Breckenridge v. Manis

Filing 3

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge James C. Turk on 11/1/2012. (kab)

/ FRK: OFF# t,. R c r
3
C: l: Ql
trrr:Nr. VA
'
t
y, ?), ha
; t; t
,

I TH E U N I
N
TED STATE S D I
STR I C O U R T
CT
FO R TH E W E STER N D I
STR I O F V I G I I
CT
R N A
R O A N O K E D I ISIO N
V
W I AM F.BRE CK EN R I G E ,
LLI
D

N0l 0 12 1
/
22
.t.,
.!
$
.
!

1--, .
l - .
. ttk,k

BY;

DEP

.

,w usax

QLERK

CA SE N O .7: V 00518
12C

Pett oner
ii
,
M EM O M N D U M O PI I N
N O
V S.

CARL A.M ANI W ARDEN
S,

By:Jame C.Tur
s
k
Se or U nied St esD i t i tJudg
ni
t
at
src
e

R es
pondent
.

W ilam F.Br c mi ,aVigi a i t pr e ng pr K ,f l t spe ii f a
li
e ke dge
r ni nma e oc edi
o
ied hi tton or
.

wrtofha sc pus purua t 28U. C.j225 Thec tc udest tt peiinmus
i
bea or , s nt o
S.
4.
our oncl
ha he tto
t

b s mmai ds s e wih u p eu ie
e u rl imis d t o t rj d c .
y
Ont ef c o h spei o Brc e rd esae t a h i c aln i j d me t fo t
h a e f i t in, e k n ig tts h t e s h l gng u g n s r m wo
t
e
sp rt saec u t a aci na j d me tis e b t sc u t S cin 2 5 pr vd sa
e a ae tt o rs nd rmi l u g n su d y hi o r. e to 2 4 o ie
ha asrme onl uponas ngt tpeii ri c i dunde t j
be e dy y
howi ha ttone s onfne
r he udgme ofasae
nt
tt
c tnvi ai oft Consiutonorlwsoft Unie Stts1 Se j2254( Thus t t
our i olton he
tt i
a
he td ae . e
*.
,o he

e tn ta Brc e rdg i atmp igt c alng a yci n lud me tp e iusye tr d
x e th t e k n i e s te tn o h l e n rmia j g n rv o l nee
e
ag ns hi i t scour, sj2254peiini nott a opraerme a mus bedimisd
ai t m n hi
thi
tto s he ppr it e dy nd t s se
w ihoutpr l di .2
t
e' ce
u

W hi Br c e rd ema c le g saec u t rmia j dg n su d rj2 5 , mu t
l e k n ig y haln e tt o r ci n l u me t n e 2 4 he s
e
fl asp rt j2 5 peiinrg r igtej d me to j d me t is e b e c o t
ie e a ae 2 4 tto e a dn h u g n r u g n s s u d y a h f he
1 Th a pr it rme frc al ngi afd rl rmia j gme ti amoto t v c t,e
e p oprae e dy o h l ng e ea ci n lud n s
e
in o a ae st
a ieo c re tt s ntnc und r28U. C. 2 .Th fdea j g n t tBr c e i ea pe r t
sd r o rc he e e e e
S. j 255 e e r l ud me t ha e k nrdg p as o
be chalengi wasent ed agai thi mor t t y year ago,and he dem onsr esno gr
l ng
er
ns m
e han went
s
tat
ound on

whc hec l pu s atmey j2 cam r g r igt sj gme t i lg o t esaut o I tto
ih oud rue i l 255 li e a dn hi ud n ,n iht f h tt e f i ains
mi
i j225 ( Thee o e t c ur wil tc sr etec re tpla nga aj2 mo i
n
5 9. r f r she o t lno on tu h u r n e di s 255 ton.
2 Und rRul 4( oft eRulsGo r n j2 4Ca e , h c ur ma s mma iydimisa
e e b) h e venig 25 s s t e o t y u rl s s
j225 p ttonç ifipl i ya e r fom t peiin a a y atc de bist tt p tton ri no
4 eii çj t anl pp a s r he tto nd n ta he xhi t ha he eii e s t
l
entted t r i i t diti cour.'
il o elef n he srct
t'

spaaec t i ve 3 SeeRul 2() RulsGoveni j225 Ca e Thec ts
e rt ours nvol d.
e e, e
r ng
4 s s.
our ummaiy
rl

ds se Br c e rd esp tto wih u p eudc , e a s h mu tfl spaaep tt n t
imis s e k n ig ' eiin t o t rj ie b c u e e s ie e rt eio s o
i
l e hi
c aln et ej dg n so spaaec urs4 Ana p oprat orderw ilent rt sday
h le g h u me t f e rt o t.
pr i e

.

The clr i die e t s nd c e oft s m e a
e k s r ctd o e opi s
hi mor ndum opi on and a co nyi
ni
c mpa ng
or rt pe ii r
de o ttone .

ENTER:Thi I4 sda ofNove , 201
s .J- y
mber 2.

A J
Se ' Unied St t Di 'tJ
t
aes s
udge

3 Br c
dge s
so i
r ed
e kenri al o appear t betm eba r under28U .S. j22 ( fom r ii a yc re t
C. 44 d) r asng n u r n
chale t t sa ecourtconvitonshe mentonson t f oft petton.
lnge o he t t
ci
i
he ace he ii

Br c e rdg speiin f l t ma ea y ce rsae n o hi cli f rr it a hi
e k n i e' tto ais o k n la ttme t f s ams o elel nd s
pe ii c ssmai y ofportonsofatans i t he doesnots i t t cour .Li aly
tton onsit
nl
i
r crpt hat
ubm t o he
t ber l
consr ng hi alegatons however i appear t t gr vamen ofBr kenrdge' pe ii i acl m t
tui s l i ,
,t
s hat he a
ec i s tton s ai hat
ti couns atan August2007 s enci hearng i t Cic tCour ofAl m are Count ar
ral
el
ent ng
i n he r ui
t
be l
y gued
i opery conce ni how t Cour coul consi rBr
mpr l
r ng
he
t d
de eckenrdge' prorsa eand f alconvitonsi
i s i tt
eder
ci n

d tr nn te2 0 sne c .Brc e rd epe iu l fldaj2 5 p tinc aln igti 2 0
eemiig h 0 7 e tn e e k n ij rvo s i
y e
2 4 eio h l gn hs 0 7
t
e
Al mal Co t u me t Se Brc e rdg v. r dae CaeNo. 1 CV00 7( . Va J y9
be re unyj dg n. e e k nl e Baks l, s
7:1
48 W D. .ul ,
201 ) Th ,Br c n i e' c r n peiin i as bs q e o , alngu e t p o bii i 28
2 . us e ke rdg s ure t tto s u e u nt ne f li nd r he r hi ton n
U. C. 2 4*)a ans as c ndo s c siepeiin.Pu s n t j2 4(9, f d r l src c r
S. j 24
g i t e o r uc e sv tto
rua t o 24 1 a e e a ditit ou t
ma c nsde as c ndors c s iej22 4 p ttono yu n s cfcc ri ai fo t Unie
y o i r eo
uc e sv
5 e ii nl po pe ii e tf ton r m he td
k
Stt Cour ofAppeal f t Fourh Cicui t t cl msi t petton meetcerai c t i
a es
t
s or he
t r t hat he ai n he ii
t n riera.

j2 4*) Be a s Br c e i eh sno obane s c c riia i byt Co t Ap a s t t
24 . c u e e k nrdg a t ti d u h e tfc ton he ur of pe l,o he
e entt tBr
xt ha eckenrdge s
i
eekst chalenge hi 2007 s e hi cur e petton m ay alo be di s ed
o
l
s
ent nce, s r nt ii
s
smis
ass
ucces ve.
si