Bane v. U. S. Trustee

Filing 32

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 03/08/2013. (rkc)

rl s OF CEU,.DI O URT
mFI s ST.
ATROANOKE,
VA
FIED
I
-

Màq 11 2 1
23
JULA C.
I DUDL M CLERK
E

I TH E UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRICT CO URT
FO R TH E W ESTE RN D I RICT O F V I G I I
ST
R N A
ROANO KE DI I ON
V SI
D A V I E.B A N E,
D

BY
:

Ci lA ct on N o.7: . 0529
vi
i
12c *

A ppel ant
l ,

M EM O R AN DU M O PI O N
NI

V.

U . TR U STEE ,
S.
A ppe l e.
le

By:Sam uelG .W is
l on
Unied St es D i ri Judge
t
at
st ct

Thi i ana a byt Cha e 7de o , vi E.Ba puruan t 28U. C.j
s s ppe l he ptr btr Da d
ne, s t o
S.

1 a( ) fom anor roft ba ptyc tde ngBa adic r be us t tc t
58()1, r
de he nknl c our nyi ne s hage ca e ha our
f
ound t tBa t a f r d pr r y w ih t i t ntt de r ud hi c e t sand t U nie St e
ha ne r ns er e ope t t he n e o f a
s r dior
he t d at s

Tr se i vo aino 1 U. C. 7 7 a( )a dta h h dk o n l ma e fa d ln f le
u te n ilto f 1 S. j 2 ()2 n h t e a n wig y d ,r u ue t as
oa hs r a di m a e i f ct by f ii t di c os as e son hi ba
t eg r ng t ral a s
a lng o s l e s t
s nknz c s he e i
pt y c dul s n

vi ai ofj7 a( ( . Es entaly, Banem s t t tt ba ptycou tsfndi of
olton
27()4)A)1 s i l
sers ha he nknl c r' i ngs
fa e i e a ecea l erone . ' sc tc ude t tt r i a pl e de et
r udulnt nt nt r l ry r ous I
hi our oncl s ha he e s m e vi nc o
s
uppor t bankr t y co tsEndi t tBa tanse r pr pe t wih i en t de r ud hi
t he
up c ur '
ng ha ne r f red o ry t nt t o fa
s
c e t s a t Unie St e Tr s e Bec us t tfndi al i s tci ntt de Ba a
r dior nd he t d at s u t e.
a e ha i ng one s uf i e o ny ne

dic ge t c tdoesnotr c t ba pt y c tsot rfndi a a fnnst
s har , he our
ea h he nknl c our' he i ngs nd fi
he

l11U .SC.j7 7 a( ) r vde,np rie t r,h t
. 2 ()2 p o i s i et n patta
n

( h c u ts alg a tte d bo adsh re t ested bo,wi itn t hn e,d ly,o
t e o r h l rn h e tr ic ag , mls h e tr t ne t o id r ea r
l
h

defaud ac e t oran om c oft esat c ge wih c t ofpr ry unde t stte,hm
r
r dior
er he t e har d t usody
ope t
r hi il s
tanse rd ...orhasper it t be ta fre ...pr ry oft de or wihi one ye
r fre
m ted o
rnser d
ope t
he bt , t n
ar
beor t dae oft flng oft peii orpr ry oft esae,ahe t dat oft flng of
f e he t
he ii
he tton
ope t
he tt
r he e he ii
t pe ii
he tton.

1 U. C. 7 7 a( XA)po ie ,npet e t r,ha çth c u t h lg a t ic ag t ested bo
1 S. j 2 ()4 rvd s i ri n gatt tdle o r s al rn dsh re mls h e tr
n
l

k i y a faudulnty,ori conne tonw lht ca e m a af s oah ora ot '
now ngl nd r
e l
n
ci
t he s , de ale t
cc mt'

rr c
? .

j
udgme .
nt2
1.

Ba sc os l hed com or ton,Aeq t sEne gy,I ,pu c e ove ffy a r soflnd
ne' l ey l
ai
uia - r nc. r has d r i t c e
a

i Roa
n noke, r ni (
Vigi a knownast t nge La Pr ry')fom hi mot ,M at Ba f
he W l ne ope t ' r s her rha ne, or
$ 0, Ba ltrobti al fom CommuniyTr s Ba Cçhebankn y e urdbya
40 000. ne ae aned oan r
t u t nk t
lsc e
pr pe l r cor d de oftus on t Ang La Pr ry.n e l n we i o deful a t
o ry e de ed r t he
el ne ope t
oa
nt nt a t nd he
ba s he e af ecos es l f J y 2,201 Theda bef r t s heduld f e os e
nk c dul d or l ur a e or ul
0.
y o e he c
e or cl ur
s l Ba e ut de dstanse ng t AngelLa Pr ryt hi s l,a on t da oft
ae, ne xec ed e r f ni he
ne ope t o m e f nd he y he
s l fl d banknl c underCha er7,whi h ha t e f c ofs a ng t f e l ur Bane
a e, ie
pt y
pt
c d he f e t t yi he or c os e.
l e volmt r l di m i s d t tCh: e 7 c e.
at r t a iy s s e ha
pt r ms

Thebank r s he e t f e os e s ef t Ange La Pr ry f J r 24,
e c dul d he or cl ur al or he
l ne ope t or anua y
2011.On De mber31 201 Ba exe ut ade ta f ri ni t pe c toft Ange
ce
, 0, ne c ed
ed r ns e rng ne y r en
he
l
La Pr pery t hi m o he f t n dola si c i r ton. I t i e i ,a of e t p c s
ne o t o s t r or e
l r n ons de a i
n he nt rm n f r o ur ha e
t pr pe t f lt ough,and Ba had t de ta f r i ni t pe c ntoft Ang La
he o ry el hr
ne
he ed r ns e rng ne y r e
he
el ne

pr ryt hi mot rnotrz d on J
ope t o s he a ie
anua y 21 2 1 La e t ta tr n,t dee wa
r , 01 . t r ha fe noo he d s
r cor d i t Roa
e de n he noke Cot y Clr sOfke,a s ty a t 5p. . t ts m eda Ba
mt e k' t
nd horl fer m on ha n
y, ne
f l d hi c r ntba u c c e t derCha e 7. Ba di notdi c os hi ta f ri hi
ie s ur e
nkr pt y ms m
pt r
ne d
s l e s r ns e n s

sae e offnancala f r . TheTr t e' i tgai howe r r veae t ta f rmswel
t tm nt i i fais
use s nvesi ton,
ve , e ld he r nse
l
asot rt di c os d m a t r . The e eve s l d t Tm s e t fl a c pl ntpu s ntt 11
he m s l e
te s
s
nt e he
t e o ie om ai
r ua o

U. C.jj727()2)a 727a)4)A)t de Ba sCha e 7dic r e.
S.
a( nd ( ( ( o ny ne' ptr s ha g

2AsEh p o iin o j7 7 a aep rsdi tedsu cie, lo fo c n u tst f n a yo eo t e
l e r vso s f 2 4) r hae n h i n tv lpro f o d c ai yig n n f h
t
j
s
sb-e t n i e o g t j siyad na ofad bo' rq etfradic ag . Fao k v Emiae Br Itl 1
u sci s s n u h o utf e il e trs e u s o sh re' ru i . rts mk n', 4
o
'
F.d24 2 94hCi,1 9 .Be a s ti c u t fimsteba ku tyc utsj7 7a()f ig ,tn e no
3 4, 4 (t r 9 4) cu e hs o r af h n r pc o r' 2 ()2 mdn s i ed t
r
rahteba k u tyc u ts j7 7 a()A)f ig .
e c h n r pc o r' 2 ()4 ( mdn s

I t r uli a s r pr e ng,Banea s td hi Fit Ame
n he es tng dvera y oc edi
s ere s fh
ndme prvie a
nt i lge nd
di nott s i y. Ba sbr he t tfed t tt de i d t t a f roft Ang La
d
e tf
ne' ot r es ii ha hey s gne he r ns e
he
el ne
Pr pe t t tpr t c t rm ot . Bane a gued t ta t
o ry o t o e t hei
her'
'
r
ha lhough he had i ed e c e a
nde xe ut d

quicai dee i hi mot ' na i c et ofert plr s t pr t ha gonet o h
tl m
d n s hers me n as he f o zcha e he opery d
hr ug
aspl d on J uar 20,2011 he ne de i r t tdee t hi m ot r Ra he ,Bane
anne
an y
,
ver lve ed ha
d o s he . t r
as ere t thi br herf m d t dee a t i m ot ' hom e,a sl ed t J ua y 20t s l
s t d ha s ot ot he d t he r her s
s tm
he an r
h ae

woul oc ura t atBanewoul notfl f banknz c a t n fld t td d wihoutBa s
d c nd h
d
ie or
pty, nd he ie ha ee t
ne'
knowl dge.Ba di nota gu t tt Ange La Pr rywasnothi pr ryatt tme i
e
ne d
r e ha he
l ne ope t
s ope t he i t
wa tans er e no di he a g t tt t a f rdi no uke pl c dur ng t yea pr c di hi
s r f r d, r d
r ue ha he r ns e d t
a e i he r e e ng s
flng ofa Cha er7 bn
ii
pt
nknl c petton.
pt y ii
Aferhe rng t e denc t ba
t
a i he vi e, he nknl c c tf und t tBa st a f rofni t
pt y our o
ha ne' r ns e
ne y
pe c ntoft A nge La Pr r y t hi m ot rptr ua t t Dec m be 31 201 dee
re
he
l ne ope t o s he ls nt o he
e r , 0, d

c tt e gr
onsiutd oundst de dic g l rj727( ( ( ,whihpr desf de alof
o ny s hare mde
a)2)A) c ovi or ni
di c r e o a de orw ho,t ih i e t hi ,de a orde r ud a c e t ora of e oft
s ha g f
bt
ç t nt nt o nder l y,
w
fa
r dior n f r he

e tt c ge wih c t ofpr ry t rt stte ha ta f r d ...orha pe te t be
sa e har d t usody
ope t mde hi il , s r nsere
s nnitd o
ta f red ... ope t oft de or wihi one ye rbef et da eoft flngoft
r nse r
pr ry he bt , t n
a or he t
he ii
he
pe ii n.' 'heba pt y c talo f
tto ' I
3 ' nknl c our s ound t tBa i e d t defa hi c e t sby f ii
ha ne nt nde o r ud s r dior
alng

t d s ls a st,u me t, n o h rmatr o h sb n n c sh d e , ia ca
o ico e sesj dg n s a d t e te s n i a k mty c e uls fn n il
s at ent , and d i t tmony a t me i ofc e t r .
t em s
urng esi
t he etng r dio s 4

3Baneofe st genealex anai f why hedi notdicos t ale la lte a a st :
r wo
r pl tons or
d
s l e he lged ibiiis nd se s
t itkesa emad i ba m z ci ,'a her le uponhi coun elwhe flng hi ba ruptype ii Thecour
t sa
m
r
e n nl pt es' nd eid
s
s
n ii s nk c tton.
t
notst Ba ase t hi Fi Am e e prviegesa di nottket sa andhetld noe bist
e hat ne s red s Rh
ndm nt i l
nd d
a he tnd,
ie
xhi t o
s
uppor hi e a ton t the r i d on hi pr vi c el Nordi Ba ca lt a t ne t t s iy con m i
t s xpl na i ha
ele
s e ous ouns .
d ne l hat tor y o e tf
ce ng

ten ndslsdprp ry j d me t, n cams ( cso a dOre 3 ECFNo. 1 )
h o -ico e o et,u g nsa d li . De iin n d r ,
l 6.
4n eba m l c c tf
nl pty our oundt tBa k
ha ne nowi ya gaudulntyomit t f l ngie fom hi
ngl nd
e l
ted he olowi tms r
s

sh d l o a st: l Ba ea dhisse' j g n a ans Ho r P y efro e $ ,0 () ro a p o et
c e ue f ses () n n s itrs ud me t g i t wad a n o v r 50 0;2 pes n l rp ry
con ane i aLouiinasor fciiyt tBa cli shedic r t bem isng a rhetld hi s dul of
ti d n
sa t age a lt ha ne am
s oveed o
s i Re
ie s che e

II.

Ba a gue t thedi noti e t de r ud whe heta f re t Ange Lane
ne r s ha
d
ntnd o fa
n r nse r d he
l
Pr ry t hi m ot ri t hour pr ce ng hi Cha e 7 pe ii The quesi ofi e ,
ope t o s he n he
s e di
s
pt r
tton.
ton nt nt

howe r i a f t li r a t ba nz c cour di notcea l e ri fndi fa e
ve , s acua nquiy, nd he nk pt y
t d
l ry r n i ng i udulnt
i ent
nt .

I r vi ng aba u c c tsde i i t sco tr vi fndi off c f ce
n e ewi
nkr pt y our' c son, hi ur e ews i ngs a t or lar

er .I r M ee t 527F. 37 375( hCi.2008) Spe iialy,Sfi ngsoff t..
ror n e rdih,
3d 2, 4t r
. cfc l ç jndi
l
ac .
s lnotbes tmsd t e scea l e
hal
e i e mls l ry aoneo ,and duer ga d s l begi n t t ba pt y
us
e r ha l
ve o he nknl c

c u t oj d etec e i l yo t ewi e s s' Fe R. n r P. 01 A fn igo fc i o l
o r t u g h rdbit f h t se . d. Bn k . 8 3. idn f a t s n y
i
n
'
c ea l er one i ,a t r vi w oft r c d,t r vi i c tf
l ry r ous f fer e e
he e or he e ew ng our onnul t a fr a de i t
a es i m nd fnie

c n ito t t ne rrha b e c mmitd.Se Kli v. o i . n .8 5F.d7 7 (t
o vcin ha a ro s e n o te
e en Pe sco l c, 4 2 6, 9 4h
Ci.1 (lho harvi ngco tmaydiag e ont ot rcour' c rceiai oft
r 988) at ug e ewi ur
s r e he he
ts haa trz ton he
fcs ft tdoe nota
a t,çha s mountt afr a dei t conviton'ofer ) Re e ngc t
o im nd tnie
ci ' ror. viwi ours
t cal de e t t bn pt ycour' c l i whe t ba u cycou tsac ountoft
ypi ly f r o he nknl c
ts onc usons n he nkr pt
r' c
he
evi nce i pl usbl i lghtoft r c d vi w e i ise ie y. Ande s v. s e e Ciy,
de
s a i en i
he e or e d n t ntr t
r on Be s m r t

470U. 564,573 ( 985)
S.
-74 1 .
Re ewi t r c d i ise iey,he c tfndst ba pt y c tsc l i
vi ng he e or n t ntr t t our i he nknz c our' oncuson
plusbl t Ba acedwih a t i e t der ud hi c edior . Thetmelneofe nt
a i e hat ne t
t cual nt nt o fa
sr t s
i i
ve s
l adi up t t t a f roft AngelLa Pr r y e t bls st tBa ta f r e ni t
e ng
o he r ns e
he
ne ope t s a i he ha ne r ns e r d ne y
pe c toft tpr ry m e e holr bef e flng hi Cha er7 pe ii wel w ihi t one ye
r en
ha ope t
r
zs or ii
s
pt
tton, l t n he - ar
m or orum on s h tans e s Thi t ns e bor c m on ba s off a i udi a l ck of
at i
uc r f r . s m f r e om
dge
r ud, ncl ng a

ast o J n ay212 l ()Ba esb n t a itrs i teMataHarsnBa eIrv c beTnzt whc h
ses n a u r , 0l ;3 n ' e ekilneet n h rh rio n re o a l s( ih e
n w ds tst h v n itrs i tetut n e e ih dd hsitr swo db wot n tig ;n ()a
o ipuc o a t o neetn h rs a d v n f e i, i neet ul e rh ohn )a d 4
j d me t eda an thm b V&V La dMa g me ti t a n o $ ,0 Ona p a, n c aln e te
u g n h l g is i y
n na e n n he mou t f 250 0.
p e lBa e h l g s h
e
a miso o te ee hbt.Ba eddn to jc t te ee hbt a dwa n tpeu ie b tericu in; o d
d sin fh s x ii n i o bet o h s x iis n s o rj dc d y h i n lso n r o
s
teee hi t b a o tec u t rs uino t sa p a pzs a tt 2 U. C. 1 8a()
h s x bi e r n h o r' eolt fhi p e l l u n o 8 S. j 5 ()1.
s
s
o
r

c i r ton f t t a f roft pr pe t f om Ba t hi m ot r t c os f m ii
onsde a i or he r ns e
he o ry r
ne o s he , he l e a lal
r l to hi be wee t pa te , Ba sr t nton ofa pa ta i e es i t pr r y
e a i ns p t n he ri s and ne' e e i
ri l nt r t n he ope t

alwighm c niue u eo ta p o e t.S eZa d r m I c v. a d v l I r S n o a)
lo n i o tn d s f h t r p ry e n e ma n . S n o a (n e a d v l,
No 9 - 3 ,1 9 W L 49 47 a * ( t Ci. g. 0 1 9 )( ic si gfco st a gv rs t
. 6 2 91 9 8
7 5 t 2 4h r Au 1 , 9 8 ds u sn a t r h t ie ie o
ap e u to of rud e titn)5 Th s f csaes fkin t s p o th b n np c c u ts
r s mp in fa uln ne t. e e a t r u t e t o u p r te a k lty o r'
c uson t tBa i ende t de r ud hi c e t s cor ngl t c ta fr t
oncl i ha ne nt d o f a
s r dior .Ac di y, he our fims he

b n nltyc u ts u g n .
a k pc o r'j d me t
11
1.

F rt er ao sae ,h c u t fi st ej d me t fteb n r pc c u t
o h e s ns ttd t e o r afnn h u g n o h a k u ty o r.
6
ENT ER :M a ch 8,201
r
3.

I
TED STATES D I
STRI J GE
CT UD

5TOCsabls i e ,t pa t s e ng t denilofdic r mus pr acua, asoppos d t
t ih ntnt he ry e ki he
a
shage t ove t l
e o

c n tu tv ,ne tt d ga d; llv ntepa tc l it t o mo nigdrc e ie c o ted bo ' itn ,
o srcie itn o e u Ggie h rcia df y f u tn ie t vd n e fh e trsne t
kul
fw ca estr ons h p oof'a c t i tadma i e a t ali e 9om t fct a cicl t ce
e s u n uc r ,' nd ours nse
y nfr c u ntnt
he a s nd r lmsnn s

sro n n teta se.De mo dv Vaas (nr Varso, 7F3 7 0 7 4( s Ci. 9 4 . e as J lil .
u ru dig h rn fr s n . rso 1 e ras )3 .d 6 , 6 1t r 1 9 ) se lo aae v
,
P se , 11 c 6 , 0l W L 1 4 31 , t*l( D. . r 8 2 1 (ttn t tt la d e titn cnb
ugly No. : 1v1 3 2 1
3 8 2 a E. Va Ap. , 01 ) saig ha çfru uln ne t a e
l
i erdho cru tnil vie c .) Lo kn t tecru tn e sro n i teta frc ut h v
nfre 'm ic msa ta e d n e' . o ig o h ic msn c s u ru dng h rnse, o rs a e
'
i ni e sv rloj cieidii ta,a e tg te,to gyidc t fa d ln itn.Th s idii icu e
de tt d e ea be tv n ca h ttk n o eh r srn l n iae ru ue tne t o e n ca n ld
i
()t lc o c n ieain frte ta se ;()a fmiy rlto s i b t e tep ris ()
1 he ak f o sd rt o h rn fr 2 a l eain hp ewe n h at ; 3
o
e
s mertninb ted bo o teu eo tep o e t;()ted bo ' f n ilc n to a te
o ee t y h e tr f h s f h rp ry 4 h e trs ma ca o di n th
o
i
tmeo ta se; 5 tee itn eofap t m o sre o ta scin a rteo sto f n il
i f rn fr ( ) h xse c
at r eis f rn ato s Re h ne f ma ca
e
df liso tra o s t yce i r; r()ass iiu c r n lg o e e t.
it te rh et f uib rdt s o 6 u pco s ho oo y f v ns
ku
o
Za dema I c v. a d v l 1 r S n ov l, 9 - 91 1 9 W L 4 7 7 a * ( t Ci. g l ,1 9 ) s e
n r n. n . S n o a (n e a d a ) No. 6 23 , 9 8
9 4 5 t 2 4 h r Au . 0 9 8 ; e
as S lmo v Kasr(nr Kasr, 2 F.d1 7 ,l 2 8 ( dCi.1 8 )( s usn tesmeG d e o
lo ao n . ie 1 e ie)7 2 2 5 4 58 - 3 2 r 9 3 dic sig h a ba g s f
fa 'e
rud' numert d i Sa val.
a e n ndo )
6n ecou tdipe e wih or agum e be us t f t andlgalc e i aeade t ypr s ntd
r s ns s t al r
nt ca e he acs
e ontntons r
quael e e e
i t m ae il bef et scou ta agum en woul notai t deciina pr ce s
n he tras or hi r nd r
t
d
d he so l o s .