9

C oncl i
us on
Fort r as s a ed, he d e nt m oto t di m i sw ilbe gr nt d i pa t nd de e
he e ons t t t ef nda s' i n o s s l
a e n ra
ni d
i pa t The Cl r i diec ed t s nd c r ii d copi oft sm em or ndum o ni a t
n r.
e k s r t o e e tfe
es hi
a
pi on nd he
a om pa ng or rt a 1c
cc
nyi
de o l ouns ofr co d.
el e r
EN TER : s
Thi

da ofJ
y
une, 3.
201
Chi fUnie St esD i ti tJ
e
t d at
s r c udge

10