Campbell v. Reynolds et al

Filing 42

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge James C. Turk on 1/22/2013. (tvt)

O FRKS OFFI U.S.D# COURT
CE
ST.
AT ROANOKE,V
A
4l.è)
21i2
7. ,
-

I TH E U N I
N
TED STA TES DI
STR I C O U RT
CT
FO R TH E W E STER N D I
STR I O F VI G I I
CT
R N A
ROANOKE DI I ON
V SI

BERNARD B.CAM PBELL,

J 22 2 1
AN
23
J
ULI ' &J'1 -'CkERK
- ' - fv ; .
('
'
BY;
DEPU'Y CL
I ERK
'

CASE NO.7: 2CV004
1
99

Pl ntf ,
ai i f

M EM OM NDUM OPI ON
NI
O FFICER S D U STI R EY N O LD S
N
AN D BENJA M I BA X LE v ,1
N

By: Jam es C .Turk
Se orUnie St e Dit itJudge
ni
t d at s s rc

D e endant .
f
s

Be na d B.Ca
r r
mpbel, Vigi a i t pr ee ng pr K ,tl d t sc vi rg sa to
l a r ni nma e oc di
o
ie hi i l iht c in

p ru n t 4 U. C. 1 8 Ca elalg st a t ed fnd n j i ofeasus de c si e
u s a t o 2 S. j 9 3. mpb l l e h t h ee a t al f il e x e sv
e
f c a i thi whe t y s a d hi wih pe rs a Upo r viw oft r c d,he
or e gans m
n he pr ye m t ppe m y.
n e e
he e or t

c u t d t a t ed f n a t' to f rs mma yj dg n mus beg a tdo tegomd
o r fn s h t h ee d n s mo in o u r u me t t rne n h r t
t tCa pbe lf ie t exha ta lbl a i sr tver m e e .
ha m l a ld o
us vaia e dm nita i e di s
I

Att tmeofe n sa i s i t slws t Cn
he i
ve t t s ue n hi a ui, mpbelwa a i t a t W e t r
l s n nma e t he se n

Vigi aRe ona J i (t VRJ'i Sae Vigi a.I hi j1 c ant Ca
r ni gi l al (W
' n lm, r ni n s 983 ompli , mpbelalges
)
l le :
1wa a tc by a i aeand f c d t de e mys l. W he Ofie Dusi
s ta ked
n nm t
or e o f nd
ef
n fc r tn
Re dsca i ot pod my a t ke fed.1i
ynol
me nt he
tac r l
mmedit l hel bot ha i
a ey d h nds n

t ara d o dont gound,yeli tlm downl' Re dspe r
he i nd r ppe
he r
lng t'
.l ynol ppe
'
s ry dme Ofi e Ba ly a c mpa idOfke Re n l .Afe s en ta 1
p a e . fc r xg ) c o ne f r y ods tr e ig h t
e
wa o t eg o n n t e itn , wa p p rs ry da anb Ba ly a trh
s n h r u d, o r ssig I s e pe p a e g i y xge ) fe e
( )ar dya knowl dIdbe ns a dbyRe ds
had lea c
edge ' e prye
ynol .
Compl 2. Ca
.
mpbels Ofi e sRe dsa Ba e s e ng mone a y da
l ues fc r ynol nd xly, e ki
t r mage a
s nd
dic plna y a ton a i tt ofi e s
s i i r c i ga ns he fc r .

' I hi c
n s ompl nt pl ntf r ered t t sdef ntasKofi Ba l ' The c twil
ai , ai if ef r o hi enda
ç fcer xsey.'
our l
r pec t ofk er sr
es t he t ' eques t ha hi name s l corec l astBaxl 'i t courtsr d.
t o ve s
peled r ty s ey' n he
' ecor

Dee nt ha fldamoin frs nmayj
fnda s ve ie
to o ur r udgme ont gr undt tCa
nt he o ha mpbel
l
f l t e us a ia e a nitai r medi be or flngt slws t a r uie u r
aied o xha t val bl dmi sr tve e
es f e ii hi a ui, s eq r d nde

4 U. C. 1 9 ea .Ca el sr s n e t d fn a t' to , kn tematrrp
2 S. j 9 7 () mpb lha epo d d o ee d n s moins ma ig h te ie
f diposton.
or s ii
1
1

Ana r o s mmayj d me ti a p o raewhe lhepla ig ,h d s o r a d
wad f u r u g n s p r p it n ç e dn s t e ic vey n
t
dicl ur ma e i so fl a a a fd t s
s os e t ral n ie, nd ny f avis how t tt r i no ge neis a t a
ha he e s
nui s ue s o ny

mae il a t n t a t emo a ti e tte t j d me t samatro lm 'F d. Ci .
tra f c a d h t h v n s n i d o u g n a
l
te f a ' e R. v P.
56() Forapa t sevi ncet r s age neis ofmaei fc s fcentt avoi
c.
ry' de o aie nui sue
tzal a t ufii o d

s mma yj d me t imu t eç u ht a ar a o bej r c udrt r av r it o t no
u r u g n ,t s b s c h t e s na l u y o l eu n e dc f r he ns
movi pat ' Ande s v. bet Lobby.nc.477U. 242,248( 986) l ma ngt s
ng ry.
'
ron Li ry
I ,
S.
1 . n ki hi
de e m i to S he cour i r qui e t vi t f ct a dr w r a ona e i e enc s i a lght
t r na i n, ç
t
t s e r d o ew he a s nd a e s bl nf r e n i

mos fvorbl t t nonmovi pa t ' Sha v.Sto 1 F. 791 798(t Ci.1 .
t a a e o he
ng ry.' w
r ud, 3 3d , 4h r 994)
A.

ThePrs Lii tonReor Ac (TLRA',
ion tgai
f m t(
' amongot rt ngs prvi si 42U. C.
)
he hi , o de n
S.
j1997 a)t taprs rcamotbrngacvi a tonc er ngprs c tonsuntlheha
e( ha ione l
i
i l ci onc ni ion ondii
i
s
frtexha td a ia ea nitai rme es Nusl v.Porer 534U. 51 524(
is
use valbl dmi srtve e di . se
t,
S. 6, 2002)
.
Thi e usi r r m e a i t $ l i t s t , t rt y i vege r l
s xha ton equie nt pples o ; l nma e uis whehe he nvol
a
ne a
c r um sa esorpa tc a e s s ...whe he t y a l ge exc s ve f ce o s e ot r
i c t nc
ri ul r pi ode ,
t r he le
es i or r om
he
w r ' a w he he t f m ofr le t i a e s e i a ia e unde t a i s r tve
ong,' nd
t r he or
e i f he nm t e ks s va l bl
r he dm nit a i

p o e u e L. Toc mpl wi j 1 97 () a imaemu tf l w e c se o tee tbih d
rc d r. d
o o y t 9 ea , n n t s ol a h tp f h sa ls e
h
o
a i sr tve pr e e t tt f ciiy pr dest pr s r a m e ta lde dlne w ihi t t
dm ni t a i
oc dur ha he a lt ovi o i one s nd e l a i s t n ha

pr edu ebeor flnghi j 1 aci Se W oodf dv.
oc r f e ii s 983 ton. e
or Ngo,5 U. 81 90-4 (
48 S. , 9 2006)
.

2

Thede e n sbe rt btr n ofpr ng t a fr ai de e et tCampbel f ie t
f nda t a he zde
ovi he fim tve f ns ha
l a ld o

e us a lbl a i sr tver m e e r ga di hi cli s J
xha t vaia e dm nita i e di s e r ng s am . onesv. k,5 U. 1
Boc 49 S. 99,

21 ( 0 7 .1A) a miitaierme yi n t o sd rdt h v b e a albei ap io e,
2 2 0 ) $ n d nsrtv e d s o c n iee o a e e n v ia l f rs n r
g
t ough no f ul ofhi own, pr ve e fom a ii hi s l ofi.' M oor v. nne t 51
hr
a t
s
was e nt d r
va lng m e f t '
e Be tçs 7

F.d71 725( h Ci.2008) Thedititc ti ç i tdt e ur t ta dee t i
3 7, 4t r
.
src our s ' gae o ns e ha ny fcs n
obl
e usi we eno pr m e fom t a on ori di ofprs ofk i l .' A g l r
xha ton r t oc d r he di
na on
ion t a s ' uia -

Av la e av Ter l, 78F.d 1 2 ,1 2 ( 0hCi. 0 7 .M o e v r f rp mo e o t e
elv d . rel4 3 2 3 2 5 1 t r 2 0 ) r o e, o u s s f h
pr e moton, hecour mus sde wih Ca
es nt i t
t ti
t mpbel on a g ui l diput d ma e i lf c .
l ny en ney- s e
t ra a t

And ro 40 F.da 6 7.Asac nsq e c , e e d n sa ee t ldt sl r j dg n o
es n, 7 3 t 7
o e u n e d f n a t r ni e o v
t
mma y u me t n
t ba i ofi xha ton onl i t y c ts
he ss ne usi
y f he an ûhow t tt e de ei s o - i d t tno
ha he vi nc s o ne sde ha

r a o a l fcfn e c udfndt a gh p io e)wa p e e tdfo e h u tn hi
e s n b e a tid r o l i h t t e rs n r s r v ne r m x a sig s

a mi itaierme is'Hi v. Bre 3 7F. p' 3 6 3 9(t Ci. uy 1 , 01 )
d nsrtv e d e . l O' in, 8 Ap x 9 , 9 4h r J l 2 2 0
' l
( n u ls e )(e esn a a r o sl r j dg n a an tap io e wh came t a
u p bih d r v rig n wa d f l
mmay u pe t g is rs n r o li d h t
prs ofiil ha hi rdhi a lt t fl a nitai gre nce)
ion fcas d ndee s biiy o ie dmi srtve iva s.
B.

The e de ofCa
vi nce
mpbel' us oft W VRJgre nc pr dur r ga di hi
ls e he
i va e oce e e r ng s
c
ompli a
ant boutt pe rs a i i nti lr el undiput Campbe lwa boo d a a
he ppe pr y ncde s a g y
s ed.
l s ke s n

imaea teji o Oco e 21 20 0 Du igt b o igp o e s Ca belsg e a i mae
n t t h al n tb r , 1 . rn he o kn r c s, mp l in d n n t
a kno edge ntf m,i c tng t theha be n pr de wih ac oft W VRJl t
c wl me or ndia i ha
d e ovi d t opy he
nma e

Ha d o k o Rulsa dRe u ainsa dha b e a vie ho t a c s t ji' g iv n e
n b o f e n g lto n d e n d s d w o c e s he als re a c
PCOCCSS.

The I a e H a
nm t ndbook s t f t t s e a i m a e m us t ke t br ng a gre nc a ut
e s or h he t ps n n t
ta o i
i va e bo

a i de a W VRJ.W ihi s ve da oft i i nt t i em us p ovi W VRJsa f
n nci nt t
t n e n ys he nc de ,he nmat
t r de
tf

w ih hi gr e nc The i a e c n s ts y t s flng r quiem e by s i tng a W V RJl a e
t s i va e.
nm t a a i f hi ii e r nt ubm ti
nm t
Re
ques For ,a s known a a ç ue s i ' r ues i a gr e nc f r . W ihi s ve da of
t m lo
s l
bl lpy eq tng
'
i va e o m
t n e n ys
r ce vi t bl s i orgr e nc t A s i t ntSe lrt Com m a rorA s i t ntSe vi es
e i ng he ue lp
i va e, he s sa
c ziy
nde
s sa
r c

Comm a rwilde e mi whe he t i i nti greva e, e twih t i t t complt a
nde l t r ne
t r he nc de s i bl m e t he nma e o
ee
W v l . g i va f m , tem ptt r s ve t g i va ,a as i a num be t t gre nc
tl r e nce or a t
o e ol he r e nce nd sgn
r o he i va e.

l t i t i nots tsi d wih t r s utonpr pos d dzi t si or a sag oft
f he nma e s
a ife t he e ol i
o e lrng hi nf m l t e he
gre nc pr dur he mus wrt hi r a onsi ade i t d s c i a t botom oft
iva e oce e,
t ie s e s
n
sgna e e ton t he t
he
gre nc f m a s i i wihi 48holr t t a o i t ofi i l Theofl i lwilr viw
iva e or nd ubm t t t n
zs o he ppr prae fc a .
tc a l e e

t a ala r pond t t i aewihi s ve da .l t i t i uns ts d wih t s
he ppe nd es
o he nm t t n e n ys f he nma e s a iûe t hi
r ol i hem a a
es uton,
y ppea wihi 72 hour t t W vlls i e n ,who i t fna a bie
l t n
s o he
t uperntnde t
s he i l r t r
ofi a e gr e nc s
nm t i va e .

Cn
mpbel frtfl abl si on Se e be 24,201 r que tngt fl g ivanc a
l is ied ue lp
ptm r
2, e si o ie re
e bout
Re dsa Ba e a t pe rs a i i nt Cn pbe lsa e i t g iva t tt
ynol nd xly nd he ppe pr y nc de . m l t t d n he re nce ha he
i i ntoc ured o Augus 15, 1, et n ayea e rir On Ocobe 2,201 a o t e
ncde
c r n
t 201 mor ha
r a le .
t r
2, n fk r
w r t a r pl t Ca pbel' g i va e,sa i t tt m a t rw a no l rgreva e be a e
oe e y o m
l s r e nc t tng ha he te s onge i bl , c us

Ca pbe lha nottld hi gre ncewihi s ve da afe t i i nt Ca pbe ldi not
m l d
ie s iva
t n e n ys tr he nc de . m l d
a
ppea t s diposton.
l hi s ii 2
C.

Dee d n sa sr ta t e a ee tte t s mmayj d me tu d rj1 9 ea b sd o
fn a t se th t h y r n i d o l r u g n n e 9 7 () a e n
l
z
Ca pbe l sf iur t fl a greva e abou t A ug t1 2011 pe r s ay i i ntw ihi
m
l' a l e o ie
i nc
t he
us 5,
, ppe pr nc de
tn
t s ve da tm e lm i a r quied unde t W V RJ gr e nc pr ce ze. The c t i t
he e n- y i i t s e r
r he
i va e o dlr
our f nds he
de e n s m oton t be w e lt en.
f nda t ' i o
l ak
2 I r ponset def
n es
o endant 'm oton, Campbel s aest thecoul notappealbeca e he di not
s
i
l t t ha
d
us
d
r ve acopy oft Oct 2,2012 r y t hi gri nce a wastans ered a f dayslt r.
ecei
he ober
epl o s eva
nd
r f r
ew
ae
4

The e de esa ihe t tCa
vi nce tbls s ha mpbelwasore e t and r c ve hi pe s lco
l
int d o,
e ei d s r ona py

o ,h giv nc p o e u e wh nhee tr dtej i i Oco r2 1 , u t a heddn tèea
f te re a e r c d r s e
ne e h aln t be 0 0 b t h t i o tl
tmey giv n eu e t ji' p o e u e mp elsva u algaint a h ddno k o
i l re a c nd r he als r c d r .Cn b l' g e le to h t e i t n w
he c d fl a gre nce s ri nots fcintt wihsa def nda s'moton. An i a e
oul ie iva
oone s
ufi t o t tnd e nt
i
nm t
cn
nnots r hi r pons biiy t u ii t gr e nc pr e e m e el by ke pi hi s l
hik s es
i lt o t lze he i va e oc dur
r y
e ng m e f

i nor ntofisa ia epr sons Ca
g a
t val bl ovi i . mpbe lsaesno f dsi cai t tt ne s a y
l tt
a ndi tng ha he ce s r
gre nc f m sa pr e eswe eno a ia et hi i Aug t2011
iva e or nd oc dur
r t va lbl o m n
us
.
Cn
mpbelc t ndst thewat d t co pl n a
l on e
ha
ie o m ai boutt pe rs a i i ntbe a ehe
he ppe pr y ncde
c us

fae t a Re n lsa dBa e , oc niu dt woki t eae o t j iwh r Ca bel
e r d h t y od n xly wh o t e o r n h ra f he al te mp l
n

wa h usda trteicd n , udp p e s ryhi a an.Cn bel le e t a çat i s
s o e fe h n i e two l e p r p a m g i mp lalg s h ts l tme
l
Ofie Re dswoul ma e co a twihmewihi i datngl kst tfa e (ilme
fc r ynol
d ke ye ntc t
t ntmi i oo ha e r d sc
a trbengs a byhi ' ( No.38,a 3. Basd o t s c r ,Cnmpbelplnnedt
fe i pryed
m. ECF
'
t ) e n he e oncens
l a
o
watuntlhi ta frt t Vigi aDe rme ofCore tons(ç
i i s rnse o he r ni pat nt
rci ç
VDOC' t c ana
' o ompli bout
)
t Augus 1 2011i de . Hewr e lte st VDOC ofk il , ki t betanse r dt a
he
t 5,
nci nt
ot e tr o
t a s as ng o r f r e o
VD O C f c lt
a iiy.

The c tc nno fnd t ea lga i s fce t ove c ede e nt moton.
our n t i hes le tons ufi int o r om
f nda s' i

Ca
mpbelslte st VDOC oûcasdi notf lila c nnots tt ef t j 1 ()
l' e tr o
f il d
ufl nd a
ubsiut or he 997ea
r quie ntt thefl atme y g iva eunde W VRJpr ed es s t tof a st r c d
e r me ha
ie i l re nc
r
oc ur , o ha scil he e oul
pr
ompty i tgaehi al gai .Furhe mor ,Ca pbelss c ai wo e a
l nvesi t s le tons
t r e m l' pe ul tve ni s bout
Re
ynol a B a e bas d o no hi m or t n t wa he t
ds nd xl y, e n t ng
e ha he y
houghtR e ds l d a hi ,
ynol ooke t m

c nnots
n
uppor afndi t tt W VRJg i va pr e ewasunaval bl t Cn
t i ng ha he
re nce oc dur
ia e o mpbel i
ln
A ug t201 . Hil 38 F.App' a 399. By hi own ad i s on,Ca pbel m a a c c ous
us
1
l, 7
x t
s
m si
m
l de ons i
de s on t f eg co pl ni a
cii o or o m ai ng boutt pe r s a i i
he ppe pr y nc dentuntlhe w asa
i
boutt l a t
o e ve he

j i.l s d i g hefie t c mpywi j 1 9 ea ' e h usinrq ie n , n o t a
al n o o n , ald o o l t 9 7 ()s x a to e ur me t a d n h t
h

b ss d fn a t aee t ldt s
a i, ee d n s r n ie o umma yj g n a amatro lw.Ae o dn l t c u t
t
r ud me t s te f a
c r i gy,he o r
wilgr ntt i m otons
l a her i .
I
Il

Fo ter a o ssae t c u t r nsd fn a t' to f rs mma yj g n o t
r h e s n ttd,he o r g a t ee d n s moins o u r ud me t n he
gr
ound t tCa pbe lf ie t exha ta nita i r m e esbef eflng t sa i The
ha m l al d o
us dmi sr tve e di
or ii hi cton.

Cl r i diece t s nd c esoft sm e a
e k s r td o e opi
hi mor ndum opi on a a co pa ngor rt
ni nd c m nyi
de o
pl i ifa t cou elofr co d f t de enda s
antf nd o ns
e r or he f nt.

ENTER:Th s 12Y d y o J n ay 2 3
i
a f a u r , 01 .
M'
W

,
.

y
.

/?2
/

Sen

6

. ,J-g -

nied Stt Ditit udge
t
aes src