Breckenridge v. Manis
Filing
3
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge James C. Turk on 11/1/2012. (kab)
/ FRK: OFF# t,. R c r
3
C: l: Ql
trrr:Nr. VA
'
t
y, ?), ha
; t; t
,
I TH E U N I
N
TED STATE S D I
STR I C O U R T
CT
FO R TH E W E STER N D I
STR I O F V I G I I
CT
R N A
R O A N O K E D I ISIO N
V
W I AM F.BRE CK EN R I G E ,
LLI
D
N0l 0 12 1
/
22
.t.,
.!
$
.
!
1--, .
l - .
. ttk,k
BY;
DEP
.
,w usax
QLERK
CA SE N O .7: V 00518
12C
Pett oner
ii
,
M EM O M N D U M O PI I N
N O
V S.
CARL A.M ANI W ARDEN
S,
By:Jame C.Tur
s
k
Se or U nied St esD i t i tJudg
ni
t
at
src
e
R es
pondent
.
W ilam F.Br c mi ,aVigi a i t pr e ng pr K ,f l t spe ii f a
li
e ke dge
r ni nma e oc edi
o
ied hi tton or
.
wrtofha sc pus purua t 28U. C.j225 Thec tc udest tt peiinmus
i
bea or , s nt o
S.
4.
our oncl
ha he tto
t
b s mmai ds s e wih u p eu ie
e u rl imis d t o t rj d c .
y
Ont ef c o h spei o Brc e rd esae t a h i c aln i j d me t fo t
h a e f i t in, e k n ig tts h t e s h l gng u g n s r m wo
t
e
sp rt saec u t a aci na j d me tis e b t sc u t S cin 2 5 pr vd sa
e a ae tt o rs nd rmi l u g n su d y hi o r. e to 2 4 o ie
ha asrme onl uponas ngt tpeii ri c i dunde t j
be e dy y
howi ha ttone s onfne
r he udgme ofasae
nt
tt
c tnvi ai oft Consiutonorlwsoft Unie Stts1 Se j2254( Thus t t
our i olton he
tt i
a
he td ae . e
*.
,o he
e tn ta Brc e rdg i atmp igt c alng a yci n lud me tp e iusye tr d
x e th t e k n i e s te tn o h l e n rmia j g n rv o l nee
e
ag ns hi i t scour, sj2254peiini nott a opraerme a mus bedimisd
ai t m n hi
thi
tto s he ppr it e dy nd t s se
w ihoutpr l di .2
t
e' ce
u
W hi Br c e rd ema c le g saec u t rmia j dg n su d rj2 5 , mu t
l e k n ig y haln e tt o r ci n l u me t n e 2 4 he s
e
fl asp rt j2 5 peiinrg r igtej d me to j d me t is e b e c o t
ie e a ae 2 4 tto e a dn h u g n r u g n s s u d y a h f he
1 Th a pr it rme frc al ngi afd rl rmia j gme ti amoto t v c t,e
e p oprae e dy o h l ng e ea ci n lud n s
e
in o a ae st
a ieo c re tt s ntnc und r28U. C. 2 .Th fdea j g n t tBr c e i ea pe r t
sd r o rc he e e e e
S. j 255 e e r l ud me t ha e k nrdg p as o
be chalengi wasent ed agai thi mor t t y year ago,and he dem onsr esno gr
l ng
er
ns m
e han went
s
tat
ound on
whc hec l pu s atmey j2 cam r g r igt sj gme t i lg o t esaut o I tto
ih oud rue i l 255 li e a dn hi ud n ,n iht f h tt e f i ains
mi
i j225 ( Thee o e t c ur wil tc sr etec re tpla nga aj2 mo i
n
5 9. r f r she o t lno on tu h u r n e di s 255 ton.
2 Und rRul 4( oft eRulsGo r n j2 4Ca e , h c ur ma s mma iydimisa
e e b) h e venig 25 s s t e o t y u rl s s
j225 p ttonç ifipl i ya e r fom t peiin a a y atc de bist tt p tton ri no
4 eii çj t anl pp a s r he tto nd n ta he xhi t ha he eii e s t
l
entted t r i i t diti cour.'
il o elef n he srct
t'
spaaec t i ve 3 SeeRul 2() RulsGoveni j225 Ca e Thec ts
e rt ours nvol d.
e e, e
r ng
4 s s.
our ummaiy
rl
ds se Br c e rd esp tto wih u p eudc , e a s h mu tfl spaaep tt n t
imis s e k n ig ' eiin t o t rj ie b c u e e s ie e rt eio s o
i
l e hi
c aln et ej dg n so spaaec urs4 Ana p oprat orderw ilent rt sday
h le g h u me t f e rt o t.
pr i e
.
The clr i die e t s nd c e oft s m e a
e k s r ctd o e opi s
hi mor ndum opi on and a co nyi
ni
c mpa ng
or rt pe ii r
de o ttone .
ENTER:Thi I4 sda ofNove , 201
s .J- y
mber 2.
A J
Se ' Unied St t Di 'tJ
t
aes s
udge
3 Br c
dge s
so i
r ed
e kenri al o appear t betm eba r under28U .S. j22 ( fom r ii a yc re t
C. 44 d) r asng n u r n
chale t t sa ecourtconvitonshe mentonson t f oft petton.
lnge o he t t
ci
i
he ace he ii
Br c e rdg speiin f l t ma ea y ce rsae n o hi cli f rr it a hi
e k n i e' tto ais o k n la ttme t f s ams o elel nd s
pe ii c ssmai y ofportonsofatans i t he doesnots i t t cour .Li aly
tton onsit
nl
i
r crpt hat
ubm t o he
t ber l
consr ng hi alegatons however i appear t t gr vamen ofBr kenrdge' pe ii i acl m t
tui s l i ,
,t
s hat he a
ec i s tton s ai hat
ti couns atan August2007 s enci hearng i t Cic tCour ofAl m are Count ar
ral
el
ent ng
i n he r ui
t
be l
y gued
i opery conce ni how t Cour coul consi rBr
mpr l
r ng
he
t d
de eckenrdge' prorsa eand f alconvitonsi
i s i tt
eder
ci n
d tr nn te2 0 sne c .Brc e rd epe iu l fldaj2 5 p tinc aln igti 2 0
eemiig h 0 7 e tn e e k n ij rvo s i
y e
2 4 eio h l gn hs 0 7
t
e
Al mal Co t u me t Se Brc e rdg v. r dae CaeNo. 1 CV00 7( . Va J y9
be re unyj dg n. e e k nl e Baks l, s
7:1
48 W D. .ul ,
201 ) Th ,Br c n i e' c r n peiin i as bs q e o , alngu e t p o bii i 28
2 . us e ke rdg s ure t tto s u e u nt ne f li nd r he r hi ton n
U. C. 2 4*)a ans as c ndo s c siepeiin.Pu s n t j2 4(9, f d r l src c r
S. j 24
g i t e o r uc e sv tto
rua t o 24 1 a e e a ditit ou t
ma c nsde as c ndors c s iej22 4 p ttono yu n s cfcc ri ai fo t Unie
y o i r eo
uc e sv
5 e ii nl po pe ii e tf ton r m he td
k
Stt Cour ofAppeal f t Fourh Cicui t t cl msi t petton meetcerai c t i
a es
t
s or he
t r t hat he ai n he ii
t n riera.
j2 4*) Be a s Br c e i eh sno obane s c c riia i byt Co t Ap a s t t
24 . c u e e k nrdg a t ti d u h e tfc ton he ur of pe l,o he
e entt tBr
xt ha eckenrdge s
i
eekst chalenge hi 2007 s e hi cur e petton m ay alo be di s ed
o
l
s
ent nce, s r nt ii
s
smis
ass
ucces ve.
si
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?