Johnston v. Astrue

Filing 18

FINAL ORDER denying plaintiff's 11 Motion for Summary Judgment; granting Commissioner's 13 Motion for Summary Judgment; adopting 16 Report and Recommendations. Signed by Judge Samuel G. Wilson on 02/10/2014. (rkc)

cœ - s OFFI U . .DI .COUIT
CE $ ST
R
AT ROANOKE, A
V
Ff
LED

FEB 12 2 1
21
I TH E UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI O F VI
CT
RGI A
NI
RO AN O K E D I SI N
VI O

J A C.
ULI DUDLEY CLERK
BY:
*

M ELI
SSA J.JOH NSTON,
Ci lAc i No.7: 2- 00617
vi ton
1 CVPl ntf ,
ai if
V.

FI AL O RD ER
N

CA R O LY N W .CO LVIN ,A ctng
i
Com m isone o Soci Se t
si r f
al curiy,

By: Sam uelG .W is
l on
Unied St e Di t i tJudge
t
at s s r c

De e
f ndant
.

Thi SocalSe urt a
s i c iy ppea by t pl ntf wasr e r d t t M a sr t J
l he ai if
ef re o he gitae udgepur ua
s nt

t 28U. C.j636( ( )B)f rviw a f t prpa ai ofarpor sti frhhi
o
S.
b)1( or e e nd or he e r ton
e t e tng o t s
pr e fndi a r omm e tonsc e ni ispr rdiposton. TheM agita e
opos d i ngs nd ec
nda i
onc r ng t ope s ii
sr t
J
udgeha fl ar por a hasr co mende de ngt pl i ifsmoton f sl ma y
s ied e t nd
e m
d nyi he antf
i or lm r

j d me ta dg a tn t Co s in rsmo inf rs mmayj d me t Th plitf h s
u g n n r nig he mmiso e ' to o u r u g n . e an if a
o jce t t er p r.Th c s i n w beo etec u t
be td o h e o t e a e s o fr h o r.

Th c u t a r ve dt eM a itaeJ d e srpo tteo j cin t t trp r a d
e o r h s e iwe h g srt u g ' e r,h b e to s o ha e o q n
pe tne po tonsoft a nita i r or a co l
ri nt ri
he dmi sr tve ec d, nd ncudest tt M a sr t J
ha he gita e udge' r por
se t
i s t ntal c r c a t r f e,a st tr por.
s ubsa i ly ore t nd, he e or dopt ha e t
A c or ngl i i O R DER ED a A DJUD G ED t tt R e ta Rec m e ton
c di y, t s
nd
ha he por nd
om nda i

(
Docke No.1 i ADOPTED,t Commiso rsdecson i AFFI ED,t pli ifs
t
6) s
he
sine ' ii s
RM
he antf

moi nf rs mma yj d me t( c e No. 1 i DENI teCo sin rsmo inf r
to o u r u g n Do k t 1 ) s
ED,h mmiso e ' to o
s mmayj d me t( k t 1 )i GRANTED, ndti c s i S CKEN fo t e
u r u g n Doc e No. 3 s
a h s a e s TRI
rm h
doc toft c t
ke
he our .
ENTER : Fe a y 1 201
bnz r 0, 4.
A

UM TED STATES DI CT J
STRI UDGE